When you long for *family* not just co-parenting

We get emotional when so many of you share your agonizing tales of breaking up when you were pregnant. Thank you for sharing your own deeply personal  stories about facing your pain, moving on, and creating  new lives as single mothers.

Unfortunately,  moving on is challenging and always requires some time.  A brand new mom — who was a former professional cheerleader — wrote us recently about what happened after she gave birth to her son.

Although her pregnancy had been a bit of a surprise, her boyfriend has really been there for her from the time the stick turned pink. “Our son was born three weeks early, and, fortunately, he was able to be there for the emergency C-section,” she writes. “We brought our healthy baby home together, and he has been here every night to help out.”

“He has been going to doctors’ appointments with us and taking us to breakfast,” she adds about her son’s father. “I really thought we were going to be a family.”

Recently, however, after getting their son to sleep, her boyfriend told her the truth: he doesn’t want to be in a relationship with her.

“He explained that he loves our son, and wants to be there for him — but not for me. Apparently, he is just there for the baby and cares just about me only to the extent of helping my recovery.”

Understandably, this new single mom is in a lot of pain. “I was caught in the cozy haze of family life for a moment, and now I’m pretty sad. I’ve told him that I want to make this relationship work, but that seems to just push him away.”

In the meantime, her girlfriends are telling her to move on. “They’re saying me, ‘At least he is there for the baby.’ “I know that, but I still want that family I always imagined.”

This single mom loves the fact that her boyfriend is still staying with her because he truly helps out with the demanding, exhausting work of caring for a newborn.  (We asked if she and her boyfriend are still sleeping together — they’re not).

Of course, she knows she must move on, but she’s not sure how to start.

Obviously, this newly (and sad) single mom desperately needs YOUR advice …

Is Dad’s constant presence only making it more difficult for her to cope with this break-up?

Should she scale back Dad’s involvement so that she can better adjust to life without his love?

Or take advantage of Dad’s involvement so she’ll have greater opportunity to seek a new love?

~~~

Photo via Flickr: USAG- Humpreys

Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

No related posts.

Comments

20 Responses to “When you long for *family* not just co-parenting”
  1. bel says:

    I was in a similar situation. We brok up when my son was born. I never really had a real family growing up and I wanted my son to have a real family. My exhusband would come visit my son 3 or 4 days out of the week and he was all I thought about. I wanted to make our family work but he wanted to please his mother and party with his friends. Just untill recently ( a year later) I have cut back his visitation days to the day that’s given to him by law and it has helped me tremendously. When ur ex is around a lot u can’t get over him. And no it won’t help u find a man because in my head if he knew I was talking to someone he wouldn’t want me back if he ever changed his mind.

  2. Dr. Leah says:

    bel: We’re distressed that you suffered so much pain living through a very similar situation. Thanks for sharing your experiences with us.

  3. traci says:

    Twitter @
    You as a mom need to take care of yourself before you can take care of your baby to the best of your ability. Having dad to help is fantastic, and as much as it’s great to have him there to help during this stressful time, maybe the overnights are a bit too much. Cutting back just a little would be helpful in the healing process, maybe even have dad take the baby out for long walks errands so that you can take a break yet they can still have time together.

  4. Jessica says:

    Twitter @
    Ahh, for once a man that wants to help! Until he is moved out of her house, she cannot begin to move on. I’m sure his constant presence is emotionally confusing to her. My advice would be to thank him for all his help and ask him to leave. You need to focus on you and the baby and to doing it without him. Please seek help if your emotionally having problems too, PPD is serious. And try to seperate the negative feelings you will have towards him from that of the baby’s needs. That means to let him see his son even though you may harbor resentment and ill feelings. People do it all the time, don’t fall into that hole. Good luck.

  5. VA Mom says:

    “I was caught in the cozy haze of family life for a moment, and now I’m pretty sad. ”

    My heart broke a little when I read this woman’s situation. That said, the line above really stuck out for me. That coupled with the fact that she had a pre-mature birth and emergency c-section makes for hyper-emotions. I think she needs to find a way (either with a therapist or someone she trusts who can be impartial) to learn to separate her feelings for the father of her child and her desire for a ‘traditional family’ from the reality of what her family is.

    Let me say that again — they ARE a family. Just not the one she envisioned for herself. I believe that is the place she needs to get to with regards to this man and his role in hers and her son’s lives. There is nothing I can say to take away the heartache of wanting more than he is evidently willing to give. However, I think moving to either extreme- be it pushing him away so she can learn to be a single mom or trying to get him to care about her the way she envisioned – are not going to help her move forward.

    If this dad is going to be a presence in her son’s life then she needs to talk to him about what that means and what it looks like. She needs to not interpret his actions as something for her when they are about their son. She needs to take control of her emotions and define her family with him in it.

    I think being the parent of a newborn, having the holidays right around the corner heightens one’s sense of loneliness. It’s a scary time as a parent but she needs to try hard to not have that fear guide her emotions.

    It’s a horrible situation for sure. If she can find an outlet for those emotions, focus on the joys of her son and find the middle ground and boundaries for the father’s involvement – specifically as it pertains to being in her home.

  6. Brian says:

    I empathize with the mother’s feelings and agree with previous posters – emotions are difficult to deal with – and I can only imagine the added issues brought on by hormones.

    There are two points I would hope you would consider:

    1) You are fortunate to have a father who works so hard to be involved in your baby’s life. I’m saddened to admit that too often fathers take the path of least resistance.

    2) Your desire to have that ‘family [you] always imagined’ can still be fulfilled. The right guy is still out there. But, only by properly defining the relationship you have with your baby’s father can you move forward with your life and find what you so deeply desire.

    As you work through these very difficult issues, please try maintain a very positive relationship with the father – you both are and will always be your baby’s parents. Your child will deal with many issues brought on by the circumstance of having parents in separate households. A healthy relationship between the father and you will go miles towards minimizing these issues.

    Case in point… my son has a friend who hung himself this weekend. His mother and I talked multiple times this weekend and for almost 90 minutes again today. Together we have devised a plan to help my son confront this situation. I can’t imagine guiding him through this without a cohesive plan with his mother… and it’s ultimately about him (my son) and not about his mother’s and my relationship.

    All the best to you.

  7. LildevilMama says:

    Twitter @
    Wow. This was so my pain five years ago. The Monkey’s Bio and I split when I was three months preggers. After a month of sharing space, we agreed to try to make it work. Be roommates and see how it went. But, the emotions were still strong and we had to deal with the emotional baggage left by our split. I wanted the family and he wanted his freedom, but to still be there. And until our son was born at 31 weeks, we pretended we were okay and that we could be together without being together. But, once we brought the Monkey home it was evident it was over. He was never home. He had a new ‘secret’ girlfriend and was living his life outside of our home. He only came home to help with our son, and that’s when the fights started. I needed to move away from him to be able to move on. It wasn’t easy, but my son gave me the motivation to find myself again outside of who I had become with his Dad.

    This was of course the hardest time in my life. I cried every night, and during naptime. But, I knew it was my son who needed his Mommy to be present and alert for his needs. If it’s meant to be with her baby’s father, he will come back in his time…but, there is no use in trying to force something that isn’t there and won’t be there no matter how much you force it.

    Make sure to talk to him and work out a plan…the Bio and I didn’t and it ended up getting ugly as we moved away from each other and into awful court proceedings and custody battles.

    Good Luck, and if this Mama needs someone to talk to, I’d be happy to be an ear.

  8. Rachel Sarah says:

    @LilDevilMama: Thanks for your kind offer to lend an ear to this single mom. We will let her know for sure.

  9. Rachel Sarah says:

    Brian: Our support goes out to the family of your son’s friend. Good for you — and your son’s mother — for being there for him during this time.

  10. alley says:

    Twitter @
    I wonder if he really feels that way or if he’s just exhausted, over whelmed and confused with the new baby. I’m not saying to second guess him, but I’ve done the single mom with a boyfriend not into a relationship thing, and it never looked like what she’s describing. Either he’s a much better man that I ever dated and had a child with, or he’s not checked all the way out yet.

    Either way, she needs to start planning her life as though he will not be a romantic part of it. I don’t think them living together is a good idea if they aren’t a couple. Eventually one or both will want to date and hurt feelings will follow.

    Start looking for a new place. Let him be daddy, split parenting time. Enjoy the help when he’s got the baby.

    I hope things work out and the two parents can continue to work well together to help each other out and enjoy their baby.
    alley´s last blog ..Lots going on- but what does it mean My ComLuv Profile

  11. sarah says:

    Twitter @
    Oh honey. I feel for you. I know how your feel. My little girls father left me when I was 2 months pregnant. He didn’t talk to me for the next three months and then returned to our lives and wanted to be a part of everything. From the name choosing, through to being present at her birth (he had no say in either). My little girl was born six weeks early via emergency c-section.

    At the start the father wanted to be around. He wanted to help and be a part of it all. I felt like I needed him. Both emotionally and because in my mind, I felt we had been through so much together, I still loved him and thought he felt the same way. My daughter was in intensive care for 5 weeks, cause she was only 1200 grams when she was born. I was at the hospital day and night, holding her hand, telling her about the world, singing to her and reading her books. The father visited every second day for about an hour. It took me 8 weeks after my daughters birth to realise that I didn’t need him. My daughter didnt need him either. Parenting isn’t a part time position. It isn’t something you do when your free. It isn’t that comes second.

    Be strong. Be Bold. Be Brave. That is what I told myself every moment I felt I needed him. The day I told him that we were moving and he would be able to see his daughter on a monthly bases was extremely hard. But I don’t regret it for a single second. I had to do what was best for myself and importantly what was best for my daughter. He does come to visit about once a month and this one visit is stressful enough. So I applaud you for being able to deal with your Son’s Father on a regular bases.

    I have the most beautiful little girl, who turns one this Christmas Eve. She makes me a better person, a stronger person and a happier person. Your son too will give you inner strength. Find a person you can confide in. Someone who you can speak completely honestly to about your relationship, your fears and your hopes. This helped me tremendously, and I encourage you to talk to someone too.

    I know you want the concept of a family. A mum, dad and children. But you are already are a family. You and your son. You need to set boundaries and guidelines for your Son’s Father. It will help you move on and in the long run it will also help your son. He will always be the Father and a part of his life, but you need time. You need to work on your family, on you and Son and that important family unit.

    It will be hard, and many tears will be shed. But we are tough. We are women and we are all wonderful mothers.

    All the best
    x
    sarah´s last blog ..And so it begins My ComLuv Profile

  12. Dr. Leah says:

    sarah: How kind of you to share your own experience so generously. Your little girl sounds like a sweet heart. One thing you said really resonated for us: we are family…our children and us. Thank you for adding to this conversation with such insight and support.

  13. Single Solo Daddy says:

    Well, I feel most badly for this baby, not for the mom. The child will never understand what a “whole” family is all about.

    It’s an awkward situation for the mom because she obviously is suffering the grief of the relationship, but she most certainly should embrace the father’s help. She doesn’t own the baby. If she isn’t set on breast feeding every feeding, she can exchange care times with the father so she can sort through her feelings without being with him as much.

    I’m going to also respond to Sarah’s comments.

    I think that our culture is seeing a change where we have been conditioned to think of men as naturally irresponsible and poor parents and prone to abandoning and must now realize that good men do make commitments and keep them. But as men adjust to not being the sole provider, the nature of fathering is changing.

    I find Sarah’s comments offensive. Women are not morally superior in their commitment as parents. Women do not own children they Co Create with a man and therefore have the authority to tell the man they are not needed. Men do not have the same immediate nurturing impulses and body chemistry that foster a mom’s physical bond. But we do experience attachment and feelings of love, often unexpectedly.

    Many men who are no longer involved with the mom do make the commitment to be great dads. Often, though, women cast out men from their lives thinking only of their own feelings and rationalize it based on what they personally need and don’t think of the importance both parents play in the child’s life.

    Men can make solid commitments and keep them. Women can make commitments and break them. I know first hand.

    I’m a single, solo dad. 1 Year ago today, my wife of 19 years decided she made a wrong decision to have moved to the US 21 years prior, missed her “family” and left me and our 2 children to live in her homeland Scandinavia. From May to November of this year the kids hardly heard from her. Every week I meet men who, like me, are truly the more committed parent and are compensating for women who decide to seek their happiness outside the life of their children.

    I am far from a perfect father, and I am no nurturing mother. But I love my kids, And while I may lack “maternal instincts”, I experience a deep sense of commitment that comes through my choice to seek out what is best for my kids.

    At some point the cheerleader may decide that she no longer wants to be a mom, and it would be then that quite possibly this man who is the child’s dad, will be the one who fills the gap.

  14. Dr. Leah says:

    Single Solo Daddy: Thank you for adding so thoughtfully to this conversation. We agree, of course, that men can and do forge strong bonds of commitment and do passionately love their children. You and your kids are suffering an abandonment no less painful than when a father makes the same choice. Please know that you are not alone in our Singlemommyhood community …we have many devoted dads among our readers. We’re honored that you’ve joined us and hope that you visit us again soon. Please stay in touch.

  15. Twitter @
    It doesn’t take a dramatic story like SSD’s; there are good men out there who can be and are good fathers without requiring a traumatic event to shine through. They just quietly go about the business of being good fathers. And there are mothers out there who can be and are equally good mothers, even if they are also at the same time not such good partners to their husbands (and/or visa versa.)

    SSD didn’t need his wife to fly away to be a good dad. This idea that as long as the mother can stick with it, the father is disposable is, well, both frightening and wrong. What if SSD’s wife had, like the Cheerleader’s boyfriend, simply decided not to be in the relationship any longer, but wanted to still be there for the kids? Does SSD get first dibs because the wife is the one who wants out? Certainly not. Does his wife get first dibs because she’s the mom?

    Well, speaking as another father whose wife has opted out of our marriage, you can probably guess where I fall on that question.

    If the Cheerleader’s former boyfriend is interested, willing, and able to participate in raising the child, it is in the child’s best interest — as well as the father’s and mother’s — that he do so.

    I agree with the suggestion above; the Cheerleader and her boyfriend should start working out a joint custody schedule sooner rather than later. Yes, this is easier if she isn’t nursing, but even if she is, adjustments can be made.

    Begin learning how to be effective co-parents. To keep the boyfriend as a live-in nanny will only prolong and worsen the romantic aspect of this relationship, and to cut him out entirely is unfair both to the child and to the father and, as hinted at above, to the mother, for that matter.

    I would also recommend that the Cheerleader read The Passion Trap by Dean Delis. It is one take on how the more you try to hang on to a lopsided relationship, the more problematic it becomes. It includes suggestions on how such a relationship can be righted, although your mileage may vary on how successful that will be. It seems to me that the advice in that book is sound: you have to be able to stand on your own two feet if you’re to have any chance at winning (back) the love you desire.

    Best wishes to you, Cheerleader, and to Single Solo Daddy, as well.
    ItNeverRainsInSeattle´s last blog ..The End of the Mexican Stand-off My ComLuv Profile

  16. Twitter @
    I know the Cheerleader is particularly concerned about her love for her former boyfriend, hence the book recommendation above, but since many of us here are advocating coming up with a good parenting plan with the child’s father, here is an interesting resource that may be of help:

    http://www.supreme.state.az.us/nav2/ParentingPlansWorkgroup/Documents/PPWguidelines.pdf

    Again, best wishes for all involved!
    ItNeverRainsInSeattle´s last blog ..Divorce When to tell the kids My ComLuv Profile

  17. Dr. Leah says:

    ItNeverRainsInSeattle: Thanks for passing on this helpful link. You’re right that many of our readers did suggest a solid parenting plan. We appreciate your contribution to this difficult conversation.

  18. Twitter @
    One thing that I have come to know for a fact over the past four years, getting out of a bad marriage and becoming a single mom, is that you can cope with anything life throws at you. Sometimes it is hard to imagine the thought of being a full time single mom but once you are “there” you don’t have a choice.

    When I look back on my nearly 3 years of being a single mom to a 2 and 4 year old and an entrepreneur I don’t know how i did it…I just did!

    I think this lovely lady deserves to move on and find true happiness and love. It may not come right away…actually it probably won’t but it will be worth it in the end.

    She is very fortunate that the Dad wants to remain involved with her son’s life…that is a gift in and of itself.

    Time to start rebuilding something new love…exciting if you choose to look at it that way! :)
    How Does She Do It Mom´s last blog ..Aren’t You Curious My ComLuv Profile

  19. Meg says:

    Twitter @
    Just wanted to say that I don’t believe anyone was advocating for totally cutting off the biological father but rather suggesting that there be some separation (not living together) so that emotions can begin to heal.

    Let me start by saying that I have raised four children on my own. The father of my older two children never had much to do with them at all and in fact when he died two years ago, my children were not even listed in the obituary. The father of my younger two children has some serious issues that prevent him from being fully in their life however he and I are able to be friendly at family gatherings, etc. I do still have feelings for him and he has said he has a “never ending love” for me but we are not a couple and he lives several hours away. It makes it very hard on me emotionally to see him but I do it anyway for the girls. I would go so far as to say that over the last nine years we have become very good friends but it’s still emotionally tough sometimes.

    I have to commend any father or mother that is totally committed to their children. And I have to totally agree with a previous post that parenting is not something that you do only when you’re free or when it’s convenient, when it’s fun at holidays, etc. Parenting is a full time 24 hour a day, 365 day a year job. Now if you have another parent involved then you may get a break now and then from physically caring for the children, but when parents do not live together you will always have one parent who takes on more of the primary care and responsibility than the other. And often this unequal caretaking happens even when two parents live together. It’s just fact.

    I think it’s great that the father has been there to help but I agree that him staying in the home is sending mixed messages to the mom and to the child. And I would bet that as the child gets older and the novelty of a newborn wears off or he finds a new girlfriend, he may be very quick to move out on this own and although he may still want to be involved with the child, she will have to do more of it on her own at that point. Waiting for this to happen will only create more resentment between the two parents and be confusing for the child when things change unexpectedly.

    I say explain your feelings to him and let him know how much you welcome his commitment to his child. Plan together for the two of you to live separately but make sure that he understands that he can see the child whenever he wants. And breastfeeding is not an excuse for him not to take the child to his own place. You can express the milk into bottles and freeze it so that he can take those with him and use to feed with when he has the baby overnight. The harder part will be letting your newborn out of your sight but if you trust him to care for the baby which it sounds like you do, then it will be a good thing for everyone in the long run.

    It’s not going to be easy by any means but it sounds like both parents are truly committed to the child which goes a very long way. The two of you may have to put more effort into making co-parenting work but if you can figure out how to co-parent in a civilized way it can be very beneficial for your child and that is what is most important.

    I wish you the best of luck. Reading all of the painful stories here has been truly touching. –Meg

  20. Rachel Sarah says:

    @Meg: Thanks for so generously taking the time to share your own story.
    This really resonated with us: “parenting is not something that you do only when you’re free or when it’s convenient… Parenting is a full time 24 hour a day, 365 day a year job.”

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled