My daughter says she’s fat. What do I do?
by Rachel Sarah
Filed under Kids, Tips & Advice
“I need help!” began an email we received recently from the single mom of an eight-year-old.
“My daughter was in tears this evening after looking in the mirror. She told me that she hates the way she looks because now her stomach is too fat! She’s NOT fat—what do I do?”
Yes, we know the stats about obesity and kids in our country, but that’s NOT what this email made us think about. Sadly, this mother’s worry hit close to him. We can both think of tween and teen girls we know who feel like they’re overweight because they don’t look “model thin.”
True, part of the problem is the way that women are presented in the media: our girls see unrealistic and unhealthy females on TV whenever they’re turn it on. And, as WebMD recently put it in a post about girls and body image:
“It doesn’t help that real-life role models, mothers in particular, too often openly obsess about their own weight; that male role models, like dads and older brothers, make clear their preference for thinner women; and that an overwhelming percentage of girls’ clothing features body-hugging, midriff-baring styles most comfortably worn by the ultra-thin.”
Still, this leaves us wondering: What should this mother tell her daughter?
She can repeat the most positive, affirming comments to her little girl — “You are so beautiful… You are healthy and gorgeous…You’re just right the way that you are…” — but what if her daughter still puts herself down? Then what?
If you’re the mother of a daughter, we’d love to know if this sounds familiar.
Does your daughter compare herself to waif thin media images? And worry that she’s fat?
Do you secretly worry that your own “fat issues” might influence your daughter’s body image?
No judgments – ever! @Singlemommyhood.
We’d love to hear what’s on your mind.
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
No related posts.






Twitter @ http://mommasunshine.wordpress.com
One thing that I started doing with my daughters at an early age is to talk to them about beauty. We talk about examples of women of all different shapes and sizes who are beautiful. Both real-life examples, and celebrity examples.
We talk about why Barbie is “boring” – because all barbies look the same, and there are many different kinds of beautiful.
My girls NEVER hear me talk about weight or obsess about my body, no matter what I may feel somedays.
I tell them often that they are beautiful – and WHY they are beautiful.
We talk about health and the importance of eating well and exercising.
My girls are still young (4 and 6), and I think it’s going to get more difficult as they get older. I struggled with disordered eating from the time I was 10 or 11 until I was 28 years old. I obsessed with my appearance, dieted and exercised excessively. When I wasn’t doing that, I was binging like crazy and gaining weight. It was a difficult struggle to overcome this, and I hope to spare my own girls a similar fate.
If the time comes, I plan on being very honest with them about what I went through, and how important it is to love and respect your body and the way you look – because the alternative is devastating.
MommaSunshine´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday – Why I Love My Girls
Twitter @ http://mommasunshine.wordpress.com
Also – there is a great book out there – “101 Ways to Help Your Daughter Love Her Body” by Brenda Lane Richardson and Elane Rehr.
Definitely worth checking out!!
MommaSunshine´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday – Why I Love My Girls
Twitter @ CorrinRenee
This email makes my stomach flip for the little girl. But I’m so glad the mother is looking for positive ways to interact with her daughter about her weight.
As a kid, my mother used to offer money, clothes, toys, and vacations to lose weight. I remember my grandfather putting me on a scale in 4th grade and betting me $10 that I was over 100 lbs.
As an adult, I could stand to lose weight. I’m healthy and active but my weight has yo-yo’d because I go between feeling ‘I need to loose weight so others look at me a certain way’ and ‘who the hell cares what they think!’
Sadly, this isn’t an issue limited to girls. My 8yr old son is the tallest and biggest kid in his grade and he hates it. We talk about healthy food choices, and that there are certain foods that will trick your body into being lazy and not giving you enough energy to do the things you want to do. And we stay active together. I’ve started putting away my scale so he won’t know I check my weight everyday, and so he can’t worry about what the numbers say when he steps on. As a child raised being told I was fat, it breaks my heart to see him unhappy with himself.
Twitter @ http://giggedygeekmum.wordpress.com/
I’d ask her why she thinks she’s fat. Find out what’s causing it. If it’s due to bullies then address that. If it’s something she came up with “on her own” I’d say a visit to a local art museum might be in order.
You can view the women as they’re portrayed given the time period. Historically our idea of beauty has changed. Ask for her opinions on the art she see’s- if the women are beautiful, if they’re fat, if that mattered to the artist, if it matters in day to day life. The real point you want to get to isn’t focusing on fat though you’ll certainly want to address her self-esteem. In the end our bodies are all shaped differently. “Fat” should be a moot point. We should instead do our best to be happy and healthy given the skin we’re in.
Satsuki´s last blog ..Something New This Way Comes
Twitter @ runpippi
My ten year old son says he is fat. After our divorce, my ex lost a great deal of weight and began exercising obsessively, to the point of compulsion. I know this has caused my son to think about his own body image. This bothers me deeply as he has self esteem issues to begin with. When my son says this in front of me, I immediately dispell the notion and try to get his mind off of the topic.
Pippi´s last blog ..Help! My Vibrator’s Battery Died and I Can’t Get Up
@Debra and @Pippi: thanks so much for pointing out that boys also experience anxiety/stress around body image. We appreciate hearing from you.
Twitter @ aprilabtbalance
My older daughter said this once a couple of years ago and I kinda freaked, too. Of course, I assured her she wasn’t, and I also pointed out that she exercises regularly, eats well, and is still growing. She hasn’t mentioned it again. She’s now 12, and while I know she thinks about her body image, she isn’t obsessive about it. She continues to exercise, eat, and of course grow and we do talk about body image, women in media, etc. when appropriate. I think if the daughter only says it once, it’s not cause for huge concern, but if no amount of talking and reassuring is doing the trick, then I’d take her to a therapist.
April´s last blog ..Having the talk
Twitter @ tsquest
This is one of my favorite quotes:
“A mother who radiates self acceptance and self love actually vaccinates her daughter against low self esteem.” ~ Naomi Wolf
I agree with asking the child why she feels that she is fat. I also agree that this isn’t limited to girls. (And I blogged about that here: http://tsquest.blogspot.com/2009/09/do-kids-emotionally-eat-too.html)
I agree with sharing examples of all sorts of body types of women.
Finally, I definitely agree that it starts with the females in the child’s life. Kids may not always listen but they definitely imitate.
I’m doing what I can to create habits of moderation and not deprivation. I hope its helping my two daughters to create a healthy attitude about food.
T´s last blog ..What’s keeping me warm this winter
Twitter @ http://cat804.blogspot.com
Great quote from T. For my son, I want to model healthy behaviors- eating right, being active, and being happy with myself. If he comes up with self esteem issues, I’d try to figure out the root cause- other kids, the media, etc, and address that.
Cat´s last blog ..Not much to write about…
Twitter @ tailgatingtimes
I’ve had to struggle with weight most of my life as well and unfortunately I’m in a period where “making time” for working out is easier said than done. I do try to model good eating habits and I cook healthy, balanced dinners most nights of the week. I send healthy lunches to school and have healthy snacks at home. My daughter simply eats when she’s bored and she always seems to be hungry. I guess she inherited her parents’ love of food along with our larger frames. My son on the other hand is tall and very thin.
I’ve mentioned before my real frustration is finding clothes that fit. I also get disgusted by her mother’s accusations that I “let” her eat too much or when she makes our daughter feel bad about herself with her comments and trying to put her on a diet. Kids can be cruel and she’s gotten upset many times from kids calling her fat. She doesn’t need her mother adding to it. She’s in sports now and I think that will help. Finding clothes that look good on her has also helped and of course I tell her all the time what a great kid she is. I think too often too much emphasis is put on how kids look…”what great looking kids you have,” etc. I try to respond with, “yes and they are very smart, talented…” Everyone was born with different gifts. For some people it’s their looks, others are intelligent, other people are funny, sweet, good singers, artistic, and the list goes on and on.
I’m pretty sure I learned stress eating from my mom and I’m trying not to pass that down. Both of my kids are in running club at school and I encourage as much activity as they’ll do.
Twitter @ BigLittleWolf
What is tragic about this is that 40 years ago it was going on. I remember being the child of an obese mother, and at age 6 everyone was trying to put me on a diet. I was a perfectly “normal” size. Needless to say, by the time I was 10, 11, 12 – especially being a dancer, issues of body image were already impacted. And that continued well throughout adolescence and into adulthood with a diverse set of unhealthy eating behaviors.
And I suspect it is far worse today. While I have teen sons, I have watched the tween and teen daughters of friends go through their periods of self-loathing and dieting (all were perfectly “normal” and healthy in weight), and several appear to have gotten through just fine. But the sense of not good enough when they look at television or in the magazines? And now with the ability to Photoshop and even further distort what is seen?
Not only do I think discussion – ongoing – is warranted, but campaigns such as the one that DOVE put out targeted at tween girls, relative to all the variations of beauty – they help. It’s a drop in the bucket, but it’s something. We need talk, and we also need close observation. And possibly – would that it were possible – taking these girls out of environments that worship the artificial and unattainable, the ultimately “unwomanly” stick figure, and plopping them visually (if not logistically) in the midst of other cultural environments. Those where a woman’s natural attributes are seen as beautiful, not something to be refashioned, according to fashion.
BigLittleWolf´s last blog ..Is this it?
Twitter @ http://www.askthesingleparent.com
I was getting out of the shower when my daughter said, “Mommy your tushy looks bigger” She was 5 1/2. I am no more than 100lbs but I did put on about 5lbs at the time and thus she was right. But, really, she’s that observant about weight at that age! She’s now 7 and already asked if her tummy looked too big. I reminded her she is perfect just the way she is. I’m still working on answers and know how as we live in a very superficial city where too much emphasis is given to our aesthetics. Wish me luck and feel free to send many many suggestions
Always,
Daniella
Daniella´s last blog ..Single Parenting | Belonging
Twitter @ FullCustodyDad
As a father, one of my MAJOR responsibilities is the self worth and esteem of my children. This is one area I feel that fathers actually have more influence over there kids than mothers–my thoughts anyway.
Let me start by saying, my wife, myself, my daughter, and my Ex are slightly overweight (my son is the skinny kids in the family). We as a family struggle with this. We model good eating habits and exercising to try to keep our weight in check. However that said, my kids and especially my daughter don’t struggle with esteem or image issues. Why?
1. We don’t own a single television in the house–not one.
2. We don’t subscribe or read any magazines that promote skinny models, etc.
3. Neither my wife nor I define “beauty” as a physical thing.
4. We don’t praise the kids’ physically beauty but acts of beauty.
5. Several times a month, I have one-on-one times with my kids–and at nearly 11 years of age, I have father/daughter date breakfasts or lunches.
6. I kiss and hug my children like crazy!
Here’s some sample lingo phrases heard around our home…
“Kids, this thank you card was beautifully written.”
“That kid’s manners were very attractive.”
“Caitlyn, your essay was simply magnificent!”
“Our waitress has the most gorgeous personality.”
Your kids reflect the way you model, dress, act and see others. To me–beauty is intelligent, humorous, personable, reflected in acts of kindness, servanthood, manners, communication skills, joy and attitude.
Fred Campos / FullCustodyDad´s last blog ..Showtime Begins & Ends in Court from Your Car Tip #308
Twitter @ http://gawlas.blogspot.com
This is why I am glad I have sons.
I guess I would remind my child that people come in all shapes and sizes and that inner beauty and values are more important than outer appearance. (I might also remove the dresser or full length mirror in her room and replace it with one that shows about shoulders up).
Maybe the mother could encourage her daughter to sit and think about all the women in her life she admires and then compare how they look to the media ideal, then ask her if she would love them any more if they were size “0″.
Just some thoughts.
alley´s last blog ..Ashes
Twitter @ http://365daysofhearingwordpress.com
Hello all! I am the mother of that 8 year old who thought she was fat. It was so great to hear from all of you. I’m especially grateful to MommaSunshine for suggesting the book–I’ve been looking for these books for sometime (so thanks!).
I find the whole thing baffling and interesting for several reasons: for beginners, we don’t have a t.v. In fact, she went to Waldorf school for awhile. We don’t struggle with weight—I don’t talk about my weight—we are incredibly active, good athletes, eat really healthy food (I’m a bit on the health conscious freak side for health reasons)—she doesn’t have a father in her life to compliment her (that could be a small part of the reason). I spent a long time thinking about this—and finally, I figured it out–she loves Taylor Swift, Beyonce Knowles, Hannah Montana, and the like, they all have flat tummies. I asked her if she wanted her tummy to be like theirs—she nodded her head. Aha! I then explained to her that if she were to look at most girls her age—most of them don’t have that kind of tummy–and then I explained to her—that along with womanhood comes: hips, breasts, menstrual cycles, pubic hair and that most of us never get flat tummies—and we’re still beautiful–and that she has a body of an 8 year old. She seemed to understand that concept more or less. But, still, it scared me–and makes me wonder—”What’s next? Or, are we finished with this tough issue that many girls (and boys too) deal with?” Pretty please, tell me, that I don’t won’t have any other challenges
Twitter @ Zoeyjane
This topic made me pretty sad – especially to see some of the comments parents have made about themselves, or their childhoods, and I have so much to say on this subject, but I don’t think that I can do it without being judgmental.
I hope Avigail74 feels a little better after her big conversation with her daughter.
Zoeyjane´s last blog ..On being out
Twitter @ singlemomchrons
Oh no, that breaks my heart! I would want to know more about why she thinks she is fat and get to the heart of it. My daughter hasn’t said anything about her weight – but she has asked me what it means when she hears people saying a woman is “hot.” (ugh)
When I compliment her, I do always refer to the person she is inside and how smart she is along with how she looks cute (or whatever I was commenting on).
I’d hate to try to block out the external influences at home because that’s just not reality – I’d rather she talk to me about it all instead of just seeing different things outside of our home (where she spends most of her time).
This is why reinforcing self confidence is so important.
Good luck – I hope your daughter can see how lovely and unique she is.
Swati
Swati Bharteey´s last blog ..Brain Fog Mom
@MommaSunshine: You know that we LOVE book recommendations. Thanks for that one!
Single Mom Seeking´s last blog ..Do you worry about your father-less son?
Twitter @ http://eatingdisorder.org/blog/2010/02/q-a-with-rosalind-wiseman/
We recently asked Rosalind Wiseman, author of “Queen Bees & Wannabes”, “Owning Up” body image curriculum, and a new young adult novel, “Boys, Girl/wp-admin/edit-comments.php?comment_status=spam#comments-forms & Other Hazardous Material,” what we, as parents, can do to address body image concerns with our children. Here’s what she had to say on this subject:
“By the time kids are four and five years old, it’s not unusual for them to start making comments about their own or others’ bodies. They may say things like, “I have a big belly” or “That person is so fat.”
Now, there’s a tendency among parents to ignore this, hush it, or say it’s not true. The problem with that strategy is that children are still going to believe what they see but they just won’t have the opportunity to talk about it. So then, it’s left up to the kids on the playground to talk about it and define how to treat people based on how they look. And that’s even more harmful because it will probably be in the context of teasing, shame, or embarrassment. And so as soon as your child starts making comments or asking questions about how people look, you have to take that as an opportunity to talk about people’s differences – you can explain that just like people can have different skin colors, people also come in different sizes and that’s just the way they are.
If your child is making negative comments about his or her self at this age, you can respond by telling them, ‘You have a beautiful body. It’s healthy for kids to have a tummy and what’s more important than what you weigh or look like, is how you eat, eating nutritious food, and being physically active.’”
We hope this helps! The rest of our interview with Rosalind is posted on our blog, feel free to take a look if you’re interested!
I am currently going through a divorce and I have an eight year girl that is under the impression that her dad left and got new girlfriends because mommy gained weight. Daddy has openly made fun of mommys weight in front of her and now she is critical about what she weighs because she thinks daddy wont want her if she gains weight. has anyone been through something simular with the daddy? how do I break this cycle her father has created?
Twitter @ msjennixoxo
Stacy,
I’m going through the same thing with my 5-year-old. There only difference is it has nothing to do with her father. My daughter was seeing a specialist at Children’s Hospital, and he was concerned of her sudden massive weight gain. Due to doctor’s comments, and me adjusting what she eats and how much, she has become weight obsessive herself – and she’s only 5!
I routinely got, “Mommy, how many calories is in that? Mommy, I can’t eat that, I’ll get fat! Mommy, do I look thinner?” For a while she would even stand on the scale every day, and ask me to look at it.
For a while I worried, and I noticed the worry actually encouraged the behavior. So I started ignoring it. When she’d stand on the scale, I wouldn’t look. When she’d ask about calories, I told her not to worry about it. When she’d ask if she was skinner, I’d just shrug my shoulders. I made it a point to show her IT WASN’T IMPORTANT.
So my biggest suggestion, is don’t feed into if you are. Also try talking to her.. remind her there was much more to your marriage falling apart, than weight gain. And what her dad had said in the past was rude, and showed how he didn’t really care about YOUR feelings.
If it continues, go to your pediatrician. Have them talk to her, and explain to her while being healthy is good, being too thin isn’t.
Jenni´s last blog ..It’s In The Genes
So last night my 5 year old told me that the kids at daycare were calling her fat, i could tell she was lying cause when i asked her who? she struggled to give me names, then she finally said “i am lying i know its naughty and i can hurt people and get them in trouble when i lie” i told her thank you for telling the truth. then i said what would make you say that then? and she said “i dont know” so i kinda let it go, I then said “you know you are not Fat and we all love you very much, God made us all different” then we went on to read a book. When we were done i said you know you can tell mommy anything even if its bad or good and if someone is being mean you can always tell me. She said “i know”, then i was headed out of the bed room and she goes “i said it because i thik i am FAT”, “i hate the way i look , and when i talk to people i just think in my brain that they think i am fat, and they dont like the way i look”.. REALLY she is ONLY 5…. i have done nothing but incourage her and be posative because my parents were very negative when i was young and i do everything in my power to be posative with EVERYTHING… i want her to love herself. so of course i said “we are all beautiful in our own ways, and God made us all different because what would this world be with only one color flower BORING, you need to look in the mirro and see the beautiful little flower i see every day and the love and joy you bring to so many people. i walked away and cried. i feel her pain, kids are cruel and i hurt for her….this all started 5 weeks ago when one of the skinny (i mean really skinny) girls at daycare told her she shouldnt wear her bathing suit cause she was to FAT. she is only 6. My daughter came home crying and i told her that she was being RUDE and i spoke to the daycare about it the next day, we dont call our friends names!.. then 2 weeks later i caught her in my bedroom standing in front of the mirror sucking her tummy in while standing in her swim suit.
ANG: A five year old checking her body shape in the mirror is a sad tale. Mean girls definitely start earlier and earlier. Do keep us updated on how your daughter is handling this bullying –and that’s what it is- definitely!
Oh dear, that’s not good. You’ll have to keep telling her that she’s beautiful & she shouldn’t worry about such things.
I was a child model & at 13 overheard one of my regular employers saying I’d put on puppy fat & I stopped eating & became very sick.
Be careful of who she hangs out with and negative tv shows & magazines.
I’m not much help but as a former model i know society these days sucks & I have to say that being healthy to me means far more than being skinny.
She’s so young it’s a terrible dilemma.
Best of luck.
Twitter @ mightbeatranny
my husband was openly critical of me in front of my daughters about basically everything, including weight. after i left he started in on my then 10 year old. she got so thin the court ordered her to an eating disorder clinic. she has gained 30 lbs in the last about 14 months and is now a healthy weight. she thinks she is fat and her father tells her she’s fat everytime he sees her. on the last visit her dad’s dad told her the same thing. i tell my daughter that some people use insults as a way to control people, put them down and feel superior about themselves. i also stress healthy eating and tell my girls that when your body is changing into a woman’s body there are curves where there weren’t before. this daughter is going to be very curvy, like my mom. its different from my body type and her younger sisters body type. not better of worse; different.
another thing. a friend of mine has a teen boy. he told her the other day that when a boy wants to make a girl feel bad (thast comment righ there is long story, there really wasn’t any bad intent) all he has to do is say she looks “chubby”. doesn’t matter if its true or not. it will upset her for a week. sadly, i agree w/ him.
Thank you all so much for your support, I will keep you all posted on how things are going, she has since pulled out my exercise video and wants to do that, and instead of not allowing her to, we do it together and i stress people exercise to be healthy. I do not initiate it but allow her to exercise and join in with her making it even more fun. She is very active and is in dance and gymnatics and absolutly loves DANCE. We start Kindergarten next week, she is so excited!
well what do i do in my situation? allow me to explain. my wife is morbidly obese,she weighs 220 pds and is only 4ft11in tall. she makes no effort whatsoever to drop her weight and while she doesnt actually over eat,she eats all the wrong foods. no fruit or veg or anything healthy. she says that is just the way she is and is quite happy with her size. now my 10 yr old daughter is heading the same way. she is 4ft 6in and weighs 125pds which puts her in the red zone. my wife says that as she is only 10 that it is just puppy fat and she will grom out of it. i am not so sure though. last night i tried to encourage my daughter to go running with me just around the muddy field down the road,i thought it would be fun but all she did was sing to herself and basically ignored me. i said to them both that 3 yrs ago my daughter was not nearly as big as she is now becuase she was doing excercises more. thats when my wife blew her top. i am the big villain here yet i try to encourage them both but to deaf ears. dont know where to turn.
@Confused Dad: we’re honored that you reached out to us. We’re wondering if your daughter’s pediatrician might suggest someone you can reach out to for specific suggestions.
It sounds like you and your daughter need some in person assistance right now. We’re going to reach out to see if our readers can help.
Please stay in touch.
Confused Dad, I do see where you are coming from. I feel that at 10 it’s a great time for kids to start making better choices and start moving more. They are in their pre-teens and this is when their body will be doing many changes and needs to make those healthy choices to even things out. Maybe a run would be a little difficult for someone who is not in shape however a fast walk would be a great start! Although mom seems to be ok with her weight there might be some inner insecurities that she is dealing with and by saying “that’s just the way I am ” she is making excuses for herself. Poor daughter probably doesn’t see anything wrong with it if mom thinks it’s ok as children tend to look up to their parents for approval. However she should know that teaching her daughter good eating habits is a Plus for so many reasons. It’s important to know you tried to help you children walk the right paths, believe me I know it’s not easy but if you have the right food available in the house they tend to make the right choices. But by all means DO NOT take all the junk food away, makes them want it more and then they will tend to over eat when it’s in front of them. (I had an aunt who did that with my cousins) I do think that a Pediatrician may have some ideas as to what you can do, and for now I believe staying positive will be your best bet. Family workouts are always fun, and make sure to always use positive encouragement. Just be careful how you approach the situation because you don’t want your daughter to turn on you or even feel that you dont love her. Maybe you could say its “daddy daughter time” and use that time to catch up on some girl drama she might want to share with you. Don’t give up and dont let mom bring her down either. Maybe a family gym membership would be a great start. Good luck and stay posative, as you can see from my post kids are MEAN so anything you can do to help them out is a plus.
My daughter has just turned five and has begun telling me she has fat hands and arms. She is not fat nor is she model thin. Last night she told me that if she was skinny she would be pretty then disturbingly said that if she stopped eating she could be skinny!!! Myself and my husband were horrified, neither of us are overweight or on diets and have tried to promote a healthy attitude towards food and diet. This morning she told me that she didn’t like her baby doll as it was fat!! I have reassured her and told her that some fat is healthy and that being skinny isn’t but not really sure if this is normal. She is bright and probably one of the tallest and biggest built in her class so can only guess she has begun to compare herself with smaller children.