When your child demands to know everything about your divorce
by Dr. Leah
Filed under All, Featured, Single Dads
A single dad contacted us this week with a perplexing dilemma: this dad — just like many of you — is keeping big secrets about his ex from his kids. His well-meaning efforts to protect his kids are backfiring, however. We’re counting on YOU to share your insight — and experience — to help him decide how best to handle this co-parenting crisis.
Here’s what this dad tells us:
“My wife had an affair with our neighbor, ” he begins. “She’s never admitted it, but she’s now living with him across the street from the kids and me. I have had residential custody of our three kids — who are 13, 10, and 3 — for almost two years.”
Candidly, this dad admits that it’s taken every bit of strength not to tell the kids what “really happened” by putting the blame for the break-up squarely on their mother. He believes, however, that discretion is what’s best for the kids. And that what’s happens between a divorcing couple is a strictly an adult matter.
Right now, however, mom’s parenting time causes stress at home. The 13 year-old boy doesn’t like to talk about anything — parents with teen sons know how difficult it is to get boys this age to open up. The 3 year-old comes back from parenting time loudly chanting, “Daddy stinks. ” But, it’s their 10 year-old daughter who’s really in an emotional crisis.
“My ex tells our 10 year-old daughter every detail about the divorce settlement. And about how she may regain custody,” this exasperated dad says. “The worst part is that she’s told all the kids that I was cheating on her throughout the marriage — which is absolutely untrue.”
Of course, his tween daughter returns home upset — and asking lots of questions. Dad has tried re-directing her, changing the subject, and giving lots of hugs. He emphasizes that both Mom and Dad love her — and that’s all she really needs to understand. Lately, however, his daughter has demanded to know Dad’s side of the story. When Dad isn’t forthcoming, she calls him a liar and accuses him of keeping secrets from her.
This single dad is a self-described “brain picker” — he’s looking for ways to make his kids’ lives easier during this rough time.
So, he’s eager to hear what YOU have to say:
What does this 10 year-old girl need to know about her parent’s divorce?
How should Dad respond to her persistent questions?
Did your kids ask questions about adult issues — like infidelity and finances — during your divorce?
If so, how did you handle these kid questions?
~~~
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
No related posts.







Twitter @ quickie_divorce
This is quite a quandary, and it’s made all the more difficult by the children’s ages. The first thing that I would advise a client to do is discuss matters with their former partner. He needs to inform her that her actions may make her feel better, but they’re harming the children. Divorce can leave children with emotional scars, but effective, collaborative and, above all, amicable parenting can negate these negative effects.
I’m presuming, however, that the wife has not been or would not be in agreement to such suggestions and this in no way uncommon. If this is the case, then a different approach is needed for each child as a result of their age.
There are several books that have been designed to explain divorce to young children and I recently wrote a blog post on this (a link to this post is attached above). It may seem far-fetched, but, in my experience, it can really help.
With the two older children a more direct, though still gentle approach is needed. It will be extremely important that he understands precisely what is bothering the children, though and he may want to make an appointment to see their respective teachers as a result – my girlfriend is a teacher and you’d be surprised how often children confide in their teachers.
Once he’s obtained this information, then he’ll need to carefully plan what he needs to say. He should certainly be honest, but should also remain calm, sensitive to his children’s needs and must ensure that he does not blame anyone for the divorce – it’s never beneficial to make the children resent one parent, regardless of what they may have done.
After he’s spoken to the children, though, he’ll still need to communicate with their mother, inform them of what he’s told the children and request that she – for the sake of the children – reinforce what he has informed them. If she refuses and the problems persist, then I would advise family counselling.
This is a difficult situation that I have encountered too often. Parents that have recently been through a divorce often forget that their children’s needs should come first and that under no circumstances should they use the children as a weapon.
Divorce Blogger´s last blog ..Divorce in the Arts: The Squid and the Whale
Twitter @ chopperpapa
Being in a similar situation I can relate. One thing that is a bit more of an issue is living directly across the street form her. That is a huge challenge.
It’s apparent that the mother’s guilt over the situation is causing her to fabricate and bring her children in the middle. The problem with the mother, and what he can’t do, is attempt to sway the children’s loyalties by spinning the story in a certain way.
My suggestion is:
1) You can’t protect your children from everything, divorce isn’t easy but don’t let guilt mean you shelter them from everything. Children are resilient and will adapt.
2) Keep it to the facts. IF the children are old enough to formulate their own opinions, then share with them to story of what happened and allow them to make up their own minds.
3) in the case of the 10 year old, a frank heart-to-heart discussion with the mom is in order. Then will she agree to sit down with both him and the daughter and tell the story.
4) take responsibility for his part in the divorce. It doesn’t happen in a vacuum and shows the children that pointing fingers is never acceptable.
ChopperPapa´s last blog ..Is the desire to be great, really a mistake?
Twitter @ singlemombooks
Dad, I feel your pain! My daughter is a plethora of questions, more all the time as she gets older and is starting to see her bio-dad more often. I’ve told her what happened in the past doesn’t matter, and that we love her and that’s all that truly matters. That’s the party line and I’m sticking to it. My daughter has used a therapist and the therapist actually works with all of us (her father, his fiancee, me, my husband and our daughter) and she has strict guidelines around conversations, boundaries, etc. If you can do it, get your kids counseling (if you’re open to it, I wasn’t for a long time). By staying neutral and taking the high road, your ex will have to live with the consequences. The kids figure it out – they’re smart and paying attention. They may not realize the nuances and complexities until they’re older, but hang in there!
Honoree Corder´s last blog ..Single Moms: Therapy Can Help You and Your Kids
Twitter @ http://newsingledad.wordpress.com
When my youngest stepson found out that his mother was had left, he came to visit, and stayed with me. We sat up late and talked about both divorces, and he said, quite emotionally, that the biggest problem was that no one told him anything about what happened, or why it happened, and that at 23 years old, he still didn’t have any idea what went on between his parents, and why. It was shocking to me, I didn’t know he didn’t know.
I know that’s only a small part, but at some unknown point, they deserve to hear the story, or both sides of the story. It’s a disservice to let them believe whatever one side tells them. A third party (therapist) does sound like a really good idea.
Good luck
newsingledad´s last blog ..Garage Sales
I agree with all 3 sharing previous responses. Take the high road, reinforce your love for your kids, make them feel safe and seek s family therapist. My kids, my ex, and I ate currently in therapy …newly…and it’s already helping my kids. Keep the focus on improving their lives and reducing their stress…not on your divorce or your ex wife’s drama. They’ll realize soon enough who they can really count on. Oh, and keep a log of all the drama with dates, etc…just in case. Be calm and love them!
marcistern: Obviously, from my perspective — as a psychologist and a mom — therapy is a logical step. Thanks for joining the conversation.
I have to admit that what he is going thru is very difficult; as a woman who was divorced from an abusive husband, who was also having an affair, I can truly understand his dilemma. My son is 12 right now, and I did what I could to preserve his relationship with his father, whom I divorced when my son was 3. At about 10 yrs old he also demanded my side, I prayed long & hard about it. Then when my son came to me the next time, I told him what he wanted to know. He cried, but was thankful that I told him. We don’t breach the subject much in specifics anymore, but he definitely trusts me more for sharing my side of the story.
Hopefully, he will consider broaching the subject with both of his older children. The truth from his perspective could be exactly what his kids need, even though it will be painful for him.
My prayers go out for them all.
Twitter @ http://hereivelanded.blogspot.com
I think the best course of action would probably be to have a conversation with the daughter and give her age appropriate information, but tell her the truth. Not telling the truth is lying….and lying is just rarely ever healthy. It probably seems scary and you certainly don’t want to stoop to moms level……..but yeah. Tell the truth, in a way that a 10 year old can get.
C Lo´s last blog ..what I’m listening to this week
I have to agree that certainly with all 3 sharing previous responses. Take the high road, reinforce your love for the kids, cause them to become feel safe and seek s family therapist. My kids, my ex, and that i ate currently in therapy newly and it’s already helping my children. Maintain the concentrate on improving their lives and reducing their stress…not on your own divorce or your boyfriend or girlfriend wife’s drama. They’ll realize soon enough who they can really rely on. Oh, and a log of all of the drama with dates, etc. In case, be calm and love them!
Tom´s last blog ..Man boobs help blog
Twitter @ tailgatingtimes
I would have to agree with the above, especially telling age appropriate amounts of the truth. They don’t need all of the details but pretending nothing happened isn’t right. From a kid’s perspective when everyone tries to act like the divorce was no one’s fault and nobody did anything wrong, there’s one conclusion to jump to and that’s that it was the child’s fault but no one wants to tell them. It takes a lot of therapy to get your mind past that one. My standard answer to my kids has always been, “We have different priorities and values”. I’m happy to share mine and if they want to know about hers they have to talk to her.
wow. doesn’t this mom realize how much she’s hurting her children, even if she only wants to hurt their dad? i suggest parenting classes for mom & dad, & family therapy. this mom is totally inappropriate, & if she doesn’t willingly agree to parenting classes, then i’d see a judge & ask him to order her to go. in massachusetts its a law that if you get divorced & you have kids, you have to take the parenting classes. in jersey, if a parent is intentionally alienating the other parent, she can get into alot of trouble. i hope their situation gets better.
Twitter @ tsquest
As the child of divorced parents, I wanted the truth. Granted, I was 22 years old when my parents divorced but nonetheless, I couldn’t stand being in the middle. And what child would??
I understand that this dad is hurt by his ex-wife’s actions but they need to seek some sort of post-marital counseling in order to be on the same page. The children need a united front…. and sadly, the new front will include the neighbor as well. It’s difficult, for a child, to comprehend how grown-ups don’t have their act together. It hurts to think that your security isn’t secure after all.
If finding a common ground with the ex-wife is impossible (and I don’t believe it is), then the next step is honesty. I believe the children, if they are asking, should understand the “facts” as much as possible. And, if possible, without the mom or dad’s “story” or emotions placed on top of the facts. The children will have to decide on their own what they are to believe. They may be hurt by the mom’s actions. They may be hurt that their mom is accusing the father of cheating as well. But in the end, don’t the facts tell the story? The mom is living with the neighbor and the father is still parenting alone. Right?
I believe the facts can be presented in age appropriate language and without blame. If this dad can see past his hurt and present the story in a way… that shows he’s forgiving and understanding… well, in my experience, the children tend to follow the adult’s lead. Can you say to your 10 year old daughter, “Mommy and Daddy weren’t happy together. Mommy fell in love with someone else. It made Daddy sad but he understands and wishes Mommy to be happy in her new life. I know that I will fall in love again some day too. We do both love you and I’m sorry that we’re not together anymore. I know it’s a difficult change for you but we are still your parents, we will both still parent you together but we’ll do it from 2 different houses. But how lucky are you that Mommy lives right across the street?!?”
Maybe that takes swallowing some pride. Maybe that takes reaching deep inside and remembering that you did once love with woman and know that she is only doing what she believes will make her happy.
Maybe that means that you and your ex need to have a discussion on forgiveness and moving forward. You’re still partners and you will be for a really long time. But now, you’re in the business of parenting.
I hope that helps.
T´s last blog ..Goals: Am I "Driven"?
Twitter @ Honoure_Stark
As a previously divorced Mom with 4 children, now re-married and proud Step Momma to 3 children, we live on the same block, I can relate!
First and foremost, hang in there! I experienced similiar issues in what to explain, to which child and why. Their ages range from 18 to 7, I understood for myself that I needed help to take the ‘high road’ because I was having a very difficult time NOT telling my older children what they demanded, and they did demand to know ‘my side’. I consulted a therapist, as a result What I have learned is this awful situation provided me many opportunities to learn/teach my pre-teens how to communicate, boundaries of what is ‘too adult’ and our different perspectives on this issue. Through all of my mistakes, even with the best intention’s providing an ‘adult’ truth to my teenager’s was innapropriate for me. It hurt my children. After learning that painful lesson, I set out very clear boundaries of what I will disclose however, I understand and listen when that isn’t making my teenager happy. I will re evaluate each step in disclosure when I know in my heart that they can process the emotions that will come along with our situations.
It was not an easy choice to make every day. I was very hurt by the accusation’s by our ex’s, I was astounded and the information provided to our children when they weren’t in our care. Mostly, I was scared to death by the feeling of losing that parenting control. I was scared that my children would hate me if I remained quiet and all of their information came from angry ex’s! I realized that these are my issues, things I needed to feel through and process and it really had nothing to do with my children. I needed to learn how NOT to parent out of fear!
Things are still growing in our family, each parent has their own way of doing things (which drive’s me insane when the children are hurt and angry) however, I know now after several years I can’t control these situations for the most part. I can control how I respond and that is by saying to each of them that I love them, respect their feelings and when I feel its appropriate I will share my journey with them. It has helped very much that my children can now say to an angry parent ‘I am uncomfortable with what you are saying’…or something similiar. They each have their own way of expressing their boundaries with being in between and discussing something that they don’t want to talk about.
I wish you and yours the very best of luck!
Twitter @ hflo99
I remember when my divorce was final my ex would lie to all of my 4 kids all the time. I remember 2 years later we ended up going back to court with a mediator and my ex lost all his rights but was given supervised visit of course he never took them but my kids remember all the lies, It helped my kids to be able to read all the papers from the courts to understand what my ex did that was so wrong. Most of my kids have grown and a few have chose to contact him and he still tells them lies to this day, but my kids know the truth by keeping them in the loop. By me never saying anything bad about their father while they were growing up and setting the good example to this day, if he says something that doesnt jive with them they will ask me and know what I have said is true. Just remember that someday they will understand, and will be able to process the whole thing. In the mean time just love them and maybe try therapy helps to open them up.
As grown child of a split family (haven’t yet dealt with this as a parent) I remember very very well the BS I went thru between parents.
Quick version of my childhood – parents split at 4 because dad was alcoholic and using cocaine and hanging out with bikers among other things (mom didn’t tell me this until I was 17) he played the victim to me & my sister for years after the split, mom wouldn’t talk about why daddy left just that it was better for all of us and we’d understand later. I resented my mother starting at about age 4, wanted to live with my dad by age 9, and relationship with mom was ruined before I was 7 or 8 because she withheld information and I thought she was a “liar” and “mean” for divorcing him. In short my dad played me like a pawn against my mom all while she sucked it up always did the “right” thing in her eyes by trying to protect us from the truth etc.
My advice having been the hurt kid in the middle of the drama. Sit down your 10 & 13 year olds and lay it ALL out. Talk to them like their humans and somewhat adults, they are going thru the same divorce you are. With the same woman you divorced. Tell them how you feel, felt and how you just want to protect them. Explain that the split was not at all their fault. Just don’t hide stuff (especially if your ex is laying it all out there) your kids know when your hiding something, they can sense it. That’s why they ask questions. I wish my mom would have been half this honest and open. It would’ve saved me from years of drama, missed relationship with the decent parent and thousands in therapy costs
Twitter @ http://singlemamamusing.blogspot.com
My heart breaks whenever I hear stories of kids being manipulated by a parent. Im sorry your family is going through this. It sounds like you’re doing an amazing job and taking the high road. I agree perhaps family therapy would be a good next step. As for sparing the details, I think this should be done for as long as possible. If we as adults can barely make sense of what and why things happen, kids get even more confused and upset. My son is not old enough yet to ask these questions, but as a teacher I encounter kids on a daily basis with too many adult problems on their shoulders. This is why I think a therapist would give you all a safe place to discuss appropriately and heal. Best of luck.
Kara´s last blog ..How do I raise a ‘good’ man?
Twitter @ mightbeatranny
if divorce were “strictly an adult matter” kids wouldn’t know about it or be impacted by it. i date, but that’s an adult matter. my kids have no idea. i have a job, but they don’t know that either, i work when they are at school or with their dad. when something impacts a child they deserve to be treated with the respect of an explanation. you don’t have to say, “mommy was having sex with other men”. But you can say, “mommy didn’t follow the rules of respect in marriage”. its truthful w/o giving too much information. there should be no shame in you telling the truth. isn’t that what we teach our children? my kids know their dad had an affair (ok, that he was sleeping around w/anyone who would have him) because he wasn’t careful. they do not know he is bi-sexual (yet. remember he’s not careful).
i have never pretended that the divorce was something that could have been prevented. they know we left because of things that were unacceptable. in many ways that made it easier. when he does something mean/hurtful/etc., i remind them that this is not new, thats who he is (abuser, liar, user). there comes a point where denying who a person is makes you a supporter of that person. i’m not going to support his bad behavior.
I’m single parent too..My advice is to have both parents sit down and tell the whole story in front of their children. So, the children won’t get confused about the whole divorce situation.
Truth,truth,truth. Stick to the facts, explain in a manner which does not assign blame, the situation. Your daughter will figure it all out herself and it’s most likely she’s simply frustrated with the lack of information. Give it to her straight, but gently. Kids are smarter than we give them credit for, there’s little sense in hiding anything. Just give her the info in a age appropriate manner, that’s all you can do.
Jenny´s last blog ..Best Strollers For Toddlers?
My advice? Tell her what happened. As a single parent to an 11 year old daughter, I have been there, done this. You dont have to tell her that her mother was out whoring around with the neighbor while dad was blissfully unaware while mowing the lawn and scrubbing the tiolet. She needs to see reality. mom was unhappy. Neighbor made her happy. She decided she wanted to be with neighbor. Now she lives across the street. Explain to her that in a perfect world, mom would have waited for the divorce to be final BEFORE starting a relationship with neighbor, BUT. Alas, this is not a perfect world, and we adults are not perfect biengs. Mom is still confused, and maybe still unhappy. Sometimes unhappy people do things to make other people unhappy too. It makes them feel better. This dad should make it clear that HE was committed to the marriage, but that mom wasnt. Kids are going to figure out that this happens. Use this as an opportunity to explain the rules of a marriage, and explain how common it it for people to take a marriage for granted. What once was a sacred bond is now little more than a piece of paper…that can be tossed a way like yesterdays garbage. Kids are going to figure this out. Just be honest. No gory details about who had what affair with who, but the generalities. Mom was unhappy. Mom was unfaithful. The end. No details. Let her know that NO, dad did NOT have an affair, mom did. The daughter will grow up and learn what was what regardless. Honesty is key.
I’m still reeling at the thought of that mom poisoning her daughter like that!
One of my best friends managed to raise her son without maligning his father, who was abusive and abandoned them six months after the son was born. Of course, she had to tell him age-appropriate versions of the truth over time; you can’t just say dad is at the grocery store and got lost…. But she never made it a “daddy sucks” statement.
If she can bite her tongue with that much justification, that mother can, too.
I agree with the idea of a third party or a therapist getting involved to mediate, and that the dad does have to tell that tween something. Kids are perceptive and smart, but don’t always have the maturity or the understanding to interpret what they’re seeing. She does need some sane guidance through this.
Anne: We agree – and how well you said it! This tween needs sane guidance. Thanks for joining the conversation.
I have to let them know that I’m single parent too..A strategy to adhere to get both parents sit down and tell the complete story facing their kids. So, the children won’t get confused about the whole divorce situation.
Selina´s last blog ..How to Make Him Fall in Love With You
Twitter @ BigLittleWolf
Some details are not for children to know. Period. Not at any age. As the adults, I believe it is our responsibility to make good judgments relative to what we say and how we say it, in age appropriate fashion, and without exorcising our demons to the detriment of our children.
I say this not only as a single mother, but as an adult child of divorce – who heard too much about too much – during the marriage and after.
BigLittleWolf´s last blog ..Do You Fight Fair?
Twitter @ http://www.singleparentmeet.com/
I believe that it is up to you whether to tell them or not. I would if I were in your shoes. The oldest is old enough to know what happened. Also do they not know that their mom lives right across the street? They deserve to know but only when they are old enough. And it seems like she keeps asking questions so tell her. Good luck!
Give it to her straight, but gently. Kids are smarter than we give them credit for, there’s little sense in hiding anything. Just give her the info in a age appropriate manner. |

hunterX0506´s last blog ..super mario bros games
I feel so sad for the dad. Added to the pain of being cheated is being accused of causing the problem. I admire his patience and strength in this very tough situation. With his traits I believe he can make his daughter understand by constantly being there to communicate and answer her questions one at a time.
Mary´s last blog ..how to meet women
Twitter @ http://urlookinggood.com
My kiddo wants to know everything that happen between his dad and I all the time. He keeps on asking and asking the same questions. Sometimes I feel like he wishes to get a different answer… poor soul…
Larissa´s last blog ..Why to Participate in a SlutWalk
Twitter @ muminawe
My kids asked, and I was never nasty about their Dad. However, as they got older, I did tell them the truth about their Dad never paying maintenance, and explained divorce has 2 sides and neither party is always right. My kids have begun seeing the truth though… Without my ever having to say anything!!!! It’s better for them to make up their own minds as much as possible. I won’t tolerate lies though, and speak to the ex if he’s lying about things.
Give her an age appropraite truthful reponse. My parents are divorced, my mother tried to take the highroad. I just snooped around (at just a little older than your daughter) until I found the information I was looking for and then I was making my own judgements about things rather than having a age approraite answer. My dad had a second divorce with my step mother. SHe had cheated he never told the kids. Everyone is grwon now and everyone found out in thier own way what really happened and at different times. Turns out my youngest sister knew she was having an affair when they were still married and it has been a heavy weight on her during periods of her life. Be honest in an age approriate way. Afterall your ex is saying you cheated, but she is the one living with the man across the street. Assuming you don’t already have a live in other actions speak plenty. A little therapy for all couldn’t hurt either.