Stumped for holiday gift ideas?

Thanksgiving is barely over. And we all know what that means: the holidays are upon us. Budgets are tight and we’re all seasoned pros at stretching a dollar. It’s the emotional challenge of gift giving that often stumps us. So, when this single mom shared her gift-buying dilemma with us, we felt certain you might also be facing this same holiday stress.

Here’s what this mom told us:

“I’m trying to be frugal for the holidays this year,” she says, explaining why her son won’t be buying gifts for his dad and family at the school’s Secret Santa Store. “It’s a nice idea, but the stuff they sell is hardly quality.”

She’s sure that her son’s dad and the grandparents would prefer homemade gifts. But, frankly, this mom is not interested in spending lots of time and money on this part of the family. After all, these people are practically absent in her son’s life.  Nonetheless, she did look online for craft ideas. Of course, she saw all kinds of instructions for coasters, coupon books. and paperweights. This mom is not thrilled with helping her son make something that will likely get tossed in the back of a closet – and promptly forgotten.

Here’s the other problem: many of the crafts say “World’s Greatest Dad”, which is nowhere near her son’s truth. And she feels even her son would balk at putting anything like that on something he made for his dad.  And there’s the ticklish issue of what to give – or not – Dad’s girlfriend.

So, this mom would love to hear your ideas:

How do you handle your kids’ gift giving during the holiday season?

What’s an appropriate gift to give an absent – or just occasional – dad?

Will your kids bring a gift to your ex’s girlfriend?

~~~

Photo via Flickr: redcleo

 

Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

No related posts.

Comments

17 Responses to “Stumped for holiday gift ideas?”
  1. MWC26 says:

    Twitter @
    Here is how I would handle it, and do handle it. Your ex’s family is just that- HIS family, and not really your responsibility to buy or make gifts for. Especially not for his girlfriend. He has the responsibility of buying gifts for his family, and if he visits with dad, then dad should take his son out to purchase those gifts. Just because your son lives with you doesn’t mean it automatically falls into your lap. My son also deals with an absent dad/dad’s family. And they live a few states away- and they always enjoy pictures since they don’t get to see my child. So I alwyas send a nice updated photo (a 5×7) in a christmas card. I’ve done ones with santa (for 25 dollars for the entire digital CD and copy rights for self printing), free ones from our church. Walmart and Target both offer really great priced packages for inexspensive picture taking. Or sit your son down in front of the christmas tree and snap some and personalize a gretting card with them, easy, inexspensive, adorable (since it’s of your child) and gets the job done!

  2. C Lo says:

    Twitter @
    Well, for what it’s worth………the coupon book my daughter made me for my birthday this year is one of my favorite gifts ever. Yes, it is stored so I can keep it forever and look at it. So……I would try not to really even think about what the recipient of the gift is going to do with the gift. That’s not really the point…………..

    I run a daycare and I often have the kids make a picture of themselves and their parent and direct them to do a specific type of picture (i.e. “draw a picture of you and your dad doing your favorite thing you like to do with him!”). Then I ask the kids to tell me in a sentence or two whats going on in the picture, then I write that as a caption on the bottom. Then frame it up really nicely. Adding the caption makes it a fun snapshot of a place in time and is always fun to look back on years later.

    If you are truly stumped about the girlfriend, maybe have your son give them a gift that can be a joint gift, like cookies he makes and decorates. That way you can include her on the tag but it’s not a big deal.

    I have never given a gift to my ex’s current fling, though…

  3. VA Mom says:

    The holidays are never easy especially in the gift department and I wholeheartedly agree that his family is not your responsibility, nor is his girlfriend for that matter. I don’t know how old the son is, but perhaps if he is old enough to express an opinion (as was implied by him likely balking on World’s Greatest Dad) I would talk to him about what he would like to do for his father.

    It seems like there is a lot of anxiety and resentment about this from the post (and I realize that can just be how it is captured here) but I think the holidays is about being thankful and celebrating the people we have in our lives. I can understand there is no love loss here on the part of the mother, but perhaps seeing the gift through her son’s eyes might help better guide what would work best financially in putting a gift together. Perhaps if you have access to a photo of the two of them he could create/decorate a frame for it and give that to him.

    I think to the extent possible – focus on the positives about his father and what you can draw out of that to make a thoughtful gift for your son to give to his dad. You can’t control how any gift is recieved, but you can control the sentiment it is given under.

  4. Anna says:

    These are great ideas!

    From my perspective, I understand that the gift giving is dad’s responsibility, but in some cases it just won’t happen, and I would not want my son to feel badly for not giving anyone presents.

  5. Kia says:

    Twitter @
    You really need to let some things go. There is some bitterness in the post but the responsibility of gifts for your ex’s family lies with your ex. end of story especially if you don’t have a good relationship with them. When my ex and i were together i purchased all the gifts for both sides, when we split i stopped and only sent a christmas card to his sisters and parents and i got a small gift from myself (not my daughter) for 2 of his nieces i’d grown very close to. When money got tight it was only cards. i saw my ex’s family more often them him because they were local for a few years and he moved out of state.

    The age of the son isn’t listed by why does he feel he needs to get these gifts for so many people? was that how it was back when you were together or some idea elsewhere. If he’s really young maybe you should redefine his ideas that christmas is about gifts for many people. In my family you never gifted upward except for your parents, anyone older than you gifted downward. My ex’s family was the same way but both me and him agreed (and its probably the only thing we agreed on) is that our daughter would never be expected to gift to us. She does occasionally but we never stress it. My ex is remarried for the 3rd time and its up to my daughter if she wants to her her new step-mother something but i won’t require anything more than her sending a card.

  6. Jessica Wall says:

    Twitter @
    Send a card, including the father and be done with it. I deal with an absent bio-dad and family, and I do not believe that the holidays are an excuse to act like a family toward my child, it should be that way 365 days a year. If your son is adamant about getting his father a gift, give him the money and let him pick it out, so it’s from him and not you. Keep it simple

  7. natasha says:

    Twitter @
    Kia, I don’t think its appropriate for you to tell other posters “let things go” You don’t know how or when the relationship ended. “Letting go” is a personal journey that takes time. Being told to do so on a forum diminishes that persons’ experience. My two cents…I will echo other peoples’ sentiment. A card or photos is all that should be expected.

  8. Twitter @
    I feel like one of my jobs as a parent is to teach my daughters the true meaning of the holidays, which is about giving to others. Whatever personal feelings I may have about their dad will be put aside as I recognize the fact that he’s their dad and I need to do my best to help them have a good relationship with him (lucky for me, he’s a terrific father). He doesn’t have a girlfriend, but if he did, I would expect that any gifts made or given to her by my girls would be initiated by their dad…same with gifts for his relatives.

  9. Twitter @
    Make a tray of cookies and stop by with it. Other then that please stop beating yourself up over this. This is not a dilemma; it’s not in your heart or your budget to do anything out of the ordinary for these people, so don’t. This isn’t you being selfish or bitter, they simply aren’t really a part of your lives, except for the fact that they have to be. But really, are you worried about that third cousin you never see? Just because it’s your son’s father and he SHOULD be a significant part of your son’s life does NOT mean he IS. Is your son even thinking about him? I kept making a big issue over my son’s father too; spent hundreds of dollars on him. He’s never gotten me a single present and now that I’m the one who is broke, I have to force him to take care of our son’s needs at Christmas. If you are not significant to someone and more importantly if he’s not even a good father to your son, why OH WHY are you even wasting your brain power on this? Let him go. Forget about him other then the child support check. It is not your job to make this man a significant part of your child’s life. It’s not your job to legitimize the situation. He’s a tool, so forget him. Especially around the holidays. As for his girlfriend, same thing. Smile, be polite, give cookies. Nothing more. My son’s father’s girlfriend (or ex-girlfriend at this point) surprised the crap out of me last year when she gave me a pair of earrings. It was heart warming and sweet. She’s a nice person. But when I couldn’t even afford presents for my son I was not about to feel embarrassed that I had not thought about her. Please stop beating yourself up about this. If you want to do something, do the homemade thing. Focus on your son and doing what is best to make his holiday great. If his dad isn’t a part of that, then let it be.

  10. Katie says:

    The child is school age, then dad can take him shopping to get gifts for his gf and his family. The only thing I do these days is send a holiday card with the current school photos of my kids. It’s well received by my in laws and I’m not obligated to do more than that.

  11. WhitewaterAtty says:

    Twitter @
    As stated by C Lo, hand drawn pictures/cards are very appropriate for parents and other family members (whether in your life or not). [Love the idea about something that the child's done with the parent and including a caption] I wouldn’t recommend spending money on a gift for an Ex/Co-parent — but a hand-drawn card/picture is appropriate.

    Nonetheless, I cannot imagine a better give that *I* could receive from my son than a hand-drawn picture including something that we’ve done together that he enjoys.

    In no way can I see it appropriate for a co-parent to have a child purchase a gift for their ex’s girlfriend/boyfriend/love/datee. While grandparents and ex’s wife/husband MAY be OK, I still think that is an area for one’s ex. However, if my son asked for my help in doing so, I would not decline.

  12. Steve says:

    Twitter @
    As a single dad, I swallowed my pride pill and helped my two youngest make gifts for their mother. My three year old gave his mom a picture of himself in a crafty little frame made of ice pop sticks and tooth picks. My daughter made her a batch of cookies. They weren’t the best cookies, but so what. I had all three buy or make a card for her. My oldest was the one who bought a card.

    My point is, and there is a point, that children should learn to respect their parents. It’s not their fight, their divorce or their battle. As my kids’s dad, I feel it’s my responsibility to show them the proper way of doing things, even if it’s not reciprocated.

    I do not worry about my ex’s side of the family though. That’s where I draw the line. It’s just way too expensive and time consuming. I will nudge them to make really nice cards, but do not spend the time with them that I would on their mother’s cards.

    As far as the “new guy”, who really was always the old guy, I leave it be. I don’t bring it up because THAT particular pride pill is way too large.

  13. Twitter @
    I plan on giving my ex something small from Peanut but thoughtful. The ex coaches the soccer team so I thought of doing a couple nice framed pics from games and practices. Peanut will probably draw him a picture also. Peanut’s dad is very involved – in my case, it has more to do with my financial situation.

    My ex is in charge of giving presents from Peanut to his side of the family and vice versa. To be honest…I have no idea if my ex gives those grandparents anything from Peanut but not my problem. I take care of my side and he should take care of his.

    I can say with 100% certainty that I will not be buying something for the girlfriend. Not my responsibility.

  14. Erika says:

    Twitter @
    I know for me, my ex and I always have given each other “presents” from our daughter for each other’s birthday and the holidays. It’s not about me or him, it’s about her, and teaching her how to be thoughtful and to give something to people that matter to her. I feel badly enough that she has to live in 2 households now, so I want her to feel that there is still caring and respect for her other parent. Now that both my ex and I are remarried, we still help our daughter remember the other parent on those specials days. It’s a small way to demonstrate respect for the other, even though we aren’t married yet. I have gotten some of the sweetest little handmade gifts from her that her dad (my ex) helped her to make.

  15. Charismaga says:

    I don’t have a good relationship with my ex, and to be honest I think he’s a terrible person. But my 3 year old daughter has a relationship with him. So I help her make a gift for him for his birthday, father’s day and Christmas. She is always very proud of crafts she makes in general, and loves doing it for him as a gift. I do think it’s important to support your child’s relationship with their father, even if the father is less than ideal. The first time I did this, it was difficult. It was hard to give a gift to someone who I feel destroyed our lives in many ways. But it was the right thing to do.

    My ex is now living with his ex-mistress. I can’t handle doing a gift for her and I really think that it’s his responsibility to do that with my daughter. I also don’t have much of a relationship with my ex’s family. My daughter sees them maybe quarterly and isn’t exceptionally close with them. So I feel that it is also my ex’s responsibility for gift giving from my child to them. If she were old enough to express an opinion about giving gifts to them, I would direct her to discuss it with her father and would hope he would do the right thing.

  16. Kia says:

    Twitter @
    Natasha you completely missed my point. I said let some things go and in this case stressing herself out over holiday gifts she needs to let go. No where did i tell her to get over it.

  17. mightbeatranny says:

    Twitter @
    omg. this is my 3rd christmas away from my ex. the first year i bought gifts for the girls to give him. i remember they wanted to get him a baseball cap (he weara them all the time) so we went into a store that sold only baseball caps. the girls couldn’t decide so i asked the clerk for some suggestions. “what kind of hat do you think of when you think of him”, she asked. i immediately thought of “ass-hat”, still makes me laugh.

    anyhoo…the gifts i purchased were not appreciated, and that was in the middle of a 5 MONTH period where my ex paid ZERO support (he didn’t feel like it). so i was using my family’s money to buy gifts for him. during this time he was also bad mouthing me all over town. he purchased ZERO gifts for me, or any of our children that chriatmas!

    the second year my kids wanted to give him gifts. i told them they could spend whatevr money they had on him, i would take them to the mall. they each purchased something for him and made him a card. he was not appreciative and made ugly comments about the spelling on one of the cards, and asked for the receipt for another “to get something i’d actually use”. he gave each child 1 small gift. i.e., the 9 year old got a poker set. (wtf?)

    this is the third year. they have already stated that they will not be purchasing or making anything for their father.

    so, my point is that you can try to “do the right thing”, whatevr that is. you can try to teach the lesson that special people deserve to be remembered. but in the end you child will know who values him and who deserves to be remembered and valued by him.

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled