Back to school: will your child have a cell phone?

by  
Filed under All, Featured, Kids

 

We’ve noticed a trend among in our single parent community. And we wonder if you’ve noticed the same thing: single parents give cell phones to their kids at younger ages than married parents do.

This isn’t because single parents are more indulging, or because we’ve caved into our kids’ pleas: “I need a cell phone!” Single parents tell us that they’re getting phones for their kids for this reason: their own peace of mind.

In other words, you tell us: “I didn’t get the phone for my kid. I got it for ME.”

Typically, kids today lead hectic lives — and your kids are no exception. Some of your kids spend time away from home, often long distance with the other parent. Many of your kids are in after-school programs, or they get picked up by another parent at the end of the school day. Your tween or teen might now take public transportation. Or, maybe you don’t trust the sitter your ex hired.

Some of us remember putting a quarter into the payphone on the corner when we needed to call our parents. Well, those days are over. So, when our kids need to contact us, we want them to have a way. And, just as importantly, we want to be able to check in with our kids to make sure they’re safe.

One single mom frankly told us why she got a cell phone for her third grader: “I want my daughter to get in the habit of checking in with me early on, before she becomes a teen.”

We’re curious:

Did you get a cell phone for your kids? How old were they when they got the phone?

Do you have a limited plan on your kids’ phones? Say, without texting? Or, maybe your kids’ phones only have programmed phone numbers for an emergency?

Instead of buying expensive phones, do you just search for free cell phones to give to your kids?

If you’re holding off on getting a cell phone for your kids, we’d like to hear why.

~~~

Photo via Flickr: ilovedeer


 

Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

Related posts:

  1. Do you plan to go back to school? We’ve gone on the record about the importance of education for both YOU and your kids. Dr. Leah went back...
  2. What are the 4 top things your kids’ teachers MUST know? A single guy — no kids — dating a single mom reached out to us via Facebook with an interesting...

Comments

23 Responses to “Back to school: will your child have a cell phone?”
  1. C Lo says:

    Twitter @
    I held off for a long while, at least by the standard of my daughters peers. MOST of her friends had cell phones before her. That I did give her one earlier than I think a kid probably needs one, and I certainly love the convenience of NOT having to go through her dad to get to her when she’s at his house. I definitely took advantage of the “going between two houses” thing in order to justify giving her one. She got it when she was 11.
    C Lo´s last blog ..what is artMy ComLuv Profile

  2. Twitter @
    I made sure that each of my kids had cell phones when they were about 10 years old. At that age they were going out by themselves generally far enough away that I couldn’t just shout their names out and know that they’d hear me. Interestingly, we were in three different countries with the kids turned that age. In the UK it was very common already in 2000 for 10 year olds to have cell phones. In the US in 2003, my daughter was kind of the odd-girl-out running around with a phone of her own. In Israel, in 2010, some of my friends thought that I was strange making my son wait so long before I got him a phone. Most kids there have a phone by the time they are 6 or 7!!

    And yes, in my case it was definitely about my own peace of mind. I don’t think that it’s just because I’m a single mom, though. It’s more to do with feeling like having the cell phone means that I can give my kids more freedom while
    Elisheva Sterling´s last blog ..About Queen Anne’s DoorMy ComLuv Profile

  3. Anna says:

    Middle school is when he’ll get one. And even then, he will have a pretty limited one, although he will not be the type to use it much. I hadn’t thought of the being-at-dad’s-and-having-to-use-dad’s-phone thing, but that’s a good reason, too. I personally don’t think they need one until they start to have a little autonomy in regards to going places on their own. But to each his own – every kid/family is different.

  4. @Kelly_o_ says:

    I’m a single parent of a 10 year old girl. Most of her friends who have married parents, have cell phones. I have often thought it would make MY life easier if her father could call or text HER instead of me. But for now, I’m holding out until she is 13. No Facebook or MSN either!! Lol

  5. Mandy says:

    Twitter @
    My kids now 18 and 16 had cell phones even before our divorce four years ago. At first the phones were just for calling, no text but once they started to communicate with friends we added unlimited texting. These days, they’re as likely to text me as to call me.

    Both kids have attended schools where they had no transportation so I’ve used the phones to let the kids know if I’m running late for pick up and they let me know if their after school plans have changed.

    The phones have also helped on occasion when we’ve had mix-ups over pick ups.

    I’ve loved the frequency and ease of communicating that having cell phones brings.
    Mandy´s last blog ..Seeing your ex as a good guyMy ComLuv Profile

  6. mightbeatranny says:

    Twitter @
    mine get them in middle school (from me). ex got each of them a phone (to be the groovy dad) when they came back to live with me. then he put tracking devices in their phones. court ordered to stop. stopped, did it again. at that point the phones went in a drawer at my house and they were told they could check them or use them whenever they wanted, but i wasn’t having my movements tracked. ex objected. took it to court, saying i was denying him access. when my attorney told the judge about the tracking device she told him to take the tracking devices off and to NEVER do that again. he started to agrue with her, saying it was for their safety. he got schooled.

    apparently its not nearly as groovy to provide phones when you can’t stalk someone because my ex took the phones back after that. now he tells them they will get them back “next time”. but next time never works out….. go figure.

  7. Holly says:

    My kids, 14 and 11, have a phone that they have to share. (not working out real well) I got it so their father could contact them without calling my phone and we do alot of keeping in touch while I’m at work. It helps me know where they are and if they need anything when we aren’t together. Just today I was helping my daughter with her homework through text while I was at work.

  8. Soccer Mom says:

    Twitter @
    I pay for my daughter’s cell phone. She got it for Christmas at 11. The Ex really, really didn’t want her to have it but certainly enjoys texting and calling her on it whenever she’s somewhere else. But I wanted her to have it and I pay for it. The Boy wants one at the same age (this Christmas)…with the way he’s going right now I’m not sure I’ll let him. I need him to get a bit more maturity. We’ll see. The Girl is 13 now, and has unlimited texting. But I better NOT catch her using it during school hours or after I’ve put her to bed. And I used to check that all the time, but haven’t lately. Let me go do that now :)
    Soccer Mom´s last blog ..Should She Stay or Should She Go?My ComLuv Profile

  9. eryn says:

    I bought my oldest a phone within 24 hours of becoming a single mom. It didn’t hurt that I needed to switch carriers so he wouldn’t be able to turn mine off. My husband had refused to allow the kids a phone, even though my oldest was 15. We reasoned, as homeschoolers, there wasn’t too many times she was with someone that we couldn’t reach her. Although, it was starting to aggravate ME that she didn’t have one. I soon found out his primary reason was that he couldn’t monitor her calls and texts so he didn’t want her to have one as a control measure while abusing her. I’m so glad I purchased hers when I did , it has certainly given me a peace of mind have that constant contact. The younger kids will have to wait.

  10. Sarah says:

    I got my kids cell phones do I didn’t have to go throughy ex. He refuses to pay for them and calls/texts all the time. I wonder if any other parents are having this problem? And what can be done?

  11. Twitter @
    My girls are only 6 and 8….no cell phones. I’m thinking that when they’re around 12 or so is the age that they’ll be getting one…before that, I just don’t think it’s necessary….not until they’re leading more independent lives.
    Momma Sunshine´s last blog ..New BeginningsMy ComLuv Profile

  12. Dr. Leah says:

    Sarah: Good question! We hope our readers chime in — does your ex refuse to pay for the kids’ cell phone?

  13. Dawn says:

    Twitter @
    My three kids were 5, 8, and 11 when I split with their dad and each has had several phones since that time (all cheap pre-paid phones provided by me for MY convenience.) One reason was we don’t have a landline and they are home alone after school daily; another was that my Mom spends a lot of time with the kids but doesn’t keep her cell turned on for some reason- only when she wants to make a call!! The older two have phones now at ages 15 and 12, the youngest never took care of hers and is rarely if ever apart from one of her older siblings who carry theirs everywhere, so it was a waste of money. I would say that here where we live most kids get phones in middle school…most of my older kids friends’ have phones but the youngest has no friends with a phone that I am aware of. At the point that she is left alone or has a reason to need a phone I will buy her one also. Virgin Mobile has a $25/ month unlimited texting plan with 300 minutes; that works really well for us. The ex calls and texts the kids frequently and doesn’t pay a dime towards the phones; but at least he isn’t bugging ME to have contact with them, and I feel better knowing the kids are safe.

  14. Twitter @
    I am well aware that the world is a scary place, and as a single / solo parent without much (any?) backup, a cell phone is a means to facilitate peace of mind.

    But – for decades, single parents were doing fine without putting cell phones in the hands of 8 and 9 and 10-year olds (not to mention younger kids). Rather, kids were given a set of life skills as early as possible to do with communicating key information about themselves (including what NOT to say), following directions, safety rules, and so on.

    I realize we’re juggling more and more, but is this really about “peace of mind” or the path of least resistance?

    I’m all for cell phones to ease logistics – but at a rational age that doesn’t foster the growing sense of entitlement (to “stuff” and more). I’m not in a position to judge what that “rational age” is for someone else, but for my kids, cell phones came at the latest possible moment – when they were in their teens.
    BigLittleWolf´s last blog ..Comment on Piano Bar by BigLittleWolfMy ComLuv Profile

  15. LJ says:

    Twitter @
    I did it for both reasons…It’s a 2-edged sword… A Single Mom w/ 2 jobs, the kids in school, and having to go with others…You have to have a way to stay in contact with them… Then you have to find creative ways to make them responsible for the use of it… It is one of my most effective “restiction” tactics… “I have it at home & you get to use/carry it when we are apart & I need to contact you…”

  16. Roxanne says:

    Twitter @
    My kids (except one) have them now. Gives me peace of mind and I like it when they choose to text me when with their Dad, and they also text me to let me know when they are on their way home from visitations, etc. Ex is not always consistent with the drop off times. As kids got older, was helpful when they arrived from school or sports activities and I have to pick them up. My kids did get them later than other families, because of cost and my assessment of kids’ maturity. I pay for them. Can’t really afford them. These days, there are often no other phones to use. Teachers and coaches assume kids have cell phones. Kids with phones need to be taught to offer kids without phones a chance to use their phone to call home. Kids completely forget this. Everything is so individualized now. Most of the time kids use the phones for the stupidest things, that have nothing to do with communication. I’m paying for unlimited messages of “hahahahahahah” and chain letters. ugh! I monitor it, but how much crap am I gonna have to monitor?

  17. Dr. Leah says:

    LJ: Thanks so much for chiming in. Please visit us again soon.

  18. Twitter @
    My son is 11 and just started middle school and 6th grade. This is the perfect age for us since his elementary school has been so close to home and he hasn’t really been too far out of reach or another parent. Middle school is now 6-8 miles away and there are new teen dynamics, and it’s good for us and him to have a “life line”. So this is the perfect age for us, but respect those single parents who get them early – so much time can be saved. When I was a kid I was taught to “touch base” with my parents, and I think text allows kids a great way to do that – can’t start that too early!!

    Also, my job is related to this topic which has allow me to get my son a more advanced Motorola Atrix Android phone. We’ve launched AmberWatch SafeText which allows parents to keep their kids safe on smartphones. AmberWatch SafeText allows parents to monitor their children’s text messages, web browsing, app downloads, gps/location. We also have a knowledge base which provides alerts of dangerous text messages in the categories of: bullying, sexual, drugs, suicide, alcohol & etc. Right now we’re on Android and Blackberry devices with others coming soon. We respect the child’s privacy and they are fully aware this is on the phone. We’ve recently been approved by AT&T and are now on their AppCenter and SmartControls websites.

    I do respect what the divorced parents have said about “GPS tracking” and that is why this feature is Optional in our service. And as I mentioned above, the child receives text notifications (at random times) to inform them their usage is being monitored by the service – no different than Parental Controls on the PC. The phones are like mini computers, and anyone can get their phone number, so we have to keep our kids safe prior to them becoming adults.

  19. anonaone says:

    My ex gave my daughter (5th grade) one this year, but there’s no data plan on it, and only emergency numbers are in it. She knows that’s all it is to be used for at this point. My son (3rd grade) does not have one. The only reason my ex really did this is because he wanted to drop his personal plan because his job was giving them phones and paying for them, and it would have been so expensive to end his contract. He’s paying for it.

  20. Dr. Leah says:

    Kyle: Thanks for chiming in with so much added information.

  21. Tammy says:

    Twitter @
    I finally gave in to my daughter and tried a few carriers. I ended up choosing Kajeet (Sprint network) even though I use AT&T and it may have been more economical. Most cell phone carriers do not have ALL the parental controls that you truly need to do it right. I learned the hard way!! My daughter used too many minutes, gave everyone her # and shared her # on the internet (she’s a teenager). It was too dangerous in this horrible day and time.

    Kajeet has excellent on-line parental controls. You can set your controls for your own situation and allow only certain numbers the phone can send/receive calls and texts, set time of day limits and minutes per day used. There is also GPS with email updates so you know your child is where they were going. Kajeet does not require a contract and they have low monthly plans from $4.99 mo for basic up to $50 mo. for unlimited use. This provider is a great option for the peace of mind you need with your child carrier a phone for safety.

  22. Dr. Leah says:

    Tammy: Thanks for offering such specific recommendations. Sounds like you did a lot of “homework” before selecting this cell phone.

  23. kims says:

    my daughter is only 5 yrs old, & she just started kindergarten. i respect those parents who choose to give cell phones to their kids at an early age, but as of right now, i don’t think my daughter will get one before she starts driving. there are too many dangers associated with cell phones. i know several kids under age 13 who have them, & they’ve had issues with sexting, inappropriate pictures, crazy phone bills from going over minutes, middle of the night phone calls/ text messages, & one boy was actually planning on running away with a girl a few years older that he had met accidentally & communicated with via cell phone. not to mention loss or theft of the phone itself. i agree with littlebigwolf – parents & kids survived without cell phones for a long time.

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled