When parenting time leads to behavior problems – Help!

by  
Filed under All, Kids

“I absolutely LOVE being a single mom,” began an email from Issa Mas at SinglemamaNYC who contacted us to discuss a stubborn co-parenting dilemma. Like many of you, this mama copes with difficult co-parenting challenges. She has  hit a wall, however, with this latest kid challenge.

We’re stumped. Please help out this terrific single mom. Here’s what Issa shared with us:

“My almost four year-old son returns from his dad’s house super aggressive and disrespectful,” she began.

Issa son’s has a seven year-old half brother, and here’s why she attributes her son’s behavior to him: this brother is disrespectful to his own mother.  Sadly, he has not been taught the skills to manage his anger and frustration.  Issa’s son is mesmerized by this older boy’s behavior — behavior that is never allowed at his mother’s house. That’s why Issa’s son is so quick to imitate this older boy.

So, her son returns from once monthly parenting time stressed out. He speaks disrespectfully, and play fighting is suddenly his favorite activity. These unwanted behaviors frustrate — and anger — Issa.  She feels that all her parenting hard work is getting undone.

Talking to her son’s dad is out of the question. Issa characterizes him as non-cooperative and combative. They communicate only about parenting time scheduling details.

This mama is hoping for a way to address constructively her son’s post parenting time behavior.

So, we’re asking for YOUR help:

Does this single mama’s co-parenting dilemma resonate with you?

How can she address these kid behavior issues on her own so she feels “in charge” rather than frustrated and angry?

Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

Related posts:

  1. Are your kids stressed out about parenting time? You’ve let us know — loud and clear — that co-parenting is a huge challenge. Although legal terminology varies, co-parenting ...
  2. When you’re facing the ADHD (or not) dilemma An avid reader who frequently comments candidly (we love her for that!) has contacted us for advice. Neither of us...
  3. When you Google your ex “I need a single mama intervention.” That’s how an urgent message began recently, via our Facebook page. We read this...

Comments

13 Responses to “When parenting time leads to behavior problems – Help!”
  1. Twitter @
    This one is all too familiar, I hate to say. My boys were older when this began, and they didn’t spend much time with their dad, but every time they’d return to town after a week or two, the behavior was markedly different. Snappish, ruder in general, more critical. The influence of where they had been would take anywhere from a week to 10 days to “wear off.”

    It took me some time to realize what was happening. (Who had replaced my polite kids with these snarky, mouthy boys?) Once I realized, I talked with them about the fact that they were being rude and it was unacceptable – they hadn’t realized.

    It still happens (though less – they’re teens), and I still have to remind them much in the same way as I did 8 or 9 years ago.

    With a 4-year old? Trickier, I imagine. It’s hard to control the “other” environment, but knowing the behavior will smooth itself out, and talking if possible, can ease things a bit.
    BigLittleWolf´s last blog ..To The Manor Born? Child Support, Money MagicMy ComLuv Profile

  2. Nicole says:

    Twitter @
    My son was starting kindergarten when he started going to his father’s every other weekend. His dad would take him to school the following Monday so I didn’t see him until I picked him up after school. His teacher would always send home a note about his behavior and that he didn’t seem like the little boy she sent home on Friday and I noticed his behavior would be bad for a few days after that. I didn’t know how to stop the cycle of behavior, but I started letting him know that it’s unacceptable and when he was disrespectful or mean to his sister, I would send him to his room, off by himself to think about how he was behaving. It took about a year and a lot of diligence on my part, but he eventually realized that what he was doing was wrong and hurtful, and not only to us, but to himself, he missed out on a lot of Momma time and our Monday night movies. Now that both of them are a little older I’ve explained to them that even though their father’s house has different rules, and the kids that are there don’t behave like we do in our house, they know what I expect of them, even if they’re not with me. Now, I get compliments on their behavior and how great they are when I pick them up from their dad’s. He’s even said he wishes his step-children (5, 15 & 18) acted as well as our 9 and 11 year old do!

  3. mightbeatranny says:

    Twitter @
    my neighbors daughter and i were exchanging visitation tales the other day. she has a 5 year old son w/ her ex. her ex is not much of a grownup (won’t get a job, misses visits, argues w/ the 5 year old) , but lives w/ a woman who is okay. this is the only child in either home.

    she was telling me that every time her son comes home he is very angry. she thinks it is because the rules at dads house are too much for the 5 year old. he is required to take off his shoes, make his bed, clean his plates, etc. not sure i agree, but anyway…..

    she said that she accepts that the evening her son comes home from visits is “lost”. but that the 2 of them sit down to draw a picture of his feelings as soon as he comes home. she thinks this helps. She talks to him and asks him questions about how he feels. guess kind of like art therapy. maybe worth a try :)

  4. Sam says:

    Twitter @
    Ahh I know this well as it happens in varying levels to all 4 of my kids. And the Dads report the 1st day with them is usually bad as well. I call it their “flip day” when I talk to their teachers, speech & occupational therapists, etc…whomever they see on that day of doom. I explained to the adults in charge that on “flip days” my kids are going to be more difficult to manage and asked if they had any input to stop the behavior. This made everyone aware of the trend and put them in the mode of finding a solution rather than simply reporting bad behavior.

    I explained to the kids, depending on their age, that Dad’s house and Mom’s house have different rules, just like school, but in NO HOUSE are you allowed to be disrespectful. I try to schedule less activities and more downtime on those days and spend more time sitting with them each and listening. Each kid is different but for my 5 yo and biggest misbehavior prne I simply scoop him up, announce to the other kids not to come in my bedroom while we are talking, and take him to snuggle on my bed. I ask him about his day and make a few jokes, high fives, sing a song, whatever I can do to devote 15 mins or so to him (you probably have an easier time with one kid, I have to schedule “Mommy time” to get everyone tended too). I really like the suggestion above to draw out a picture and talk about how he is feeling that day. Sometimes the kids are just like us and need a friend to unload on to feel better! I also like the idea of having special set time like movie time on the flip days-ours is pizza and movie night every other Friday. It gives the kids something to look forward to that is lowkey and not stressful. Also, consider letting him burn off some energy outside, at the park, on a walk, use the Wii, whatever. Boys are more physical than girls and act out feelings in play. Hope this helps, you are not alone in this struggle and it will be worth it in the long run!!

  5. Janis says:

    I’m so glad it’s not just me in this situation. I felt like i had to accept the disasters I get back from Dad’s every other weekend. Their dad and I have a good relationship but he just doesn’t get it. I don’t know what to do other than be understanding of my kids needs.

    glad to hear other suggestions!

  6. Jennifer W says:

    Twitter @
    Oh, yes! This is our house too. It wasn’t as bad when it was every other Saturday night at his dad’s. After two weeks there this summer it was really bad. My ex’s 13 yo son was there for his summer visitation and was not a good influence on our 5 yo. My ex didn’t care or was clueless. It feels like it takes forever to get my real kid back after he’s with his dad.

    I loved the ideas given here and I’m absolutely going to be trying them the next time he sees his dad – whenever that might be.

  7. Jilly says:

    Twitter @
    When Mini-Me was younger, she would come home from her father’s house with a crappy attitude. I attribute this to two things, 1) their dynamic and the behaviors he finds acceptable are different and 2) according to everyone else in the world, she is the best behaved child in the world. So she saves it all up for me…all the stress, all the noise, all the snarkiness. Because I am home. I am Mommy. I am safe. And when looked at that way, it’s kind of sort of flattering.

    No worries, as she grew older (she’s 5 now) and learned better coping mechanisms, the situation improved drastically. Just talk to him about why his behavior is unacceptable when he is with YOU. He’ll catch on…he’s a smart kid. He’s got a smart mama.

  8. Rachel Sarah says:

    @Jilly: well said! Mommy truly is home, where it’s safe to let it all out.

  9. T says:

    Twitter @
    Yes! I would definitely agree that this is when you explain rules. Every house has different rules. I had to teach my daughters this not only from their dad’s house but every friend’s house we went to.

    She has every right to remind him what will and will not be allowed at her house. She could also explain that the way the other boy is acting isn’t respectful…. and hurts feelings. A toddler may not understand “respect” but they generally understand hurt feelings.

    Good luck, Issa!!
    T´s last blog ..Healthy, Fit, Strong and LovedMy ComLuv Profile

  10. Issa says:

    I can’t thank all of you enough for weighing in on this. When I reached out to Dr. Leah for her advice as a psychologist I was at my wit’s end, and now armed with everyone’s suggestions I feel both empowered with new tools and reassured that I’ve been handling it better than I thought. Thank you!!!!!
    Issa´s last blog ..Single Moms Sunday Series, Featuring Donna McKeeMy ComLuv Profile

  11. Anna says:

    I might also make a visual cue to post right inside the door to be very clear about what exactly the “house rules” at mom’s house. Visual cues and reminders are GREAT for my son.

  12. Missy June says:

    Twitter @
    We have a very similar dynamic, except my children see their daddy weekly. For me, it helps to have limited plans during the evening of their return and to be very strict in enforcing discipline when their behavior escalates. They have not had consequences with Daddy, so I have to remind them that with me, that behavior is not tolerated.
    Missy June´s last blog ..Good ThingsMy ComLuv Profile

  13. Melissa says:

    My kids have issues on Fridays when they know their dad will be there after school to get them for his weekend visits. Every other Friday…i get at least two phone calls from the school nurse. My kids are sick. They have a tummy ache. They have a headache. They cry for no apparent reason. It took my about six months of this before I realized…oh my goodness. This ONLY happens when they know they have to leave for the weekend. They hate it at dads house so much they will make themselves physically ill. My oldest will even throw up. They think if they are sick, they wont have to go. Its so sad that kids have to go through this. Only time and patience makes this better. As more time passes my kids have gotten a little better on these Fridays. Or perhaps its because I have had numerous discussions with the school nurse and so she knows if they come in on a Friday, chances are good that the kid is not sick with anything more than a bad case of anxiety. Its understandable for me, because if I was faced with spending an entire weekend with their dad…i would be physically ill as well. AAAH the things our kiddos have to go through…its tough.

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled