When your boyfriend says he never wants to get married
by Dr. Leah
Filed under All, Featured, Single Moms
We’ve talked about getting remarried — or not — before. You’ve told us that you have mixed feelings. Some of your worry that your single status might be forever. And some of you relish your independence — we get it. We’ve never discussed, however, remarriage fears from a single dad’s perspective. So, when this single mom wrote to us about a relationship stalemate, we wanted to hear from YOU!
Here’s what this mama told us:
She is the divorced mom of three kids. Her boyfriend — whom she first met 10 years ago — has two kids. And his divorce his very recent: it was finalized six months ago.
“After his divorce was final, we started to date,” this single mom tells us. “He has not introduced his kids to me as his girlfriend. But our families do things together as ‘friends.’ ”
“My boyfriend has said that his kids need more time to adjust to the divorce,” she goes on. “I get that, and I feel like I’m being patient.”
Here’s the issue: This single dad has been divorced twice. He was very young when he married for the first time — they were more like best friends than husband and wife. His second marriage, however, completely changed his life. He and his ex practiced a strong religious faith. And he worked hard to make sure this marriage would last.
Eventually, they divorced — they were unable to reconcile after his wife’s infidelity. This dad discovered subsequently that his ex wife withheld many secrets. He’s really angry that his marriage was shattered. Moreover, the fact that he no longer lives with his kids breaks his heart.
Both of this divorced mom and her boyfriend have agreed to take things slowly. They’ve been open with each other about their feelings for one another. And they’ve talked about what they’re looking forward to enjoying together in the future.
Yet, last night her boyfriend dropped a bomb. He told her that he can feel walls going up. And the longer they’re together, the more more fearful and uncertain he feels. He also talked openly about his dread of handling the inevitable blended family challenges.
“I know that you want to get married someday,” he told her. “But I just don’t think I can take that step.”
This boyfriend went on to tell this mom that he does NOT want to lose her. She knows that these conversation about marriage — or not — are about the future. She feels that if they stay together and he works on his issues, there’s the potential for a wonderful marriage.
Yet this mama worries. She does NOT want to stay in a relationship, if there’s no hope for an eventual marriage.
So, she’s asking for YOUR advice:
Should she take the chance and stay in this relationship — hoping that her boyfriend’s feelings will change?
Or should she walk away from this man — despite the fact that he has made her feel that she can love again?
~~~
Photo via Flickr: Bhamgal
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
No related posts.






wow did I write this post and not know about it?? This is so my life these days, I can totally relate!!! My boyfriend (of a year) has been honest that he doesn’t really know how he feels about remarriage. I have been clear from the get-go that I am interested in remarriage as a long term goal. We have both fallen deeply in love, but he is still really marriage-shy after having such an unhappy marriage for so long. I admit that we have had many moments of talking about it and me being unsure if I wanted to continue in a relationship where there wasn’t a goal of marriage.
Recently I had to come to terms with the fact that I had knowingly fallen in love with a man who didn’t know if he would ever be married again. And I didn’t know what to do or what to think or what to hope for. That I had gotten my kids involved in the relationship made it that much more complicated. I have tried so hard to not let it get to me, but I went through a period of real stress about it.
We kind of took things easy this summer and just let things happen as they might and well, honestly, we both kind of came to terms with our relationship. We both want a committed relationship, he’s just not ready to think about it being as permanent as marriage – he needs to take things slower than that for a while longer. In his thinking, it’s only been a year and with the families involved he feels like he needs more time than that to be sure. It has made our relationship a lot stronger to have both come to compatible conclusions – after all a relationship is often about compromise and commitment anyway! He has come to terms with my need for some kind of future goal, and recently asked if we could make our first long term goal living together starting next summer. While I feel like that is baby steps in a relationship that is as strong as ours, I can accept that it is all he can comfortably offer and I have to respect that.
For me, it was a difficult decision that I agonized about. I had to let go of a future I thought I needed and embrace a future that works with the man I love, and with both our families, too. But, when I stopped living in the future my anxiety about a lot of the relationship dropped significantly. I say embrace the love you have now and embrace the relationship you have NOW and let things grow into something extraordinary, whether or not it ends up being marriage or not.
Twitter @ ivelanded
A couple of things.
1) TAKE PEOPLE FOR THEIR WORD. Especially men.
2) DON’T EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER get into a relationship hoping the person will change/you can change them. Just no. That never works.
3) I take issue with the fact that this mom feels like she’s been patient. Divorce was final 6 months ago? That’s NOTHING.
4) Oh, did I mention…don’t EVER go into a relationship hoping the other person will change.
If it were me…….
I’d probably just chill out for a while and enjoy what it is. Putting more pressure on this seems like it would backfire.
The fact that he says this right now strikes me as a red flag, but it could just be fear and pain talking. Who knows. I’d be careful that it IS a red flag and protect myself accordingly.
Something this mama might find useful right now would be to honestly write down a list of “dealbreakers” for relationships. Is getting married REALLY a dealbreaker for her? If not……all this stress may be for nothing.
C Lo´s last blog ..an open letter to Scott
Twitter @ WhitewaterAtty
I really agree with most of what C Lo said above…
First, he’s ONLY 6 months out. There’s still TONS of emotions going through his mind — especially if it was a harsh divorce. This Mom hasn’t really been patient yet, and his emotions could easily change as he settles into his new life.
Second, he is stating his intentions. And if after some more time, he’s still just as adamant about his “no marriage” intention — then this Mom NEEDS to be prepared to move on… That said, I agree with C Lo in that I would recommend that this Mom “chill out for a while and enjoy what it is.”
Yep, six months is not long at all. And, I’d chill out and enjoy him for now if you really care about him that much. NOW is the time to practice patience….
Twitter @ jsawalker
Thanks Janis!! That is exactly how I feel things should be. The stress came up as his feelings became stronger and stronger for me. I in no way have pressured him about marriage but he knows that I eventually want to be. He has a long way to go in his healing process. I still have healing of my own to do. But when this conversation came up, his fears came forward and it brought out my fears of being hurt. All I want is for us to be able to be together and live day by day with no pressure about the future for either of us. I just hope that he can do the same and not let his fears get the best of him.
I would realllllly put the screeching brakes on and literally force yourself to go the route of patience. When two people connect on a level like that and take things a step further and are connected spiritually/religiously – there’s a bond there that is amazingly indescribable….unfortunately it was broken for him and UNDERSTANDABLY so – he has every right to feel cautious, reserved, etc in approaching a new relationship. As hard as it is to want to know about ‘marriage’ in regards to the future – skip that talk for now and enjoy getting to know him…and I can sense that you have, but I only speak this because of his issues he needs to work through. In the end if you spend a lot of time together and find out marriage is not for you guys – you’ve learned alot about yourself, him and what you want for a relationship – kind of bites having to start over again. Continue as you are, enjoying each other, enjoying the moment!
My post-divorce coach has told me that it takes approx. 3-5 years to heal from a divorce. This guy is 6 months out? He’s not ready to date and shouldn’t be. He’s not in an emotionally healthy place. He should be focusing on himself and his kids and rebuilding. And instead he’s avoiding reality by entering into a relationship he’s just not really ready for.
And anytime someone says they don’t want to get (re)married, believe them. My guy friends have translated this as a) they really don’t want to get married to anyone but most often it’s b) they don’t want to get married to you.
Twitter @ MommyTRex2010
Fully agree with Clo, truer words could not be spoken. Take people at their word, it will save you lots of trouble. Just take the relationship as a day by day thing, your bf has been out of his marriage for 6months which is no time really. I doubt he is going to change his mind, YoU are in the drivers seat here, its your choice to stay or go. If marriage is what you want with no exceptions be prepared to walk away and chalk it up to a delightful relationship. But personally for me I think life is too short to compromise. If marriage is what you want there is a man that can fullfill your needs.
I definitely think that BOTH people need more time. To heal, to get to really know one another, etc.
She should evaluate, on a scale from 1 to 10 (10 being very much so) how important remarriage is to her. If it is a 9 or 10 and he does not budge his position in say another 6 months or a year, then she needs to decide whether to stay or leave. I mean it is a very personal choice and NOONE can tell her what she should do on this matter.
Personally, I can really relate to the guy. lol.
I got divorced nearly 3 years ago and walking down the aisle again is just NOT any kind of a priority for me. Mind you, I am not dating nor am I in love. I am just concentrating on my job and my kids right now.
But anyways, my advice to this lady would be to give it some more time and then decide with both head and heart.
I wish her good luck!!
Twitter @ http://deleted
After an extremely painful divorce where all my trust for my ex went out the window, I had a lot of fear about EVER being able to get remarried agian. At the 6 month mark of my divorce being finalized the hurt, the pain, and betrayal, and fear were still very much staring me in the face, and for a long time I couldn’t even imagine dating someone else agian. Besides when yu have been with someone for so long, feelings don’t just go away, it takes a while to heal, and so instead I focused on my child, and trying to move foward, start over and heal. And a relationship, let alone remarriage just wasn’t my focus. Its now been two years since my divorce and I am thinking maybe I could date agian, that might be nice, and just maybe I could get remairried agian. But I still fear about getting hurt all over agian. I say that 6 months isn’t really enough time, and it might just take more time for this man to heal, and with healing, he may change his views.
I was in a very similar situation and we agreed to just go with the flow and not push. It’s been 2 years and he asked me to marry him last weekend. It was unexpected and I’m kinda scared but I told him I’d think about it…. what I’m saying is be patient. The universe will bring you what you really need when its time. Good luck and blessings.
dharma: Thanks for sharing your life with us. Patience is wonderful advice — but, often hard to “feel” every day.
I agree with the others who said that 6 months is just not much time at all. If he started dating you right after his divorced was finalized, he wasn’t even ready for dating yet. I don’t feel you have been patient, and you guys have been going full speed ahead into dating before he was even ready for that. You really need to be patient and take more time, and give him the time and space he needs to get himself sorted out. My divorced was finalized 6 months ago and I know that I am not emotionally ready to date yet. My therapist has also said that people are not ready to jump into dating so quickly after a divorce.
At this point, you have to take his word that he doesn’t know if he may ever marry again. These feelings may change or may not change as time goes on. If it’s an ultimate deal-breaker for you, and you aren’t willing to even consider being in a long-term relationship without a marriage, or would feel that being in this relationship for a few years and then breaking up due to that issue would be a terrible thing for you – then get out now. I just feel that you are putting a good deal of pressure on yourself and on this guy whose divorce is fresh and who you are really just lucky is dating you right now to begin with, as I doubt that he is truly ready for even that.
Charismaga: You’re right: many in our community feel that six months is simply not long enough. Your thoughtful contribution to this conversation is appreciated. Please visit us again soon.
Twitter @ BigLittleWolf
Six months?
That’s nothing. Give the guy a break! Especially after two marriages, dealing with infidelity, and not seeing his kids as much as he’d like.
As for not wanting to marry again, I can’t say I blame him. But I would ask – why does this mom want to marry again so much and why is she convinced they would have a wonderful marriage after relatively little time “dating?”
A few key pieces of information are missing – his age, her age, ages of the children, whether or no she wants more kids, financial situation. All of this matters. Those of us who have been divorced with kids for a considerable period know this.
She needs to slow down.
BigLittleWolf´s last blog ..Triangle
Twitter @ http://nokomis-daughterofthemoon.blogspot.com/
She should stay if she loves him. Thats it. Thats the only reason. She should NOT hold out for him changing his mind. That would be foolish. He has been straight forward about his feelings. Too often women stay in relationships in hopes their man will change. Dont do it. Stay with him for who he is or leave the relationship. You’ll only grow recentful otherwise.
Twitter @ jsawalker
I would like to thank everyone who has shared there thoughts and opinions on my situation. It is very much appreciated. I guess the one thing I should have clarified is that his divorce has been final for 6 months but he was separated for a year and half before that. I questioned him on several occasions, if he was sure he thought he was ready to date. Before we went out he had been on several dates and a few girls he had gone out with more than once. I’m so glad I found a place that I can share my thoughts and get so much feedback. Thanks again to everyone and keep that advice coming.
Twitter @ http://www.themomarchy.com
Unfortunately, your man needed a soft place to land. Infidelity tends to cause you to question yourself — are you loveable, desirable, good enough? Relationships that occur soon after a separation are designed to confirm that you are good enough so, of course, he will tell you he is ready for dating — and he is. He just isn’t ready for a long-term commitment. It is okay if he is Mr. Right-Now but he probably won’t ever become Mr. Right. He may have already begun to pull away. He has suddenly become very busy at work. He calls or texts less. There may be days when he simply is unavailable and you don’t know why. Enjoy this time but with eyes wide open.
Twitter @ Barblicious
From personal experience, believe this, if a man tell you he doesn’t want to get married – he means – he does not want to marry you.
Oh he might get married to someone else later on, sure, but he is being kind and giving you a blanket statement. He is saying he doesn’t want to get married ever, but what that means is he does not want to marry you.
Sure he doesn’t want to lose you. Of course not. You tolerate his wishy-washy behavior and his inability to commit. He wants to hang on to you, to make sure his needs are met until he feels ready to move on, to the woman he will actually respect and marry.
Good luck with that.
Sorry if I sound jaded but I was strung along by someone like that, and believe me, he won’t change his mind – he isn’t going to marry you. In the end I suspect, much like my experience, you will be told that he loves you, but just not in love with you enough to marry you. You are his security for now, there will be no future, take his word on that.
Barbara Doduk´s last blog ..New & Improved
Twitter @ tressalee22
My dear, I am in the same relationship, although he has never been married and I am 15 years his senior. I say don’t pressure him to do what you want MARRY…Men always will do the opposite make it his idea act like you don’t give a shit and he will probably ask you,,,Reverse secret or whatever you want to call it,,,release the FEAR and here will stay with you,,,he already says hes not going anywhere so dont push or you will push him away nobody likes to be controlled…although I want to pressure mine it doesn’t work…I know how hard this is…love him each day that’s all you can do hun! enjoy your moments, there is no promise of tomorrow for any of us…Love T
tressa: Your comment made us chuckle. We’re not sure what motivates men (or women for that matter) to make the choices they do, but pressuring them definitely never works. We’re so glad you’ve joined us.
Twitter @ tsquest
Yep, CLo said it best.
It sounds like we all agree that 6 months post marriage is NOTHING. Hell, I was still hoping we’d work out our marriage 6 months after we separated…
It’s very difficult to recover from something you hoped would last forever. ESPECIALLY if he’d already been married before. The 2nd time, he knew she was the one… and then she had an affair? Now they’re divorced? This man is hurting big time. I don’t even know that she should be anything except his friend right now. Especially if she feels the need for a commitment so soon.
Good luck.
T´s last blog ..Saudade* – Long(ing) Distance Relationship
Twitter @ CherSeattle
My boyfriend and I have been together just over six years now. We have a five year old daughter. I’d known him exactly three months when we got pregnant. It took another 11 months for him to decide he really wanted to be in a “committed” relationship. It took another 3 years for him to move to the state we live in, and move in with us (I’m still not sure that was a good idea btw).
He told me the VERY FIRST NIGHT that I met him that he didn’t want to remarry. Ever.
At that time, he was four (4) YEARS out from having been divorced from his ex-wife, with whom he has two daughters, now aged 12 and 14.
6 months is really nothing in terms of actually dating someone – whether they’ve been married before or not. So in that respect, I say chill out. Relax. Enjoy. Take it slow. Have fun. Do stuff together with the kids, and without the kids.
But please hear me when I also say…
1) LISTEN to what he is saying to you.
and
2) BELIEVE him.
Men only choose not to marry for two reasons:
Either he really doesn’t want to get married, or he really doesn’t want to marry YOU.
Harsh. But true. Ask any man you trust. They’ll tell you.
My personal story, complicated as it may look to my friends and family, works for me and my daughter. For now.
Do I want to be married some day? Absolutely! I’ve always wanted that, for me (and for her).
Do I think it’ll be to her dad? Probably not. Because I heard him when he said he’d never go that route again. And for today, I’m cool with wherever the journey in between takes us. Because who really knows what tomorrow will bring anyway?
Wishing you the very best. Dating is a hard enough road to travel, even without kids and ex-spouses to muck it all up.
Cher ~
Cheryl´s last blog ..THIS cracked me up. #earthquake…
Twitter @ mightbeatranny
“there’s the potential for a wonderful marriage”. that right there is the scary part of this whole situation. i will NEVER get remarried. it isn’t a matter of the right person comming along, it’s a lifestyle choice. i don’t want the burden of someone there that i have to take into consideration at that level. yes there are things that are “wonderful” about marriage (in my head i hear “blah-blah-blah”) they aren’t enough to off set the way i feel.
i had a relationship after i left my husband w/ my college boyfriend. i was recently seperated, he lived far away, we got to know each other online. i was VERY open about NEVER getting married/living together. but you know, it wasnt the answer he wanted, or he thought he could change my mind, WHATEVER. after awhile i felt the same way your boyfriend is describing. like something more was expected. like my choice was limiting the other person. like i was the source of his unhappiness.
there is NO POTENTIAL for marriage is the other person doesn’t want it. accept it and deal. either decide you don’t want marriage, or decide you do and move on.
look at it like this. what if someone told you that you have great potential to be a gay wife. or great potential to be a soccer star. its not who you are. you don’t want to put in the work. no matter what other people think/want/hope/need = its just potential.
in my case, i ended the relationship because i got tired of explaining/justifying my decision. i’m a grownup and i don’t want to have to explain myself; ANOTHER reason i’m not getting into another permanent relationship!
its not you. its situational.
Twitter @ traciwhitney

The first thing that comes to my mind, besides what everyone else here has already stated, is why do YOU want to get married to someone that just divorced 6 months ago? Why did this conversation even come up at this time? Is there some reason why you’re feeling insecure about this issue, when it’s not even really an issue yet. All I’m saying is that there could be some insight into why you’re feeling a little anxious about this so early on. Or maybe not, just a thought
traci whitney´s last blog ..Kids and lazy summer days gone by
Twitter @ jsawalker
Thanks again for all the comments. It’s interesting to hear everyones take on my situation. @Traci, I think a lot of people are under the assumption that I am ready for marriage and that couldn’t be further from the truth. When my boyfriend and I were just talking as friends we confided in each other that he wasn’t sure he ever wanted to get married again and I stated I do eventually want to get married again but that I was no where near doing that again. I feel like I still have a lot that I need to work on within myself, also. The whole reason this conversation came up was because he felt his feelings for me were getting stronger, which scared him and then he went into complete shock when we made the terrible decision to take all kids with us on a cruise for the first time. All children got along great with each other but his 2 daughters fuss alot being sisters and 4 years age difference and my 2 daughters fuss alot with the same age difference and being sisters. Plus my son being a toddler was a handful. A cruise was so full of activities that we were busy from 7 a.m. till midnight every day. Everyone was exhausted and we had no alone time what so ever. WOW!!! I had a mental breakdown when we returned from our trip and so did he. We were physically and emotionally exhausted. It was after that whole ordeal that he said he didn’t think he would ever be ready for marriage. That he is afraid of not being a good enough father to his own children and he doesn’t want to let me or my children down. My children and I came out of an emotionally abusive 12 year marriage. I was completely shocked that he was bringing this up because since before we started dating the subject of marriage had not come up again and I had not even thought about it. We just started dating!!! He said he knew I had not said anything but he feels like if things keep going as good as they have been, besides the cruise trip, he can see that being a possibility to him and something that I deserve. He wanted to know that if he never wanted to marry again ever would I still want to continue to date him. My answer was….that I am happy being with him right now and just want us to continuing being together the way we are. I prefer not to look ahead at what may or may not be and just live each day as it comes. I hope this helps some of you who had more questions about our situation. Please, keep the advice coming. I love hearing from everyone. Dating with children is not an easy thing on top of being a single parent.
Twitter @ momma_sunshine
In my opinion, it’s foolish to stay in a relationship hoping that the other person will change for you. Take him at his word. And if marriage is something that’s more important than being with this man and NOT married, then you need to move on and find someone whose ideals align with yours.
Momma Sunshine´s last blog ..“I Want to be *THAT* Guy”
I had a relationship like this once several years ago. We were great, our kids were great together, everyone loved eachother. BUT when we reached a crossroad was when the issue of moving in together came up. I have my kids full time, he has alternating weekends. Moving in together would mean MY kids moving into HIS kids’ bedrooms. (we each have one boy/one girl). It would mean the girls share a room, and the boys share a room. Things came to a halt when he started feeling like MY children would be more of a presence to him than his own because of our differing custody schedules. Anyway, when it came down to it, he just felt like it would be betraying his kids to move me and mine in with them. Waiting for the kids to grow up was simply not an option. In the end, I was very much ready for the next step toward marriage, and he just wasn’t. It tore my heart out to say goodbye, but i maintain the utmost respect for him in his decision to do what he thought was best for his kids. In the end, thats what matters. (though secretly i hope that we will meet again when our kids are grown and we will live happily ever after!) Also…things ended for us abruptly after this discussion of our inability to live together. I dont want to wait around for a man to decide I am worth it!
Twitter @ muminawe
“if marriage is something that’s more important than being with this man and NOT married, then you need to move on and find someone whose ideals align with yours.” – this is what I have to figure out.
The hardest thing to read is:
LISTEN to what he is saying to you.
and
2) BELIEVE him.
Men only choose not to marry for two reasons:
Either he really doesn’t want to get married, or he really doesn’t want to marry YOU.
Harsh. But true. Ask any man you trust. They’ll tell you.
I don’t want to believe that. EVer. It hurts too much.
Wendy´s last blog ..Sticky apple compote
No never wait! I waited 7 years he never married me….If he says he doesnt want to TRUST HIM..I had to move on and finally got married.
hi Dr Leah
i need your help and tell me what should i do
we been 4 years together with my boyfriend and dont live together yet,
back to 3 and half years and my story was
when we met each other he was with his bussiness live-in partner and he has a ring on his right finger,to show the world he was married. when the first time i met him,i liked him he was funny talkative and out goers person, as myself i am outgoers too, so we send email ,we sent texts and we seen each other sometime in sundays ,he have to give an excuse to get away from home to come to see me,so 3 and hafl years we survived seeing each other,without the partner knows, then times and days passing by i get jealous and i want him to more to see me ,spend more time with me but he cant do that althought he say he loved me so much, the time and days passed by i sat on my chair crying ,thinking what should i do,then all the thought i had i have to get firm and get away this relationship as long as possible without telling him, so one sunday i went out with friend to the bar and i met this guy we dated and get to know each other till a serious conversation came and he was obviously sincere ,he was a great guy and he met my parent back to philippines, having relationship 3 months with this new guy ,my ex boyfriend found out everyhting about us, he did all his best to get me back and be together again he cried ,he gets helped to my friends called my familly everyday and he said he will left his bussnes partner for me and i will do everything to win you back he even proposed ”will you marry me’ istill love him so much ,he makes smile ,he is the funniest man i ever met and that make me fall inlove with him , so after 4 months relationship with the new guy i met it turn upside down, i emailed him that i cant be with him cuz i still inlove with my ex andwe planning to get married ,he emailed me back only the words ALL THE BEST GOODLUCK” so everything for this new guy i met i put only like my dream,,, so not even 1 month i got back with my ex he left his bussness live-in partner and he telling me they never been married i was shocked that day if i knew they were not married,i will keep the relationship not making a single mistake and hoping one day he will choice the right person to marry,
now i broke up with this new guy and i choice my ex to be back again,he promised me a lot of things
when i asked him when we are get married, he answer me did you know what thing you have done to me ,you make me like a stepping clothes ,why should i marry you, i want to marry you but you hurt me so much .. i think DR leah he wants to revenge .i undersatnd what you going through but i just wanna know when we get married ,and he said nothing ,he only say ,the important i am still here ,still with you..
DR Leah my english is not very good apologized ,i just need your help
and i look forward to your reply
should i move on and look someone who wants to marry me and willing to have a famly in the future please help!!
best reagrd
nadya