When you’re facing the ADHD (or not) dilemma

by  
Filed under All, Featured, Kids

An avid reader who frequently comments candidly (we love her for that!) has contacted us for advice. Neither of us have coped with this particular parenting dilemma. Yet we get this part: it’s tough to cope with kid problems alone. But it’s so much more difficult when your family is critical of you.

Here’s what this solo mom has shared with us.

“I’m the parent of a very overly active seven year-old son, ” she says. “I get no help from his bio-dad.”

This reader goes on to describe her son as independent, stubborn, and non-compliant. It always has to be his way on his time schedule. This little boy also has significant anger issues, which Mom believes are fueled by the way his bio-dad treats him. Specifically, his father will make a sudden appearance and make big promises. And then he will disappear without a word for the next year or so.

This little boy’s behavior is growing more difficult to manage. And it interferes with his learning at school. This mom is worried (understandably) — yet she has done her homework.

She recently concluded that her son might have some form of ADHD (Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder). And she made an appointment to have her son evaluated.

In the meantime, this mom’s extended family — mother and sisters — are telling her that an ADHD diagnosis is a cop-out for lazy parenting. So, this mom is not just facing a kid crisis. She’s also dealing with harsh judgment from her mother and sisters.

Please step in here and offer some advice:

Have you had any experience parenting a child with ADHD? If so, please do share.

What treatment(s) were most effective? Medication? Therapy? Diet? Or, some kind of combination?

Was your extended family supportive? If not, how did you cope with their criticism and denial?

~~~

Photo via Flickr: allmothers

 

 

Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

No related posts.

Comments

29 Responses to “When you’re facing the ADHD (or not) dilemma”
  1. Betty Matharu says:

    Twitter @
    My daughter has ADHD. I put off medication for a while hoping that behavioral skills would help, but she got worse. i finally put her on a very low dosage of Strattera to get her through school at least. It wears out quick. Being single with non supportive father, and two other children, she was draining my energy. Now with meds we are all a lot more peaceful.

  2. Dr. Leah says:

    Betty: Thanks for sharing your experiences with us. Please visit again soon.

  3. anonaone says:

    My 8 year old son has been evaluated three times for ADHD, though not formally through a psychiatrist – it’s only been through the school system. He just finished a pretty bad 2nd grade year, but, in all honesty, a lot of that had to do with a really bad teacher/kid mix, and that teacher decided at the end of the year to retire (one year too late for us!).

    I feel for this mother whose family is so anti-medication, as my ex-husband is the same way. If my child were to be definitively dx’d, I’d have a major uphill battle to fight WRT to medicating. We have decided to hold off on formal testing for a while, and during the second half of this school year that was just finished, we had him in counseling – play therapy which he really loved. Whether or not it translated to improved behavior at school, I don’t know. Unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on how you look at it), all of his issues are in school and not at all. He was a really difficult/defiant/oppositional baby and toddler at home, but now he’s not like that at all at home…just at school. It’s really hard to say if this child would have ADHD or not considering what the mother has shared about the father and the relationship there. It’s possible it’s just severe anxiety, etc. over being so hurt :( . Nevertheless, it absolutely can’t hurt to have him evaluated so she at least knows what she’s dealing with. The evaluation process is not hard on the child, and in fact my son has always loved it because of the one on one attention.

    Best of luck!

  4. MLC says:

    My daughter has Asperger’s, not the same as ADHD, but I recognise the issues this mum faces. It is hard when your child does not behave in a socially acceptable way, despite your consistent and committed parenting. People assume that you are a bad parent if your child is still acting up beyond a certain age. As ADHD and autistic spectrum disorders are ‘invisible’ disabilities, and also are misunderstood, there is no way to educated everyone you come into contact with about your child. I used to wish I had a badge on, and a stack of leaflets to hand out, but in fact even when people are educated about these things, they still often don’t understand them, and ‘poor parenting’ is an easier concept than neurological difference. I have taken years to learn to parent my child, and learn to deal with her behaviour, in a way which does not take into account strangers’ opinions of me. If someone on the bus or in the park thinks I’m a terrible mum, well then I will just have to live with that. Learn to tell yourself that you know best. You do. Everyone else is wrong! (ha ha!). One last thing: after my child was diagnosed, one friend said to me ‘you must be relieved, did you ever think that she behaved like that because you were a single parent?’. It hadn’t crossed my mind, but her view shocked me, and we’re not really friends any more. Sometimes you just have to cut people out of your life to keep yourself sane. Other mums with ADHD kids/special needs kids, will be your support, as will true friends who take time to educate themselves. OK, this is so long, but I hope it helps!

  5. Kate says:

    I understand! My daughter has ADHD (though the inattentive type) as do I. My mother thinks that it’s a bs diagnosis, because “we all probably have a bit of it, and moat people cope just fine.” I know it’s probably so hard to let het mothers comments roll off her back, but she’s the mom. Forget what others think. You know in your gut what’s best for your son. I would proceed with
    formal testing, with a psychiatrist. In my
    experience, the school testing isn’t as thorough and takes way longer. There’s nothing wrong
    with medicating a child who needs it and with the support and advice of doctors. We did wait three years to medicate, exhausting other behavior and tools to help her. It just was time. Her doctor said, “If she had diabetes, you’d give her medication. If she needs it to function to the best of her ability, thats what it’s there for.” I also think the situation with bio dad is exacerbating the situation, so it would probably be helpful to have her son talk to a therapist. My divorce was amicable and her bio dad is great and hands on, but we had her see a therapist to head off problems when we divorced and it was enormously helpful. There were anxieties and some things that we didn’t see, and were able to address them. You know in your gut whats right for your son. Once he gets the help and mess he needs, I would imagine that things will be a little easier for both of you. Good luck!

  6. Kia says:

    Twitter @
    My daughter has autism & ADHD. Both have been formally diagnosed by doctors and the school district. She still didn’t go on meds for 3 years afterward. Many people think you go from diagnosis to meds but that’s not true. A great doctor will work on strategies and alternate therapies first. My daughters doctor requires parenting classes first.

    Meds allow people for whom the other options are working to focus. You know why it took 3 years at home? Because while she was a mess at home, she was doing great at school. Then she wasn’t. She couldn’t make it thru lessons without the urge to flee the classroom. The meds helped & her grades went back up. It’s been 6 years since the autism & 5 since the ADHD diagnosis and it still took years for family & my ex to come around. They get it enough to not fight it, but I still get the random bullshit questions, like the one with my ex last year over genetic testing his insurance doesn’t want to pay.

    Hugs because it won’t get easier. Take your son to a psychologist one who you feel listens & is through. It might not be ADHD. Not to scare you but it could be ODD, or something else. Your post is leading me to think it’s not ADHD but something else or a combo. The right diagnosis is important. Your family will take a long time to come around. Don’t wait for them, you are your son’s best advocate.

  7. GM says:

    Twitter @
    I agree that it’s a good idea to see a professional. However I wouldn’t jump into the medication game right away. ADD/ADHD is a common misdiagnosis in children.

    I know this is my own personal belief speaking but I think we’re too quick to turn to pills as the answer. I was misdiagnosed with ADHD when I was 7. I knew I didn’t have it. I was just an angry child suffering through a divorce, bad parenting, and a lack of opportunities for active play. Of course medication was the first thing my mother turned to. The fact that I skipped taking it for four months and she still “saw an improvement” didn’t help my cause even though I thought it would. It’s easy to get hung up on a diagnosis once it’s given. Because of this I strongly advocate in favor of always getting a second opinion and giving other options a try before adding medication to the mix, especially for children.
    GM´s last blog ..SYTYCD Season 8- Top 20My ComLuv Profile

  8. Anna says:

    I am a teacher and a mom to a son with autism and undiagnosed ADHD.

    First get the diagnosis. Then go from there.
    Meds are not bad for all kids. My son is on Strattera (the only non-stimulant med out there), and he does really well with it and has no adverse reactions. We are lucky. Sometimes it takes awhile to find the right answer.

    As for the family, ask them to babysit frequently and they might change their tune. All of those naysayers out there are never the primary caregivers or teachers that have to deal with the behaviors. It could be a long haul with them, and it won’t be easy. Labeling you as the “lazy parent” is the easy, lazy way out for them. My son’s uncle actually called him a “spaz” one Christmas and I stopped talking to him.

    Talk with the school social worker about the anger issues. My son’s IEP dictates that the SW work with him on appropriate ways to deal with his anger on a regular basis (my son’s is most likely due to his father’s inconsistency, as well).

    Keep a diary of his diet, too, if you have the time and are so inclined. Some kids really react to things like sugar, and others don’t. I noticed that goldfish for whatever reason set my son off, so we don’t buy those anymore.

    Therapy would be good, too, if your insurance covers it. If not, use the school SW for sure.

    I agree with Kia — get a diagnosis from someone you feel good about. I thought ODD (oppositional/defiant disorder) might be a possibility, as well.

  9. Carrie A says:

    My heart goes out to this reader. It is very likely she is correct and her son–his dad for that matter, could have ADHD. I have always been disorganized, in the clouds, spontaneous, forgetful, and reactive my whole life. I found a husband who is as adventurous and spontaneous as me! He is also has trouble finish tasks and can be very reactive. We have kids, which are like us. And guess what? After years of denial I can now say: WE ALL HAVE ADHD. It is as fun as it is heartbreaking.

    My advice: Trust yourself. Get a good evaluation. Try medication (it will not work if it is not ADHD). Get support from doctors and educators. Love your son. Take Mommy breaks often!

    Medication, ADHD coaching, and ADHD meditation are all very helpful. You are not a lazy parent. You are a parent who wants your child to learn and listen. You want him to be happy and self-assured, to build lifelong friendships. With treatment kids learn to manage their strengths and weaknesses. They are less likely to do drugs and less likely to develop unhealthy coping strategies which lead to the coexistence of oppositional defiance, or obsessive-compulsive disorder, or anxiety, and depression. You can choose who you want to talk to, and if people around you disagree know you are doing what you believe is best for your kid! Remember your son is a chlid, your child, don’t look at him and say he is just agumentive just like his father, look at it in a positve! He sure is smart and can voice his opionion!
    The reader is doing the right thing! There are lots of people who deny the existance of ADHD. I can say I have ADHD, it is not made up or caused by parents (unless you could the genes), it just is there are great things about us, and not so great things about us. We make up about 5-10 percent of the population so most of the world is organized with a differnt view of the world.
    Good Luck!
    CA
    Carrie A´s last blog ..Summer Clutter Overload 5 Tips to Spend More Time a the BeachMy ComLuv Profile

  10. Jessica says:

    Twitter @
    Hi everyone. I am the OP in this dicussion and I appreciate all of your advice.

    We did have out meeting with a therapist yesterday and it went very well. I grilled him on the types of cases he deals with and (thank god) many of his clients are children with absent fathers and behavior issues. My son and I felt really comfortable with him, as he also has two young boys at home.

    The therapist did state that he felt that my child did not have ADHD/ADD but more likely ODD. I have never heard of ODD before but am after reading up on it, my son seems to fit the bill perfectly. The therapist suggested Family Therapy for the both of us, which will establish some new parenting techniques for me and behavior modification for my son.

    Currently I have contemplated terminating the bio-dad’s parental rights due to his emotional/financial absence for over 3 years and his drug/alcohol addiction. My therapist stated that he felt it is more of a detriment to allow bio-dad in and out of my son’s life every few years than to terminate his rights. That made me feel better about my impending decision, because I want what is best for my son.

    I appreciate all of your comments and advice too.

  11. Dr. Leah says:

    Carrie A.: Thank you for your generous comment – so much useful information. We agree: mommy breaks are essential. Thanks again!

  12. Wendy G. says:

    Twitter @
    My son was diagnosed with ADHD at 5 years of age. He’s also been diagnosed ODD (Oppositional Defiant Disorder) & pre-bipolar. He’s now 10. He’s also a very intelligent kiddo. I had to put him on meds when he was 6. His current meds are Focalin XR (morning) & Respiridone (morning & evening), he gets Clonodine (very low dose) in the evening to help him sleep.

    I’m a single mom with very absent bio-father. However, I have a wonderful mother who helps a lot. My father & brothers also help out with the male role model aspect. My kiddo is in counseling every other week and he’s in various extracurricular activities such as karate (for the past 5 years) to help siphon off some of that extra energy. Processed foods seem to contribute to some of the symptoms, so I’ve been taking those out of his (our) diet, as I can afford to. A milk substitute also might help. Otherwise, a strict schedule works well, as does consistency.

    It’s a challenge, but not an impossible one. You can do it, mom!!!

  13. Dr. Leah says:

    Wendy G.: Just said @Carrie A., but your comment is so generous, too. You shared so many excellent tips —exercise, consistency, shying away (when possible) from processed foods, and counseling. We’re so glad you can count on your mom. Thank you again for your help.

  14. rob says:

    Twitter @
    Food for thought: I’m a 28 year old single father who started treatment for ADHD about 6 months ago. I have gone through so much in life always feeling like I could accomplish more if I could just sit down and “get to it.” I am a classic underachiever am have squeaked by school and just about everything else in life. When I told my mom that I was being treated she told me that I didn’t have it because I was tested when I was a kid. After that, it was dismissed. Misdiagnosed? I am now starting to accomplish “some” things in my life… I feel that I’m am to write ideas down instead of keeping them in my head. Life is slowly changing, about 25 years later than it needed to be, maybe?

    Now my son is starting to hit key developmental and learning stages. His mother and I are aware of the signs and we won’t make to same mistake, if it comes to it.

  15. Boyce Hewett says:

    My daughter has Asperger’s, not the same as ADHD, but I recognise the issues this mum faces. It is hard when your child does not behave in a socially acceptable way, despite your consistent and committed parenting. People assume that you are a bad parent if your child is still acting up beyond a certain age. As ADHD and autistic spectrum disorders are ‘invisible’ disabilities, and also are misunderstood, there is no way to educated everyone you come into contact with about your child. I used to wish I had a badge on, and a stack of leaflets to hand out, but in fact even when people are educated about these things, they still often don’t understand them, and ‘poor parenting’ is an easier concept than neurological difference. I have taken years to learn to parent my child, and learn to deal with her behaviour, in a way which does not take into account strangers’ opinions of me.

    If someone on the bus or in the park thinks I’m a terrible mum, well then I will just have to live with that. Learn to tell yourself that you know best. You do. Everyone else is wrong! (ha ha!).

    One last thing: after my child was diagnosed, one friend said to me ‘you must be relieved, did you ever think that she behaved like that because you were a single parent?’. It hadn’t crossed my mind, but her view shocked me, and we’re not really friends any more. Sometimes you just have to cut people out of your life to keep yourself sane. Other mums with ADHD kids/special needs kids, will be your support, as will true friends who take time to educate themselves. OK, this is so long, but I hope it helps!

  16. Rachel Sarah says:

    @Rob: We’re so honored that you’ve opened up and shared your story here. We have a feeling this is really going to resonate with many parents. Thank you.

  17. Tanya Gesek says:

    Twitter @
    I am a child and adolescent psychologist and have heard so many of your stories. I hate that so many of you have been called “lazy” or “bad” parents. Being a good parent is about knowing how to be a good fit for the particular strengths and weaknesses of your child.

    Raising a child is like driving a car. Tough and overwhelming at first, but before long, you get the swing of things. Some kids are like 18 wheelers, though. You need a little instruction and coaching! Psychologists like me are here to provide that support. You are not a bad parent, but you are the main driver of this car and I love that you are all reaching out to all of your supports.

    I try not to use labels in my practice. I see kids as having strengths along with significant weaknesses and skill deficits. It is up to us (me and parents) to identify those weaknesses, teach the skills necessary, and build on strengths! Sometimes, the ones that need teaching are others in the kids’ lives, like teachers, for example.

    I am so inspired to hear all of your stories and how much you care for your awesome children!

  18. Dr. Leah says:

    Tanya Gesek: Thank you for adding so much comfort and wisdom to this difficult conversation. (Dr. Gesek is a personal friend. And an *expert* on the difficult kid behavior issues so many of us face.)

  19. kerry says:

    Twitter @
    Two of my children (both my boys) have emotional/behaviour difficulties. My eldest (12) has had a diagnosis for ADHD, but now that is being questioned. I’m a single mum with 3 children and I get no help from family or bio father etc. Although I love all my children dearly, I find life a struggle and dealing with the behaviour is very very hard. I’m sorry I can offer no advice. I hope everything works out for you all.

  20. Dr. Leah says:

    kerry: Our hearts go out to you. Keep us posted on what happens, particularly with your older boy. HUG!

  21. I’ve worked for many years on the issues with my son. I’ve been through a legion of psychologists, psychiatrists, and “friendly” or “parental” advice. I’ve been through the ADHD route, explosive child route, oppositional defiance disorder, and more. Each of these requires an almost entirely different and often opposite approach to how you deal with the child. Probably the best thing I read is that MOST children really are trying to do well and please the adults around them.

    Issues like ADHD mean that some of these kids have a very difficult time controlling their impulses. The traditional “Good” parenting strategy generally means you punish them, often severely, so that they don’t do it again…it means you assume that whatever they did was willful on their part. The constant correction and punishment often leads to depression. Children are people and things are rarely straightforward. Emotional distress can manifest itself in many ways often causing children to exhibit ADHD symptoms.

    It isn’t easy trying to get to the root of the issues going on, but a “good” parent isn’t necessarily the one that has the perfect child, a “good” parent is the one that never gives up on their child and does what they have to do to help them succeed. I struggled from around the time my son was 2 years old and still am. Going through medications and treatments, having to miss a lot of work for counseling appointments, etc. Eventually we found the root cause to be Asperger Syndrome. As far as advice, I look for progress with any given professional and diagnosis. If after a couple of months there isn’t any progress, you need to start questioning if something else may be going on. I have had to change psychiatrists when they showed very little interest in digging deeper when after several months my son showed either no change or was getting worse. Often, I was suggesting the medication or dosage instead of the psychiatrist.

    Suggestions I can offer include looking for a psychologist/psychiatrist combination that are active, involved and interested in helping children and your child. Therapies that can include counseling, diet, medication, and neuro-feedback as appropriate. Make sure that they are tracking progress or lack thereof. You have to keep evaluating as well. Find and get involved with parental groups for children with special needs. These parents will not be judgmental of you or your child and will often have great information on medical practices and how to force your school system to provide the help and support that your child is entitled to by law.

    What eventually made the difference for me and my son was a chance meeting with a parent who had a child with Asperger. That led me to finding a local group of Asperger parents, and eventually to a diagnosis and a root cause. Once I had the root cause, many things that didn’t make any sense over the previous 10 years all fell into place. I was able to get my son the right therapy and support professionally and at school. The difference has been amazing. I’ve gone from having nearly weekly meetings at schools to getting maybe two calls in the past two years. Neurological and emotional issues are not cut and dry. You can’t put a tissue sample into a petri dish, look at it with a microscope or put a couple of drops of a chemical and say looks like you have . It takes time, observation, and perseverance. No one will fight for your child, only you.

    As long as you are actively working on the problem you are a great parent…and certainly your child is a great and fortunate child.
    Crazy computer Dad´s last blog ..12 Week Body Transformation ChallengeMy ComLuv Profile

  22. Dr. Leah says:

    Crazy Computer Dad: Thanks so much for sharing your experiences and insights with us. The “dad” perspective is always welcome. Take care.

  23. Anna says:

    While I understand Dr. Gesek’s viewpoint about not wanting to label children (we teachers struggle with this concept a great deal), many times you need the diagnosis to get services and/or insurance coverage. I agree that labels sometimes obscure what each child needs, but caution other parents to make sure to get a diagnosis if you are concerned.

  24. LYNNE HARRIS says:

    Twitter @
    I am a mother with ADHD, I have no dad in the picture for my two daughters, one who has ADHD and one who has ODD. I am taking medications for my ADHD, but I am still extremely disorganized and forgetful. I know that for my children a rigorous schedule would be ideal, however I am unable to maintain consistency, a symptom of my disorder. I live in a rural area and both of my children are seen at school as “bad kids” and I have been accused by school personnel and school board officials of “spoiling” them. This is not the case at all but, they have been labeled and regardless of their diagnosis and counseling it seems that I am unable to be the parent they need with my disorder still getting worse as I get older and medications loose their effectiveness.

    I spend a great deal of time feeling overwhelmed and searching for a better way to deal with our family dynamic. I do not have a support system, my mother has passed away, my father is a truck driver and in a new relationship, although he does provide a great deal of financial support to us, he is unable to provide much else. I do not have any friends that are able to spend time on my family nor do I have a significant other, I could not imagine trying to begin a relationship in the pandemonium of our family. It is an all day everyday thing trying to deal with each of our needs and with my inability to stay focused myself and the madness of disorganization…I am also at a loss, I did not include anyone in my decision to use medication and other than the schools and medical professionals I have not shared our diagnosis with anyone else.

    I would love to know of any resources that could shed some answers on my parenting with ADHD…to help me be a better parent. I love my kids madly…as we all do and I do have a lot of fun with them daily, but our life as a whole is very difficult for me to manage, I forget appointments and loose things a lot. I am the adult and I know they look to me for stability, what can I do?

  25. mightbeatranny says:

    Twitter @
    at some point NOT giving meds is abusive. if your child had diabetes would you insist they had the medical treatment he needed? This is no different.

    As far as a diagnosis; you need to pay out of pocket. forget your insurance carrier. start every appointment this way, “I need a daignosis that will help me, help my son, to get the services he needs to learn and be a happy child. if you can’t help me please tell me now so that I can find the doctor that can”. You’re out of time, so cut to the chase.

    Then, here is a hint; speach & social delay gets you services like/1 session of group speach a week & one social skills class twice a month. You need the BIGGEST diagnosis you can get. Don’t worry about what they call it. A friend of mine and I joke that they can call it “Blue Monkey Syndrome”, if it gets our kids the services they need. If they will put your son on the autism spectrum it would get you a lot more services. Don’t let the name scare you. and the talk about labeling is bunk. there are privacy laws and your child is entilted to the least restrictie environment.

    7 is a little old to just be getting a diagnosis. No one ever suffered from to much “help” or too many services. what is going to be different this coming school year than what happened last year? Nothing, unless YOU make it happen. Your family is NOT A RESOURSE. Admit that now and stop passing information on to them. You are the mom, your word is law; the end.

  26. carrie a says:

    Lynne,
    As an mom I always worried what my messy house, forgetfulness, and scattered brain does to my kids. I worried about how it is perceived by other parents, and teachers. Over the years I have heard, and read that I need to provide: consistency, scheduling, organization, planning…

    I have never had a teacher tell me to help my kids with their algebra. They offer places to get support for these things, they provide help-sites, math labs.

    Schools and teachers often give advice based on criteria, sometimes it is helpful sometimes not helpful. If they ask you to provide something you can’t say you need help. If it feels like they are wrong speak up. I was once told my son’s learning difficulty would be helped if I read to him everyday. He has been read to everyday since the day he was born.

    I think consistency and structure should really be love and support. If you are giving them love and support all the other stuff will get figured out. ADHD kids my at least don’t respond as much to correction or punishment as they do to reward. Be proud of their achievements, help them find their passions and gifts.

    When I find I am taking the blame, I try to give credit too. I am the mom who built forts. I am the mom who does not panic. I find OK to combine monopoly with Lego. Who buried treasure in the sandbox. Who spent hours chasing them in the playground while the other mom’s sat on the sidelines like recess ladies. I am the mom who wrote color coded spelling words who read every parenting book at the library. Who I am the mom who carried a squirming biting five year old back to a quiet car, when the swirl of people at a holiday rush caused a meltdown. Now I am the mom who goes to school meetings and doctor appointments and takes notes. I provide lists and actions. My kids are the ones who figure out the solution. They make the plans, now I am just the note taker.

    Here are some of my favorite books:

    For parenting, I like all the love and logic series of books by Jim Fay and other co-writers.

    For ADHD kids and me: Smart but scattered by Peg Dawson, Richard Guare
    For women and girls I also like:
    Understanding Girls With AD/HD by Patricia O. Quinn, Kathleen G. Nadeau, Ellen B. Littman
    Women with Attention Deficit Disorder: Embrace Your Differences and Transform Your Life by Sari Solden.

    “Smart but scattered” is the best one I found at working together on weaknesses. I am no expert, I just have ADHD.

  27. Cmommy says:

    About a two years ago, when my ds was three, he began having behavioral issues every single day at daycare for two or three weeks straight. I was getting phone calls from the daycare on nearly a daily basis and sometimes had to pick him up early. One after noon when I picked ds up his daycare teacher told me he had had another rough afternoon, but all of the children had been a bit crazy after snack time because they had served red kool-aid. When I asked her for clarification, she told me that some children have a very bad behavioral reaction when they consume red #40. I was stunned, because I had never heard about this particular sensitivity before, and told her that several weeks ago we had begun buying a caffeine-free, sugar-free orange soda that ds absolutely loved and had been drinking several glasses a day. I stopped giving him the soda and other red #40 containing foods and it was like flipping a switch, his problems at daycare just stopped.

    I still occasionally let him have treats that contain red dye, but when he gets too much I get a dramatic reminder of why we don’t eat those things. I had gotten careless with his diet last summer and it resulted in a rough few weeks at the start of his kindergarten year, he was came home with red/yellow frowny faces on his daily reports several days in a row. Once I cleaned up his diet and got him “back on the wagon” he seemed to have no problem staying on green every day.

    It pains me to think how many children may be on medications for ADHD, when simple dietary changes can have such a dramatic effect. I asked his pediatrician about it and she more or less dismissed me, but since then there has been more empirical evidence released supporting my observations. It may not solve all ADHD problems with all children, but it is very easy to try a Red #40 free diet for a week to see if there is any improvement.

  28. Dr. Leah says:

    Cmommy: As a psychologist, I can add that research studies to prove the harmful effects of food coloring and additives are limited. This is why pediatricians are not always keyed into such concerns. Here’s why: deliberately giving kids potentially harmful substances (red dye #40 as one example) to see if kids’ behavior is affected is not ethical. Many parents, however, tell us of night and day behavior changes when they eliminate such substances from their kids’ diets.

    We do not tell anyone how to raise their kids. That said, if your kids are experiencing behavioral problems, eliminating things like red dye #40 and substituting water for soda (as pediatricians recommend), might just help solve these kid issues — with no downside.

    We’d love to hear from other parents on this issue.

  29. Birdly says:

    When it comes to disapproving relatives, I have found it most useful to isolate and focus on what is best for my child. It’s been very hard. Up until recently, I did not feel my child would be safe if left in the care of any of the well-meaning relatives who thought I was an over-protective, out-of-whack, too-permissive, first time mom who was letting my child rule my life. It meant alienating family. It meant that vacations to visit them were massively stressful, trying to travel and protect my child at the same time, and then putting the pieces back together upon returning home.

    As my child has matured, he is at last resilient enough to spend unsupervised time with various relatives. And at last they “get” it. But I felt I couldn’t risk the real harm that would result before this point. And I know in my gut that I made the right choices.

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled