When your boyfriend doesn’t want a life with kids

Single parenthood changes everything about dating. Balancing responsible parenting with finding love is never easy. Sometimes our romantic partners just don’t get along with our kids — we get it. Here’s what recently surprised us: a single mom contacted us with a relationship crisis. Yet, when we asked what it’s like when her boyfriend does spend time with her kids, she said that everyone gets along famously.

We’re looking forward to hearing your advice. Thanks! Here’s what’s happening:

“I’ve been dating a wonderful guy exclusively ever since my husband left me,” she began. (Her ex re-connected with his high school girlfriend via Facebook).

“My boyfriend and I were very communicative at the beginning. He knew that my kids — who are four and six — came first. And I knew that he wasn’t interested in marriage. He told me that he had no desire to have kids.”

Obviously, this relationship started out strictly for fun — without expectations. But, nine months have gone by. And they care deeply for one another.  Her boyfriend is kind and patient with her kids. And they adore him. Of course, they do spend most of their time together without the kids, which they both prefer.

Recently, her boyfriend opened up to her and started the “where is this relationship going?” conversation.
He told her that he’s frustrated with their part-time relationship — and he wants more.  In the same breath, however, he insisted that he doesn’t want a life with kids — in fact, he wants nothing to do with fatherhood. This mama understands that, unless her boyfriend has a change of heart about her kids, there’s really no future.
Still, she’s loving this relationship right now — and he agrees they’re great together. So, this conflicted mama wonders:

Should she continue in this relationship — for right now?

Or, should she break off the relationship — immediately — before everyone gets really hurt?
~~~
Photo via Flickr: Vasa

Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

No related posts.

Comments

35 Responses to “When your boyfriend doesn’t want a life with kids”
  1. Jenni says:

    Twitter @
    What, exactly, does he expect her to do with her children? What a disappointment he turned out to be. Fine, he was honest at the beginning saying he didn’t want a life with children. And fine that they both liked each other probably more than they thought they would. But his ultimatum is what leads other women with children (whose well-known name and legal case will go unmentioned here) to do things that are unforgivable.

    Advice for him. Don’t date women with children.

    Advice for her. There is a man out there who will love her AND her children. Wait for him, and tell this guy to get a life; a new one that doesn’t include her or her lovely family.

    Jerk.
    Jenni´s last blog ..Mommy GuiltMy ComLuv Profile

  2. Coleen says:

    Twitter @
    Oh gosh, another one of those kind of men. I say break up right now. Since, she introduced him to the kids already, continuing to see him when she knows there is no future with him will only hurt the kids down the road.

  3. Dr. Leah says:

    Jenni: Likely, that sums it up: this mama is disappointed and sad. Your advice is well stated. Thanks for adding so much to this conversation. We hope you visit again soon.

  4. Bluegal says:

    I agree with Jenni. He wants more, but what exactly does he expect to do with her kids? She was clear with him that they came first. Now he says he wants more but no go on the kids. I don’t understand that. He needs to either adjust his thinking to include kids in the relationship or let the relationship go.

    If I were her, I’d tell him either things can continue as they are (until she gets tired of it) or, if he wants more from her, then it will include her kids.

  5. VA Mom says:

    OK so here’s the unpopular opinion. Both people were honest when this started. She said her kids were her priority and he said he didn’t want a family – YET they chose to engage in the relationship anyway – fully knowing that there were fundamental flaws in going forward because of where their priorities around family were.

    The fact is the woman in this relationship had something beyond herself to consider. And I understand that hindsight is 20/20 but I don’t understand introducing your children to someone who has told you they don’t want to be a parent. As a single parent, I believe we absolutely should and can have adult relationships and that not all relationships need to lead to marriage and commitment to my child. That said, as the parent you have to draw the line in the sand – a separation of church and state if you will. She did not do that and now is in a crossroads that has real emotional consequences.

    I think as adults they are both responsible for where they have landed. He’s a bonehead for thinking getting involved with a woman with children was a good plan and she is equally responsible for putting herself into a dead end position.

    If she was simply fine with the relationship being strictly ‘for fun’ she probably would not have involved her kids by introducing them to this man. Again, I realize we are “Monday quarterbacking” this situation, however, I don’t believe this is exclusively the boyfriends fault. Both adults are responsible for the situation they have found them in.

    But I believe in the truism – when someone tells you who they are – BELIEVE THEM. This man will not change and since she has already involved her children, she should cut her losses sooner rather than later and learn from this as she dates moving forward.

  6. WhitewaterAtty says:

    Twitter @
    You have a life with your children — who you love more than anything. And you knew that he didn’t desire kids.

    He wants a life with you without your children — despite knowing how much you love them. In fact, he wants MORE, but MORE without your children.

    Sounds like this relationship is approaching a dead end: And further, it sounds like he didn’t even SUGGEST working to make things work with your children.

    But most important: WHAT DOES THIS SINGLE MOM WANT? If you’re happy with a flingy, no-future relationship, then you can keep things going KNOWING that there’s no future. But if you’re thinking of ANY future (and if he’s hinting a a future with you being around your kids less) then you need to think of letting this relationship go…

  7. Twitter @
    This makes me think back to when the Bio and I first split. I was too broken to date, but when I did I used every broken piece of me to pick men who had no business being involved with a single Mama. They either didn’t want kids, or were unsure they’d be a good father or had Daddy issues of their own. It prevented me from introducing me to the Monkey and kept me running away from my feelings. Aces all around!

    This Mama has pulled a classic single woman post-breakup move only she has kiddos. She has taken up with the first man who can’t give her what she wants and in her heart she knows it. We always know. It just takes pulling ourselves up by our bra straps and realizing we need time to make things right for us and our children. Whether she knows it or not yet, he is her rebound. He is great on paper maybe, or awesome to hang out with and do fun things but when push comes to shove he is not her future.

    I’ve got a rule, if you don’t like/want kids, let alone mine then you aren’t for us. This Mama needs time to iron our her priorities and figure out what she’s really looking to do in her life, let alone relationships.

  8. Karen says:

    Twitter @
    It sounds like the previous posts are pretty much in agreement. As hard as it is to end a relationship that feels good, comfortable and appears to be working the longer the relationship continues, the more pain that will incur.

    Pull the bandaid off quickly. If doors are left open, there will be more pain regarding this relationship in the future.

    This guy sounds great….and would be a super ‘favorite uncle’. But a marriage requires a different status. If the guy isn’t on board, the mom will be continually walking on eggshells splitting time and affection between her husband and children.

    I don’t think there are ever regrets when choosing the welfare of your children first.

  9. Dr. Leah says:

    Karen: “I don’t think there are ever regrets when choosing the welfare of your kids first” … resonated deeply with me. Thanks for joining this important conversation.

  10. mwc26 says:

    Twitter @
    I agree with VA mom on this one. First I don’t see the point in starting a relationship with a man who doesn’t want to have kids (or even stay in one after he says it) when your a single woman with kids. What does he expeect this woman to give her kids up for him so that they can be together? I don’t think so. And if the relationship is/was supposed to be for “fun” and a nonpermanent thing, since it can’t be because he doesn’t want kids, and dooesn’t want to step into a parenting role with her kids, why risk introducing this man to her kids? They shouldn’t be attached to someone who doesn’t plan/want to be a permanent ficture in thier lives. Sorry, but when you have kids, thier well being comes first.

  11. Robyn says:

    Twitter @
    I am in a similar situation to this mom — I’m a single mom of 2 young kids dating a man who doesn’t have or want kids. We also started out just “for fun”, but we have been together nearly two years now and it works very well for both of us. He’s great with the kids when we’re all together, but most of our time as a couple is spent when my kids are with their dad (2 evenings a week and one overnight on the weekends). That’s about all the time and energy I have for a relationship anyway, and neither of us are all that interested in getting married.

    What confuses me about this mom’s situation is that her boyfriend wants more. Why push things after less than a year? That is not enough time in my opinion for either of them to know what they want long-term, especially with the kids in the picture. I would tell him that he has a choice — keep things as they are for the forseeable future or leave. If he really loves her and wants to build a future with her, he’ll stay. If not, she’s better off moving on now.

  12. Tara says:

    End it. It’s ok if he doesn’t want kids but he will be in a role mOdel position and u don’t want your children to feel like they are unwanted around or it’s separate life. Been there. Left him

  13. Dr. Leah says:

    Tara: We never considered the possibility that this guy will make the kids feel unwanted. Thanks for sharing your thoughts with us.

  14. Lovebabz says:

    Twitter @
    “When People Tell You Who They Are…Believe Them!” This is the advice Dr. Maya Angelou gave to Oprah. Now This lovely and vibrant woman can go on and continue this, but he has already told her who he is. Now she can play the fool all she wants. But she has kids who are investing their hearts every minute he is spending time with them. And when he bounces….and he will under the cloak of “I told you” She will have to pick up the pieces for them again.

    We all deserve a love supreme and many of us will settle for amazing mindless no strings-attached sex for a while. But when that heat simmers down the reality of what is can’t be changed. He doesn’t want to be a DAD.
    Lovebabz´s last blog ..And Baby You Are Worth ItMy ComLuv Profile

  15. Avigail74 says:

    Twitter @
    Ultimately, it really doesn’t matter what you decide to do with this man~ but please, keep the children out of this. That’s all.
    Avigail74´s last blog ..The Four Day TripMy ComLuv Profile

  16. The relationship will go nowhere because a fundamental issue is not solved. Unless both are willing to settle for a non-committal relationship, it is useless wanting more from each other without sacrificing something in return, i.e. the man will need to stop his “I don’t want kids” nonsense or the woman will need to make alternative arrangement for her children.
    Unhappy Marriage´s last blog ..Can A Marriage Survive Infidelity?My ComLuv Profile

  17. Twitter @
    “He told her that he’s frustrated with their part-time relationship — and he wants more. In the same breath, however, he insisted that he doesn’t want a life with kids — in fact, he wants nothing to do with fatherhood”-

    How does he get away with saying this in the same breathe? He knows she’s a mom. What a terrible position to put her in. You don’t fall for a single parent then insist they keep their kids away from you. Yes, I read that when they’re together they get along famously. But he’s still insisting that his interaction with the kids not be full time, but their relationship should be!? It can’t be both. Is she supposed to have the children live with their father full time? I can’t imagine that being a fair request. In the end, if your children don’t come first you’ve failed them. You don’t have the choice to put this man before your kids. It will scar them irrevocably. My experience with my mother was wicked. To this day I have no respect for her. We get along, but I have no respect for her.
    I realize your ex must have traumatized you by leaving the way he did. That’s just wicked. But is he in the picture on a consistent enough basis for you to sit your boyfriend down and say:

    “Well, the kids won’t be with us on Wednesdays, or on the weekends- that’s when they’re with their father- aside from that I won’t make any changes. These are my children.”

    Seriously- it’s great that you’ve found someone you connect with, but don’t feel like that’s an isolated occurrence. There ARE other people out there. It’s only been 9 mths of your life, 9 mths where you probably needed the distraction he provided. But now it’s time to get real. No more love haze. You stand by your kids and that’s that.
    Michelle Santagate´s last blog ..Nokomis: IMPORTANT- Let’s start talking about thisMy ComLuv Profile

  18. Natasha says:

    Twitter @
    I have to agree with VA Mom.

    This is not the man for the poster. This relationship can never become anything – it’s not built on a solid foundation.
    Natasha´s last blog ..WW – Daredevil EditionMy ComLuv Profile

  19. Chevy_momma11 says:

    What the heck would he do if her situation was like mine and the father of the children had passed away? He sounds selfish and she sounds vulnerable. He needs to find a woman that doesnt want kids (they do exist) and she needs a MAN who will adore her kids as much as he care about her. Its like Bill, HERES YOUR SIGN!

  20. Dr. Leah says:

    Chevy_momma11: Well said. The “signs” do seem quite clear. Thanks for adding your perspective to this conversation.

  21. Lesleigh Nahay says:

    Twitter @
    What would the point of continuing such a disturbing relationship be? They can’t be great together if they are in such drastic variance on this extremely important aspect. My now ex told me a few months into our relationship that he’d changed his mind and did not want any more children, (he was a divorced father of two)while I did want kids. Still, I said that’s ok, but that our relationship is pointless, and we separated. A year later, we started talking, and he wanted to get back together again. I said ok, but I still want marriage, I want children, and he claimed to be in agreement. When our second was born, his animosity and resentment for me and our life went haywire. No, I never tricked him, never manipulated him. I assumed his change in future wants was sincere. But because it wasn’t, because it was born out of lonliness and fear of being alone, my life, our kids’ lives, his, are a little shambled. This guy is not going to change his mind, and she shouldn’t want him to. We are all super vulnerable after a divorce- men and women- and we may not make the most logical decisions when it comes to love, or fun, or dating. This became clear when I was in my ex’s shoes and began dating again. I got myself into a similar mess post-divorce. What was also meant to be brief and fun spiraled out of control. He was a divorced dad with sole custody of his son and so I wrongly allowed them to meet my kids. He quickly began to resent my kids’ presence in my life- I should be focused entirely on him and his son. Out he went. Quick as he came. She has to realize that it trully is ok to be single. If my ex had realized that, it wouldn’t have destroyed my life. If I had realized it, I wouldn’t have put myself through Mr. Resentment #2. Would she rather he berate and abuse her children? Is that what she’s waiting for? She can’t let his behavior with them confuse her. He’s obviously not a bad guy, however he’s face to face telling her: “I do not want YOUR kids, I do not want ANY kids’. Staying in this sort of arrangement is damaging to her, him, and the kids, even if they don’t actively feel it happening.

  22. Dr. Leah says:

    Lesleigh Nahay: Thank you for sharing such a deeply personal story with us. You’re right: we are so super vulnerable after a divorce.

  23. anonaone says:

    I can somewhat relate to this mama, although my experience is the guy that I’m on-and-off dating wants kids and I don’t want anymore for many reasons. It really causes such problems in a relationship (which is a major reason why we’re on and off) even when everything else is great. It’s hard on both sides to tear yourselves away :( . I think this man must care for her a lot if he hasn’t already fled, but I’m wondering what he proposes as a solution – does he want her to relinquish custody to her ex and only see her kids one weekend a month or some other such arrangement?? Maybe this mom just really believes he will change his mind, and it’s definitely possible since that does happen, but if he hasn’t said that’s a possibility, they need to end it :( . How old are these two? I’m just surprised he’d even date a woman with two children at all.

  24. Colleen says:

    Twitter @
    I’m a recently separated, divorce is definite, momma of three. I totally understand the desire to see what’s out there and to have some fun. The whole dating thing is a bit scary and so is the idea of balancing the responsibility of being a mom with being a fulfilled woman with a personal life. Everyone has posted really good thoughts and so the only thing I have to add is that the time she continues to devote to this seemingly dead end relationship is time she isn’t using to find someone more appropriate for her family.

    I think that the boyfriend in this situation is sending confusing, mixed, manipulative messages. And frankly he doesn’t sound very mature.

    I’m all for fun and flirty adult relationships as long as everyone involved is being honest and respectful of boundaries. It sounds like they both allowed boundaries to become fuzzy and to get crossed (easy to do – no judgment here).

    If what we’ve been provided is the whole story then I really see no other way to handle it but to move on and end the relationship. Hopefully next time the kids won’t become involved unless the boyfriend is interested in the whole package.
    Colleen´s last blog ..UpstreamMy ComLuv Profile

  25. Dr. Leah says:

    Colleen: Well said. By not involving the kids, lots of needless drama can be avoided. We hope you visit us again soon.

  26. Brandi says:

    Been there – while not every relationship is built for the purpose of marriage, if she eventually might want to pursue a marriage (with anyone!) It’s time to move on from this dead end disaster.
    Brandi´s last blog ..Emotion Glide KayakMy ComLuv Profile

  27. Tina F. says:

    Twitter @
    Back when I was a single mom, I did date someone who seemed to have little interest in my child. In fact, the better I got to know him, the more I saw that he had little interest in his own kid. It wasn’t he had no love for kids, but his priorities were for himself first. Luckily, I generally only dated when my child was away on visitation with her father, but when the time came to see how he would be with her, I saw the truth. Not at first because I liked him so much, but eventually I had to own up to it and I chose my child’s well-being over my own. I broke it off and am happier now for it. When I see how the man I later married dotes on my child, I cringe to think that I could have stayed with someone who would not be an involved father who puts children before himself. It would have been terrible for my children and for me, as well, because I could not have stayed in love with someone who didn’t love my child.
    Tina F.´s last blog ..About It Is What It IsMy ComLuv Profile

  28. Dr. Leah says:

    Tina F: How inspiring that you found love — after you made the choice to put your child’s needs first. Thanks for sharing your story with us.

    Brandi: Lots of other readers agreed with you: this guy does sound like a dead end disaster.

  29. Shannon says:

    Twitter @
    I was also in a similar situation as this except that my boyfriend never wanted kids and ended up having 2 with his x-wife. We dated for 8 months and it was great until things started getting more serious. Then our whole relationship became a circle of questions, where is this going? He didn’t think he ever wanted to get married again. Are the children going to be hurt even more if we as adults don’t make the really tough decision that is staring us in the face. So we ended our relationship about a month ago and I have missed him terribly. It has been very difficult but bottom line is my children come first and they have been through enough. There is someone out there that will love you and your children the way you deserve to be. Don’t rush it and love yourself being a single woman with her kids. Good luck to you!!

  30. Lala says:

    I understand the relationship is going good, but it cant be that great if he wants nothing to do with her kids. At this point there is no point in going forward with a man that doesn’t want to be a father to her kids. Leaving him will hurt, but its best to find a man who wants YOU and YOUR KIDS.

  31. beachmama says:

    Wow, I am riveted by all of these comments! I am the single mom and author of this issue who initially contacted Dr. Leah last month. To begin with, thank you all for such solid, from-the-heart advice.

    Well, it finally happened. This past weekend, my boyfriend ended it based on the fact that we had no future–he clearly does not want a future with kids and I have them.

    I have been sick all weekend, can’t eat or sleep and feel so, so sad. The hardest part for me is that we are so happy and in synch–with the exception of the kids issue, of course. I’ve never ended a relationship an an upnote, which is perhaps why I am struggling with this so much. He claims that it is best to end it now before resentment on both sides builds. I am sure he’s absolutley correct, it just hurts.

    My children are my life. Period. And while I know there is no future with this relationship, I was enjoying the day-to-day of it. He made me feel like a beautiful, sexy woman again, treated my very well, and we had such good times going on dinner dates, traveling and especially cooking together at home.

    I am just feeling empty and that such a huge part of this happiness that I finally seemed to get back is gone. Again, I know there was no future, now I just ask myself, how do I get through?

    My friends and family have been so supportive, even saying things like I’ll meet someone new, yet that’s the furthest thing from my mind right now.

    However, I do know in my heart I need a man who will love me and my two amazing children long-term. It’s going to be a bumpy road ahead.

    Again, my heartfelt thanks to all of your strong, incredible single moms who have provided me with such good advice. I am evergrateful.

  32. Dr. Leah says:

    beachmama: Your thoughts are with you. Please stay in touch.

  33. Christine Johnson says:

    Twitter: Bodhismommy

    I understand the pain of being alone again – however, by loving the ones who love you most, and by doing things that you love, you will attract a true love.
    Be happy with what you have.
    Someone mentioned he was your rebound. He was. He gave you the gift of knowing you are attractive, that you can have an adult life without children, but this needs to be shared with one that can accept your children when they come home.
    Lame is not being able to share the joys – the achievements and the heartache of parenthood – with your lover.

  34. missbiker2 says:

    Run!!! Run!!! I’ve been there and all it does is cause heartache for you and the kids! Run!

  35. Susan says:

    Twitter @
    Knowing -nothing- about this situation… I got the impression he was just saying, “Where is this going? (nowhere) Because I don’t want kids and you do.” I think he’s letting her down “easy” persay. It’s a break-up talk. That he would like more but there’s no future there.

    I also get the impression he was being passive aggressive so she would then have to be the one to actually pull the plug.

    No-win situation. Might as well break-up now unless one of them changes their minds. And if the Mom changes her mind and ships the kids off to Dad or whoever, well… that’s a whole other comment.
    Susan´s last blog ..Social Media for Stay-At-Home Parents (And How Creative Businesses Are Hatched)My ComLuv Profile

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled