Keep listening or take action? We disagree.

Dr. Leah was quoted in Newsday recently as a parenting expert — and her advice hit me hard. Yes, I understood her perspective, and I always value her opinion.

But I would’ve acted differently.

Here was the question: “What should a mom do if her tween son comes home and reports that he over heard two other boys bragging on the bus — about how they were going to bring marijuana to camp the next day?”

3062199961_f316b08a11_m

Dr. Leah advised not to inform the camp officials.

Citing how adolescent boys love to brag, Dr. Leah said the conversation was an idle boast. Assuming that the camp had been vetted for security and supervision, she thought it was fairly impossible that the two boys would have the opportunity to sneak away and smoke pot.

And, if they did, surely the camp staff would quickly take appropriate action. Dr. Leah stressed that telling camp officials about an overheard bus conversation might inadvertently lead to her son getting dubbed the “camp narc.” And that unintended consequence would definitely insure that her son would likely not confide in Mom again any time soon.

Her advice? Keep listening. And definitely ask your son the next day about what did (or not) happen with those boys at camp.

I, on the other hand, would inform camp officials ASAP.

Why? I would feel responsible for the welfare of those other boys. Are they bragging or are they really going to bring drugs to camp? Are the camp officials really going to detect this plot,  if they don’t get a heads up from a concerned parent? I’d take action and call the camp right away. Won’t my daughter “get it” that responsible people report potential wrong doing? Even if she gets labeled a tattle tale?

Dr. Leah and I strongly agree that this is a difficult and challenging parenting dilemma.

So, we’re wondering:

How would you react if your kid shared that overheard conversation with you?

Do you have any experience with getting help for young people at, say, teen drug rehabs?

Personal stories always welcome.

Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

No related posts.

Comments

16 Responses to “Keep listening or take action? We disagree.”
  1. Anna says:

    WOW!! Dr. Leah is naive if she thinks kids can’t sneak things anywhere they want to. I had to confiscate a knife from a 6th grader once, and prescription drugs from another girl — if they want to bring something, they will find a way, and probably not get caught UNLESS another student tells someone.

    These days, you cannot trust the innocence of children, anymore. “Idle boasts” are less and less common. Often, these kids want to be caught, and are very serious when they bring things like this up.

    If there is concern about your child “tattling”, in this situation, there was a bus full of kids who could have heard it, and probably did, so I doubt that the boy would have been singled out as a “narc”. And I agree with Rachel Sarah — don’t we want to teach our kids to stand up to people/actions/ideas that we don’t agree with??

  2. Kari says:

    This one is a tough one.

    This year was our first year in middle school… my kiddo came home with all sorts of terrible stories about friends of hers. One was cutting herself, another one was talking to an older man on the internet, and yet another one was living in a car with her mother because they lost their home among others.

    Some of them I called for the welfare of the child. Some of them I encouraged my daughter to find help at school where she could best help her friend because the school was likely to investigate and take action with the appropriate people.

    Overall, I listened and we decided together what should be done. She learned how to find help she was comfortable with and that she could talk to me about anything. She could trust me.

    It was a fine balance, my daughter seems to want to ‘save’ everybody person, animal, creature… she can’t do that and it isn’t healthy to think she can. Sometimes it is better to let something go and sometimes it is better to speak up. Most of all she is too young to ‘save’ everyone.

  3. judy says:

    My DD was always in the principal/counselor’s office reporting some playground criminal action by someone (bullying, discrimination, racism) until 5th grade when I spoke with the school to discourage this as she is a total narc. out of love and compassion.

    I would thank her for talking to me about it and discuss where every it went including slipping in
    “the lecture” on not being able to change others, knowing where she is and who she is with, bragging, and keeping her mouth shut unless someone is being hurt.

    I would then call the camp and say hey, this was overheard on the bus today..I don’t know these kids or if there is reason for concern or not but as a mom I would want to know and as a teacher and mandated reporter I wanted to let you know. I am sure you will handle it appropriately as it was announced on the bus for all the kids to hear.

  4. CMC says:

    I totally agree with Anna’s comment above. I would definitely NOT leave it up to the camp counselors to detect, as kids are pros these days with sneaking stuff. I agree with Anna that there’s really no “idle boasts” anymore these days – kids mean what they say.

  5. Eathan says:

    Twitter @
    I was a teen boy and I have 2 boys. And I wouldn’t report it either. I have a great relationship with my boys. But there are 2 different issues here. One is being the one who ‘narcs’ or ‘snitches’ on other boys. That subject is a long one. But to sum it up, no snitching unless it’s going to call physical danger. I have a strict mind your own business rule and snitching on someone isn’t minding your own business.

    Now the main thing is it’s camp. Even though there are lots of kids there.. trained counselors can spot behavior that kids using drugs will have. I don’t have to see kids doing the drugs to know that they are high or using.

    As a parent I teach my kids about drugs. And since they drug test athletes in the Texas schools..that’s just one less thing I have to worry about. Sports are more important to my kids than the temptation of a good time with drugs.

  6. RJ says:

    LOL. What a nice sheltered life some people live to think that kids do not get away with things like smoking weed. lol I think this is a GREAT opportunity to do BOTH. YES, LISTEN, talk, explain, support, and INFORM authorities. TALK TO YOUR SON! What does your son think? Do they think this is for real? What would they do? What do they want to do? Is it right? Is it wrong? Why? Talk to the camp/school? What are their procedures? Can they take care of this without your son being singled out? COMMUNICATE.

  7. Barry says:

    Twitter @
    If I ran to the authorities every time one of my kids came home and told me something like this, I would would be exhausted!

    It is not my job to raise these other kids. Keep my kids at a distance, yes.

    Having said that, if it was a discussion about bringing in a fire arm, I would call the camp and let them know what I heard. If the kids are high, they are effecting their own brain cells. If they’re bringing something that could harm my child, I am on the phone pronto!

    Rachel, you better get ready as your daughter gets older. She will hear this all the time. Just be happy she is telling you and therefore, probably not involved.

  8. gregpeckfan says:

    I think camp is a special circumstance. It is close quarters, little parental supervision, and unknown or ‘new’ children together for an extended period of time. It’s different if it is a normal school day or sporting event where you know the children, you know the parents.

    This is the type of thing that has to be reported. Children discussing bringing illegal and mood altering substances into that type of environment could be potentially dangerous (even life threatening, if there are sporting events involved, swimming, climbing, etc).

    I hear the point about overreacting to “every time a child says something” but this is not overly fussy parenting. This is common sense.

  9. I’m humbled by what I’m hearing.

    RJ: Of course, communicate. That’s how to alert camp officials and minimize the social fall-out for your child.

    My own experiences as a mom are similar to Eathan’s – both my kids were athletes and closely supervised even on college lacrosse road trips. Likely, those parenting experiences influenced my advice. I had no idea drug testing was now mandatory in Texas.

    Kari and Judy: Our daughters are so much alike. My little girl used to tell me all kinds of things (sadly, all true). Almost nightly we sorted out the appropriate options. These efforts really took a toll.

    Anna: The things you describe used to happen “once in a career”. Obviously, much has changed in schools and not for the better. I appreciate the wake-up call. I’m rethinking this whole situation.

  10. Anna says:

    I was thinking about this all day today, and it’s a sad day in our society when we aren’t concerned about the children of others. “It’s not my kid” is a very selfish attitude, and one which is uncommonly American, unfortunately. The kids who get into trouble often need more people looking out for them, not fewer.

  11. SDMktg says:

    I have a bit of a different perspective on this having been on the flip side of a major miscommunication as an adult. Someone I thought was a friend of mine overheard part of a conversation and not only misinterpreted what he thought he heard but completely overreacted.

    I won’t go into details but the bottom line is what started out as an admittedly inappropriate joke turned into a nightmare for everyone involved. I was never given an opportunity to explain what happened and I won’t ever work with or talk to the guy again.

    Every situation is different so if the kids were just talking (and I agree there’s a pretty good chance that it was more than that) they could find themselves in a lot more trouble than they deserve.

    I guess it depends on everyone’s relationships and how reliable the source is, how believable the claims are, etc. There are consequences either way.

  12. StudentMama says:

    Twitter @
    I’ve been reading for awhile but just decided to post. I think SDMktg has a point – do you have *all* information, or could it potentially be something different and misunderstood?

    It’s not an easy situation, and I would assume that we would all want to make sure children are safe. However, we also have to remember that all the facts simply aren’t there. To potentially get the boy in trouble may impact more than just his day at camp, but his relationship with his parents. We can’t assume that all children have understanding parents.

    I think if I were in the situation, I may not alert camp officials. Mostly due to the fact that I don’t forsee the benefits outweighing the potential costs – especially with a lack of information.

    I think my open relationship with my child is important. If that stays open, I think there is a much greater chance for preventing them for joining in, which is my primary concern.

    Of course, once there is more information in and actual proof the claim is more serious – there may be cause for action. My original approach would be to keep the channels open and act only if there is something more than an “idle boast” to go on.

  13. Rachel Sarah says:

    @StudentMama: We love it when lurkers come out and comment!

    So true: we all want to make sure that our kids are safe, and as you add, “I think my open relationship with my child is important. If that stays open, I think there is a much greater chance for preventing them for joining in, which is my primary concern.”

    Thanks!

  14. April says:

    Twitter @
    This reminds me of a situation I recently encountered with my own daughters. The kids at their summer camp had all gotten into this website (which shall remain nameless), and the staff decided to disallow the site once they understood that it allowed you to “friend” people. (No, it’s not MySpace or FB.) My girls and their friends had all added friends, some of whom they knew, and some they didn’t.
    My first reaction was going to be to call one of the Staff members and let them know who all had be-friended. As a parent, I would want to know what sites my kids were visiting if there was potential danger involved. But my kids freaked out. They did NOT want me to get involved, they totally feared that their friends would be mad at them, and in the end, I respected their wishes, so long as they de-friended everyone from the site that they personally did not know.
    I felt it was the best way to ensure that communication between my girls and I would continue to be open. And I also appeased myself that the Staff at the Club already knew since they were the ones who stopped letting the kids go on it. Now, no Staff member told me about the incident, but the girls did. And that’s what I chose to make the priority.
    I think my first instinct is always to tell someone because of Columbine. That hit me quite hard. And it is heartbreaking to know the loss that was suffered because some did not speak up. So it’s not an issue where I would say there is always a “right” answer. The risks need to be carefully weighed.
    In the above situation, I would probably let it go.
    (BTW, Rachel, great post topic :)

  15. John F says:

    Twitter @
    I am with Dr. Leah on this one!

    Freshman year of high school my son told me some kid offered to sell him pot. I asked what he did and he said he told him “no”. Whew, I done good.

    He still looked a bit off and I asked what else was bothering him. He asked if he should have told an administrator.

    I told him two “right” answers. The legal right one was to tell. The street right was to do just what he did. Had he told and was found out, he just sentenced himself to getting his ass kicked for the next three years. By saying nothing, the kid knows he is not interested and will hopefully not approach him any longer.

    I told him that if the kid kept approaching him that we would cross the bridge when we got to it!

  16. Lovebabz says:

    Twitter @
    If my kid told me this, then I would handle it…not my kid. I would be the heavy, not my kid. I would approach the camp from a place of concern rather than just running and telling. I would encourage the camp to have a group talk and reitterate the NO DRUGS policy and if there isn’t one then one has to be created.

    See you don’t want to create an atmosphere of fear and spying. And You don’t want your kid to be labeled as some rat for something that may be just boasting. But do take it serious and as the parent have the proper conversations with the camp leadership.

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled