When you’re dating a man without kids
by Dr. Leah
Filed under Single Moms
We heard recently from a single mom by choice with a three-year-old daughter who’s in a long distance relationship… but with an unexpected complication. They’ve been dating for 18 months and fortunately, their work schedules allow them to see each other frequently with a bit of planning. Luckily, her own mother doesn’t judge her — and she’s happy to help out. This woman loves her boyfriend and their chemistry is great.
So far, everything sounded terrific. Right?
Here’s the unexpected complication:
This single mom — who got pregnant through donor insemination — told us that her boyfriend has no experience with children. And he has never dated anyone with children.
Occasionally, she brings her daughter along for their weekend visits because she wants to give her mom a break. And she wants her daughter to feel included.
This single mom, however, doesn’t get a “warm fuzzy feeling” when they are all together. In fact, she gets the impression that he’s a bit annoyed. The boyfriend does not go out of his way for her daughter. She feels that he accepts her daughter’s presence out of fairness to her mother — not because he wants to include her daughter in their relationship.
Her (mostly married) posse tells her they would feel the same about someone’s else kids, too. They’re urging her to give him time. After all, he’s not mean to her daughter, or anything remotely like that.
This single mom feels guilty for ignoring these concerns. What if he never warms up to her daughter?
Despite no marriage plans in the immediate future, she wonders if this is a situation she can afford to ignore.
Frankly, this single mom is considering breaking up with him. After all, given the way she sees him with her daughter, she’s dubious that he would ever want children of his own. Or be a good father figure to her daughter. Something is just *missing* with her boyfriend. And she does not want her daughter to feel slighted in any way.
So, this single mom is counting on your wisdom and experience:
Should her boyfriend show more interest and affection toward her child?
Is he possibly clueless about kids, and he just needs to be shown the way? Or he is just NOT kid friendly?
Is she living in fairytale, hoping for a man who will care for her daughter as his own?
~~~~
(Photo courtesy of Silver Puppeteer via Flickr)
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
No related posts.






Twitter @ http://mommasunshine.wordpress.com
I say that she should give it some time. Bonding with your partner’s children isn’t automatic…it simply takes time. Likely more time for someone with little experience with children. Use this as an opportunity to help teach him how to deal with children. If he doesn’t come around, then it’s time to cut him loose and keep looking. But for now, I vote to give him the benefit of the doubt and give him some time.
MommaSunshine´s last blog ..Priorities and Patience
I say give it some time. If he hasn’t been around kids, then he doesn’t really know how to relate and that’s going to take some work. She should probably talk to him about it though. If she wants more kids in the future, that’s something that needs to be addressed anyways. Does she need him to be a father figure? It’s not really an issue in my case, since my daughter’s father is around. I just need someone that can be a good role model and friend to my daughter.
Twitter @ http://www.singleparenttravel.net
I have dated several women who don’t have kids. It was at varying ages of my own kids and I have to be honest, they just don’t get it!
While I would never begrudge anyone from wanting to be the love of someone’s life, anyone I date or become involved with must know that at best they are going to be number 4 (I have three kids).
Dinner plans will be ruined because of a barfing kid. Romantic weekends will be interrupted with a hormonal teenager.
Without having kids themselves, they really don;t get it. Perhaps a teacher might have a clue, but for the most part–not.
John Frenaye´s last blog ..One Space Left
Twitter @ http://badmummynocookie.com
I would cut and run. If it’s been 18 months and he hasn’t learned to roll with the fact that she has a kid…
She could ask him to take more interest. Ask him what is holding him back. Remind him that she’s a package deal. But I think an interest in kids comes from the heart.
Twitter @ blacktating
Dump him! If this woman wants to get married (and it sounds like she does), she is going to have to find someone who loves her daughter as they are a package deal. Not likes her daughter or can put up with her, but loves her. This guy doesn’t seem to be weary, he seems disinterested. I don’t think he is into the instant family and the reality of it is, if they weren’t in a long distance relationship it would’ve probably ended long ago. Cut your losses, mom! It sounds like your instincts are telling you to walk away so listen to your gut.
Twitter @ runpippi
I agree with John. I have two divorced female friends with children who are both dating men who do not have children. A frequent vent is that their boyfriends “just don’t get it” when it comes to the joys, responsibilities and stresses that come along with having children. Also, I agree with bad mummy…if it’s been 18 months…
Pippi´s last blog ..My Sweet 8
Maybe she should talk to him about it. I mean, it’s been 18 months and she doesn’t know if he would want kids? Does this mean she wants more? Does he know that? Do they talk about other important things? It sounds like there might be more missing than a burgeoning relationship with her daughter.
Twitter @ http://singlemommindy.blogspot.com
I think it’s wrong to expect a man with no prior experience with kids to be instinctivley nurturing or even comfortable around someone else’s child. Maybe he’s worried about coming off too strong or trying too hard and doing something wrong so he plays it safe and does the opposite.
She should have a healthy conversation with her BF about the issue and if he’s agreeable to addressing her concerns then he needs time, support and encouragement as he developes a rapport with her daughter. If he is resistant to it and doesn’t warm up after that, then yeah, show him the door.
Mindy@SingleMomSays´s last blog ..Getting to Know Each Other
Twitter @ ewokmama
From my experience being the daughter of a single mom AND being a single mom myself – this is not good. The man may not have the instincts, but if he shares the longterm vision of the relationship he should be interested in learning how to be a step parent. It doesn’t sound like this mom is wanting her romantic life separate from her family life, otherwise there wouldn’t be this question over what to do about it.
My fiance does not have children and very little experience. With that said, he has been amazing with my son. He has paid attention to the techniques I use to parent and employed them. His view of it is that my son and I are a unit and it’s his job to blend into that – not our job to change our life around for him. He absolutely understands and supports the fact that my son is my number one priority. When he has questions about why I have done something a certain way, he will do research and talk about it with me. Communication is essential!
It IS possible to get a partner who wants to be a family. If the person you are dating seems annoyed by your child, they are not the right person for your lives.
Ewokmama´s last blog ..Stick and Carrot
I’ve been that guy with no kids dating the single mom. I can tell you from experience that if he hasn’t “warmed up” by now, he won’t. Even the most heartless SoB can have fun with a 3 year old and make them laugh…it’s not like he has to warm up to a moody pre-teen/teenager. A package of Goldfish, some playdoh/crayons, and tickle fights…..
If it’s been more than a couple of visits and he’s still reticent/hesitent/annoyed – he won’t come around. It’s time to decide between the two of them.
As for me – that was 6+ years ago and now my daughter is almost 10 and is an amazing little person.
Jeff: The single dad perspective is ALWAYS welcome. It’s obvious that you’re a great dad. Thanks so much for stopping by.
Twitter @ singlemomchrons
I think that 18 months is really long enough to “warm up.” I have dated men without kids too – and while they may not know exactly what to do and when to do it, you can tell when they are just “taken” with your child or not…which I think is what you want in a step-parent situation. I wouldn’t want my daughter being raised & feeling like my partner was just putting up with her.
I think you’ll know what’s best for you and for her.
If you decide to break-up with him, I hope you do tell him why so he doesn’t enter another relationship with a single mom lightly.
Good luck!
Swati
Swati Bharteey´s last blog ..I’m Up in a Tree and Feeding Penny Pig
Dr Leah – thanks for the welcome – but I’m not a single dad….I’m now the Poppa to two awesome little girls – one of which was a package deal with her mom.
I was the kidless guy that never thought he’d want kids – but fell in love with both mom & child. And I can tell you, I knew it almost immediately. If I had any doubts, I never would’ve pursued a continuing relationship with the mom (now my wife). To do otherwise would’ve been selfish, irresponsible and possibly emotionally damaging to the child.
Twitter @ Zoeyjane
I’m curious, like Kristen, what the couple’s discussions about it have brought up. Because honestly, regardless of whether he might, one day, warm up to her daughter (her friends and she hopes), the potential of him already knowing he’s not interested in the whole package, or having some sort of incite as to why he’s not warm and fuzzy with her daughter is much more valuable than anything friends, family or we could say.
Communication has to take place, I think, before she should make a decision. But if the results of it are that he just doesn’t think he’s interested in her daughter, then honestly, I suggest breaking up. Her daughter’s acceptance should be one of the top priorities in her life.
Zoeyjane´s last blog ..On rhinovirus
Jeff: Sorry for the confusion …I DO stick by …you’re a great dad. And I do agree that it’s damaging emotionally to a child when he or she senses that the new man (or woman) in his mom’s (or dad’s) life, frankly, wishes this was a “kidless” relationship. So nice to hear that dedicated “kidless” guys can change …such a happy story. Please do visit us again soon. We love our married readers … they’re valued members of our Singlemommyhood community.
Twitter @ http://roxannima.com
Ask. Him.
Whatever happened to good ol’ fashioned conversation? She 100% NEEDS to know EXACTLY where he stands on the kid issue. She 100% NEEDS to know EXACTLY how he feels about her having a kid, and if she wants another, she’s gonna need to know where he stands on that too. There is no two ways about it when it comes to being a single mom. These conversations need to happen early, and not taken lightly.
This is NOT a time for guessing or asking friends what they think or testing him. This is not a game.
Ask. Him.
And if he can’t have a serious conversation about this, then go find someone who can.
Roxanne´s last blog ..5 bad habits my child is inheriting from me
I agree with Mindy. Has she talked to him about it? Sometimes people come off as aloof if they are scared witless. If he has not experience, he probably has some anxiety about what he should do (and what she’s expecting him to do) around/with her kids.
If she talks with him, and he is disinterested in the kids, kick him to the curb. But I have a feeling, he’s just nervous about what to do.
Twitter @ grace134
While giving him time may be in order, I don’t think this is a tenable situation for the long term. She needs to talk to him about it, he needs to be willing to make a concerted effort towards her daughter, even if he is inexperienced/clueless.
Ask him about it. He may be unaware of his behavior. Or if he is truly uncomfortable around her daughter and unwilling to build that relationship, then this is probably not the guy for any sort of longterm relationship.
Miss Grace´s last blog ..Weekly Winners – Friday Night Out
Twitter @ http://gawlas.blogspot.com
End it.
She’s been seeing him for long enough that he should be comfortable with her by now. If one partner in a relationship isn’t comfortable, the relationship should end. Simple as that.
alley´s last blog ..No Sparks
Twitter @ modernlovemuse
As a now married former single mom (how’s that for an intro) I have to agree that a conversation is a must, but I’m concerned that they’ve been dating this long and haven’t yet worked this out. After 2 months of dating my now-husband, I knew EXACTLY where he stood on the kids issue, and he knew EXACTLY that loving me meant loving my son too. We were, in the words of a good friend, ‘matching Louis Vuitton luggage, and only someone who got that was worth traveling with.’
In my experience and observations, you don’t have to be a parent to ‘get kids’ per se, but it certainly helps. I could tell from the get go that my husband was falling in love with my son as much as me, and that he wanted to be a father as well as a partner. I was the first woman he dated with a child, and yet he managed to develop a strong and committed bond with my son in very short time.
Now we are married with a 2 year daughter, and you wouldn’t know that my son has a different biological dad based on the way my husband treats our children.
Good luck!
I am a single parent with full custody of my son. I have tried to date a couple of women that didn’t have kids. When it became apparent that they weren’t interested in kids I ended it. Most after just a couple of dates, and they didn’t meet my son.
I definitely agree with the comments above that she should talk frankly with him about the relationship and parenting. It won’t be easy as they have been dating quite a while, but it needs to be discussed and possibly some hard decisions have to be made.
Twitter @ http://lovebabz.blogspot.com
I think a “Come To Jesus” talk (deep conversation) is in order. Otherwise to continue to date him and feel his “annoyance” about your child is a waste of your time. You and your child is a package deal. Love me…love my child. Either he wants kids and likes them or he doesn’t. Doesn’t make him a bad person…just wrong for you. There is no convincing in love. Your child should not have to be sold/auditioned for anyone.
Lovebabz´s last blog ..TRUE LOVE TUESDAY: CHEERING MYSELF ON!
Twitter @ solomother
@lovebabz I love the analogy. Come to Jesus, indeed.
All of us are talking as though single dads are a better catch for us single moms. I say nuh-uh. I was in a relationship with a man who had two kids, and it was finally painfully apparent that the family dynamic would always be his kids and then my kid, and he wasn’t making any effort to assimilate my kid into his life. Rather, the KoE annoyed him. And my son, sensing that, doubled his efforts to get this man’s attention. The day that man got between me and my son an started yelling at him? Was the last time we saw him. It was plain as day that some day, some how, that man was going to hit my kid. I asked him to go to counseling, either with me or independently, to work out his anger issues. He absolutely refused, which made it pretty clear where my side of the smashfamily stood. Out in the cold. We ran.
If a woman can’t talk to her man about kids, then there’s not a long-term, integrated relationship there.
Solomother´s last blog ..Bad kid or bad sugar?
Twitter @ maryileen72
Honestly as defensive as I get about my daughter and us being a package deal, I have to say that I think this issue is more about the relationship than the kid. Long distance relationships are tough. You can’t expect him to commit to the package if he hasn’t committed to the relationship. Try moving closer…at least in the same area. Cut him loose if he doesn’t like that idea.
Twitter @ andthedamnkids
I have just lost interest in men that haven’t been interested in my daughter. She is the biggest part of my life and if they aren’t interested in that, then frankly, they aren’t interested in me. If after a couple of dates they haven’t shown interest in her (even before they meet her they have to be asking about her and trying to find out how she is doing and who she is) then I’m mentally/emotionally done.
I don’t think that a single dad is necessarily perfect for a single mom. There are plenty of men with no kids out there who would love to be a part of a ready made family. I know many single moms who have married men with no children and the kids are put first. Sounds like this guy is just not in the same place as she is. As single moms, we have very little time as it is. I refuse to waste it on someone who isn’t interested in the most important thing to me.
Semi-Hippie Single Mama´s last blog ..I hate when rumors are true…..getting laid off.
Twitter @ tsquest
I really have nothing more to add than simply agreeing with this: COMMUNICATE and do it HONESTLY.
You can’t expect a man to warm up instantly to children. And besides, he may feel that her having a child is taking away time from him. He may feel resentful to be 2nd in her life (or 3rd if she’s putting herself first!).
Allow him to give his honest thoughts and don’t begrudge him if he isn’t into playing daddy. That just means it isn’t a good match.
Hope all goes well.
T´s last blog ..Pity party
Twitter @ _katarena_
I think that 18 months is a long time to be in a relationship with someone who doesn’t show interest in your child. She should definitely sit down and talk to him about this but I get the feeling if the talk hasn’t happened yet it’s because she knows deep down how the conversation is going to go. You have to go with your gut and get out of a relationship that isn’t the right fit for you and your child. You’re missing out on the opportunity to be with someone who appreciates both of you and truly makes you happy.
Kate´s last blog ..Intervention
Tinamarie Bernard: Thanks so much for sharing your story. Striking words …”partner and father”. What a tribute to your husband when you say that your children are literally indistinguishable to him.
Like most other commenters, if it’s been this long and he’s still a bit annoyed by the presence of the little one and the subject hasn’t been broached… I’d say end it.
Both are living in denial, to some degree. I’ve recently broken up with my “soul mate” — with the exception of he just could not, would not make anything other than superficial attempts to bond with my daughter — everything was great when we were alone. When little B was around, threatened by his infrequent presence (he tended to visit when she was at school, or asleep) she, in her willful way, became uber-challenging. And he just was not up to the challenge.
I’m getting over the feeling of “us” not being enough for him to take this on – it could be so good. But I know that it’s not me, it’s him. The guy has to realize that single moms are a package deal.
Sorry to say, end it.
Twitter @ CulminatingLife
First thought with men who don’t have kids, is tough by it’s nature. It literally takes having your own kids to get it.
Unless he is willing to put some effort into it.
18 months? That is more than long enough to really get the idea. And if he even makes a small attempt at trying to learn about her, and treating her as a possibly his own, he would of in no time melted and really became attached.
He’s not really trying. And that would be concern. And then the next thought would be that he will grow into her, especially if he has his own child, right? wrong. that’s a misconception. He will end up being more attached to his own child than her. And jipping her out of having the ideal father role in her life.
This guy needs to first open up his heart to her daughter.
Travis´s last blog ..This Thought Brought To You By Fry Sauce
Twitter @ BigLittleWolf
There is a lot of missing information here for any of us to give a credible impression, for example her age, his age, if they’ve discussed this issue (18 months is a long time to be together, particularly if they’re both in their mid or late 30s; if they’re in their mid 20s, it’s a different story), the nature of the long distance relationship (and if either is in a position or desires to close that mileage gap). And plenty more.
But I’m a firm believer in one’s gut feeling. We need to listen to our inner voices, and even those impressions we sense that we cannot articulate.
It’s tough enough being a solo mother. Having to deal with tiptoeing around the relationship between a so-called partner and one’s own child seems foolish.
BigLittleWolf´s last blog ..Do you know your body’s rhythms?
Twitter @ mom2themonsters
I meant to comment on this earlier, but somehow I forgot to. I think she should just communicate her feelings to him. Ask him boldly how he feels about her child and “us” being family….I personally wouldn’t even let it go that long (18 months) without him state his intentions and how he felt about my children. I kind of agree with everyone else after 18 months of dating, if he hasn’t shown interest, he probably isn’t and just imagine if you decided to marry him. What kind of life would that be for your child?
Mommy to the Monsters´s last blog ..Closing the Doors
I have yet to read anyone asking this single mom if she is even letting him be interested in HER child. I find some single moms to be quite territorial when it comes to their kids and almost force any romantic interest to be on the outside with their nose pressed up against the glass.
And does this guy want to be a step dad? Or does he want to be a dad,but isn’t getting the impression he will ever be allowed to actually parent this kid? I also disagree with the idea that the kids come first,because without parents who love/respect and are passionate about each other putting themselves first as a couple our kids suffer regardless.Just in a different way.
Being told the highest i would rank in her heart is 4th after her 3 kids would send me running for the hills.
I’ve dated 2 men who’ve met the kids, and what dramatically different responses. The Guy #1 was much like yours, indifferent, seemingly annoyed, but not never said outright that he didn’t like the kids. No “warm fuzzies”. The kids sensed it, and knew he “just tolerated” them. Guy #2, never married, no kids, 40something, told me flat out he never wanted kids and wasn’t a kid guy, but when they met, everything just clicked and he dove right into the hands-on thing (even though I tried to discourage it.) Warm fuzzies all around.
You just know. Go with your gut instinct.
Twitter @ msjennixoxo
I had a relationship with someone who didn’t have kids a while ago. It lasted several months. He was one of those people that never saw himself as being able to accept the idea of having kids of his own one day. After hanging out with my two girls, he completely changed his mind.
He LOVED my two girls. It was also semi-long distance [2 hours away]. He would visit me every weekend, and I would go see him solo once a month. One the weekends he came to see me, he always included my girls. We went to the zoo, the aquarium, the park. He would play with them for hours. My girls were never uncomfortable around him, and he was never uncomfortable either.
There was no “warm up” time needed. To me, if they aren’t comfortable with my kids, then they’re not going to someone I want to spend my time with.
So my advice? Breakup with him.
Jenni´s last blog ..‘The Alone Feeling’
Thanks so much for all the helpful advice! We’ve had the talk in the beginning of the relationship and in the fall that I needed my daughter to be more included. Someone said if the relationship wasn’t long distance, it probably would’ve ended long ago…. I think so as well. So his response is that he knows we’re a package deal and understands my concern with my daughter feeling left out. He said he is accepting the fact that I have a child. It just takes time, but he’s getting past it. I’m going to have the talk again and this may be the last talk. I don’t want my personal life and family life to be seperate. And at this point, I don’t see it ever being together with him. I guess what makes it hard because we really get along and I truely love him, but I don’t feel like a family when we’re all together. I’m not making him out to be a monster… please he is sweet. I just feel that after 18 months, he should have more of an interest. I don’t think she is in his thoughts at all. Maybe there is more to it, I’m going to have the talk and keep you posted with results. Thanks for helping me think through it and it will help me.
OMG… Jenni, so on the money! That’s exactly what I mean. When I bring my daughter up to visit him, he has no agenda and makes no effort to make her happy. I mean… it’s the little things. It’s so easy to please a 3 yr old and you make their day by the simpliest things. Shouldn’t it come naturally?? That’s what I feel it lacking.
I keep making excuses when I know what the right thing to do is… =(
i am dating a guy who have no kids he keeps calling my son spoil …because me son is 3 years old and …just learning to sleep in his bed causeof or situation in our last place one bedroom… he keeps sayingmy lil boy is spoil and he should not come in my room late he needs to stay in a child place hmmm… am so mad but like him ?
I’m going to throw in my viewpoint from the opposite side of the spectrum. I’m a childless woman who’s dating a divorced man with a daughter. As someone who hasn’t spent a lot of time around children over the last 6 or 7 years, I was extremely apprehensive about meeting her. But like Jeff said, interacting and getting along with a 3 or 4 year old isn’t all that difficult. I wasn’t – and am still not – all that interested in having kids of my own, but I adore my boyfriend’s daughter and we warmed up to each other almost immediately.
If it’s been 18 months, and he hasn’t come around yet or at least made attempts to engage with her, I feel like the likelihood of him changing his attitude towards the daughter is unlikely to change. From a single and childless standpoint, I don’t think it takes that long to determine if the “package deal relationship” is something you’re ok with or not.
Lauren: Your point is well made. Of course, we’re sorry to hear that things are not going well. Thanks for sharing your life with us. Please visit us again soon.
@ Dr. Leah
Thank you. But, what do you mean “things are not going well”?
Lauren: I obviously misread. Please accept my apology. Are you on Twitter?
Oh, no worries! I was just confused for a minute.
Hi, My name is Crystal and Well I been engaged for 3yrs now with my fiance. He has had a kid unplanned due to a condom being broke and was tore away from his from his own child becuz he was mixed. His child life was not the best either with his alcoholic dad either and abuse.. I also gave him the benefit of the doubt.. that he would vent to me and open up to me bout anything and everything. Honesty is the best policy and trust and and #1) Communication which we had til we moved to Wi to help my mom. But I have read all these posts bout dating a guy or girl that dont have kids or raised kids in paticular he never raised his son but has one.That his ex adopted to her parents. Anyhow I feel now that he connected with my daughter since she was 5 mo. old and that he got attached but at the same time my son was 6 and it was new for him and he has adhd/odd and anxiety. My son and my fiance never seem to get along they had there times but it was never great you know.. like some of these post said he tolerated my son and out up with it. I feel that is what the last two years have been. He tolerates my kids for the sake of me and our relationship, and i feel awful I let it go this far.He knew in the beginning and I knew in the beginnin he played guitar and wanted to start a band and i was find maybe not at first but I accepted it and I thought he accepted taking the role of step dad. I feel the last year he makes every excuse to not spend time with my kids our as a family.. and that his bFF the other band member thinks I treat him badly but I am only trying to protect my kids.. They dont deserve someone like that.. he yells at my son becuz he is defiant becuz of his disorder.. and gets frusterated..and then he blames it on my and my kids that he never gets to practive for his band and his music.. and we say in the beginning we are a team.. and also when i met him he had nowhere to go and well I took him in becuz that was the type of person i was after dating him for a month or so.. I just feel i gave my all and he has gave nothing..I dont get the warm fuzzies ever when he is around them. My son feels it too. Now my daughter that is 3yrs old barely wants to be around him.. we argue in front of them and i am working my hardest not too, but he will start it or say something to my son or daughter i feel was not fair or should be tolerated.. I know I am not perfect.. but I feel I should end it.. what should I do, Ia m scared cuz i wasted all my time to someone that just tolerated my kids and put up with them this whole time just for me and he is just as done as I am probably.. I love my kids and I think they deserve that becuz i let this go on to long becuz i let blindself let it all pass me.. I guess I was hoping it was becuz of my sons behavior problem but I cant let my son take allt he blame..i dont think he is ready for the long long haul..??? any suggestions please please help!!
Crystal: Thanks for sharing your story with us. You’re right to listen to your heart. When someone is not ready for the long haul …wishing on our part won’t make it so. Keep in touch, please.
I am in the same situation, but its only been 3 months and I am already thinking of dumping him for now warming up to my son. However, I guess its too early to judge him plus he does want to get married and does want kids. I just fear when we have a child together he will treat his child the best and treat my child like, well, a step-child. I would want him to love them both the same, but I guess its too much to ask atleast this early in the game.