When mean girl starts early
by Dr. Leah
Filed under Single Moms
We’ve followed with great concern the tragic events linked to bullying by tween girls. Single mom Michelle Renee bravely recounted at Huffington Post what she did when her 7th grader daughter endured cyberbullying “for several weeks at the hands of those that used to be her ‘friends.’ “
Of course, we’re appalled by the sexting phenomena, incessant virtual taunting, and the apparent rise in face-to-face bullying in middle schools.
We felt confident, however, that as a psychologist and a journalist, we were ON it. We thought these worrisome tween and teen behaviors were simply an unwelcome part of the adolescent parenting challenge.
So, when we received this email from a single mom of a first grader, we paused to talk seriously.
Here’s what this single mom told us:
“My seven year old daughter came home from school yesterday sobbing. The girl who sits next to her in class told her that she was ugly and fat. She said that no one liked her — and she wasn’t going to get invited to any more birthday parties. The worst part of it was that the rest of the girls seemed to go along with it.”
“I just was not prepared for this now,” this mom added. “I thought this jealousy and competition among girls happened in middle school when they got hormonal and boy crazy.”
This note gave us a lot to think about. It doesn’t seem surprising that younger girls might imitate what they’re seeing on shows like “Gossip Girl.” Girls this age are also captive audience to cell phone rants, as well as radio and television shout-fests.
After all, kids imitate almost everything they see and hear. Don’t you agree?
Research on taunting and other types of cruelty by young girls is relatively new. It’s already clear that young girls do use friendship (or not) as a social weapon beginning in preschool.
These researchers and some parents do worry that the kind of taunting younger girls do — criticizing each other’s appearance or threatening to ostracize another girl — can lead to full scale bullying by adolescence.
However, other experts — as well as many parents – do not agree.
Some parents dismiss this taunting and teasing as “girls being girls.” While a “no tolerance” policy does seem to apply if a child is bitten or hit, many parents and some experts do adhere to the “sticks and stone” point of view.
So, we’re wondering how you see this controversy:
Are you concerned with the taunting you hear from little girls?
Or do you feel that these verbal skirmishes are just as “girls being girls”?
Have you also coped with a very upset little girl after she was taunted or bullied?
Any advice on how best to handle such situations?
~~~~~
(Photo courtesy of *eternal miracle* via Flickr)
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
No related posts.






Twitter @ singlemomchrons
Oh my goodness – that appalls me! I think the “girls will be girls” thing does exist as one-offs…you cannot and should not jump on every little thing. But this sounds like a situation that’s too harsh, too mean, too fast; it has a “let’s gang up on her” component to it as well. I am 42 and I still remember situations in 5th and 6th grade (I was much older than your daughter) that made me feel like this. There were a few where I could have used more adult cover – but I never told anyone.
I think that as the parent, you should go talk to the school and have them broker a conversation with the other parents. I wouldn’t go directly to the other parents unless there is a previous and strong relationship with them (a few parents at our school have tried it, and sometimes are stunned by the rudeness with which the other parents responds).
Good luck – it’s such a tender age. My daughter is 8 – this must have hurt you so deeply.
Swati
Swati Bharteey´s last blog ..The Relationship – Chapter Five (a very short story)
My daughter is now 10 and in 4th grade. The taunting also started in first grade (with one girl hitting and poking her), peaked in 2nd grade (she was called the queen of the losers), but still exists to some extent now, although it is much more subtle (others not letting her play at recess or some girls not letting her sit with them). The school has been very supportive, both on an individual level and setting up a classroom program with the school counselor to address bully and dealing with friendship/conflict issues.
I’m not sure what the answer is or how effective these programs are. I do know we adults have to step in to acknowledge the behavior and say that the behavior wrong. To say “girls will be girls” is to be complicit in the bullying. Kids don’t necessarily know right from wrong instinctually and have to taught this.
Twitter @ http://giggedygeekmum.wordpress.com/
Thanks to the bullying I received throughout school my whole sense of self and esteem was shaken for years. “Girls will be girls” is only acceptable if we’re fine with children being emotionally harmed when they should be free to learn and thrive. She NEEDS to address this situation with the school asap. Cut it off before it gains more momentum. Bullying is NEVER acceptable!
Satsuki´s last blog ..Dye Jobs, The Lazy Way
Twitter @ aprilabtbalance
So timely – my oldest daughter and I just went to a conference about this by the author of the book that inspired the movie “Mean Girls.” What the author told us is that what’s most important is how we help our girls through it when it happens. To raise “women of substance,” we have to guide them in using their voices (in a healthy way) to speak up for themselves. I wrote about it here: http://formerlyaprildawn.blogspot.com/2010/03/two-parenting-seminars-in-one-post.html
April´s last blog ..All I really needed to know…
Twitter @ http://singlemommindy.blogspot.com
I would disagree that bullying among young girls is a new developement. I can remember it going on when I was in grade school 30 years ago! Back then we had to take our lumps and learn how to deal with it with little, if any, parental or teacher involvement. I think it was also a character building opportunity; either you joined the mean girls, ignored them, or you stood up to them. Some girls fared better than others, depending on their personality and how they chose to react, but these types of challenges and situations dont cease the minute we become adults either. There are plenty of grown up bullies out there and dealing with them is something we all have to learn to do.
I am by no means condoning bullying behavior but I have to wonder if the bullying has increased in severity these days because parents DO become more involved and often in unhealthy ways instead of just letting their child sort it out. And quite possibly these parents were mean girls themselves or were picked on and overreact based on their own experiences.
I dont argue that t.v. plays some role but I think parents make a much bigger impression on a child’s character.
Mindy@SingleMomSays´s last blog ..Snow Day!
Twitter @ http://giggedygeekmum.wordpress.com/
I’m just curious as to what you would have this little first grader do?
A first grader is not developmentally ready to navigate these waters on their own. Yes, we can force them to do it but why would we want to do that?
It’s a parents job to protect their child when they need it, not just suggest they suck it up and take their lumps or fight back. That’s how school violence & suicides start.
Satsuki´s last blog ..Dye Jobs, The Lazy Way
Twitter @ tailgatingtimes
I definitely agree that confidence is a big part of how people deal with the teasing. I’ve taught both of my kids that teasing isn’t ok and I’ve had to fight the temptation to give them stinging comebacks that would make them no better than the teasers at times. Both of my kids have been teased and they both know I don’t approve of them doing it to others. Fortunately for the most part they are strong kids and it doesn’t rattle them too much.
I just saw an interesting example of girl teasing at my daughter’s softball game last week. One of their team cheers/chants consists of taunting the other teams with stuff like “Hey first baseman, do your hair…hey second baseman, do your makeup…etc.” Both teams were doing the chant until our coach heard it and made the girls stop. He told them they didn’t like it when the other team did it to them and he didn’t care if the other team did it but our team only talks about how good we are. We don’t put down the other team. The next game one of the girls started the chant and several others stopped it. That was nice to see.
As a teacher it is much easier to look at a case of hitting or stealing and say “this is a problem” than it is to look at how girls can be to each other. I certainly don’t feel comfortable saying to a student “you need to quit excluding that girl” and the victim usually wont tell the teachers about it.
One thing I don know is that little girls of all ages use social status the way boys use physical status. So if a girl wants to bully another girl she will start by trying to socially isolate the girl, refusing to speak to her and the like. Kids do imitate what they see and hear so certainly as parents we need to make sure they are not exposed to the wrong sorts of influences.
One thing you can also do is monitor the situation. If it continues speak to the classroom teacher about your concerns. If that doesn’t get results, go to the building administrator. Every child has a right to be free of all sorts of bullying, but sometimes parents need to advocate for their children in order to make sure that happens.
alley´s last blog ..Hey look!
Twitter @ tsquest
I have seen some of this taunting with girls in school and between my two daughters! Kids are just mean to each other. Kids are trying to establish an identity and will step on another kid to do that.
I point out to my girls:
Is this a true statement about you?
Can you ignore that child and understand that they are acting out because they have been treated badly too? Or perhaps they’re sad? Or tired? Or hungry? Or having a bad day?
I have taught my children the same thing about people who make choices to not treat others well. Most of the time, it comes from a sad place, a resentment or anger builds and gets taken out on whomever is near.
I think kids do the same thing. I’m doing my best to point out that they should try not take it personally because it isn’t about them. It is about how the other child feels in that moment and what they feel they can do to be accepted.
Now is when we teach them the golden rule: Treat others the way you wish to be treated.
T´s last blog ..The Inspiration for the Quest
Twitter @ http://asmymotherbeforeme.blogspot.com
My girls are now nearly adults. One is 18 the other is 17. I too taught them (as T) that others who are mean, or suicidal or just plain attention getting, are probably fighting their own battles…
However, recently a best friend decided she no longer wanted to be her friend. Possible out of jealousy. But no matter the cause, she has been incredibly horrible toward my daughter ever since.
My daughter has done her best to ignore her but sometimes that is just not possible.
It is beyond name calling and snotty looks, it has turned into the other girl making life unbearable for my 17 year old.
Telling lies to mutual friends (whom I explained to my daughter must not be REAL friends), groups sitting down at the lunch table seconds before her, even so much as in public right in front of me, her mother. Although I was distracted at the time and missed it.
It is a major cause of suicide, lifelong issues such as alcoholism and drug use.
It is not excusable!
Twitter @ _katarena_
This is heartbreaking to read. I don’t remember really being bullied in grade school but when I was in junior high I went to a very small private school. There were 6 kids in my grade and the only other two girls were brutally mean to me. They became an exclusive club and tried to get others to exclude me as well. The worst part was that one of them had been my best friend my entire life & all three of our sets of parents were close. We moved past all of it after a year or so and one of the girls and I are friends again, I was even in her wedding but I never felt the same or trusted them completely again. It made me very insecure about who was really my friend all through high school. Luckily my mom constantly reminded me that these girls were lashing out and that I was the bigger person. While they may not have been much comfort when I was 12 or 13 and being ignored at lunch, it made me very aware of what people’s actions really say about them. It’s made me a more compassionate adult and parent.
My only advice to this mother would be to encourage her daughter to branch out and make other friends. To remind her how special she is and to tell her that girls that act that way are almost always doing so as a way to hide their own faults and insecurities. She can’t force the girls to be friends & trying to do so would probably only make the bullying worse. I think that parents are ultimately responsible for how their children treat others, and while I disagree with blaming television & shows like Gossip Girl for the way children (or teenagers or adults) act, I do think that by watching shows like these we tend to desensitize ourselves. We look forward to watching what cruel thing is going to happen next week & who is going to reign as “queen bee” that we forget that if these things were happening to our own children (or if our children were behaving this way) that most of us we be devastated.
Kate´s last blog ..an open letter
Twitter @ http://momandmadness.wordpress.com/
I don’t think it’s just a girl issue. When Squirt started preschool at 3, he started coming out with “Do this and I’ll be your friend” or “Fine! Then I’m not going to invite you to my birthday party!” He frequently came home upset because So-and-So said they weren’t going to invite him to their birthday party (which was usually months away!).
Now that he’s in kindergarten, it’s progressing fast. The attacks are more personal (stupid, ugly, fat, funny hair, talks funny, etc.) and the kids are more inclined to gang up on each other in these attacks. “He’s not my friend any more because he’s friends with So-and-So now” or “All my friends wanted to play with So-and-So and wouldn’t let me play because I have funny hair.” (or the wrong kind of clothes/shoes/backpack which is terrifying coming from kindergartners!) It scares me to death because Pork Chop is very sensitive and also has a speech impediment so I know he’s going to deal with this.
I basically deal with it the same way T described. I have zero-tolerance for my boys saying these things or treating others this way, but when they’re on the receiving end, I remind them they know these things are not true and that the person saying these things is dealing with hurt of their own.
I was thrilled the other day when Squirt came home from school and told me they have a new kid in their class and he gets in trouble all the time and is mean and picks on people but Squirt just keeps trying to be nice to him because he knows he’s not a bad kid, he’s just having a hard time figuring out how to act in a new school and he probably has some yucky feelings in his heart that make him be mean to people when he doesn’t mean to.
I think there’s a delicate balance between teaching kids to deal with it on their own and protecting them when they need it. If it’s really out of hand, definitely talk to the teacher about it so that she can keep an eye on it but I do think it’s a normal part of child development and it isn’t necessarily healthy to run in and “rescue” kids from every little thing.
wondermom´s last blog ..Big plans
Twitter @ tsquest
Aw! I love Wondermom’s little Squirt. What a wonderful response to the new kid in school!
T´s last blog ..Reach down between your legs and rub…
Twitter @ msjennixoxo
I have noticed this early taunting with my kids, and they are only 4 and 5! A lot of it has to do with the fact that my babysitter brings her daughter every day. My babysitter lives with her two sisters, and between them there are 5 boys.. 5 boys can teach a little girl a lot of not-so-nice things, and I have to hear about it every day.
My sitter’s daughter likes to team up with my 4 year old, and gang up on my 5 year old. They tell her they aren’t going to play with her, which is of course heartbreaking to a little kid. They have even resorted to name calling. And for a while, my 4 year old was physically lashing out at her older sister. It started to get so bad, that my oldest was begging me to enroll her in pre-school, because she didn’t want to deal with them anymore [unfortunately, I just don't have the money, since my ex wont pay child support].
This is not tolerated in the house, AT ALL. After several months of time-outs, having privledges taken away, and the occasional spanking [spankings only happened when she would get physical - like throwing dolls & hitting her sister in the face], my 4 year old has finally stopped taunting her older sister. And my sitter has also started correcting her daughter, now that she has seen how much upset she can cause.
This IS a learned behavior. Whether from siblings, TV, movies, etc. I think that if my sitter’s daughter didn’t share a house with five boys, she would have a much more gentler approach to other kids.
Jenni´s last blog ..2010 Kite Festival
Twitter @ http://locsandlittleones.blogspot.com
Actually I DO remember this kind of thing happening at a very young age. Perhaps my situation wasn’t as harsh at this woman’s daughter, but I do recall being told I was fat in the second grade and a weigh in by the nurse revealed that I was a whole 4 pounds heavier than everyone else. And once one person said it out loud, every one started saying it, and that image stuck with me through out the rest of my time in elementary, middle and high school. (I just so happened to graduate with a lot of the same people that were in my kindergarten class) Looking back at pictures now I think I must have been nuts to believe them, but at the time I saw a very different image in the mirror from the moment they began to tease me.
My mother did attempt to intervene in the school and with the parents and that only made it worse. They knew that they had gotten to me. Every time I reacted, they teased louder. This is something that is nearly impossible for a young child not to react to though.
I think the best thing is to reinforce at home that she is beautiful and loved. Teaching her to love herself and not take to heart all the things that people tease her about will be of great help. It will be hard to make that impact right away, but she’ll really benefit from it down the road. Even by the next school year.
My son came home crying from Kindergarten. He told me that no one liked him. I immediately felt like that little girl that was being called fat all over again. Unfortunately my mother prescribed to the idea that if they were making fun of me, it must somehow be true and it became MY fault, which only served to hurt my self image. With my own son, I immediately began telling him his worth was in himself. That I loved him and his family loved him and the negative things that people said to him didn’t matter. It didn’t help immediately, but now that he’s in the 3rd grade, I see him becoming a very confident and caring person. He tells me that he wants always to be true to himself and has even gone out of his way to befriend the kids that find themselves the object of such teasing.
I know that there is also a curriculum in his school to teach the kids about bullying (physical and emotional) and how they should handle it. Talking to the school may be in order to get some programs in place for the WHOLE school. That way there isn’t one child being singled out as the “victim” but rather a dialogue letting the students know that it’s not acceptable to hurt their classmates on any level.
That’s just my two cents.
Marquita: Your “two cents” is welcome @Singlemommyhood. Thanks so much for joining this important conversation. We agree: the most important lessons are learned at home.
Twitter @ modernlovemuse
My son has been both the bully (in preschool), and has been on the receiving end of bullying (in first grade). I know both sides of this coin.
When he was rough with others, we took a zero-tolerance stand, and made him attone for it, by apologizing and by taking away priviledges. He’s now almost 8 and has learned those behaviors are FULLY UNACCEPTABLE by his parents. He doesn’t dare do so now, and we know this because his teachers, and other adults, report to us. We ask all the time.
Unfortunately, not all parents share this attitude. When we moved last year, the kids in our new neighborhood began to mistreat my son. The incidents were horrendous, enough to make me worry for his physical and emotional safety.
I brought it up in a parent meeting. One dad said, ‘it’s the law of the jungle.’ I was stunned.
Attitudes like that have no business in a parent’s repetoire of responses. If we – parents, teachers, family and grown ups – don’t act as the architect of our children’s character, who will?
To the teacher who said she isn’t comfortable teling other kids to include the isolated child, I ask, WHY NOT? You are in charge of that classroom. You can shape their behavior. You can call the parents and explain that you are doing this, and why it needs to be done. I want you to feel empowered to do so! Although I understand that today, we’ve stripped too much control from those who deal with kids, only emboldening the bullies more.
There is no honor in being the parent of the queen bee, or the top dog, only greater responsibility in teaching our youth that might does not make right and that teasing is not humane. Confusing bullying with ‘leadership’ abilities (as some parents do) is also a great disservice to our children, and their futures.
Bullying should be stopped immediately, the consequences should be harsh, and the child/children who bully should be shamed, yes shamed, for their behavior.
And so should the parents who don’t get it.
Any response less than that is a dereliction of duty, in my opinion.
Twitter @ tiiajoneslove
From a teacher’s perspective, the bullying is endemic (at least among girls). I teach sixth grade, and sometimes there is more to worry about with that than the material that I need to instruct. I take it very seriously and so should every teacher.
From a parent’s POV (I have a 13-year-old daughter), it’s just so hard to see your child hurting. My daughter does NOT like me interfering, however. She uses sense of humor to combat the bullies and now she helps to defend others from them (recently stopped a fight involving a disabled girl). From a very young age, we talked about it–what to do and how to handle it. I always told her to “take the high road.” The girls who seem to fare the best are the ones who can find a way to laugh it off. My two cents anyway.
Tiia Jones´s last blog ..Ten Ways to End a Date: Guest Blogger Leah
Twitter @ http://www.vomitcomit.wordpress.com
It’s not just girls-my daughter dealt with this from a little boy she was friends with while they were 5/6 years old. And it was most, if not all, learned at home. Watching his mother interact with him made me realize why he was saying and doing the hideous things to my daughter. (escalating in one time mixing hair gel in water and giving it to her to drink-this was quite shortly before the relationship was severed when his mother stopped caring for my children). His mother yelled, ridiculed, belittled him-and this was only what I saw. Based on his behaviour, I’m pretty sure he was ignored as well as outright physical abuse at times.
My daughter still talks about this, nearly a year away from that little boy. And while I can explain to her that he was very mixed up, and a lot of what he said and did was because of his mother not always being there, there’s still trying to get her past how he hurt her feelings. We talked to the mom. We talked to the school about the “play with me or I will never play with you ever again, and no one else will either.” But how do you change the way a child is? All i could do was urge mine away, and ultimately, make sure that little boy was not around her.
We did what we could on the weekends we’d have him over. But the end of each weekend, after blossoming under some limits and attention, he’d almost be well behaved and mannerly (he was a 6 year old boy after all..
) But then he’d go back to his mother, and we’d start again.
Lesson for my daughter-you can’t change people. But you can control how YOU handle the situation, and what you take from it. She’s learned that you can only feel as bad as you let other people make you feel. And I think, and hope, that this lesson will serve her.
Other kids haven’t been able to touch the level of hostility that little guy did, so we haven’t had any further problems. yet. I remember my grade school years though, so I’ve already started preparing her with the “it won’t matter in the long run” speech. Nothing makes it better at the time though.
Twitter @ msjennixoxo
My oldest daughter is dealing mean girls and bullying in KINDERGARTEN. While writing my post, I kept thinking of the one here on Singlemommyhood.
Linky: http://dearestmexo.com/2010/08/31/bithches-and-jerks-kindergarte/
Jenni´s last blog ..The Chunky Child Are Growth Hormones To Blame
@Jenni, Please let us know when your post is live so we can read it. Hugs!