When co-parents disagree about homework
by Dr. Leah
Filed under All, Featured, Kids, Single Dads
We all know that kids thrive on routine and structure. We also know that as single parents, you have A LOT on your plates! Whether you’re juggling everything solo — or coordinating with your ex — many of you tell us that homework is a BIG parenting issue.
We get it: the homework load increases every year. And your work schedules are more hectic than ever. So, when this single mom contacted us to ask for specific advice on homework, we knew it was time to open up this conversation.
“I read so much conflicting advice about homework. And, honestly, these ‘experts’ really have no clue about the ‘doing it all’ challenge that’s part of every single parent’s life,” she says.“And, in my situation, there’s also a co-parenting conflict.”
This mom’s school-aged kids do homework alone in a quiet place – usually at their desks in their rooms. She feels this cuts down on the distractions, especially since she’s got a noisy toddler, too. She meticulously checks every assignment. And she insists that every assignment the kids turn in is perfect. Backpacks are also checked before the kids leave for school.
Her ex – they have shared custody – lets the kids do homework at his kitchen table. Music plays in the background. He feels this homework set-up lets the kids ask him questions immediately, if they get stuck. And he does not check the homework. The kids also load up their own backpacks.
Right now, the kids seem to handle these different homework approaches without huge difficulty. Still, this mom wonders if there’s a *best way* to tackle her kids’ homework. Or, if her kids would find things easier if she and Dad got on the same page with handling homework?
So, this mom would LOVE to hear from other single parents …
What’s your approach to homework?
Do you closely monitor your kids’ homework?
Or do you take a more casual approach?
Are these co-parents doing their kids a disservice by not handling homework in the same way?
We’d love to hear from dads on this important kid issue. Please chime in.
~~~
Photo via Flickr: Christel Hendrix
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
No related posts.






Twitter @ muminawe
I think the kids benefit from both experiences. They learn to work in noise and quiet, and the dad makes them accept responsibility for what they don’t pack or badly done homework. The Mum has set a good standard by checking, so they know what’s expected. I recon the Mum should let it be. Kids are able to adapt quite well, and it’s a great skill to learn!
Twitter @ http://hereivelanded.blogspot.com
The mom sounds a bit high strung. I’m the “strict” parent in my home, but my 7 year old does homework like the second scenario here….at the kitchen table, generally where I can supervise and help with issues that come up. My daughter who is 12 does her homework in her room at her desk because she’s more capable and responsible and she should be able to do MOST of it alone.
The fact that this is a “conflict” when the mom admits that the situation is actually working fine for the kids tells me that this mom is more interested in controlling her ex than what is best for the kids. Kids are adaptable. She says they are doing fine. What’s the “conflict”?
I would advise this mom that one of the first things we can do as single parents to be happier is to let go of the idea that we can control anything in the other home. And, especially if the kids are doing ok and are loved and cared for….the other parent doing things DIFFERENT does not equal that they are doing them WRONG.
I would agree with the other posters — don’t create more work for yourself — this is not a co-parenting conflict. The fact that he makes them do their homework, and is actually there while they do it is a big plus in my book.
On a side note, (coming from a teacher), homework is (should be) a type of formative assessment that lets the teacher see where her instructional focus should be. For instance, if most of the class turns in homework that shows that they don’t understand fractions, she knows that she needs to re-teach fractions. If you insist on homework being perfect before it is turned in, the teacher is getting a skewed view of your child’s strengths and weaknesses. Kids need to be allowed to make mistakes — it’s how they learn.
Twitter @ http://365daysofhearingwordpress.com
I think that it’s terrific that both parents care a lot about homework~ both parents have provided a time and space for the children to complete the assignments~ and what’s even more terrific is that no matter which home the children are coming from, the homework is complete. As a teacher, I have seen so often where one parent is responsible and the other is not~ so half the time the child would come with homework, and the other half, none. I don’t see any harm in the way the parents are handling the homework differently~ because they both seem to have the same underlying message which is: School is important.
I do not closely monitor my child’s homework~ I do, however, closely monitor her planning book, to make sure all homework is complete~ and I also review her “Monday Folder” where all completed assignments are returned~ I think it’s more important that she learn from her mistakes and notice where she did well by going over returned assignments/homework that the teacher has marked.
Twitter @ singleguywkids
I agree with all the other posters as well. The fact that both parents are DOING the homework is a huge victory for the kids. I can’t tell you how many times homework is neglected on the other end and I spent countless late nights trying to get it done.
As an educator I think the different parenting styles will benefit the children in the long run. Parents can have different approaches just as teachers have different methods of educating.
As they get older and approach those college years, they may have a busy dorm room or many distractions they can not get away from. The kids have two different experiences and will know which environment works best for them.
I also like and encourage the idea of learning to be responsible for your own work and on those days where the children are with their dad, they know they will be held accountable for completing their assignments. The idea of mom holding high expectations is also a fantastic way to teach her children to have pride in the things they hand in to their teachers.
Sounds like things are going in the right direction if you ask me. Kudos to mom and dad on this one. Things that may not seem perfect to us may be just the right fit for our kids.
Twitter @ mightbeatranny
bottom line; you can’t change what your ex does. save yourself the worry and accept things as they are.
since the kids aren’t bothered and things are getting done; its not really as issue for anyone but you.
Steve: Welcome! We always appreciated hearing from our dad readers.
Twitter @ http://deleted
I don’t see this as a conflict- at least dad has set aside a space and time for the kids to do their homework, and is willing to engage with them if they need help. It would be a conflict if he didn’t care whether or not the kids did their work, or didn’t make them do it. He might be doing things differently than you are as far as homework is considered, but that doesn’t make it a bad thing. If your children are old enough to finish thier homework without being micromanaged and pack thier own bookbags, then he’s teaching them about responsibility, and being accountable for thier things. Now if the kids forget something at his house that they absolutely need, have him run it to you if it can’t wait- he’ll see the importance of just checking to make sure they have everything.
Twitter @ WhitewaterAtty
I have to agree with just about everyone here (as usual C Lo is spot on)…
If it ‘aint broke don’t fix it. Sounds like both environments are productive and workout out well for the kids. No need to micromanage your ex-partner’s parental behavior so long as it isn’t creating a problem (perceived or otherwise) for the children. Be happy your kids are doing well, and worry about things that actually deserve worrying…
Children do well with routines and predictability. However, the idea of consistency is highly over rated. Children are incredibly adaptable — more so than adults. They have to be for their own survival! Children know what grandma will allow that is different from what Nana will allow which is different from Dad, which is different from Mom. They also know how different teachers are different! When parents approach parenting differently, this is the child’s first experience with diversity! Seems as though these kids have adapted successfully to their two different homework environments. Who has a problem here? Instead of focusing on the non-existing problem, seems like this Mom could take advantage of discussing the differences, advantages and disadvantages of these two different strategies with her children and help the children develop their own best homework environment.
Twitter @ http://gawlas.blogspot.com
They are both right but dad is righter. Immediate clarification and feedback is better for learning and no learning or work environment is free of distractions. She is setting up an unrealistic expectation of having all homework perfect before its turned in. She should check that the assignment is finished and spot check three or four items. More is overboard.
Oh I’m a high school teacher. I might know what I’m talking about.
Twitter @ mightbeatranny
^^ please tell me you do not teach english, lol.
Twitter @ notthecar
The mom is creating a conflict that doesn’t actually exist. In both situations the children are doing the work and getting whatever help they need. Not everyone learns the same way and not ever child needs to forced to study the same way, finding what works is more important. in this case everything works don’t stress it.
Twitter @ BigLittleWolf
In this case, my own style was a little bit of both – depending on the child, the circumstances, the age… I took my cues from the kids, and how well they managed and what sort of environment suited them.
Checking every homework assignment so it’s perfect? Um… I’m not sure their assignments need to be perfect; I do think it’s reasonable parental engagement to check that children feel they’re learning what they should be.
As they get older, as the load gets heavier, observation (and performance) may reveal if and when kids can take initiative to finish everything without so much checking. Eventually, they’ll need to. And at their dad’s house, it sounds like that’s required already. (Maybe not such a bad thing, unless there’s a recurring problem?)