What does “more space” really mean?

When single guys — who are dating single moms — write to us, we’re always fascinated by their perspective on what can be tricky relationship territory.

So, when we got an emotional email from “Dr. C” — a physician — we asked him if we could share his story with you.  Dr. C. is a single guy with no kids who has been dating a single mom with a nine-year-old daughter for six months. He says that he really loves his girlfriend — and adores her daughter — but every time they start to get really close,  this single mom says she needs “some space.”

This threesome has a great time together. The little girl has been very articulate, however,  about the difference between “friend” and “boyfriend/”  From her perspective,  “boyfriends” come and go; yet “friends” are forever.  And she’s  crystal clear that she wants Dr. C. in the “friend” category.

Clearly, Mom is fearful and hesitant about  getting emotionally close to another man as part of a committed relationship. (Her ex was  abusive, and she left him when her daughter was a baby).  Her daughter is looking to love and trust “forever,” but it’s hard to know what unspoken feelings may lurk beneath her words.

Things are starting to get (more) complicated: This summer, this single mom told Dr. C.  — again — that she needed a month apart to think about things. In the meantime, Dr. C. decided to go on a lunch date with another woman — “against my better judgment, but due to a friend’s urging mostly” — and this single mom briefly dated another guy.

Dr. C. still loves this single mom.  But, she keeps asking for “more space.”

“My friends tell me to give up and move on, say Dr. C.  “And they tell me that I’m a glutton for punishment.”

This physician is looking for a “second opinion” from YOU . . .

Is this single mom’s repeated request for “more space” a clear signal they have no future?

Or should this single guy hang in there and give her “more space” to heal and learn to trust again?


~~~

(Photo courtesy of Ashenzil)



Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

No related posts.

Comments

30 Responses to “What does “more space” really mean?”
  1. Nancy says:

    Sorry Dr. C … she’s “just not into you”. NEXT

  2. Avigail74 says:

    Twitter @
    Doesn’t matter—it’s much better to be with someone who wants you as much as you want him/her.
    Avigail74´s last blog ..The Four Day Trip My ComLuv Profile

  3. ofthesea says:

    Twitter @
    I kinda side with Avigail on this one. He should have one serious talk with her and tell her how he feels regarding their future together, then ask her for an answer. he should not be hanging on there forever, and she must realise she may be hurting her chances with a good man who loves her and her daughter.

    If she say “no way Jose” can someone give this guy my email address?
    ofthesea´s last blog ..Reason 56 – It’s work if I say it is My ComLuv Profile

  4. jessica says:

    Twitter @
    sounds to me like the single mom is fearful of getting hurt so she’s trying to end it before things are totally serious. but its not fair to the Guy to be put in this circle of not knowing what she wants. I say let her have her space and he can date in the meantime, he might find someone who is deserving of his love.

  5. Lovebabz says:

    Twitter @
    It’s not what she says…it’s what she does. She is telling him by her actions: “I am not that into you” It’s hard to hear, because she is leading him on by not telling him directly and clearly that she does not want this relationship to move forward. Now He can spend his time trying to convince her that He is “The ONE” but she doesn’t feel it. Move ON! Fiind someone who celebrates the beauty in YOU!
    Lovebabz´s last blog ..BURGER &amp BEERS TO YOU! My ComLuv Profile

  6. Stacey says:

    Twitter @
    Actions aren’t matching up with words. She’s just not that into you. You can sit down and talk to her to just ask her if she’s acting out of fear. But don’t be surprised if you don’t get a straight answer. It’s not fair to get the whiplash she’s giving you. It’s hard to move on when the other person won’t let you, but you need to do it. Good luck!

  7. Twitter @
    I’m torn here. First I must say she has some healing to do first, obviously. Coming from an abusive relationship as well that ended with a final divorce over 5 years ago, I can relate. It is tough to trust again. BUT, he should give her that space and date other people. She asked for it. Perhaps by staying in touch sporadically (not daily not even weekly) will let her know he is still interested but he should continue to make other female friendships and look elsewhere as she has inclined with the “space” request.

    If after a couple months or more of only touching base and briefly – she makes no notion of trying to get back with Dr. C. – then, sadly she may not be the one.
    Katherine SOLO dot MOM´s last blog ..My new favorite My ComLuv Profile

  8. alley says:

    Twitter @
    Wow, sounds like he’s put up with a lot. It sounds like she either isn’t ready to be tied down to just one guy and wants to date some more or she’s got trust and emotional intimacy issues.

    either way, if I were him, I’d back off from her maybe for a while, or maybe for ever. I’d let her know I cared about her and wanted to be part of her and her little girl’d life, and then I’d back away. And stay away until SHE called.
    alley´s last blog ..The return of responsibility My ComLuv Profile

  9. Dr. Leah says:

    Stacey: Thanks for chiming in. It does seem that Dr. C is getting a bit of a whiplash.

  10. Swati says:

    Twitter @
    Hmmm – I don’t think it’s all black and white – sounds like the single mom has been through a lot. That said, the one month on/one month off thing is too rough emotionally to really go through again and again…I would part company and see if you want to reach out to her in about a year – or see if your paths just cross. She may have legitimate things to work through – and there isn’t anything you can do about it and it isn’t fair to you to be on again/off again. I would say move on, but with compassion take it from someone who had a lot to work though too).

    Swati
    Swati´s last blog ..How to Ask For a Raise at Work My ComLuv Profile

  11. Dr. C says:

    Thanks for the feedback everyone. Problem is, if I ever truly felt that “she isn’t really into me” I’d have given up long ago. There have been too many other signs that she IS into me that I can’t ignore.

    I work in a group practice owned by someone else and the woman I love (let’s call her Lucy and her daughter Stacy) is an assistant in the practice. When we first met neither of us could stop gazing at one another. In fact, we both got disciplined by the management for simply smiling at each other… okay, it was every time we saw each other and it was obviously electric. We were told that if we wanted to keep our jobs we needed to look at the floor every time we passed one another. That went on for two weeks and then things got back to normal and we learned how to work together without attracting attention to ourselves. That was over a year ago.

    Another time, I point blank asked Lucy… I said, “Sometimes I wonder if you’re really that into me or not. If you just say the word, I’ll back off.” Her response was strongly negative to that idea, meaning she didn’t want me to back off.

    Recently, when Stacy told me she wanted her mom and me to always be friends, she took me aside and told me this privately. This was the night before I took them to the airport to fly to Spokane to be with Lucy’s parents. Lucy was coming back in a week and Stacy was staying an extra two weeks to visit with her grandparents. She was concerned that I would try to become mommy’s boyfriend during the two weeks she was away. It confused me at the time, so I wanted to speak with Lucy about it… I figured sometimes a kid will repeat what she’s heard her mother say, and if that was the case, and all Lucy ever wanted was to be friends, I should know. Well, when Lucy found out what Stacy said, she became noticeably upset with her daughter and said, “You did NOT hear that from me young lady… I’ve always said that Chuck and I are friends for NOW, and you know that.” Neither of us realized at the time what 9-year-old Stacy was really getting at until later. After some reflection, I realized she probably was saying she wanted me to stick around, and when I told Lucy what I was thinking she agreed.

    These are just a few examples of instances where Lucy has had ample opportunity to say something that would deter me, but she’s never even hinted that she wanted me gone long term. She just says that she needs to go through one-on-one counseling to deal with the physical and sexual abuse from her ex (who stalked and threatened to kill her and beat her in front of Stacy… so much so that she had to move three states away and move into a temporary home for abused women for several months). I think she wants to be able to have a relationship, but she can’t focus on both her healing and a relationship at the same time, especially when she’s dealing with difficult issues that she needs to learn to trust me with before revealing the deeper aspects of her past with me.

    And when she asked for space, I’ll admit, I was being very “relationship oriented” and not really understanding her need for wholeness first. And when she went out with another guy, she told me all about it, including that she didn’t even find him attractive and she went out with him after, and in response to, my telling her about my lunch date with another woman.

    Does this info provide any other thoughts? I do so appreciate everyone’s input!

  12. dbombsmom says:

    Honestly I would say this sounds like it should be an on-again off-again relationship and not a “dating for this period of time” one. Not because you all don’t want to be together, but the simple time/energy issue. It sounds like she has unresolved past/individual issues that take a lot of time to resolve and become the new normal. I would back off but keep in touch. Timing is everything.

  13. Dr. Leah says:

    dbombsmom: *whew* So right …timing is everything. Thanks for chiming in.

  14. T says:

    Twitter @
    PTSD.

    I dealt with someone with this same issue. Too scared. Didn’t want to let go but too frightened to move forward. It, indeed, does feel like whiplash. One of the questions I was frequently asked, because I too was “relationship oriented”, was “Why does it have to be all or nothing?!?”

    Well, that relationship ended precisely for that reason. I couldn’t be with him and wait patiently while he sorted through his fears and couldn’t move forward with me. I waited and waited and *sigh*… you get it.

    Define what YOU want, Dr. C.

    There is no harm is moving forward and staying in touch, as others recommended. After all, this little girl wants you to be in their lives forever. Perhaps friendship is the best way to do that.

    I would definitely have a discussion with her about your feelings. Let her know that you are there for her but you also feel very strongly about your own needs. You should honor yourself. It will be best for all of you if you do that.

    “Never make anyone a priority when you are only an option.”

    She has to decide if she’s willing to trust that you’ll hold her hand through her sorting out these post traumatic issues or if she really desires to sort through them alone.
    T´s last blog ..Loyalty- Communication and the blog My ComLuv Profile

  15. TeeH says:

    I know Dr C. personally, and have for several years. He is a close friend of mine of which I have few in my geographical area due to my recent interstate moves. Anyway, ironically, I am in a similar situation as he! I think what breaks my heart and Dr. C’s is that we care immensely about these women in our life. We feel we are right for them – can help them – but we are willing to move on. We feel they don’t see how good we would be for them! We both feel, but esp. me, that it has been immensely unfair for the women in question to have such little communication after such intense professions of love and adoration, etc etc. (In my situation, I have had sporadic text msgs but the last phone conversation w/”Misty” was June 18.) It just defies logic. I feel *I* am more ready to move on than Dr. C. (I have this bad feeling that as soon as I meet someone w/whom I have mutual romantic interest, Misty will be calling me for sure to try to win me back). Anyway, any feedback would be appreciated. NOTE to all women: Be honest and communicative with any man who remotely deserves or whom you have been intimate with. It’s not only fair, it’s your duty as a human.

  16. TeeH says:

    P.S. In both Dr. C’s and my cases, it just seems odd that they REALLY seem to want us to wait it out – that they value us greatly – but, like a previous poster said, their actions have shown otherwise. If these women were “liars” or “manipulators” we would move on readily. But they are not. Therefore, logic would dictate there IS hope for future “reconciliation” . . . when the “timing” is right.
    P.P.S. If anyone reading this believes in prayer, they will surely understand how this situation is one that has required some of the most intense prayers of my life!

  17. momof1 says:

    It’s completely up to you to decide what you’re willing to accept in this relationship. I can understand both sides of this relationship.

    IMO, she has a lot of baggage to deal with. Considering it’s been 9 years, though, I’d like to think she has the strength and determination to work past that. That is part of the struggle, the other part may be that she’s been doing th single mom thing on herown for almost a decade.What happens if the relationship goes sour?

    I think Dr C should tell her what his expectations are before “just moving on”. He sounds like a great guy, and I hope she realizes this before it’s too late.

  18. Sara says:

    Twitter @
    I get frustrated reading about things like this. I agree totally with the woman who said that timing is everything. The timing is obviously not right here and toss in a bit of ‘she’s just not that into you’ and the answer is move on. I always believe what my mom told me in my teens – if it’s meant to be, it will be, but maybe not now. Both of you seem like great, sensitive, men. There are many amazing, emotionally available women out there – time to move on and find someone else who can appreciate you. While not manipulative, perhaps your ladies just like to know that someone is there. I hate to say it but we women, and many men I know, can be like that.
    Sara´s last blog ..Back to the Grindor is it Back From the Grind My ComLuv Profile

  19. T says:

    Twitter @
    I agree with Sara. Both of you men are available for a relationship and longing for one with emotionally unavailable women. It seems that this is a common problem among mostly women. Hence the reason I love this website so much: http://www.baggagereclaim.co.uk/

    But just as equally, there are emotionally unavailable women out there too!

    Honestly, I have been in a few long term relationships, including a 13 year marriage, and every time, the relationship just “happened”. It didn’t take work to get it started. It didn’t take one of us feeling something that the other one didn’t. It was a MUTUAL wanting to be together.

    Otherwise, it was simply unrequited love.

    Of course these women don’t want you two to go away. Of course they realize what wonderful men you are. They, more than likely, do not feel worthy of what you offer them and so… they keep you at arm’s length, dangling carrots and leaving you crumbs.

    Don’t you both deserve more than crumbs?
    T´s last blog ..I just realized My ComLuv Profile

  20. jessica says:

    Twitter @
    Can I have your number? Lol

  21. TeeH says:

    Thanks for the feedback. I am trying to move on, while trying to understand “Misty” at the same time (the reader should keep in mind that we have known each other for over 5 years, and a strong mutual attraction has ALWAYS been there).

    The other point is that I’ve been with a few awesome women in the past. I feel I gave up too soon when “trouble” hit, and, frankly, regret it. Looking back, at least 2 of those women would have made great long-term partners, if not wives. I’m trying to not make the same mistake here. I’m trying to learn from my mistakes. I believe these days, too many people give up too easily on their partners – they want/expect everything to be smooth sailing all the time, which is highly unrealistic.

    Also, I want to be with someone whom I adore – not someone who is just “tolerable”. Maybe that’s my mistake? Do I need to look for women who are “steady” but not “exciting”? Ones I like and feel compassion for, but who are not “a thrill a minute” to me? (It does kind of seem like the women who I am “less” excited about seem to be more attached to me.)

    @T: you may be right, or you may be dead wrong. Relationships sometimes take work. And Misty has professed over and over again how much she adores me, and how she “loves me more than you know”.

  22. T says:

    Twitter @
    I SOOOO agree about being with someone whom you adore. And that someone should adore you just as much.

    I agree that relationships take work and you shouldn’t ditch it at the first sign of trouble. But I also agree that both parties should be trying to make it work.

    I also agree that a relationship means discussing the future, looking forward together, determining that you want the same things, that you do see yourselves together, as a loving, couple, sharing secrets and plans and pains…

    Do you and Misty both agree on this?
    T´s last blog ..I just realized My ComLuv Profile

  23. maryanne says:

    Twitter @
    Before you give up or moves on or “hangs in there” let’s consider a few things first; 1) What do you want? What exactly does this future you have in mind look like and are both you and her ideas of this future compatible. In other words do you want a commitment? For her not to emotionally abandoned you ? You may need to earnestly investigate your intentions as these will be a key factor in the foundation for the rest of the relationships success.

    Next you wants to stay mindful while considering your goals and desires of your current girlfriends capacity for intimacy. Is she aware of her tendancy, has she done any “work” on herself? Been to therapy, have a self care or spiritual practice? Her “tool belt” and skill set will need to be considered if you want to accomplish greater intimacy.

    And – it looks like you’ve already identified a strong pattern; the closer you get the more space she needs. Has she identified this pattern? And how easily can you guys talk about such things. Responsible communication is also key to healthy sustainable and fulfilling relationships. Tough to create intimacy with someone who has a habit of clamming up or taking themelseves away rather than discussing , relating and exploring what needs attention.

    I think once you get more clarity as to wants, and what your partner is capable of, you will have your answer to all the questions including whether or not you are a glutton for punishment.

    Blessings!

  24. Lisa says:

    All I can say is I WISH I had someone like Dr. T or his friend. I have just the opposite problem with the man in my life ( I think he’s in my life, this week, not sure about next week!)

    Lucy shouldn’t settle but realistically she should understand that good men who want a relationship don’t come around everyday. She should find a way to work through her issues(its been a decade) and keep Dr. T in her life.

  25. TeeH says:

    @T: you said “discussing the future, looking forward together, determining that you want the same things, that you do see yourselves together, as a loving, couple, sharing secrets and plans and pains… Do you and Misty agree on this?” Answer: we talked about that kind of stuff until she got so stressed out from being a first-year school teacher (who really do have a stressful job, esp in the state we live in), and had to go into counseling for depression and anxiety. Ever since then, there has been a lot of silence.

  26. T says:

    Twitter @
    TeeH… Just something to observe and think about. Listen to your heart and soul.

    Honor yourself.

    Good luck!
    T´s last blog ..Our love- as illustrated by Looney Tunes! My ComLuv Profile

  27. Dr. C says:

    Hey all!

    On Lucy’s birthday I left her flowers and matching necklaces for her and Stacy on her doorstep. She loved them! We went out last weekend and had an awesome time. We made plans for this weekend and next weekend, so we’ll see. I think she really appreciated the fact that I took the time to try to understand her when things got tough between us… and that I hung in there and am still here for her now. She and Stacy both acted like they missed me SO much… and maybe I shouldn’t say “acted” because they seemed totally genuine.

    Dr. C

  28. Hil says:

    I read every post by everyone (and I loved it!!!)….one thing no one brought up was this: Dr. C and TeeH, what is it in you that is attracted to somewhat distant women? Are those women more of a challenge, more to work for?

    I really agree about the scads of emotionally available women that are out there…but maybe those types of women aren’t as attractive as someone more…aloof, shall we say. I know you guys treat these women well and honestly, as long as they don’t have to put forth much effort, they’re gonna keep letting you do that bec it’s easy and convenient.

    How do I know of this? I had a guy just like the two of you who abs adored me and did evthing he could to get my love and attention. The diff is, I was in college, running a household and prod’g/dir’g a local tv show while raising two boys all by myself and had very little energy left over for the r’ship. He knew what he was walkin’ into, yet he depended on spending time with me for his fulfillment and livelihood (is this you C and T?)…finally, one day, he decided what he wanted: more of his partner’s time and he walked away.

    Y’all can go along with these women and accept their 20% contribution or leave. It’s that simple. Get quiet, go within, decide what you reeeeeeally desire – and it’s not any of our places to judge you – and stand firm.

    Loves, Hil

  29. Dr. Leah says:

    Hil: We appreciate your candor in sharing your own similar relationship experience. Lots of truth in what you share …thanks SO much for joining our conversation. Please visit us again soon!

  30. Dr. C says:

    Hil, Let me ask you a question… If you had SO much on your plate (or large overfilled tray), and you were really into this guy… why not consider how much easier life would have been if you had someone beside you helping to carry it? Was he good with your boys? Do you think if you’d hung in there you would have eventually made time for him? Or was there some other underlying reason that kept you away? Or was it just the busyness of life? I sometimes wonder why women with kids get to feeling so overwhelmed with the busyness of life that they overlook their kid(s) need for a father in the home… and the improvement that could take place in all their lives. In my case, if Lucy wanted to quit working completely and be there for Stacy, she could, if we were married. And she’d live in a beautiful home instead of a dinky apartment. Or if she wanted to work only part-time and get off when school lets out, she could, because we both work for the same company and they would allow just about anything to keep me there. (Not that I’m planning on going anywhere.)

    It’s not that I depend on Lucy for my fulfillment and livelihood. I have plenty of friends that want to do things with me. And I’ve written two books and am working on another, so I can keep myself busy and entertained. I just happen to see some very beautiful qualities in Lucy that I don’t see often. Namely, her demure and pleasant nature, and the fact that we instantly connected when we met over 1-1/2 years ago now.

    I don’t know… what were you thinking when you let a guy who abs adored u slip away?

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled