When is it okay to leave your child at home alone?
by Rachel Sarah
Filed under Kids
Your emails have alerted us to many *new* parenting worries. (Thanks – we do read every single email from you.) We have also wondered when it’s OK for a child to get a cell phone (or not). And we share your worries about the frightening rise in bullying at increasingly younger ages. And we understand that some of you grapple with mind boggling co-parenting worries.
Well, there’s one parenting decision has always been worrisome: When is it okay to leave your child at home alone?
This recent email from a single mom sums up this parenting dilemma nicely:
“My kids haunt me constantly to let them stay home alone. At 10 and 11, the girls feel they should NOT have to go with me on errands. ” (They like their respective after school programs, so that’s not an issue.)
“The girls have got all kinds of arguments why they’ll be F-I-N-E home alone. We live in a safe neighborhood (whatever than means in these crazy times). I hear all kinds of promises about what they will and won’t do if I PLEASE let them stay home alone.”
We’ve been buzzing back and forth on this topic. For Rachel, this parenting dilemma hits close to home — literally!
We’re sure this conversation is happening in many of your homes, too. Parenting experts seem to agree that it’s not a good idea to leave children younger than 10 years old at home alone. These expert opinions, however, don’t always reflect the availability of cell phones and other easy ways to access help, if needed.
And as “real life” families, we count on our kids to cope with sudden changes in routine or plans. Since our own children have insisted they were ready to stay home alone long before we felt they were ready, the relentless “Please let us stay by ourselves” campaign does not surprise us.
There seem to be no definite rules. And no easy answers. So, we’re asking you–the real experts:
When did you leave your children at home alone for the first time?
What told you that your child was ready to assume this privilege and responsibility?
What should parents consider when making this decision?
~~~~
Re: the photo, Don’t children always promise you they’ll read the ENTIRE time …?
(Phot0 courtesy of the Obsessive Compulsive Photographer)
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
No related posts.






Twitter @ http://lovebabz.blogspot.com
I have 4 kids: 13, 11, 9, 8. They are not ready to be left alone for long periods of time. But I have been testing them with their knowledge. I would drive around the block park for 15 minutes and then come back. I have driven to the neighborhood store a few blocks away with the youngest one in tow.
I have taught them all how to do call 911, call their Dad, and a couple of neighbors. The most important thing is to train them in the event of an emergency. To make sure that they understand what a stranger is and not to open the door for anyone. No friends are allowed unless we agree and the friend arrives before you leave (with other parents permission).
These are indeed troubing times, but if your child is responsible, I think 13 is about the right age to take on a little alone time on their own…not hours mind you. and not on a routine basis. (I used to be a police commissioner so safety is critical) predators depend on routine as a way to plan. Don’t be alarmed, just be mindful and aware. At some point you will get comfortable leaving them… I am not there yet

Lovebabz´s last blog ..HE IS GETTING MARRIED.
Twitter @ http://kitkat4real.blogspot.com
I have two children. One is 11 and the other is 15 (I know – I gave birth at age 12, ok?) (just kidding) but I started leaving my oldest home alone at the age of 12. I think if they are mature enough at this age (you be the judge) and you can trust they won’t leave a stove burning or start playing with the knives drawer… that they can stay alone.
But like Lovebabz says not for long durations of time… only a couple hours after they get out of school or while you run errands would be acceptable. I say 12 others may say 13… but again each child should be evaluated based on signs of maturity.
Being a single mom you count down the days till you can eliminate some of those childcare expenses – so I perhaps pushed that by starting at 12 … but again, it was for not for hours on end and we’ve not had any problems to arise. (so far)
Katherine SOLO dot MOM´s last blog ..Marriage Proposal via Twitter – no kidding!
Twitter @ notthecar
Someone asked me this exact same question 2 weeks ago. Her son is close to 13 and my daughter is 12. I will tell you that some states have it on the books what you can and cannot do in terms of leaving children alone. We found out that in our state as long as they aren’t caring for a younger sibling it can be as young as 8. so a 10 year old alone is ok but not if there’s a 10yo with a 5yo. It’s under fire code statutes (bizzare i know).
In my case i started leaving my child home for short trips, 10 minutes get gas, picking up takeout when she was 10.5 i built up in small increments over time and now she’s capable of coming home from school alone and waiting till i get back from work.
Its not something you do where you go straight to 4 hours and i would never go out after she went to bed. I still feel guilty with a work dinner drags on because we are at some 5 course place, but i still come home make her dinner and call a few times while I’m out to check in. She knows the #1 rule if she asks me to come home now i do immediately. there have been times she has and i always made my apologies and ran out the door to my car.
I think as long as the parents understand that 1- their child knows what to do if something goes wrong, 2-the laws int he state they live say its ok 3-the parents feel the child is emotionally ready and has done some short trial runs 4-the parents are emotionally ready to detach then its ok. Because if the parent isn’t ready ti doesnt matter how soon the kids are.
Twitter @ http://gawlas.blogspot.com
I think this honestly depends on the kids, parents, and numerous other factors. I have a very responsible oldest, he doesn’t babysit his younger siblings, but there are days that because of schedules he gets home before I do. He lets himself in and watches tv or reads until I get home. He also leaves for school after I leave with the younger kids for work. He has never skipped or even been tardy for school. Never gone back to sleep and missed, never changed into a different set of clothes. WOuld I trust a less responsible kid to do these things? No. If I (single mom with minimal support that I am) had a choice other than this, would I take it? Yes. But has it, imperfect though it is worked? yes.
The world we live in now is safer, with less violent crime and fewer crimes against children that the one in which we grew up. With cell phones we can literally track our kids’ locations if we want.
I think this over protectivness that has invaded parenting has done our children more harm than good. Kids stay inside and play or have pre arranged play dates with only pre screened kids, so they don’t learn any negotiation skills. They don’t go out into the neighborhood with instructions not to come back until the next meal time, so they don’t learn how to entertain themselves or play spontaneously. Instead we have these little cyber kids who want to be plugged in 24/7 and think playing is only done on a ball field or court with a coach and a team.
Its time to lighten up folks. Give the kids the rules, test em a few times, and then give a chance to make a friggin mistake.
alley´s last blog ..The Breaks
Twitter @ FullCustodyDad
In and of itself is a hard question to answer and varies greatly from kid to kid. Currently my 6 YO son is very mature and would certain be just fine left alone for a short or long periods of time. However, my 11 YO daughter is no where near ready or even close to being left alone. So the age is hard to determine and would have to vary from kid to kid as it cannot be universal.
However, something you have to keep in the back of your mind if you are in a highly contested custody battle, you CANNOT do this without exception at any age. Read that line again. Sadly caseworkers and judge frown on children left alone for any length of time for any reason even for five minutes.
Therefore, for the above mentioned reason, my kids have never been left alone and will never–not even for one second until they are 18–but then again my situation may be different from others. Nevertheless for some, it is something you have to take into consideration outside of just the maturity of the kids.
Fred Campos / FullCustodyDad´s last blog ..Listen for Good Attorneys in Court Tip #80
Twitter @ BruceSallan
Hmmm, I didn’t struggle too much with this one as it was relatively obvious, to me, when my boys were ready to be left alone. First, I did it gradually. Testing how they’d do for short periods of time. As I grew to trust them and they fooled me completely – oops, I mean convinced of their complete and total maturity – I became more comfortable with the idea.
10 or 11 is too young for any kid, in my opinion. BUT, the single parent is always struggling to have their own lives so we might want to see that they’re ready sooner so we can go out without paying and/or having to find a babysitter.
As I have two boys, that means of course, that one is older. When he was about 13 it felt appropriate to start leaving him alone with his younger brother who was a mature 10 and really did love to read and would read all night, then, if I let him.
With so many parenting choices, it’s about when and if your particular kid is ready!
This is just one dad’s point-of-view…but, I was a 24/7 SAHD for about 5 years so I was tested on this and many other decisions!
Good post!
Twitter @ http://www.jane-sliceoflife.com/
By the time I left my oldest home for periods of time, she was 13. Having been a single only parent for five years at this point, I recognized that there was a huge difference between, maturity, and survival skills. Single parents often aren’t often aware that their kids are functioning on survival skills, that have nothing to do with maturity. What I chose to watch was her coping skills. And it worked well for her, and her sibs. That was, however, 11 years ago. A friend recently had drama in her home, leaving her 15 year old, with two younger sibs, due to the fact that her daughter is text/cell obsessive (my words, and now, her mom’s). She simply was not paying attention.
I however, feel, that even with the challenges that we are faced with today, checking coping skills and making sure they are age appropriate, is still a sure fire measure.
Jane´s last blog ..Do you parent your friends?
Twitter @ annie_fox
Clearly it depends on the maturity level and “readiness” of the child. And remember, some kids don’t like being left alone in the house, even for short periods of time. You don’t want to force it on them or shame them in any way if they aren’t comfortable being left alone.
But if your child has a track record for being responsible, for following the house rules even when you’re not standing over him with the eagle eye, and (s)he likes the idea of showing you that (s)he has good judgement, then let him/her go for it!
Start on a low gradient, like running a short errand nearby… Make sure the child knows how to reach you and/or 911 if (god forbid!) the need arises. If there are two siblings involved, another thing to put into the equation is how cooperative the two of them are with each other. If you spend time frequently refereeing battling sibs, you’d be foolish to leave them home alone together until they have figured out how to CONSISTENTLY work through their conflicts in non-violent, respectful ways.
All that said… Responsible kids of age 10 who want to be left on their own at home for a few hours will probably feel really good about themselves (and the way they’ve taken care of the house) in your absence. Giving them a chance to step up is good for their growing independence. It’s also good for you to realize that they are growing up and becoming more independent. That’s something both of you should celebrate.
Twitter @ runpippirun
Annie, thank you so much for your post too! I have a responsible ten year old (and an eight year old) and I have been wondering about when it is ok to leave the ten year old alone. I have started to leave him alone during short errands and he really seems puffed up about it (in a good way) when I get back. He has low self esteem issues and I think this might be just the ticket to helping with some of that.
Pippi´s last blog ..Do they make this in men’s underwear? *giggle*