Can I live with Dad?
by Rachel Sarah
Filed under Single Moms
“Can I live with Dad?” When solo moms in our Singlemommyhood hear this question, they often feel confused — and respond with stunned silence.We understand. These “daddy questions” are among the most perplexing. (Of course, we also understand that many loving dads face the same difficult questions about an absent mom. )
You’re not alone: We’ve been hearing from LOTS of solo moms wanting to talk about this unnerving experience. For example, here’s a recent e-mail from a solo mom with an ex who vanished years ago:
“My five-year-old daughter asked me yesterday if she could live with her dad,” she says. “And I’m heartsick. I’m trying so hard. Is this a signal that’s she’s deeply unhappy? How am I supposed to respond to this question? Help!”
Another solo mom with a young son and daughter told us that her ex has significant addiction issues. She was thunderstruck when her children asked her about living with Dad. Say what? This solo mom thought the children understood her careful explanations of Dad’s illness? She had been convinced that the children were okay with the fact the Dad could not be part of their lives now.
So, Dr. Leah and I buzzed back and forth about what this startling “dad question” really means. We’re convinced that this question has a totally different meaning when asked by a young child — compared to a teenager. Do you agree?
Lots of you have personal experience responding to this “dad question. So, we’re hoping you can add some insight to this conversation:
What does a young child raised by a solo mom really mean when he or she asks “Can I live with Dad”?
What should solo moms keep in mind when responding to this “dad question”?
~~~~
Photo courtesy of Abigail Harenberg
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
No related posts.






Twitter @ http://gawlas.blogspot.com
My guess is that you are correct. Little kids go to school and daycare and are aware that some kids live with both parents and get curious.
with older kids its probably a combination of factors. My ex is all about fun and games when the kids are over there. Compare that to the house where there are rules and routines and I am sure a teen would want the “fun” house. Other requests may be because the teen and non-custodial parent aren’t getting along.
alley´s last blog ..Over posting.
Twitter @ ChasingAmy206
I was forced financially and emotionally to give in to a 4 year relentless custody battle last year and give my daughter’s father primary custody. I won’t go into the emotions of it all because it’s all too much for anyone else to fathom.
The truth is she is just as much his child as mine, regardless of what he did or how he behaved up to this point. That is a fact that will never change. He fought for this, he wanted this, well he got this and it’s not as easy as it looks. We are walking in each others shoes and he won’t admit it but I know he’s struggling as much as I am.
Is she happy? She’s doing fine. She’s in therapy. Did she want this? No, but she’s a child and she needs to know her father for better or for worse. The curtain has been pulled back and the all mighty Oz isn’t the mysterious hero he once was, that’s for sure.
We have lost so much. What we gained is yet to be measured.
She will be my child for another 60 years hopefully. He can’t change the fact that I am her mother and regardless of where she lays her head at night we have a bond that has been strengthened by this and will continue to grow with us. He thinks he’s “Won”…..he just doesn’t see yet what he’s lost.
Twitter @ http://locsandlittleones.blogspot.com
My son hasn’t asked to live with his dad since he was a toddler. Yes, I believe that it was to not only get under my skin, but because Dad is just so much more fun.
My son is now 10 and because I’m not allowed any vacation time in the summer months and day care is double the cost when he’s out of school, his father and I decided to start letting him spend summers there. I call everyday to see how he is, but I think the experience gives him a real perspective on how Dad has to be when he’s the parent for more than just a few days a month. My ex ended up calling me a few times to find out how to handle behavior issues and found that being cool fun Dad doesn’t work for 2 months straight. My son now really appreciates the time he spends with both of us and realizes the grass isn’t always greener.
As a teenager I asked to live with my dad. My reasoning was to get away from my drug abusing brother. Not only did my mother bristle at the idea but my dad backed out too. I saw that I was where they wanted. My dad didn’t want to lose his freedom and my mother wasn’t willing to let me leave.
I fear letting my son go, but if he wants it and his dad is willing, I’d go along with it. We are both his parents and he should get to see what life with Dad is like too.
Twitter @ canadianbaldguy
My daughter has used the “I want to live with daddy” card with her mother numerous times. I’ve talked to her mom about it and I’ve been 100% honest…if she uses, call her bluff.
I say that because I would love to have my daughter move across the country and live with me. No hidden agendas…that’s just what it is. And I’ve told the ex this, as well…just so that there are no secrets.
I don’t know if she’ll ever take me up on the offer, but at 11 years old I think the primary reasons for her saying this are (1) she wants to hurt her mother (for being punished, maybe?), (2) she thinks the grass is greener on the other side (I’d probably be more strict, though), and (3) she really means it.
Obviously, each situation is a one-off and is unique…but that’s the case with me.
Canadian Bald Guy´s last blog ..Is Sex Better After 35?
Twitter @ http://singlemomscircus.wordpress.com/
Fortunately, I’m not single parenting solo. The ex has our boys 3 days a week. He’s not super dad but he loves our boys and takes care of them. Recently my 9 yr old was upset about sharing a toy and threatened to run away to Daddy’s house. I explained to him that his dad would bring him back and would agree with Mommy on the sharing. While I really don’t feel like he meant it, it still hurt. I can only imagine how it feels to hear this from a child who’s father is absent. From the child’s standpoint, I’m sure it comes either out of anger or curiosity over their father. They may think if they live with him, then they’d get to know him. I can only imagine for a child how hard it is when one of their parents is not involved in their life. Their little brains can’t reason to the same degree that and adults can. Nonetheless, it doesn’t make it hurt less to hear those words come out of your child’s mouth especially when you know that you are giving them everything you can to grow them into happy, healthy, functioning adults.
The Ringleader´s last blog ..It’s A Wash
Twitter @ http://www.jane-sliceoflife.com/
Kids are kids, and their questions about the absent parent happen for one of two reasons. The are actually curious, and at times want to emulate what their friends are doing. Or, they asked once out of curiousity, saw this dramatic response from in house parent, and have it filed away for future use in manipulation.
It is our perception of what that question means, and it has nothing to do with their reality. And to be perfectly honest, we put too much pressure on our kids to understand. Where I see this at its worst, is with teens. We as custodial parents can explain all we want, and our kids won’t get it until they are older. Why? They are not adults.
Maintaining a matter of fact attitude if the choice is not in the child’s best interest, whether they are 4 or 16, is a wise move. Their question generally has nothing to do with you as a parent or person, but general curiosity. With teens, it is because they don’t like the boundaries that are set at home. And the squirrelly fantasies that have lived in their heads for so long, look kind of good, even if they have nothing to do with reality.
Sometimes it is tough to hear, but keeping emotion out of the responses and understanding their age and reasoning capabilities, helps a lot.
Jane´s last blog ..Do you parent your friends?
Twitter @ http://smarttalkers.blogspot.com
It’s a hard one but I usually call their bluff and say ‘Shall I ring him now?’ They soon change their mind!
Libby´s last blog ..Will Teaching My Baby Sign Language Delay His Speech