My boyfriend just got a vasectomy. Now what?
by Dr. Leah
Filed under Relationships

A blogger whom we greatly admire has shared has shared a recent personal dilemma with us. For confidential reasons she isn’t comfortable posting on this topic.
Here’s what happened:
Our single mom blogger friend is seriously dating a divorced dad whom she describes as a “private person.”
She does her best to respect his private nature — so she writes about him infrequently on her blog. This isn’t easy, however, because she’s as open as anyone you’ll ever meet.
Anyway, this blogger just found out that the very “private” man she’s dating got a vasectomy last week – SURPRISE!
Fortunately, our blogger friend is not interested in having any more biological kids. And her “private” man obviously feels the same way. So, there’s no “family planning” conflict here.
Still, this blogger still feels off kilter and a bit upset.
Here’s what she’s wondering:
No mater how “private” he is, shouldn’t her boyfriend have talked with her about getting a vasectomy with her before the deed was done?
Or, is this strictly his personal choice?
~~~
In case you’re not following us on Twitter…
Heather @RookieMoms and Deesha @coparenting101 won copies of The Package Deal. Congrats!
(Photo courtesy of KristyKay 22 via Flickr)
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
No related posts.






Twitter @ http://runningleap.wordpress.com
It’s both a strictly personal choice (if you’re not married to the guy) AND he should have talked with her before the vasectomy.
This would not make me happy, mainly because it seems to me to indicate a lack of interest in her feelings. It displays, at the very least, a lack of emotional intelligence that would trouble me.
C´s last blog ..Gregarious, Piquant, and Sunny
Twitter @ writingtosanity
This really hits home with me. Not so much the vasectomy, but the disregard for her feelings/thoughts.
Is this the first time he has done something like this? I was in a serious relationship with a man who, basically, viewed me as being on a need-to-know basis with him. If he felt I needed to know, he would tell me; otherwise, I was left to assume or, even worse, find out after the fact. Looking back, I wish I would have played a different part… instead of allowing him to treat me that way, I would have ended it long before he ended it with me. Frequently, I felt that he treated me different because we WEREN’T married, and he (in so many words) acknowledged that he did.
Completely frustrating, especially when you ARE in a serious relationship. Don’t write off this behavior… pay attention NOW.
Desiree´s last blog ..And so we begin
Twitter @ http://notyouraveragesinglemomma.com
True its your junk…its your decision but what the hell…how private do you have to be to NOT mention THAT?! Really…how “private” is your man? He’s that private even to his girlfriend….whats the point?
singlemomma_cc´s last blog ..Gets out of hand quickly…
Twitter @ http://www.singlemommindy.blogspot.com
Hmmm, seems to me it would be something that was shared in a healthy relationship. The decision is his and family planning is not an issue but still…
Is he emotionally distant in other ways?
MindyMom/Single Mom Says…´s last blog ..The Good, The Bad & The Rest of the Weekend
Twitter @ singlemomchrons
I think he should have discussed this before he made a final decision; it’s good neither of you want more kids…but what about future decision making? This one worked out ok – but it easily could have gone the other way.
I am in a serious relationship as well, and I do consult my boyfriend in regards to major decisions..and I expect him to do the same. Otherwise, it just doesn’t feel like a partnership.
Now my caveat is this – if you want to be able to make your own decisions independently too, maybe this a relationship that works for the two of you?
Best of luck,
Swati Bharteey
Swati Bharteey´s last blog ..Talk to Your Kids About Working and Why It’s Important (Secret 5: Balancing Work and Single Motherhood
Twitter @ http://bigcitydadnyc.blogspot.com/
I guess it depends on how serious they are and how long they’ve been going out, but if they’re serious and talking about a future, my opinion is that it should be discussed at the very least. Kind of a team decision if you’re in a committed long term relationship.
Big City Dad´s last blog ..Our Secret Spot
Twitter @ BigLittleWolf
Depending upon her age and desire to have children, his age (and desire to ever have more), and what she considered the relationship – I’d say – get out of there now.
He just did this last week? And said nothing?
Not much of a relationship, unless you’re about 3 or 4 weeks in.
Get out.
BigLittleWolf´s last blog ..Sudden Outbreak of Rhymatoid ArtWriteUs; CDC Contemplates Next Steps
Twitter @ momma_sunshine
I agree that this is a very personal decision, of course, but he showed complete and utter disregard for her by not sharing this information with her. I’d call that a HUGE red flag, and if it were me in that same situation, it would give me cause to step back and completely re-evaluate things.
Making a decision this big without even discussing it with your partner is a HUGE breach of trust.
momma sunshine´s last blog ..Making it Work
Of course it’s a personal decision, however, I question the relationship and how serious HE’s taking it if he hadn’t even discussed the possibility with her. Seems to me that children or the lack of wanting them, would have been discussed in a relationship that was even slightly serious. I’d tell her to get out now before there are bigger issues not being talked about!
Christine´s last blog ..Do You Blog About Family?
Twitter @ Singlemomindebt
I know my response is going to be totally different from the other comments, but my thinking is that he probably didn’t tell her so that his decision was not influenced not to go forward with it. I am not sure how serious they are, but maybe they have not had the talk about whether or not they each want any more kids. By not telling her, he went with his own decision to not have anymore children and not to have any unplanned pregnancies. I think she needs to look at it from his perspective of making his own decision. And no harm if she had no intention of having anymore children. I can totally get why she would be a little upset by not knowing before hand, but you must pick your battles. Its done and since she says she doesn’t want any more children- it is a moot point. What good can come from arguing about it?
I really really don’t think this is a breach of trust. My reason for saying this is that it is his decision. I have some friends who found themselves in unplanned pregnancies who decided what they wanted before they told their partners. Their reason for this is that they wanted their decision to be their decision and not influenced by their partners (mainly not wanting to be pressured or persuaded into having an abortion).
My thoughts are that this boyfriend really does not want to have anymore children, support anymore children, etc. Unfortunately, even a vasectomy sometimes is not 100% effective, but it is much more effective than a condom. We are always rallying for men to take care of birth control and not leave it up to the woman, this man took control, got the vasectomy, is 100% responsibly for his own fertility. Maybe he was a little worried if he told his girlfriend, she *might* decide that maybe she wanted another child and was not ready for him to do this. Just my opinion.
Single Mom Paying Off Debt´s last blog ..Extra $1250 to pay towards debt !!!
Twitter @ Ysabo
I didn’t consult the guy I’ve been seeing for the past 9 months before I switched birth control methods. I just figured it really wasn’t any of his business what I used since we use condoms anyway. If I decided to get a hysterectomy, I probably wouldn’t ask him either. The only reason I might discuss it with him would be because I’d be out of commission for a while and he’s a nurse. He might want to come over and check on me, just in case. Granted, I’m very independent.
If he decided to get a vasectomy and didn’t tell me, it wouldn’t bother me. The only reason I’d care would be so I could be there to take care of him afterwards if necessary. It doesn’t sound like this guy wanted or needed that, so it didn’t apply.
Twitter @ http://goingsaneinacrazyworld.blogspot.com/
I agree that its a personal issue, but one that needs to be discussed in a relationship like any major chnage. This kind of belief of after the fact sharing can cause a lot of troubles.
Mike´s last blog ..Habits
Twitter @ divorcedwomen
You would think the subject would have come up at some point.
He doesn’t need her permission. And since they are only dating what she might and might not want doesn’t have to be taken into consideration.
If I were her my only concern would be that I was dating a guy who had surgery and failed to mention it. I mean, who doesn’t tell their girlfriend they are having surgery?
I’d also wonder what else he was failing to mention and how his need for “privacy” would affect a long-term relationship.
Cathy´s last blog ..In Defense of Dads who Leave
Twitter @ ChasingAmy206
The fact is he hid something that was sort of a big deal and there is now a breach of trust there. Whether it was his choice to move or get a vasectomy he didn’t include her in a life change and that’s sort of a big deal in relationships. Without telling her he’s saying “I’m not sharing or consulting with you on issues that affect my life.” Moving forward she will probably always wonder when the next undiscussed issue will come up. Is she sharing more of herself with him than he’s sharing or willing to share with her? That’s not good. That’s not give and take and it’s not equal. It’s unbalanced. If she’s a open sharing person and he’s this private I don’t think it’s going to work. This hurt my feelings for her. It’s a betrayal and I feel badly for her.
This conversation is simply outstanding. So much understanding and insight. You certainly raised points we didn’t consider. We’re proud of our Singlemommyhood community!
chai_girl: We always marvel at your practicality. And we applaud your independence.
Momma Sunshine: Your point about RED FLAG is well taken. As Christine mentioned, you wonder what other issues are not getting discussed.
Big little wolf and Big City Dad also raise important points about the length of the relationship. If this relationship is brand new, as in a couple of weeks, the silence about this life altering decision would be easier to understand.
Twitter @ http://www.threeunder4whatwasithinking.blogspot.com
I agree with the posts above. I don’t think that the actual act is what the problem is, it is the fact that he was not willing to share that part of his life with his girlfriend… and frankly… that is something that should have been shared. Honesty in this relationship seems to be one sided, and before I get through under the bus… sure, he was not dishonest with her… I am sure she didn’t just randomly ask last week if he went off and got snipped and he lied… but in the end omition is a form of dishonesty. There is a point in any relationship when you have to stop thinking of yourself as an indepenant person and start considering the feelings of others. He should have mentioned it to her.
Jolene´s last blog ..Stay at home mommy
All of the above are good, but I have an additional question. How did she “find out” about the vasectomy? Are they living together and he wanders in with an ice-pack on his boys saying “hey honey guess what i did today”, did she find out when she went over to visit, did he call her? In other words, did he voluntarily tell her or wait till he “got caught” or didn’t have any other choice? I’m wondering whether this is privacy or secrecy. Secrecy is a HUGE red flag and run, honey, run. If it truly was/is a PRIVACY issue then I think the situation and how it affected her emotionally needs to be discussed so that his privacy issues don’t cause bigger problems down the road. He may not have realized how it would look to her and that’s “workable” for a relationship with a little communication, but if he was actively trying to hide it from her, hmmm, I gotta think twice on that one…
CJ´s last blog ..Little Man’s 1st Counseling Appointment
Twitter @ canadianbaldguy
I think it’s an extremely personal decision and, ultimately, 100% the man’s decision.
Having said that, it speaks volumes that there wasn’t even a DISCUSSION about it…not even an fyi or ‘hey, by the way’.
Sunshine and I have talked about it and she knows where I stand on the issue. Because of my age and because of the seriousness of our relationship, I just can’t imagine NOT talking about it.
Interesting point @Single Mom Paying Off Debt: this guy certainly DID take control when it comes to birth control.
And @singlemomma_cc: You crack me up! (“It is your junk…”)
Very interesting discussion here. I have a habbit of sharing blogs I’m reading with my boyfriend to get his perspective. It always makes for good conversation. He had an interesting point on this one. Because we are missing some details to the story, it may or may not apply. But if this couple had already discussed the fact that they both don’t want children, does it matter that he got the vasectomy without discussing it first?
My boyfriend’s words verbatim: “I don’t run it by you before I get a haircut, but we both know I’m not going to let it grow long.”
So I suppose his perspective, which makes some sense to me, is in line with that of Single Mom Paying Off Debt. If the couple doesn’t want children, then maybe the fact that he took the birth control into his own hands is a good thing.
That said, I certainly do agree that it is strange and raises a red flag that anyone in a serious relationship would have ANY type of surgery without informing their significant other. Not to get her permission, but just to share what’s going on in his life. The concern here is the lack of two-way communication. It seems that this boyfriend shuts his girlfriend out. Vasectomy or no vasectomy, this doesn’t sound like a relationship worth investing in.
Lauren´s last blog ..Foreign Ground
Lauren: We agree . . .the essence of a relationship is sharing what’s REALLY going on in your life. Not just the superficial stuff. Thanks for joining the conversation.
Twitter @ Singlemomindebt
Let’s face it- you can only trust yourself. As much as we all want to admit that we would never do anything like trick a guy into getting pregnant, it happens. What if he would have told her that he was planning on doing this and she talked him out of it, telling him that she is on the pill and it would never happen. And BOOM she is now pregnant and he has a child to support, against his decision. He decided to not have anymore children and fixed himself so that he would not be able to have anymore.
I am not saying that this woman would do this, but it does happen. How many people have been in relationships and felt that their significant would never do something, such as cheat, lie, etc. and then they divorce and the story changes.
I do not know how I would handle this if my bf did this, but like Lauren said, what does it matter if neither wanted another child. I have a feeling that this guy didn’t tell her because he didn’t want her to try to change his mind, therefore he told her after the fact. I doubt that he would have hidden the fact that he was having surgery to have his tonsils out, but for something like this, he did run the risk of his girlfriend maybe second guessing her decision for them not to have children and perhaps trying to talk him out of it.
Question: In the post it says “our blogger friend is not interested in having any more biological kids. And her “private” man obviously feels the same way.” It is obvious that he doesn’t want anymore children since he had the vasectomy, but from the sound of it, it sounds as if they did not have a talk about having children together. He probably only knew that she did not want anymore children. Doesn’t sound like they discussed them ever having children together, so is it really a breach of trust if they never approached the subject?
Single Mom Paying Off Debt´s last blog ..Extra $1250 to pay towards debt !!!
Single Mom Paying Off Debt says “I doubt that he would have hidden the fact that he was having surgery to have his tonsils out, but for something like this, he did run the risk of his girlfriend maybe second guessing her decision for them not to have children and perhaps trying to talk him out of it.”
Doesn’t that just point right to something dysfunctional in the relationship? Let’s pretend he didn’t tell her about some “other” girlfriend cause she might talk him out of dating other people???? Secrecy based on fear of her reaction is still secrecy which means intentionally hiding something from another.
I’m still curious about the duration and nature of the relationship as well as how she discovered the vasectomy (did he tell her after the fact or did he wait till she “found out”) because I think it will tell a lot about whether this was truly a “privacy” issue or a “secrecy” issue.
The issue to me isn’t about kids vs no kids, it’s about sharing your life with someone else. Surgery, recovery time, no hanky-panky till the boys have healed…you’d think somewhere along the line there’d have been a reason to mention it.
CJ´s last blog ..Assertiveness training
Twitter @ http://www.weparent.com
This is a really interesting discussion.
I believe that our partners mirror for us issues we need to address within ourselves. Although this conversation is surrounding his decision not to communicate his decision in advance, it seems like there is a bigger question of how his need for privacy affects her more broadly. I would try to focus less on whether he was wrong and more on what her feelings about it tell her about the relationship. I don’t think the red flag Momma Sunshine mentions is necessarily about his trustworthiness but rather about potentially misaligned values.
Talibah´s last blog ..Real Families: Meet My Co-Parent, Part I
Talibah:Thanks for joining the conversation. Misaligned values is certainly another possible issue.
Had this happen to me this week.My boy got it done and told me 5 minutes prior on a text since i was out of town.Hurt!I wanted kids and am much younger then him(15)years.But he did not want kids and I knew that.He promised me a few months prior that he wouldn’t yet do it and see firsthand where the relationship would go.But he went and did it behind my back.I am so hurt and I dunno if I can get over it….We have a non refundable trip to Mexico over Xmas.I have no clue what to do about all this…yuck!
Funny subject, as we (my fiance and I) had this very conversation last night, 4 nights after my surgery!
She told me last night that I had been selfish in having the operation, although she’s 46, I’m 43, we both have children from previous relationships and we’ve had those chats before, with no intention of having more, I thought it the responsible way of behaving in a stable, loving relationship.
The appointment was booked a few months ago, a letter arrived 2 months ago, with the exact date, this was then put on our kitchen chalkboard, date and time, it’s been there for 2 months!
Last night, with the help of a little vodka, she complains that I never asked her opinion.
I was shocked to hear this, a few months of notice and letters, the date being on the board, I explained if she wasnt happy, she could have raised the subject anytime, now I’m worried it’s just her expressing her control over our relationship, she always seems to need something “over” me, whether it’s reading all my contacts in my phone, asking me to delete any “female” ones, reading my emails, seems that even after 12 months of living together, she needs control, or me being on the “back foot” at every juncture, to control situations. Now it’s her feeling upset, because I didnt discuss it with her. Thing is, since we met, I made my feelings clear on children, I have 2, I’m happy with that and now, at 43, I’ve done my bit for humanity. We have had a chat about the surgery, when the letter came through, she said then I could have asked her, but that was all, that was 8 weeks previously.
Whatshisname: Thanks for sharing this very interesting post surgical tale. Hmmm
Dr Leah, You’re welcome, 6 days since op now, have had some terrible days of pain, ice seems to help! We’ve not talked about it since the night I mentioned, regrets? None for me, even the endless pain hasn’t swayed the actual decision. For anyone who’s partner is thinking about it, my only advice would be, buy as many frozen bags of peas you can!
Whatshisname: *OUCH* Feel better!
Wow, I see I’m really late posting on this, but I just stumbled across the post, today.
I am utterly cringing at the replies “Disregarded her feelings” “DISCUSSION” “bigger issues not being talked about!” etc.
Seriously, if this was a topic of Should a woman tell her boyfriend she’s is changing her pill or having taking the morning after pill I think the answers would have been much different.
These 2 talked about no children and he was serious, so it is solved. Why is she hurt? They weren’t married.
If a woman has the right to her own body, so does a man. Period. Get over it. The end.