What’s this single dad’s next logical step?
by Dr. Leah
Filed under Single Dads
We received another email this week from a distraught single father — and it has stumped us.
This 35-year-old man fell deeply in love a few years ago, but, unfortunately, the relationship was on-again-off-again. A year and a half later, they broke up for good. She moved back east, and he remained on the west coast.
Soon, he received this text message that shocked him: I’m pregnant.
“When she was pregnant, she’d text or call me one day. But the next day, out of the blue, she’d order me to stop contacting her,” he tells us. “It was very confusing.”
He didn’t know where his daughter was going to be born, or what her name would be. “A day after my daughter was born, I received a text message with a picture.”
Understandably, he was heartbroken: “I very much wanted to be involved in my daughter’s life. So, I contacted an attorney.”
When their daughter was a few months old, he was granted a temporary visitation order. He took an extended leave of absence from work and stayed with family members to be closer to his daughter.
In the meantime, his ex had met a new man, and they now live together. He says that between this new boyfriend, his ex’s mother, and her best friend, they have done everything possible to prevent him from visiting his daughter.
“I pay $1400 per month in child support, 100% percent insurance, and her mother makes $50,000 a year. It seems that if anyone would play these childish games it would be me. Yet I have tried to be the bigger person. I want to be in my daughter’s life.”
He has continued to fight for the right to spend time with his daughter. “I’ve spent more than $48,000 in attorney fees so far. I get the chance to see my daughter just once a month, along with every other Christmas and half the summer.”
This baffles him even more: “If I call, email, or text her mother in reference to our daughter, she takes her time responding. But if I do not inquire at all, she sends me pictures, texts, and email updates often.”
We admit we’re confused, too. So, we’re anxious to hear your thoughts:
Why does this single mom fail to respond? And generously respond when he’s silent?
Are her boyfriend, BFF, and her mom possibly calling the shots?
Or do you feel she just likes to jerk him around?
This dad is NOT walking away from his child.
So, what’s this single dad’s next logical step?
~~~
(Photo courtesy of Ann-Marie Clapham)
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
Related posts:
- When should parenting time be supervised? A divorced single mom who follows us @Twitter sent us a terse email a day or so ago. Our hearts...






Poor guy. Unfortunately paying attorney fees is going to be his only solution. It seems horrible now, but one day his little girl is going to see how hard her dad worked to be involved.
Actually, I applaud him. Not to many people would have the strength to fight… continuously. He’s doing the right thing, though expensive.
She is playing games. The others in her life are playing along. Just don’t get mentally involved in the game.
Keep fighting for your rights.
Your daughter isn’t going to benefit from you talking to her mother over the phone. If you get more info by not contacting her, then let her do the contacting. Although she will probably start something worse if you don’t ever contact her, because she is playing a game and wants to have control.
Keep a journal of everything that happens and your thoughts. Your daughter, as an adult, might need to know these things.
The court can put everything is writing. Follow those guidelines, enjoy your daughter, and remember you are doing the right thing.
Stay strong. I wish my son had a father who cared this much.
Diapers & Dates
Twitter @ http://scribblingsofasoccermom.com
I almost got tears reading this…this is horrible for the child. A girl needs a dad in her life–many studies have said this. Fight for full custody. I don’t see what choice he has at this point. The judge can then order the mother to respond appropriately for visitation. You’re not shirking your duties as a father so I don’t see why you shouldn’t fight for the full custody. Judges do award custody to the father more often now. The question is, are you going to move to the East Coast to be near the child if the judge orders 50-50 physical custody or visitation? It seems like you’ll have to to have a quality relationship with your child. Get a job, move nearby and force the issue in court if you have to…your daughter needs you in her life!
Soccer Mom´s last blog ..High Cost of Getting Sick
In all honesty, given that we’re talking long distance visitation with a young child, his access doesn’t sound particularly unreasonable. It will likely increase as she gets older to include school breaks as well, at least on an alternating basis. But really, what this LD dad has now is…3 days a month less than your standard non-custodial father who lives in same town.
As to the information share, I think when Mom is doing it on her terms, she feels comfortable doing it and like she is in control of her life. When Dad is asking, she may be taking it as a demand (even though I’m sure he doesn’t mean it that way) and responding to it as such. This one seems an easy fix to me: Back off. Let her come to you and share. Show interest when she does. Be appreciative. Follow up on anything open ended. But let her set the pace, given that he’s apparently not being denied when she does.
And no, I don’t think it’s a given anyone else is “calling the shots.” I think she’s got a life that works for her. And she doesn’t see much of a place in it for him. Especially if that means sending her daughter off out of her sight and protection for large chunks of time. Plus, she probably feels very much like her boyfriend is Dad, so she’s not really feeling the “a girl needs her father” argument. In her mind, her daughter has one and he lives with her fulltime. I’m not saying that that’s right. And Dad certainly doesn’t need to embrace that.
But I think unless he’s willing to move permanently to where his daughter and her mother live, he’s going to have to accept that there are limitations to the relationship he’s going to be able to have with her. And that those limitations are not Mom’s responsibility or her problem to correct.
Twitter @ http://www.mommiesneedlovetoo.blogspot.com
This post breaks my heart. I am divorced and would love to be free of my ex but we have two daughters together. And he is a good dad. And they love their daddy. I know that having a good daddy in their life is important for little girls so that they grow up and make the right decisions about relationships. I would never keep them from their dad. We share equal custody which allows for him to basically screw me on child support, but I chose to do it for my kids.
Even if we had been split up before they were born I would have made sure he was part of their lives. Even if their father had been a one night stand I would want him to be part of their lives if he chose to be because its important for them.
Here we have a dad who wants his daughter. Many dads in this situation would disappear when given the chance. I don’t understand why this mother would not want him more involved. He sounds like he has this little girl’s best interest at heart.
I am rooting for him on this one. Something has to change.
Athena´s last blog ..Where did the Love go
Twitter @ JBSirius
This one hits close to home. I am a dad of a daughter 1500 miles away from me. And my situation is a result of my ex’s mother pushing me away. I was 19 then and didn’t know my rights. I also came across the same treatment when I’d call or email and get nothing. But, then if I let it be, I’d get random information sent to me, along with “since you haven’t asked…”.
All in all, I think Kimberly already put it best. With your distance, you didn’t get such a bad deal. If you can find a way to be closer, then you could try for more.
Good luck. And, keep in mind, kids are on computers young these days. Thanks to Facebook, I have constant contact with my little girl now.
I completely disagree that this dad should be grateful for the scraps this mother is willing to give. That child has two parents who want an active role in her life. She should be afforded that benefit. This isn’t about the mother and what works for ‘her life’. This is about that child and what is in her best interests. If the mother was so dispassionate about the father of her child she had every opportunity to never tell him she was pregnant. She had moved clear across the country, there was little chance of his ever knowing the truth. When she sent him the text “I’m Pregnant” she made a choice to include him in her life and the life of her child. That she has someone who is ready and wants to step in and own his role as a parent is an amazing gift that only someone who is on the opposite side of that fence can appreciate.
That said, I think if this father wants to be more engaged and have more siginificant time with his child then he needs to make the decision to move. The distance, especially with a young child is difficult at best to overcome. And his visitation schedule given that distance isn’t unreasonable. But if what he wants a bigger role in her life, he needs to be near her. Because like it or not possession is 9/10′s of the law and as such his ex is holding a good deal of the cards in this case. Proximity will help level the playing field.
As for the outside influences on her decisionmaking – We are only hearing his side of the story and we all know there are three sides to any story. I think that he needs to find what’s going to work for the two of them towards the best interest of raising their child. Engaging in anything beyond that is a losing proposition.
Twitter @ iswirls
Tough situation for the dad. If it’s possible to live closer that would be a great option, which would give him more visitation. But since he doesn’t, he will need to just take a deep breath and realize that as the daughter gets older, the daughter will maintain more contact than the mother. I’ve experienced something like this years ago. And it all changed when my son was about 9yrs old and he took a vocal stance. He pursued a relationship with me as much as I did with him. And his mother/grandmother wasn’t able to interfere.
I’d suggest, continue with all things you’re doing… eventually things will change for the better.
Twitter @ http://www.cathouseteri.blogspot.com
As much as my heart aches for this father (my son is in a similar situation with his baby boy), the focus of the law is always going to be the rights of the child to see his or her parents and not on the parents’ right to see their child. Fortunately, the law agrees that the parents need to be involved. They do take into consideration the role that the non-custodial parent has taken in the child’s life to date. The sad thing about that is that if you have not had the opportunity to have a large impact on the child’s life yet, you don’t have as much of the law behind you.
Having said all of that and having seen a lot of this in my little half-century long life ~ there is nothing more important than fighting for your children. Keep fighting. And I agree with the above comment ~ it will get better. Those children grow up and make their own needs known and become their own advocates.
Twitter @ lildevilmama
My son’s Dad lives close by, and we have struggled with how he feels he fits into our son’s life. He doesn’t feel his visitation affords him the same type of relationship he would have if we had stayed in a relationship, but our therapist encourages him to understand that sadly this is the choice we made when we chose not to be a couple anymore. Distance made it tougher, and so he moved closer. Albeit it was only a couple hours, but the closer this Dad lives to his little girl the easier it will be for him to assert his parental rights. And, regardless of Mom’s situation he deserves those rights just as much as any parent who cares enough to be there.
It sounds like Mom is in the same striking pose I was in when I was newly single and starting over with an unborn child…we defend, and put ourselves in a place where this person can’t hurt us or our child ever, without wanting to see the big picture. And of course rallying the troops makes it feel like we’re doing right by our kiddo. I’ve done it and once I saw how it would impact my son over the years, I began to work towards a solution and not an uphill battle. I do think this Mom just isn’t sure what to do or how to handle this situation. It’s hard when things don’t work out the way you hope.
This Dad needs to assess the situation with his logistics, and if he’s willing to relocate then he could probably get the true 50/50 custody that he wants but, before he battles for full custody he needs to think about how that would impact his little one long term as well. And, yes I agree with Kimberly, visitation even with the distance between my son and his Dad was limited because of his infant age, and the distance of just a couple hours. Things have progressed with this age, and the new living situation, but that takes time. Every parent who splits and wants to be there and be a part of their kids lives deserves to, but all factors involved need to be taken into account before making big choices either way. If this Dad can maintain communication, and make it clear to Mom that he’s only interested in doing what’s best for their child, she might hear him eventually and take down some of those defenses.
Best of luck to him in his journey!
Twitter @ http://www.eatdrinkdivorce.com
He has to stop allowing her to jerk him around. Have her upload photos to a agreed upon site. Don’t accept text messages. If there is an emergency have a designated number for that. Keep his attorney on this. He is gving too much power to that woman and she is slapping him upside the head with it. See, she knows how to rip his guts out and goes there everytime. Stop trying to connect with her family. His fight is in the courts. Her family is on her side. Has he had a paternity test done? I am always suspect of folks who play these kind of games with children. He has to steel himeslf and insulate his heart. This is a long haul. I would also advise that he keep a journal, scrapbook with entries of when he tries to contact the child, list of birthday gifts, child support, photos of his visits with her and his family etc. That child will not be a child forever. Someday she is going to be old enough to seek the truth. It is unfortunate. There is no magic wand, only his ability not to let this break him and make him bitter. That child deserves a sane, happy parent.
Lovebabz´s last blog ..YOU HAVE THE ANSWER
“Have her upload photos”? Are you kidding me? The day photos were demanded of me would be the day I stopped taking any (or at least admitting to doing so).
I felt very, very generous in that when my daughter’s father was finally at the point of establishing contact with her, I made a CD of over 50 pictures of her and gave it to him. But I did that to be nice. Had it been demanded of me, he never would have seen a photo of her that he didn’t take himself.
Want to refuse my texts? Ok. But I don’t answer my phone often, so good luck actually communicating with me outside of registered letter (which is what I do when I want to make absolutely certain that my daughter’s father cannot dodge my communication. Well, that and CC his lawyer on correspondence.)
Basically, responding to power plays with power plays doesn’t really work out well when you don’t actually have much power.
This is sad, women complain about men not taking responsibility for their kids but then we have cases like this, where a man wants to be a real father and the woman wants to separate the kid from the father, and at least I wonder how come. It is really discouraging and unfair. I wish that my daughter’s father would be interested in seeing his daughter and looking to do so instead of me having to chase him for a visitation with his daughter!! The only way here for this man is to keep going to COurt and fight for more visitation time. Unfortunatly, this man wasn’t married to the mother therefore in most States he will have less rights than the mother and it might be very difficult for him. I would tell him just not to give up, keep on insisting, send his daughter letters (btw it wouldn’t be a bad idea to keep a copy of them to show it to the daughter in the future in case that the mother won’t allow her to see them), keep on calling your daughter, send her mail, e-mails constantly, do everything ou can to keep contact with her. Even if the mother doesn’t allow him contact, someday the daughter will grow up and he can show her that he did as much as he could to be near her and it was the mother the one who tried to keep him away.
Twitter @ alwaysmarly
My son is a single father of two daughters. He has sole custody of his girls and the mother has lost all custodial rights due to some very bad behavior. However, it took him around $30,000.00 and an incredible lawyer to get this. Even with the fact that the mother had drug problems and so on. He did everything in his power to get his daughters and to protect them from the life that their mother would have inflicted upon them. We went online and checked all the stats on ‘child custody’ lawyers and picked out the one with the best record. He talked to a private investigator and got the heads up on some good info as to what to do as well. He sought out some of her old friends and got their help to video and record some of her bad behavior. He insisted on the most advanced drug testing..and so on a so forth.
I realize that this man is not wanting to take this woman to task for total custody, but being informed on your rights is the first step. He has to do his homework. My son is thinking about starting a ‘free’ information help line for guys in this situation and I think after hearing this story that a lot of guys would benefit from this. He has already helped a couple of his friends get their custodial rights. I pray that this guy loves his child enough to keep on trying. Unfortunately, the system is still biased in the mothers favor regardless of the circumstances, but things are changing.
Don’t give up!!
Has the dad considered that there may be no ill will intended on the mother’s part when she sporadically sends information about their daughter? Isn’t it possible that in her world, if she hadn’t heard from him in a little while, she feels she should reach out and keep the communication open, and when she does hear from him, she knows that the lines are open? I’m not sure we should assume she’s playing any kind of game at all. Having a young child and a full time job (she makes an income, I can only assume) and managing a new relationship are all pretty time-consuming.
Has the dad considered moving closer to his daughter?
Twitter @ mattvjohnson
To get increased visitation, 50/50 and more it generally requires several things. Living close to the child is important and having documentation on visits/activities is important.
To the posters that think there is no real problem with her treatment of him you are on another planet. Some women know exactly what they can get away with in court and in divorce, all to protect the kid from their big bad father.
Things are changing though and will continue to change, and this will be in the best interests of the child. More shared/joint parenting=successful kids.