When your child cries for Daddy
A sweet email from a solo mom grabbed our attention because both of us have coped (n0t always successfully) with our own kids’ absent dad questions. What makes these absent dad questions so unnerving is that your kids often ask about their father unexpectedly, and at different ages and stages.
As solo moms, we’re often left feeling uncertain that we’ve responded to these kid concerns in the best possible way. So, here’s this solo mom’s “Daddy dilemma:”
“I’m a big fan of Dr. Leah’s book. And your Singlemommyhood community is a big comfort, ” this she began. “Right now, I need some help.”
This mom told us that she is divorced from the father of her three-year-old daughter. She was pregnant when they broke up, and this bio-dad has chosen to see his daughter only once or twice a year. He recently remarried, and although his new wife is apparently pushing him to have more contact with his daughter, he remains distant and uninvolved. Frankly, this mom doesn’t miss him and counts herself lucky to live without co-parent drama.
This solo mom has explained to her three-year-old that their infrequent visitor is “Daddy” — but her daughter has never seen Mommy and Daddy interact in her own home. And this bio-dad’s infrequent and brief visits never include comforting or soothing his child.
Here’s what got this mom so perplexed: “My daughter has started crying out for ‘Daddy’ when she’s when she’s hurt or upset.”
At first, this mom thought maybe this happened because her daughter just saw her father — after not seeing him for a year. But she continues to bring him up, say, when she’s playing with her dolls and pretends that one doll is “Mommy” and another doll is “Daddy.”)
So, this solo mom is wondering….
Is her daughter simply imitating other kids when she cries out for “Daddy” when she’s hurt or upset?
Is she also just imitating other kids’ doll play?
Or, is her daughter sending a strong emotional message that she misses her father?
If so, what’s this solo mom’s logical next step?
~~~
Photo via Flickr: VioletMuse
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
No related posts.






Twitter @ jeciwall
I believe given the child’s age that its a mixture of both. Children imitate what they see around them, which could be TV or other children. But if she had just had a recent visit with Bio-dad, she might be exhibiting the need to see her father more often. Its difficult to make any uninvolved parent make extra efforts to see their children and sometimes it can backfire. So my suggestion would be to open up communication with him and also the new wife. She will have more influence over him than you would. Goodluck.
Twitter @ englishontarget
Fulfill her wish in words: I wish you could be with your dad, that would be nice. (No buts…)
Twitter @ tsquest
Oh my goodness, I think ALL kids do that. They see other kids with mommys and daddys and it’s on TV or in books… My kids used to do it when they were in trouble with me or when they were overtired. Then, when they were with their dad, they’d ask for ‘mommy’.
Personally, I don’t think there’s anything wrong with her exhibiting this. It sounds like the mom is trying to build an example to her daughter that a “family” should include a mommy and a daddy or else she wouldn’t let this seemingly uninvolved “dad”* near her child. Of course the little girl will begin to accept that ideal in her own mind.
I say the mom could start to give examples of other families. Single parent families. Two mom or two dad families. Families that are cousins or Aunt and nephew or whatever. Allow her to see (which also means the mother convinces herself) that family can mean LOTS of different things and doesn’t always have to be a mommy and a daddy.
My family includes neighbors and daycare providers and best friends (including some male friends). I hope my daughters grow up to make “family” wherever they are. It is very powerful, for the mom and the daughter, to be able to bloom where they are planted.
(*The reason I put “dad” in quotes is because this man doesn’t sound like a father at all. There’s a difference between fathering a child and being a father.)
I am the person who wrote to Dr. Leah originally with this question.
My response is to T. I would caution you to make assumptions about me or my parenting style. I do not believe that a family constitutes a mom and a dad, most of the people my daughter interacts with are friends and family and I always explain that families all look different. In fact, I am lucky have her at a daycare where the kids in other classrooms have diverse family situations including 2 mommies and lots of single moms. Unfortunately in her class, there are all 2 parent families, including moms and dads. I have spoken to her teachers about this and made sure they don’t give the impression that she is not from a “normal family” as compared to her classmates.
I do not think the answer is to shield my daughter from seeing her “uninvolved” father. I think that is a setup for her to be angry in the end because I may have prevented her from getting to know him, even if he doesn’t come around much. I allow him to see her so that she can make her own decision about him. He is not dangerous, just irresponsible in being involved in her life. I highly recommend Dr. Leah’s book on this topic, it helped a lot. My instinct was to cut him out completely too, but learned that a reaction like could come back to haunt me later.
The question really is because I am perplexed that she cries out for her father, even though he has never been around. She knows also who she is talking about because she’ll mention his wife, his step-daughter, her baby brother, etc. I tell her that he lives far away, and that is about it. I am at a loss at what else I should say.
My daughter does this a lot, I also don’t know where it comes from! I suspect its the influence of media and the other kids that she is around. He and I have been apart since before she was born so, like your daughter, she doesn’t know us as a couple. Keep doing what you’re doing and she will understand at some point.
Good luck to you.
S: We wondered about how much the media might influence this little girl’s cries for “Daddy”. Thanks for sharing your perspective. We hope you visit us again soon.
Twitter @ notthecar
The easy and 95% true answer is that it has zero to do with your ex. I will admit I don’t have experience with this as my daughter was non-verbal as a toddler but I’ve seen it in other children from single and married households. In fact it happens A LOT in married households at that age. Children mimic other children as well as tv. Children with 2 parents tend to also go through a phase where they call for whomever the non-primary caregiver is.
I don’t know if you have a circle of married friends with children but ask them about parent rejection. It happens and I’ve seem it reduced happily married women with involved husbands to sobbing tears.
It’s not you or your ex. Don’t worry
Kia´s last blog ..NotTheCar- @sparklyfarts no wonder so many criminals went free
Twitter @ tsquest
@D: The only assumptions I am making are in relation to the brief synopsis I have here in this post. Absolutely, I have no idea what your parenting style is or else my advice may have hit home with you. That’s the thing about a forum like this: we can only give you our experience.
I still stand by my earlier point that books or TV or other children (as you mentioned in her daycare class) are influencing her. And I also applaud you for showing her other definitions of family. Keep on doing what you’re doing. She is observing you all the time. Kids learn a lot more by observation than what they are being told.
Children also go through LOTS of different phases. Stay consistent. She’ll always find security in that.
Regarding the father: I didn’t mean to imply to cut him out. Again, I don’t know the specifics of your situation with him or how he is with her. This post sounded like he didn’t really have any desire to be that involved. If that’s the case, I wouldn’t “cut him out” but rather not force things with him. I would think, and I’m not Dr. Leah nor an expert on this, that forcing a man to be involved when he’d rather not be is worse than not being involved with him at all. That may or may not apply to you. That is just my opinion of a situation where that is the case.
@D: Thank you so much for chiming in here. I just wanted to add my two cents that I don’t think T was making assumptions about you or your parenting style. Thank you both for continuing this conversation with obvious mutual respect.
Twitter @ IssaMas
I’ve been a single parent since pregnancy as well, my 3 yr old son has never seen his father & I living together, and in fact, barely sees us in the same room together. His father legally has a one evening a week visitation for 3 hours (which he follows through with VERY inconsistently), and overnights one weekend a month visitation (which he has never followed through with). Just today my son woke up and said, “I miss my Daddy” (how freakin’ timely for this conversation, huh?). It used to hurt when he said things like this, or when he’d cry out for him when I’d scold him. I realized most of that was my own baggage/pain about his father’s absence. For the most part, I think my son cries out for his father for a few different reasons: a) He genuinely misses him, b) He sees through the NickJr programs he watches that everyone has a mommy AND a daddy, and that they all live together (to that point I think Dr. Leah, Rachel & I should develop a cartoon about a kitty who lives with Mommy only and sometimes gets to see Daddy too, and then pitch it to NickJr), c) He is getting messages from everywhere, not just media, that most families are 2-parent families, even though we know that is simply not the case in this day and age. I only very recently came to a place where I found the right solution for me: when he says he misses his daddy, I reply, “I understand”, and give him a hug. That’s it. For me it was a simple matter of separating my issues from my son’s and addressing his feeling of loss in the simplest of terms, giving him comfort, then moving on quickly. If he cries out for his father when hurt or scolded I ignore it. I don’t feel it imperative to address it then, I address whatever the actual issue is (misbehaving or being hurt). This is what works for me now; I’m sure I will have to adjust that along the way as he gets older. This topic is always a challenge. I’m hoping I was helpful. ((Hugs))
Issa – Single Mama NYC´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday
Twitter @ SoloParentGuide
I think I would feel heartbroken and pissed at his dad at the same time. Then I would probably regard asking for Daddy as a symptom of something else– a wish, a want that he can’t express yet, and would ask: “Why do you miss Daddy? If Daddy were here now, what would you say to him or do with him?” My goal would be to drill down as far as possible to find out what he feels so that I have as shot at comforting him and providing options in 3 year old language. With my kids sometimes they miss dad because he plays Wii with them, other times they just want to hug him. I can play Wii but I can’t be him.
Then I would try to use this opportunity to teach my kids coping strategies for life. An example of the life lesson conversation I might try after asking question: “Sometimes we feel sad. When I’m sad, I cry and then I feel better or sometimes I listen to music or I draw a picture of my sad feelings. Would you maybe like to listen to music or make a picture?”
My daughters ask for Daddy randomly even though they see their dad about 40% of the time. We usually draw pictures, write him an “I miss you” email, or look at a calendar together to count days until they see him again. The calendar doesn’t sound like an option but maybe something else is helpful.
Twitter @ SoloParentGuide
So, sorry, I came away imagining you had a son when clearly you have a daughter. I am going to get some caffeine now. My apologies!
Twitter @ TatterScoops
Issa, thank you so very much for sharing how you handle the situations. I’m separated for 9months and my soon-to-be-ex haven’t seen my son in 3months, never calls, he even ditch my son’s birthday party after I invited him. My son is old enough to remember his Daddy and where I live, very few people are single parents so ‘normal’ family constitute of mommy, daddy and kiddos. My son had stop asking me to come home to his daddy but he still does say ‘daddy’ and yes TV does influence this like that one “I love you Daddy” song commercial for Nick Jr shows they use here. I still don’t know how to handle the Daddy question coz I’m still hurting but I keep trying to tell my son that Mommy and Daddy loves him so much. Thank you again. And to D, I’m wishing you all the best! You’re all strong strong women!
Tatter Scoops´s last blog ..Celebrating Motherhood &8211 The 4th Year
Twitter @ urbanmomsdiy
I think a ton of it – especially if she’s in daycare – is mimicking what she hears. I’m a choice mom of a 2.5 year old and even though he will announce that ‘he no have a daddy’ – he sometimes calls me daddy or refers to others as daddy. it’s tougher for you though – I just say ‘you don’t have a daddy but you have….and he rhymes of all of his ‘peeps’.
Sara´s last blog ..This Song Reminds Me of ThursdaysWATCHING THE WHEELS
Twitter @ solomother
D, Irma’s advice is great. You can’t change who your ex is, and you are right in not blocking their visits, no matter how infrequently.
My ex has seen the Kid three times in the last four years? Maybe four. And only just this year did he start Skyping with the kid on a regular basis. When my son was your daughter’s age we split.
The kid has gone through his stages–last was being so angry that his father does nothing to help him out. He went through a phase where he wanted his daddy, but that was when he was sick of being parented by me. He has never wanted his father for comfort…
I reflect what my son says, and I leave it at that. I don’t give him reasons, I don’t try to take advantage of the moment to slag the ex. I do say I’m sorry he feels like that, or that I’m sorry his father doesn’t do xx, but I tell him his dad is doing the best he can, we just have to accept that.
You’re doing all the right things. She’ll grow out of it. Breathe.
I thank each and every one of your for your very thoughtful comments, they have helped immensely. I love the idea of just validating her feelings. I am a social worker so that should be easy!
I feel absolutely confident that I have kept all of the doors open for him to have a relationship if he wants one. I even told him about Skype and that skye was on it, and he’s “called” her maybe 2 times in the last 8 months. He’s the one who has a lot of explaining to do in the future when she asks, if she asks
T: I absolutely agree with everything you said. I wholeheartedly agree that it is not a good idea to force a relationship. And I agree that media has a strong influence on all of this.
Issa: lets get started on that NickJr special girl
I just came onto this site to see if there was anyone else addressing this issue. My son has just turned two. His dad lives on the other side of the world and has had no contact with me since I discovered i was pregnant.
My son has just started saying daddy a lot! First thing he says in the morning. He is calling other friend’s partner’s daddy. He points at men on the street and says daddy. I don’t know what to say to him and it breaks my heart.
Sorry I don’t have advice. I just wanted to add to the chat because I need help with this too. What do I say to him? I thought I had a few more years before I needed to address this.
@Moz: We are honored to hear from you, please keep us in touch about your son — and we will be posting more about this topic soon.
@Moz: It is totally normal! I had the SAME thing happen. It was alarming at first… she would see random men in the grocery store and call them Daddy. You can imagine how horrified the guy’s girlfriend of wife was…. I always responded, “Well, he might be a Daddy to someone, why don’t you ask him?” And I would joke to the wife or partner of the man my daughter called “Daddy” and say, “I swear we’ve never met”. Made for a good laugh at least. I found that dealing with it like that worked for me. Now my daughter doesn’t do it anymore. She’ll see a daycare dad arrive for his child and say, “That’s (child’s name)’s Daddy”. My daughter has a lot of “Tios” (uncle in spanish). When her real father showed up for her birthday last year, she called him Tio. I told her that he was her father and could call him Daddy if she wants. She calls him Daddy now, even though she doesn’t see him much. Now she is almost 3 and doesn’t call random guys Daddy anymore. The phase will pass. Sometimes a little humor and a positive attitude is what gets me through the tough times. Hopefully it will for you too!
Good luck.
Sara: We’re always happy to welcome another choice mom. Preschool kids are simply figuring out the world …calling someone “Daddy” or repeating what they hear other kids say is just part of their development. But, it’s hard not to over analyze their language exploration when this daddy issue is so close to our hearts. Thanks so much for joining the conversation.
Twitter @ tailgatingtimes
I just wanted to add my two cents and say this used to happen to me a lot with my daughter. Anytime she would get upset and especially when she was disciplined she would start crying and saying she missed her mom. I think to some extent she just wanted comfort and of course she also genuinely missed her mom. For a little while I told her that I missed her too (I did) and though it rarely happens anymore now I just tell her that I know she misses her and that it’s ok. A couple of years ago the family dog died and then that was who she cried for. I think there are all kinds of reasons why kids do this. Some of the time I think it’s because it can elicit a strong response from the parent that is present. The high road is never easy.
Twitter @ http://www.howdoesshedoitmom.com
Having been in a very similar situation many times I have to admit I have found myself perplexed over the same topic several times.
I was a single mom for 3 years before meeting my fiancée and he moved in with us. I answered and dealt with tears and “I want Daddy” more than I wished I had to. While my situation was a bit different (their dad saw them twice a month) it was still mind boggling to me…mostly because he is a father who is pretty much absent with the exception of those two weekends a month. I could never get my head around why they would still call a for a man who had done nothing but let them down.
And then I realized something…they didn’t know that they had been let down. They did not know that their dad put his own life before theirs. I most certainly never told them any of that..so where does that leave them…kids who know that there are Mommy’s and Daddy’s and that theirs wasn’t around…of course they would ask.
As for this little tyke above perhaps it isn’t so much that she misses her own Daddy’s because he is clearly uninvolved but maybe she is asking for Daddy purely out of the knowledge that there is such a thing. I know for my kids when their step-dad moved in and they had a strong male role model in their life the asking for Daddy stopped for the most part. I think that one of the things they needed was that regular male interaction.
Sure they still say they miss him sometimes but I think that is normal…it doesn’t bother me or confuse me so much anymore. I have come to understand that it is natural.
How Does She Do It Mom´s last blog ..How to “Do Something With Your Life”
My 4 year old son cried until there were no more tears last night. He woke up at 12:45am and i heard the whining and then all of a sudden when i asked him what was wrong he just started with this gut wrenching crying..it was so bad that i started to break down and cry with him. He wanted his Daddy who does not call or keep in touch at all. He left us when my son was 18 months old and now lives in Florida (we live in DC) he now has a girlfriend that has 3 kids that live with them. My son has cried over his Dad before but never ever this much or with this much hurt. I told him that i didnt grow up with either my mom or my dad and that some kids have no arms, no legs, no food to eat, no home, and that he should be happy and strong and that no matter what i will never leave him. i told him that his Daddy is not able to live with us because he has another family. I told him that his Dad loves him very much but if he wanted to be here he would. I want my son to be strong but i’m not sure if i’m telling thim the right things. I told him to pray and that he was bigger than the universe and that God was inside of him. I was just pulling things from left and right but eventually he said that he felt better and I just asked him to be strong and then i sung a lullaby to him. He said “mommy i want you to sing that lullaby forever” my heart totally broke last night. I hate to see my son go through all of this pain.
Donna: We got emotional reading your comment. We both know that helpless, panicked feeling when your child is in crisis over a deliberately absent parent. And you have no idea what to say. That lullaby is sacred now to both of you. It’s your personal code that signals to your son that you will never abandon him. Next time your son brings up his father, quietly ask him if he’d like you to sing “your lullaby”.
Thank you for sharing your struggles with us. We’re all stronger when we stick together.
My son is 1 year old and within the last month he has started crying EVERY time i pick him up when i try to take him from his father (or his grandfather – who drops him off every once in a while), when i drop him off, he’s perfectly fine. I feel horrible – like he doesn’t want to come with me and it’s so hard when i love him so much and can’t stand our time apart – what can i do to make it so he doesn’t cry anymore when i pick him up? and why is he doing this?
@Amber: Your comment really touched us. Transitions are tough for kids (and for adults!). It sounds like your son is communicating his feelings in a healthy way — by crying. (And we know how hard it is for YOU when your baby cries!)
It sounds like you’re doing your best by holding him in your arms and nurturing him. He’s working out his feelings, and it’s NOT because he doesn’t love you. Saying good-bye is tough.
You might also try acknowledging his feelings by saying something like, “You seem very sad” or “I know it makes you sad to leave Daddy’s house.” And remind him that he’ll be coming back to Daddy’s next weekend, etc. Please stay in touch.
My 6 year old was crying a lot yesterday saying his misses his Daddy. His father lives in FL we live in VA. He sees him for like a week every 3 months. Well yesterday he just had came back from a 5 day trip to FL with his father. His father and I have been broken up since he was 2. Well yesterday he started asking so many questions like why we broke up and saying he wish we hadnt. And he cried so much saying he misses him. I cried with him. I have never seen him that bad or crying for his Dad. Before he would just say he misses him but never cried. I told him that i love him and i have a 1 year old son with my current fiance and that his little brother loves him and Luis too ( thats my fiance). I texted his father today to call him but i havent heard back. I dont know what to do or what the right thing to say is. I feel so bad. I wish i could take all his pain away. The truth is his father left me for another woman with 2 kids. But i dont want to tell my son that, i think he’s too young to know.
@Jen: We hear how emotional this is, and we get it. It sounds like you did just the right thing for your son: holding him close and listening to him as he grieves. Keep us in touch.
So what is the right thing to do when my 4 year old starts crying for his mother and she isn’t available. I ask her to call she doesnt. I text her to call she doesn’t. We split custody so he will see her tomorrow but in the mean time I’m dying. Please help.
@Rich: This sounds challenging. Hold your son close. Tell him you love him. Let him cry. Remind him that he’ll see his Mom tomorrow. Please know: you are enough and you provide the comfort he needs right now.
Rich: We obviously don’t know your little guy, so it’s hard to know exactly the best approach. Since he’s four, however, he does understand that print has meaning. So, you might offer to write down what he wants to tell Mom. He may simply feel frustrated that he can’t tell his mom that special something that’s on his mind right at that moment. Alternatively, you can help him draw a picture depicting what he’d say to Mom (or how he’s feeling right now), if she was available via phone right at that moment. Learning how to tolerate frustration is a key developmental task for four year-olds.
Thanks again for stopping by. Please let us know how any of these suggestions work out for you.
My 5 year old so burst out crying in the car for his father. he has not seen his father in 6 months (his father hit me infront of him and is on a restraining order amongst other things like drug addictions etc) i cried i didnt know what to say. he kept saying that his father has apologized to him “in his head” and is sorry for what he did to me and he wants to see him and tell him he loves him and misses him..
i assured him that once things are better he will see him in a playground (supervised visitations ) but he kept insisting on going to ” daddy’s house and playing with him.. i dont know what to do.. im trying to shield him from learning bad behavior from his father who is a horrible role model.. but he just kept breaking my heart. i told him that i loved him and im sure his daddy does too but he is in time out for a little while longer (1 week).. he fell asleep crying and woke up today wanting to call him and tell him he loves him ( again we cant do that because of the restraining order) this is the first time in 6 months he has wanted to see him. before he would refuse to even speak about him..
i wanted to also mention that when he was involve with his life it was always arguments and problems he would never drop him off on time or pick him up or anything. but he did see him every other weekend and call him.. i am just so confused.