Is it OK if my kids call my girlfriend “mom”?

Dads are important members of our Singlemommyhood community. And we so appreciate when these special guys chime in to offer their perspectives on whatever dilemma we’re hashing out together.

When we received this email recently from a single dad, however, we must admit it tugged at our hearts. Here’s what this single dad told us:

“I guess if you ladies are solo moms, then I’m a solo dad, ” he began in an endearing way. “My boys’ mom took off when they were still toddlers.  I felt lucky that the boys and I didn’t have to deal with her substance abuse issues. Truthfully, neither of them have too many memories of her actually being here with us. ”

This solo dad described the all too familiar struggles of trying to do it all without any help from the other parent. Eventually, they divorced and he got sole custody. He doesn’t count on regular child support. His boys are now nine and eleven years-old, and they hear from their mom occasionally. When they mention her every once in a while, interestingly, they refer to her by her first name.

“I thought I would NEVER get married again,” this solo dad told us emphatically. “I was just too hurt by what happened. And, frankly,  I wasn’t sure whether I could manage my kid responsibilities and be a loving husband, too.

We’re sure you know what happened: This sweet solo dad met someone. There was instant chemistry and their relationship has grown into a forever love.  This solo dad waited to introduce his boys to her until he felt confident that he was not setting them up for yet another loss. Yes, creating a blended family is a tough challenge, yet as their wedding date approaches, things just feel right. This solo dad described his boys as simply happy.

Sounds like a happy ending (or beginning), right? Unfortunately, this loving dad is troubled.

Here’s why: more than once he has heard his boys refer to his soon-to be wife as “mom.”

And this dad knows that this signals that his soon-to-be wife has replaced “bio-mom” is his boys’  lives. This truth has left this dad with mixed feelings that need sorting out.

Should this solo dad gratefully encourage his boys’ attachment to their “new mom”?

Or do you feel that he should handle this blended family issue in a different way?

Personal experiences are always welcome. Please do share.


~~~

(Photo courtesy of sweet.finds)




Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

Related posts:

  1. When your divorce is recent. And your ex’s girlfriend is long term. A very recently divorced single mom contacted us when she found out her ex already had a *girlfriend.* Apparently,  this...
  2. My ex is in love with a cop killer An email which began, “I was relieved to know that I was not the only single parent whose ex was...
  3. When you’re dating a married man Many of you have told us loud and clear that dating a married man is a big “no no.” Yet...

Comments

28 Responses to “Is it OK if my kids call my girlfriend “mom”?”
  1. Maria says:

    In this case it feels like an ok thing for your kids to call your soon to be wife mom.
    As I understand, they never had their mom in their lives on a regular basis, so of course they want one!
    Good luck with your marriage and kids.

    (I call my bio-dad by first name and my “step-dad” dad, because he is and acts like a father)

  2. Jenell says:

    Twitter @
    If the boys are comfortable and that’s the role your soon to be wife is filling, then I would see no harm. I too am in the same boat as Maria with bio-dad and step-dad. Having kids doesn’t make you a parent anymore than buying a piano makes you a pianist.

  3. Kylie says:

    What a wonderful dad he is. I believe the names “Mum and Dad” aren’t just names – they’re a life long responsibility and when my kids call me Mum, in my heart I know I’ve earned it. My kids also have a step-mum, but I’ve also discussed with them how important I think the name “mum” is – they have never called their step-mum “mum” and though I would never assume to tell them “don’t do it” , by discussing this issue with them I think they’ve also come to realize the value of the name.

    I think it’s a gorgeous beginning to your life together as a blended family.

    Having said this, I don’t think your two boys have ever had someone (sadly) who has earnt the name and calling your fiancé “mum” is not only touching, it’s also their way of showing unconditional acceptance of your fiancé into your family.

  4. Dr. Leah says:

    Kylie: We’re thinking the same thing. Calling her “mom” (or “mum”) may signal unconditional acceptance. We’re wondering if other readers feel differently. Please do chime in.

    Jenell: Thanks so much for adding to this conversation. A profound thought: having a child does not make you a parent.

  5. Kelli says:

    Twitter @
    I disagree. My daughters biodad was not in the picture my fiancée of 2 yrs took on that role and she called him daddy. We recently split. She is confused and doesn’t understand. I was sure about him then things change. I will never let that happen again. I don’t think it’s a good idea.

    Just my opinion.

  6. LildevilMama says:

    Twitter @
    Personally, I agree with Kelli. I have a friend who has kids with her hubby and kids from a previous marriage and there are big issues with who calls who what.

    However, this is something that should be discussed pre-wedding with his soon-to-be-wife. If he’s having reservations about it, then it is an issue for him and it really needs to be talked about before they make the walk down the aisle. While his boys may be close to their new step-mom and accept her as their ‘mom’ it sounds like Dad has some unsettled feelings about their replacing their bio-mom, whether or not she’s irresponsible and chose to leave, she’s still their Mom. Maybe the grown-ups she talk about it, and then have a chat with the boys to make sure they are good with whatever they discuss and agree upon.

  7. Ashley Smith says:

    Twitter @
    I personally feel that it’s not that deep of an issue. You can try to look at it a million different ways and ananlyze it, but it comes down to this: These kids obviously love this woman and so does he. If she treats the kids as a mother should, and accepts them, then why not call her Mom? These days, finding an unbroken family without issues is a rarity. So embrace what you have, love who you can, and try to make life as happy as possible for everyone, especially children.

  8. Mandy says:

    Twitter @
    I think if the boys want to call their soon-to-be stepmom “mom,” it’s a sign of both their connection to her and their desire to have a mother figure in their life. I don’t see any problem from the child’s perspective. Dad however, should discuss it with his girlfriend and see how she feels being called “mom” – is that how she’d like the boys to call her? I’m assuming that they’ve already discussed that by agreeing to marry, she is agreeing to step into the mother role with all that that entails.
    Mandy´s last blog ..Divorce means learning how to cook My ComLuv Profile

  9. Rachel Sarah says:

    Twitter @
    @Kelli: Thanks for sharing your own personal experience about this issue — and please feel free to reach out to us about your recent split. Sending you a big hug.

  10. VA Mom says:

    All families are different and I can see both sides of this argument. I agree with Jenell – giving birth doesn’t make you a parent. Nor does it give you claim to the title of parent (mom or dad). You earn being called mom/dad. I think is very telling in the story above that this dad’s sons refer to their mother by her first name. To me, it speaks volumes to how they have processed their feelings/relationship to her.

    I think we need to take our cues from our children and their needs, while trying to protect them. If the boys are referring to her as mom, I think he needs to understand why they have chosen to do so – these are not toddlers, but young boys who can process emotions around why they make specific choices. Talking to them – within the context of them becoming a family with his fiance is important.

    That said I would also think it wise for he and his fiance to have a discussion about her intentions, does she want to adopt the boys legally when they are married?

    My cousin married when her son was 10 years old, for all intents and purposes her husband became the boy’s father, even prior to marriage. When the boy was 13 he asked to be adopted because he wanted that sense of assurance that he their relationship was true and real. He called him dad – but wanted to know and understand that their relationship was independent of the marriage and he wanted to carry his father’s name.

    Another cousin, adopted his now ex-wife’s daughter while they were married. When they divorced, he did not change his relationship to that child. He cares for her, spends time with her, etc as much as he does his biological children.

    Again, every family is different and I believe when it comes to children you need to look at those relationships independent of your romantic relationship. Because as someone above pointed out – there are no guarantees that the relationship will work out.

    I think when someone comes into a child’s life, regardless of marriage, that relationship they take on with your child needs to be guided and defined. Easier said than done for sure, but over the long term I believe it is the best way to protect the continuity and long term interests of your child.

  11. April says:

    Twitter @
    I love VA Mom’s take on this, and I agree. I think it’s more of the wife-to-be’s call than the dad’s (or ours). And I also think it’s a good idea for them to discuss what would happen in the (hopefully) unlikely event of a split. I know one couple, where each had kids from a previous marriage, that did an agreement that laid everything out before they even moved in together, let alone got married. It helped them work out their issues of how they were going to enter into this blended family and talk about the difficult things. I think it’s part of why they’re still happily married now.
    April´s last blog ..The Plans &amp Mission My ComLuv Profile

  12. Louisa says:

    Maybe he could discuss it with his girl-friend to see how she feels about it? If she is fine with it (I don’t know a single woman who wouldn’t be honored by being called that), then perhaps it would be a good subject for a “family talk” meeting. As the mom of a blended family I have found that those discussions are what have brought us closer. Besides, the boys may have some things they’d like to ask/share that they wouldn’t normally have the opportunity to. Best of luck to this family!

  13. Dr. Leah says:

    Louisa: Thanks so much for bringing your life experience as a “blended family mom” to this conversation. A family talk about this situation might be just the right way to approach the situation.

  14. Anna says:

    If the kids are choosing to call her that, then they are comfortable with it, and that’s the most important thing. Maybe dad could have a conversation with the boys about the importance of the word “mom”, a la Kylie.

    The ex sees my son 3 times a year or less. Last year my son came home and mentioned “Grandma so and so” (the ex’s girlfriend’s mother, who he had met once). I told him, “She’s not your grandma”. That’s the only time I have ever said anything to overtly contradict something his dad (or gf) told my son, but people earn their titles, even personal ones. I never heard any more about “Grandma So and so”.

  15. T says:

    Twitter @
    I do agree that this solo dad needs to examine his own fears around the children calling her “mom”. Even still, this is the closest to ‘mom’ that they’ve experienced in their lives so far. If the marriage didn’t work out, for whatever reason, why couldn’t they remain in touch with her? Why couldn’t they still refer to her as “mom” if they feel that she is the closest thing? Sure, she may not have any legal rights post marriage, unless she adopts them, but that doesn’t mean the emotional connection won’t still exist.

    I think the kids feel a connection and attachment to her. He does too. I believe, honestly, that it is his own fear (from the past pain) that is causing these questions. And who could blame him?!?! I’d be frightened of the same thing!

    Definitely search inside and examine these fears. Definitely talk with the fiancee and see what her intentions are. Discuss openly, honestly. And then allow those boys to love as freely as children do!
    T´s last blog ..Who would you be without your story My ComLuv Profile

  16. Holly says:

    As a person who has had numerous step- parents throughout my life I think it is ok for kids to call their new mom , mom. I think all kids want growing up is to feel loved, wanted and accepted for who they are. They want routine and structure. I think if the kids, in the above case, feel comfortable calling her mom then the dad should let them. What ever the kids feel most comfortable with calling her is what should happen. Kids are smart, and I’m sure thy realize this woman isn’t there to replace their bio mom. And even if they were to separate later down the road, as tough as divorce is, the kids should be encouraged to continue relationship with the step mom. My first stepdad was married to my mom for 13 years and they divorced when I was 19. I’m 29 now and I’m still in contact with him and my kids call him grandpa. The kids obviously love this woman, so to the dad, keep encouraging that bond and love and support for those boys.

  17. Rachel Sarah says:

    Twitter @
    @Holly: We’re glad to know that you are still close to your own step-dad. Thanks so much for adding your wise words to this discussion, re: “kids are smart, and I’m sure they realize this woman isn’t there to replace their bio mom.”

  18. ylhoff says:

    Maybe if he’s feeling that awkward about it, he could let them call his girlfriend, “Mama-XXX”? So it’d be like “Mama-Chris” ….. That’s endearing and it lets her know her place in their family and hearts, but doesn’t reject the fact that they do have a bio mom.

  19. Swati says:

    Twitter @
    Hi there
    I think everyone has been through enough…and so truly if you are fortunate enough to have something finally that works, why change it? They’ll know they have a bio mom – but why make them call someone they feel attached to something else? Let it be easy for them – just let them call her mom and move on and enjoy life.

    Swati
    Swati´s last blog ..Mommy Gets Schooled Guest Post by Author Maggie Lamond Simone My ComLuv Profile

  20. Barb says:

    Twitter @
    I can see myself being very hesitant about being called ‘mom’ by someone other than my biological children. Being called “mom” doesn’t make a woman any more or less that role.
    But some are more sensistive and guarded by that ‘title’.
    I think the dad is having some hesitations about it and most definitely needs to talk to his soon to be wife about it.
    It sounds as though she has become a very important figure in the boys lives and she and the dad should discuss it and then take the boys feelings and needs into account.

  21. Twitter @
    I can understand why it’s scary for this dad to hear his kids call the new wife “mom”…but those are fears that he needs to overcome for the sake of his family. The kids are attached to her, they don’t really know their biological mother, so why shouldn’t they call her mom?
    Momma Sunshine´s last blog ..Weekend Adventure My ComLuv Profile

  22. Eathan says:

    Twitter @
    Its common for kids to call stepparents mom/dad. My oldest has used the word parents because it’s easier than explaining to others. But it also reflects how close and how much the kids appreciate the new person in their life. And I think it’s a sign of trust.

  23. alley says:

    I think that if you never try to tell them that she is their mother in the biological sense, and if you are open to allowing the bio-mom to re-enter their lives when and if she gets her act together, then the calling the girlfriend “mom” is ok.
    alley´s last blog ..Sushi – Heavy Metal- What a day! My ComLuv Profile

  24. John B says:

    Twitter @
    Ok, I have 3 personal perspectives.
    I had a step father, never called him dad. He never “felt” like dad. His interest was in my mother and I think he resented that he’d raised two boys and they were off in their own lives and now he had to start over.
    I then had a legal guardian dad after standing up for myself in mid teens and leaving. That man, I will always call my dad. He taught me to be a man, he showed me what a father really was.
    I then met a woman that had a 6 year old daughter. It was difficult entering a 6 year mother daughter ONLY situation, but I fell in love with them both. I’ll never forget (eyes welling right now) the moment she looked up at me, cocked her head and said, “can I call you daddy?”.

    Children are pretty smart. You can protect them, give them advice on this if they ask for it. But, they know what feels right to them. If they’re asking to call someone mom/dad, they really feel it. Of course, down the road when she says No to something, it’s possible she’ll have to be prepared to hear “you’re not my mom.” Stings, but they won’t mean it.

    Good luck to this dad. It’s hard enough to find someone genuine to settle down with without children involved. That must be a great woman he’s found. I hope it all works out for the best in all aspects.
    John B´s last blog ..My life in a nutshell Brainstorm √-list before getting started on a book that I hope will help others My ComLuv Profile

  25. John B says:

    Twitter @
    Oh, also that little girl, is now 19 and still calls me daddy. :)
    John B´s last blog ..My life in a nutshell Brainstorm √-list before getting started on a book that I hope will help others My ComLuv Profile

  26. skipper says:

    Every kid wants a Mom and a Dad. They’re comfortable calling her “mom”, so that should be ok. She should celebrate that honor and make sure she lives up to the responsibility that comes with it.

  27. Miley says:

    Seeing as their mother is not an integral part of their life, if the kids are comfortable with it, I wouldn’t see an issue with them calling the soon-to-be-step-mom “mom”.
    My parents divorced when I was 3 and both had remarried by the time I was 5. My dad NEVER asked me to call his wife “mom” and even though I love her VERY much, I cannot bring myself to call her “mom”. My mother’s husband, insisted that I called him “dad” and I resented every moment of it. They have since divorced but I was pissed that I HAD to call him that.
    Now I am grown with 2 kids of my own and have been divorced for a few years.
    Their dad has a live in girlfriend that they call “Miss H____”. My daughter is afraid that if they get married, she will have to call her “mom”.
    I told my kids that they will NEVER have to call someone by a name if they are not comfortable with is, as long as they use a name that is appropriate and respectful. The same goes for any man I date or may want to marry.
    I would never expect any child of a man I marry to call me “mom” unless they are comfortable with it and that would be up to them. I don’t want/need to be called mom by someone else’s child. They have a mother, whether she’s in their life (alive or deceased)…
    Ultimately, though, I think it should be the child’s choice. If they are comfortable calling a step-parent mom or dad, and have not been asked to do so, it’s OK.

  28. Dr. Leah says:

    Miley: We appreciate this incredibly thoughtful comment on an issue that many single parents (justifiably) find upsetting. We hope you visit again soon.

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled
ss_blog_claim=2dba28946b740b47821f4be875666330