When a dad is downgraded to family friend

by  
Filed under Single Dads

We’ve had some incredibly frank conversations about co-parenting here. You’ve told us emphatically that co-parenting is a constant struggle. And you’ve confessed that sometimes you genuinely envy solo parents. You’ve also done some serious soul searching when it comes to co-parenting – or not — with your kids’ bio-dads.

When we received this email from the wife of a man who was caught in an outrageous co-parenting dilemma, it really struck home:  co-parenting is endlessly and uniquely complicated. And everyone involved has a different perspective and personal agenda.

We’re anxious to hear your reaction to this co-parenting quandary. Frankly, we’re shaking our heads.

“My husband and I are attempting to co-parent peacefully his three year-old daughter with her mother and her soon-to-be husband,”  this wife explains. “My husband and this woman were never married. ” (Hmm…this woman? That caught our attention, too.)

Although they broke up when she was pregnant, her husband sued for paternity. He voluntarily began to send child support payments, added the child to his health insurance plan, started a college fund, and sought scheduled and frequent parenting time. And then he met and fell in love with his wife.

From this wife’s perspective, the whole situation has been a nightmare. The wife feels that there’s so much animosity between this child’s parents because the mother never resolved her feelings of disappointment that this failed relationship meant that she’d raise her child as a single mother.

This single mom wanted to co-parent strictly on her own terms. And she insisted that Dad conform to whatever time schedule she determined. Eventually, her persistence wore Dad down, and he made a fateful and foolish decision:

After almost two years of this endless battling, Dad took a six-month break from the parenting time schedule. He thought that a cooling off period would ease the mutual resentment and anger. Sadly, Dad now recognizes that this was a poor decision.

When the parenting time resumed, Dad and his wife were astonished to discover that his daughter had been told her mother’s soon to-be husband was her father. Dad is now downgraded  to “family friend.” This little girl now calls her mother and her soon to-be husband “Mommy and Daddy.” Poignantly, she recently asked during parenting time what name to call her father.

Dad and his wife feel she is too young to understand the concept of step-parents. So, they simply tell her that she has two sets of parents who love her. In the meantime, Mom and her soon-to-be-husband refuse to discuss the situation with Dad and his wife.

So,  that’s the situation in a nutshell. This dad and his wife simply don’t know how best to handle this outrageous co-parenting stand-off.

What’s the best approach when a non-custodial parent is downgraded to family friend?

Is there a way to tell the truth to a three year-old without destroying her trust in her mother?

Or is it best to forgo the drama and explanation for now?

Should this dad wait until his daughter is older before fully explaining he’s actually her father?

~~~

Photo via Flickr: nokuckle

Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

No related posts.

Comments

13 Responses to “When a dad is downgraded to family friend”
  1. Twitter @
    In my opinion, he needs to insist that this child know he’s her dad. He doesn’t deserve this “downgrading”. Children all over the world have two dads and/or two moms, and this little girl doesn’t have to be any different. Just because her mom has her the majority of the time doesn’t mean she gets to all all the shots, particularly when, from the way this story was relayed, the dad has been doing his part to support his daughter financially and be there for her.
    Momma Sunshine´s last blog ..The Care and Feeding of Fear – Part One My ComLuv Profile

  2. Jessica says:

    Twitter @
    It’s obvious to me that the Bio-Mom is harboring ill feelings toward the Bio-Dad still after 3 years. That issue needs be addressed because she is taking it out on her child. Bio-Dad needs to get his legal rights for the parenting schedule and both of them must abide by it, the Bio-Mom doesn’t have the choice to play with scheduled parenting time, that’s called Contempt. It’s sounds to me like there is immaturity on both sides and the issues need to be dealt with or there will be one confused little girl out in the world.

    No matter what happens, Bio-Dad cannot take a 6 month break again. That just added fuel to the fire, you don’t get breaks when you are a parent. Suck it up.

    And the 3 year old does not understand Biology yet, so forgo that conversation. She knows who loves her, that’s what matters.

  3. Kia says:

    Twitter @
    I completely agree with Jessica. The mom is bitter and the father screwed up by taking a break. He should have gone to court instead but moving forward he needs court ordered custody arrangments, and because he is involved the little girl should be told he’s her father. She’s got 2 sets of parents. Not a foreign concept to a 3 year old.
    Kia´s last blog ..Flat ironing all that takes a long ass time My ComLuv Profile

  4. Steve says:

    Twitter @
    Parental alienation is illegal as it is a form of abuse. This father needs to go back to court and put a stop to it. He should also press for a formal custody agreement as others have mentioned and obviously his daughter needs to know that he’s her father. I’ve heard of courts ordering parents not to refer to step parents as mom or dad but it’s very difficult to enforce. I also agree that giving up is nearly always a bad idea. As more fathers press for joint custody and more are actively involved in parenting their children those decisions are being handled much differently than in the past and dads aren’t always relegated to every other weekend anymore. The most important thing is to be involved. Get to know teachers, care givers, doctors, anyone in the child’s life and make sure everyone knows how important your child is to you through your actions as well as your words.

  5. Brian says:

    First: there are no ‘breaks’ as a parent. Suck it up and move on.

    Second: parents don’t get to make unilateral decisions. If bio-Mom can’t act appropriately, get the courts involved. Come to a plan of action then follow it.

    My ex-wife and I get along famously after our divorce. She can still tick me off in seconds and I’m sure the reverse is true, too. Bottom line is that we as a couple are over. Move on. We as parents live on and must cooperate. No two ways about it.

    So…
    Step 1: if bio-Mom can’t step up, go through the courts.
    Step 2: never be absent from your child’s life… they don’t understand.
    Step 3: no matter how angry you are, never ever speak ill of or angrily about the other parent to or around the child. It’s not their fault and don’t need to be a part of that battle.

    Speaking for myself, being my son’s Dad is my most treasured role. I’ll let nobody… and I mean nobody… demote me from either the role or title.

  6. alley says:

    Twitter @
    Wow, what a mess. First, I am glad he admits that “taking a break” from co-parenting was a bad idea.

    I LIKE the, you have two sets of parents who love you, approach. I DISLIKE, that the dad has been removed by the mom, that isn’t fair or right of her. I can see her marrying and the step dad and daughter building a relationship to the point that she calls him “dad”, but this isn’t what’s happened.

    I suggest that the dad get some legal standing with visitation, take mom back to court, negotiate hard, and then stick to it. Allowing her to bully him was a bad idea, but he can stop it.

    Second, while at court, try to address the whole, he’s not your dad thing, there are some places that look very unfavorably on an attempt to break the parent-child relationship. I’m not saying try to get full or physical custody, but assert your rights.

    Third, realize that three year olds are very suggestable, and just because she’s using the work “dad” doesn’t mean she’s got those feelings. Also realize, that it is very important that the daughter not know that her sets of parents aren’t happy with each other.

    I hope things work out well for all involved.
    alley´s last blog ..I am a miserable human being My ComLuv Profile

  7. Twitter @
    This is heartbreaking. For everyone involved. Of course, we don’t know anything about the relationship of the mom and her soon-to-be husband. So the knee jerk reaction of “go to court” could wind up being very costly and not yield a manageable result.

    And I say manageable because co-parenting is rarely a win or lose, it’s a constant set of challenges, even when it works.

    Whether Bio Dad’s 6 months off was a bad move or not strategically, it’s water under the bridge. Perhaps before pulling expensive (and adversarial) attorneys into the mix, some sort of counselor might be more helpful?

    Just a thought.
    BigLittleWolf´s last blog ..No Knowledge My ComLuv Profile

  8. Dr. Leah says:

    Brian: Thanks for joining the conversation and contributing so much. (We love your avatar – a handsome father and son!)

  9. Tara says:

    Twitter @
    It sounds to me that they have not put their daughter first and thought about it from her perspective. The father should have never let 6 months go by without seeing his daughter. That definitely sends a message to the mother that he does not care to be a part of his daughter’s life. However, I feel that the mother shouldn’t be teaching her daughter to call the husband-to-be, a father just yet. This is a fragile situation for this little girl. These parents need to realize who and what is most important here. One day this will all be water under the bridge for how they feel towards one another, but the emotional damage and confusion that can be done to this child will last forever. They should be able to look at it as they all have one interest in common…their daughter and she will love all four of them the same if they could all just get along for her sake.

    I am a single mom to a 3 year old little boy. I wish my ex would want to be a healthy part of my son’s life. These people have a chance to fix all of that and get along. They should work on that before its too late. This little girl could have an amazing chance at having 2 families that love and support her.

  10. ChopperPapa says:

    Twitter @
    While the response is a bit delayed I’ve unfortunately had some experience with this. My ex remarried her personal trainer (cliche, but true) rather quickly after our divorce. My children were both under 3. Rather suddenly afterwards, my kids began referring to her husband as ‘dad’. After I picked my jaw up off the flow I had to thoroughly access the best way to respond so as not to be arrested for disorderly conduct. With my kids being so young, there was the issue of confusion but more importantly was my pride. My children only have one ‘dad’ (me) and someone else being called that threw me for a loop.

    Having the dad label doesn’t change my affection for my kids. In your situation the big mistake was the dad bailing out for 6 months. He obviously sent the message and it was received loud and clear.

    Going to court isn’t going to solve any problems, and I don’t feel that parental alienation (if this is the only issue) is plausible here. Where I this father, I would attempt to have a civil conversation about how this makes him feel, with the understanding that him backing off for 6 months, meant he passed the baton on to the soon to be husband.

    If that doesn’t work, he should continue to act the role of dad, that he is, and soon enough the child will get it.

    Fortunately for me, the ex understood after my feedback, and referring to him daily as ‘dad’ went away, but they still call me their “other dad” to this day. And that’s just something that I’m not willing to fall on the sword about.

    They know full well who their ‘real dad’ is.

  11. Rachel Sarah says:

    Chopper Papa: we always appreciate hearing from Dads!

  12. skipper says:

    The bio-dad bailed on the mom when she was pregnant. The bio-dad bailed on the child for 6 months, which is a huge chunk out of this child’s entire life, during the time the child is starting to recognize who the primary caregiver(s) is/are and starts to lable these people accordingly. Many times a child just picks up the title “Mom” or “Dad” from books, tv, other media, and other children just naturally without any ‘coaching’ from another adult, such as is assumed in this story.

    If this bio-dad is interested in developing a strong relationship with his daughter, the bio-dad must first prove that he can be trusted to stay in her life. So far, his record isn’t so good, and I can’t blame the mom for feeling the way she does about this. If he is concerned about proper visitation, he can get an attorney and go to Family court like the rest of the good co-parents do in the world.

    Parents on both sides need to remember that parenting is not an entitlement, it’s a privilege. These children need us, so we better be there for them and stop whining.

  13. JE says:

    Sorry, but if he so wanted to be a parent to the child then when he found out his girldfriend was pregant instead of sueing for parernity he should have, as Beyonce said “put a ring on it”. This father has never lived with the child, he has gone almost a quater of her life not seeing her. Uncle daddy sounds about right.

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled