When a married mom secretly plans for solo parenthood
by Dr. Leah
Filed under All, Featured, Single Moms
When we asked if sometime single moms — married moms who blithely refer to themselves as *single* when their husbands are temporarily unable to help out at home — offend you, single moms told us, “YES!”
We also heard from married moms who told us quite a differently story. Married moms wrote in to share stories about feeling like single moms. We got emotional reading about partners — not so much — who do little to help with the kids and ignore their spouses’ emotional and physical needs.
Obviously, there’s a huge difference between feeling like a single mom and actually being a single mom. But, this recent message from a married mom alerted us that there’s lots more undercover married mom relationship drama than we ever suspected.
Here’s what this mom told us:
“The only reason I am still with my husband is that I can’t make enough money to pay the bills and child care costs until I get my degree,” she candidly disclosed. “I envy single moms because they are able to distance themselves from the person who hurt them.”
Apparently, her husband went emotionally and physically AWOL right after their child was born. Almost three years later, they are still married – -despite a trial separation — because this mom believes her son is happier when she is not working two jobs. Her husband remains complacent because he doesn’t think she’ll ever ask for a divorce. In the meantime, this determined mom is methodically planing her exit from the marriage, which she has confided in only a few close friends.
We had lots of questions: Her husband’s “issues” are irresponsibility, neglect, selfishness and poor money management. She handles everything except working his job for him. This mom has learned to function — no matter what. Of course, she worries about the inevitable “Dad” questions — it’s unlikely he’ll co-parent with any meaningful involvement. But, she looks forward to not spending twenty minutes every morning trying to get him up for work. Or, responding to her child’s middle of night distress only to see that he’s been up all night playing his X-box (again).
We applaud this mom’s efforts to make a better life for herself— and her son.
Yet, we’re wondering . . .
Can you relate to this mom’s plight … marriage to a neglectful and irresponsible guy?
Is it common for a woman to keep divorce/breakup plans under such tight wraps?
Did you escape from such a marriage? If so, how?
Personal stories are always welcome
~~~
Photo via Flickr: Kel’s Vision
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
Related posts:
- When a married mom faces BIG co-parenting conflicts A married mom urgently contacted us via Twitter for custody and co-parenting advice. At first, we shook our heads. Obviously,...
- What MUST this soon-to-be divorced mom know? We received an email from this soon-to-be single mom who asked us if we’d reach out to YOU, our readers....
- Dating as a solo mom? Over the holidays, we heard from the choice mom of a toddler who wrote to tell us about her resolution...






Twitter @ WhitewaterAtty
Clearly, this Married Mom with a Plan is frustrated and it seems that her husband has not been ideal or helpful as soon as they had children. And it’s great to see that she’s going back to school. And clearly, if there is dangerous behavior (physical abuse, substance abuse, reckless behavior) then you need to extricate yourself from the marriage
However, absent those very serious issues, EVERY NEW PARENT NEEDS to realize that MOST marriages have trouble once a young child comes into the family’s life — and that frustration/trouble does not necessarily mean that ones marriage is over. This is true even if one’s spouse is neglectful and irresponsible.
To this Married Mom with a Plan: PLEASE before you make a set plan to exit the marriage (1) communicate with your spouse and (2) TRY to bring professional counseling to your marriage. You made a vow to be with your spouse in good times AND BAD. This a bad time, and you should do what you can to see if the marriage can be rectified… and this obligation is more important when you had a child. That’s not to say you should stay in the marriage for your children, but you should TRY to save the marriage if it can be save for your, your spouse, and your children. Marriage isn’t easy, but neither is breaking up a family.
You and your spouse might be able to reconnect to what you once had, but you will need help — and counseling can be that help. I know that he might resist going, but you just MIGHT be able to have a happy life/home that you desire with your child’s two parents together in one home/family. And wouldn’t it be nice to have that happiness without having to go through divorce/custody issues?
I would agree with WhitewaterAtty. Marriage problems usually go both ways and at least with counseling if the issues can’t be worked out no one will feel blindsided. Sometimes it takes seeing how serious things are for a person to change. Also, I don’t think anyone can automatically assume that a parent won’t be involved after a divorce. Sometimes people become more involved once they see what they stand to lose.
Twitter @ mightbeatranny
im not offended when a married mom says shes really a single mom. I had that exact situation. my life got eaiser the second i left. my husband was not only no help (never once got up with any of the kids, went to a doctors appointment, etc.) he was verbally abusive and then at the end physically abusive (i have a restraining order).
i had to go to the ER at 2:00 in the morning for a bladder infection (by then i was peeing blood) because my husband refused to watch our kids so i could go to the doctor, and wouldn’t pay for a sitter so i could go. i had to take my 3 year old to the ER for a broken arm at midnight, because he didn’t want to pay the $100 co-pay, and refused to let me take her.
we weren’t poor. 3 kids in private schools, country club memberships, i was a stay at home mom. it was horrible. we were all screamed at everyday and blamed for anything he didn’t like. my sleep was disrupted if he wanted something (where are my keys…i’m hungry) and i had no access to money for nearly a year before i left.
all dads are not created equal. some should not have unrestricted access to their kids because they are abusive. our court system is a mess. what other venue forces a victim to have unsupervised contact with their abusier?
word to the wise; he will lie about what a great dad he is and how you are a parental alienator. the judge assumes the truth is somewhere in the middle. do the math.
Twitter @ http://www.vomitcomit.wordpress.com
My ex was the same, stayed up all night talking online to random people, playing his guitar, listening to music, basically acting like a teenager. No pleas for counselling were ever met with anything other than laughter and outright refusal. The problem was never him-it was always me, or the kids, or having to work (part time I might add, and never did much around the house). Complained when I worked through the weekend.
If he’s acting like this, I have very little belief he’ll do anything to try and change. Why would he? Make your plan, and stick with it, and get out.
Twitter @ http://onesmarmymama.blogspot.com
I guess you could say I escaped from a situation like that.
I had wanted out much earlier however I felt the same…..money prevented it. In hind site, that was an excuse to do nothing and keep myself and my kids in a dysfunctional home. Rather, I knew I SHOULD leave, but that is a VERY hard choice to make and even harder to follow through with. It was easier to say “I can’t afford it” then to just go.
Her child will probably be happier, in the long run, out of a conflicted home than having to deal with mom working a lot for a year or two. I think a lot of us can attest to the fact that you often have no CLUE just how bad it is till you get out and get some distance.
That said, I agree with WhitewaterAtty….having been there/done that, I understand that there are two sides to every story. Mom very likely has some responsibility in this situation and it probably is worth going to marriage counseling. If anything, counseling can potentially help you communicate better so that if you DO split, you are better equipped to be effective co-parents.
At the end of the day, no matter what she choses, the question should be “Is my happiness and my child’s happiness WORTH this???”
C Lo´s last blog ..Mothers Day
Twitter @ alimd11
This woman seems to have a romanticized version of what being a single parent is all about. I work three jobs and I have custody/care for my son 95% of the time…and for the record, he’s very happy.
He’s happy when I am happy and I believe that is a fairly general rule of parenting as we all tackle this gig from vastly differing angles. We likely all would agree that there is no magical formula of time spent per child, or jobs, work, or hours of cartoon watching, etc that constitutes how happy your kid will be/how they will turn out.
This woman is prescribing to the idea that more jobs equals less happy to her kid though, because it suits her and her “story.”
It blows my mind how many people get on these single parenting blogs and plot online how/when/if they just bail from their current situation, and when they do how it’s all going to look during and after versus looking at themselves first (and in the present) and fixing what’s wrong with THEM NOW…then turning to their partner for an honest discourse on how to fix what’s broke.
This woman appears to be lashing out at this man for doing what he’s always done (being lazy by her account), while she is in the background secretly plotting her revenge (being sneaky/dishonest by my account).
I think she is giving the guy far too much credit and *thinking* he knows how she feels/what specific actions he could take to make ALL their lives easier/better and instead she’s choosing to pick at all his misgivings/failures and put herself in the position of being a victim to all of his insensitive actions. Granted, she could have spent ten years in fruitless therapy for all I know from reading this, but it certainly doesn’t appear so from this discourse.
Guys are not mind readers. They also, from what I have witnessed in the marriages of many friends, will by default take a back seat in the child rearing and household duties unless they are given some time by the woman to flounder around/make their own mistakes/create their OWN different mechanisms for solving the same problems/obstacles. I believe this is a large part of why some dads have next to no interest when they were married but then shine as co-parents.
If this woman is stepping in and “saving” the situation all the time (read: doing it herself because he’s so lazy/worthless), or making the man wrong for what he DOES try to do, I am sure he is simply reverting back to what he has always done…which is work and “earn” his lazy title. Why not? He’s in a lose/lose situation.
If you step back and give this guy the benefit of the doubt, which I believe we’re all warranted, it’s very, very unlikely that he wants a crappy, unhappy relationship with his wife either. He’s getting labeled for dealing with things in a certain way and she’s perpetuating it by being sneaky.
I have to wonder, if this woman put as much energy into venting, plotting, etc as she did into being brutally honest with first herself (about why she’s created the victim/sneaky position to begin with) and fixing what is already there, would we even need to have this conversation?
Ali´s last blog ..Ritual
Twitter @ WhitewaterAtty
Well said, Ali.
I was in a very similar situation, however I did say that we needed to get counseling. In the end, we went for about 4 sessions, but he was upset that I had “given him an ultimatum”. He said we could work out our problems on our own. In the same breath, he would say that he didn’t care about me or our son, and that he was going to move out-of-state, back to his mom. In the end, I gave it my best shot and got the hell out. Life is exponentially better now, and I say that if she has the opportunity to plan a bit for it, more power to her.
Twitter @ serial_writer
“The only reason I am still with my husband is that I can’t make enough money to pay the bills and child care costs until I get my degree,” she candidly disclosed. “I envy single moms because they are able to distance themselves from the person who hurt them.”
I don’t agree with that statement at all. It sounds like a cop-out. A single mother is forced to make due without a husband to pay the bills, whether a woman has a degree or not. We have to cope. This individual seems to be using her bills as a cop out to stay in a dysfunctional relationship.
And just b/c a single mom is not with the father, that doesn’t mean that we can necessarily distance ourselves from the person who we once loved/hurt us.
Twitter @ http://dallassinglemom.blogspot.com
WhiteWaterAtty, Ali and Caroline bring up great points. Bottomline: this woman and this marriage needs counseling. I have a friend going through the same exact thought process and telling me, “I will get divorced when the kids are older.” Do you know what my response to her was? You are getting divorced for stupid reasons. Let’s face it, no matter how much “PLANNING” you do, life is not greener on the other side – whether you are married or single. Work on what you got NOW!
Heather Buen – Dallas Single Mom Examiner´s last blog ..Hop Aboard the Moms Blog Hop Train and Giveaway!
Twitter @ WhitewaterAtty
Some unhappy spousal relationships (as C Lo and thordora state) are bad, cannot be saved, and are best for all parties to be ended — this is true even if there are children involved.
Some unhappy spousal relationships (as Ali and Steve state) are in a rocky/rough place and can be saved if both parties (1) look towards their own behavior and (2) work to try and save the marriage. This is often the case with first-time parents who have young children.
However, absent dangerous behavior (e.g., physical abuse, substance abuse, reckless behavior), when someone is in one of these two types of unhappy spousal relationships the parties themselves — especially without communication with their fellow spouse — are often not good judges at whether the relationship can be saved (or is worth saving) or not.
When you have a child, your decision to end your spousal relationship has SERIOUS consequences. Thus, you owe it to you, your spouse, and your child(ren) to communicate with your spouse and TRY (hopefully with therapy/counseling) to see if your marriage can be saved. Plainly, when your only complaints are essentially irresponsibility of your spouse, planning to unilaterally leave the marriage surreptitiously is selfish.
Twitter @ RobinsPeace
First I will admit that I am writing without reading, only glancing the other posts first but I thought I would get this off my chest for the 100th time and too many times to the NY Times Op/Ed Dept. Single Motherhood is just that~SINGLE. I have done all case scenarios and now I have sole custody for the last 4 years of my 2 sons, now 13 and 15. There is no dad in the picture, physically, financially or in spirit. It has been a long ugly divorce that is still going on after 8 1/2 years..I am in court for Trail today. There was violence and I stayed, thinking I was a single mom under the same roof and I was not. I was seperated with no child support and joint custody and thought I was single but until now do I know what it truely means to ba single mom 24/7 with no breaks. What ever your situation is stay strong but move on. Most importantly raising children in a loveless marriage only shows the children the lack of love within the family structure. Moving on my children moved on with me on their own. With no job, welfare lines, hand outs from the church to feed my boys I made it. Tired of the abuse and refusing to raise 2 boys in a violent household I needed to break the cycle of abuse and drinking.
I now am the Speaker at the VA Hospital in Westwood, CA. for the Women’s Conference, am an Art Therapist, DV advocate and an amazing although sometimes tired mom. Going back to school I took my boys with me and they have watched me grow, learn, fall, get back up and fight some more for what I wanted for my family. All of these lessons have been a blessing because there is nothing like real life to teach your children values, ethics, morals and perserverence. How I handle my stress is how they will grow up and handle their stress. My younger son recently came back from a trip to London for Soccer training, tonight is his Pentathalon Award Ceremony and my older son is in a special pilot school for Film and TV in Orange County. My boys walked out on their dad 4 years ago when the court refused to give me custody. I still today have tempory sole custody and their father, a smart attorney who has tangeled this divorce case up for the past 8 1/2 years has been finally disbarred from law. There are so many nights I go to bed grateful, exhausted, sometimes frustrated but never angry at the system. I work as a Therapist because if I could beat the odds like this, ~I had nothing going for me, you can do it.I believe that everyone has the capability of living their life to the fullest and raising healthy loving children. I was not going to raise mini DV, no respect for women boys in order that they go in life and continue what thier dad was doing. Do the research, computers are free at the library, figure out what you need to do and start a plan. Sure you can have 20 minutes for a pity party but the next 10 mins. grow up and raise those children and yourself to higher standards than just sticking with the bad. Hanging in there for the kids does not work because by the time they are old enough to figure it out which is a lot sooner than you think , they will have no respect for you or themseleves. They too can learn the computers at the library, check out a book and learn a different way. Children are more resilent than you think. It really becomes the women who do not want to change the status of thier lives. Think hard about your descions but stay strong…you are stronger than you think
Twitter @ tsquest
Wow, I honestly have nothing to add. I loved Ali’s points especially. And this last comment by WhitewaterAtty? Perfect.
T´s last blog ..An open letter to me- as a Mom and parent- on Mothers Day
Twitter @ BigLittleWolf
I was struck by this: “I envy single moms because they are able to distance themselves from the person who hurt them.”
There’s plenty of assumptions packed into that phrase – that you will get through the long divorcing process unscathed, that there will be sufficient financial support provided to help care for the children (rare), that you will have a “reasonable” custody situation, that you will be able to enforce your support agreement, that legal representation won’t put in you in debt for years to come, and so on, and so on.
Sadly, there is little reality to what divorce is really like for those who go into it rather blindly. Much depends on your situation (which you cannot predict), your family, your age, your health, your lawyer, his lawyer, and your state of residence. And more.
I would caution all women (in particular) who are painting themselves a pretty picture of post-divorce life to gather some data. REAL data. Talk to others in their area and think carefully about what they’re doing before they do it.
And this doesn’t even address the potential problems/challenges for the children. They can be considerable – even in a situation of amicable divorce.
BigLittleWolf´s last blog ..Parenting Advice From Non-Parents – What Do You Think
Twitter @ ewokmama
ABSOLUTELY! I totally understand this. My marriage with my ex almost ended a couple of times during the 9 year stint but we stuck with it and tried everything, including therapy – nothing ever improved on his end because he doesn’t follow through. In fact it got worse and he even told me I expected too much of him (which is ridiculous – I would have been fine if he at least cleaned up after himself). When our son arrived, it dawned on me that even our child would not encourage my ex to grow up. I did everything for that man (laundry, cooking – including cutting his chicken off the bone in restaurants!, all the child care, and all the bill paying) and when it became clear that I was doing everything for him AND our child, it really hit me that it was a bad situation and I was single and parenting TWO children by myself.
Those around us saw it and said nothing – they all thought that it was “just the way things were” and that I accepted it. While I thought of leaving many times, I didn’t feel I could abandon him when, say, he didn’t have a job and was a student with no family anywhere close. Finally we moved back closer to family and he got a decent employment contract and we split. It was mutual and fairly amicable – he recognized that he couldn’t meet my needs (or wouldn’t). He is now repeating the cycle with his fiance, though…
I can’t tell you how relieved I was when I moved out on my own. It was so much easier than being in that marriage. I knew I had done the right thing immediately. My ex had been stressing me out so badly that I was dealing with chronic fatigue but I was able to get back my normal amount of energy without him. I’ve never, ever doubted my decision in over 2 years.
It is not all roses. I of course have to continue to deal with my ex because he sees our son. I get ONLY the bad things about him now. I don’t get to shield my son from his dad’s influence as I did when we all lived together but I try to balance it out. Thankfully, our son is doing great!!
Ewokmama´s last blog ..Interview with Jack
I agree with BigLittleWolf on this. I wasn’t the one that wanted the divorce and after over 6 years my ex still finds new ways to both disappoint and hurt the kids and me. Even if marriage isn’t forever divorce with children can be a lifetime. We had 2 “good” years and then circumstances changed. My daughter still wishes we could all be together and her mom just tells her to “get over it” and I still occasionally stumble on something that brings up issues from my parents’ divorce over 30 years ago. Certainly divorce can be a change for the better but it’s almost never easy and it’s nearly always unpredictable. No amount of planning can prepare you for the reality and uncertainty of it all.
Twitter @ http://dallassinglemom.blogspot.com
I’m adding another comment because I just thought of something while I was at the bank. It’s mothers like this one that give Single MOMS the bad reputation that all single moms are money grubbing gold diggers. Her statement, ““The only reason I am still with my husband is that I can’t make enough money to pay the bills and child care costs until I get my degree,” perpetuates individuals like Mike Huckabee to spread outright lies about single mothers being “very poor, under-educated, unable to get a job, and relying on government assistance in order to feed their kids.”
There is no guarantee that once she gets her degree she will even get a job since many people I know have degrees but are unemployed. What will be her excuse then? We need to fight these stereotypes NOW and women should be helping women.
Heather Buen – Dallas Single Mom Examiner´s last blog ..Relate to your sons- single moms CAN raise the next generation of fathers
Twitter @ mightbeatranny
one mom changes everyones opinion? wow, she’s powerful!
i think she’s being pro-active. only she can say if her husband i a true partner. sounds as if he isn’t.
my husband is secretly a bi-sexual transvestite who abused his wife and kids. he plays the good catholic man. to our neighbors, our church, the kids school and his family, i am the horrible bitch that left for no reason. if they knew the truth they would likely think a little differently.
my husband closed all credit cards, bank accounts, etc, as soon as i left. he was ordered to pay me support but didn’t until he was literally about to go to jail. christmas past, all 3 of ur kids birthdays passed, MONTHS passed and i had no money from our community property and no court ordered support. he tried to force me to go back to him. i didn’t have to go back because i had resources. if i hadn’t had them it would have been a different story.
if you don’t understand where this woman is coming from consider yourself fortunate. there is a level of desperation in wanting to escape for the safety of you and your children ans knowing that the allmighty dollar stands in your way.
in a perfect world we would have a nice polite conversation about how the marriage isn’t working and both parties would behave like adults. but we live in a FAR from perfect world. and we have to prepare for what we know will come when we make those hard decisions that are best for us and our kids.
Twitter @ divabylaw
Married Mom is a living example of what I have declared in my case of divorce. I had no incentive to stay because my husband packed up and left without notice. So depending on his income was not an option. He wanted to come back home, but I had no fight left in me to save our marriage. In spite of religious beliefs, I divorced my husband. Knowing me, I would have–and did–deal with minor irritations that were far and few between, but the chronic episodes I could not see myself waiting for change well into my winter years with no chance of experiencing some glimmer of happiness in marriage. I can identify with Married Mom looking forward to divorce for the anticipated peace. If I had her option of a husband at home, that would have been incentive enough for me to keep trying to work on my marriage.
I read all this and I am sick to my stomach! I raised 8 kids by myself with no therapist psychiatrist etc! I don’t believe in having a lazy man around. I don’t believe in being dishonest to your spouses. You can only do so much as a parent. It’s child’s well being we need to think of first! Too much time plotting and waiting AND not enough time communicating as a family.
I hold family home evenings once a week. Anyone in my family has a problem? Now it’s the time to speak up! So we are able to deal with it together. For the XBOX? Tell him to either go fight the real war and stay off Black Ops! I have 2 kids at home 12 & 16 they don’t see XBOX until Friday & Saturday Only! Don’t wake him… it’s not your responsibility!
Twitter @ tsquest
Go, Lala, GO!
T´s last blog ..Compliments welcome!
lala and T: T. is right Lala – you rock! Are you blogging? We tried (eagerly) to visit your site, but unsuccessfully. Please visit again soon. Your “no nonsense” approach is just what some of us need to hear. If you’re on Twitter, please let us know. Thanks again!
Twitter @ mightbeatranny
a lot of you don’t understand that in some relationahip the womans choice is taken away. its not always possible to leave. sometimes its not called leaving; its called escape. and you can’t do that on the fly with kids.
Twitter @ http://onesmarmymama.blogspot.com
@mightbeatranny
You’re right……there are the rare circumstances when it truly is near impossible to get out. But there are ALWAYS options and this situation doesn’t sound like that at all. It sounds like a situation that MANY of us have been in. We’ve walked in those shoes. We understand how truly hard it is to make that choice. Maybe instead of criticizing those of us who’ve been there and made it to the other side, you could listen and learn something. Sounds like you’re in a pretty unhappy situation yourself.
I don’t think anyone means to be unduely harsh. If this mama were my best friend, those hard truths are the things I’d tell her, because I care. Because I understand what it’s like. Because I understand how hard it can be. But also……..because I got through it and I know how things can be better.
C Lo´s last blog ..Mothers Day
Twitter @ justmewith
Not to make light of such a painful situation, but isn’t this kind of like what old ladies used to say — always have mattress money? A woman should always have some sort of an exit plan, evening married ladies. I didn’t, but I think that’s what my Mom’s generation always thought. And my mom is still married. It’s not completely new or shocking. Maybe women think (but don’t say) — when the kids are older . . ., when I’m out of school, when this, when that — I’m gone. It happens. Hugs to everyone in difficult and hurtful marriages.
Roxanne´s last blog ..My High School Sweetheart is Getting Married
Twitter @ mightbeatranny
not sure if that was directed at me, but MY comments didn’t pass judgement on the situations of others, so….
i got out, with my kids. i have a restraining order and we are safe and happy. everyone’s road is different and if planning is what this woman needs to do, then so be it.
why do women have to belittle the choices of other women? you don’t see men doing that.
Twitter @ WhitewaterAtty
@mightbeatranny — no one is belittling the choices of others.
The point that many of us are making is that just because SOME marriages (such as yours and C Lo’s apparently) are not savable and beyond repair does not mean Married Mom with a Plan’s (MMP) marriage is not savable. Your marriage was so bad that you needed to get a restraining order; however, MMP’s husband planing video games is not at restraining order level.
An Unhappy Spouse and/or Irresponsible Husband does not (and should not) necessarily equal: “Leave the marriage because you’re unhappy.” Now, one needs to DEAL with that unhappiness — because no one should ever be stuck in an unhappy relationship. However, unilaterally ending the relationship is NOT THE ONLY PATH towards ultimate happiness. Absent dangerous/harmful situations, the first response — ESPECIALLY when there are kids — should really be: “How can we fix this?” And then, if someone cannot fix the relationship AFTER A TRUE TRY AND COMMUNICATION (hopefully with counseling), then that spouse has every right (and SHOULD!) make a plan to leave.
Twitter @ barblicious
I think we can all agree we all are unique individuals and dealing with our own unique scenarios. Based purely on the information in this post…
I think that this mother’s ‘grass is greener on the other side’ notion will not hold true. Planning her exit, in this covet method does seem shady, given that the husband in this scenario was not painted as abusive – merely uninvolved and maybe immature.
It always takes two to tango. I have to say though, she seems immature in her behavior too. She seems to have merely given up. This mama has enabled her husband to slack, and is seeming to play the ‘poor me’ role. She clearly isn’t involved in the relationship either anymore, how does she expect her husband to be interested in her emotionally when clearly she is not interested either – she’s only there for the money (support) and planning to leave as soon as she can afford it, that hardly makes her emotionally in it.
It is also very naive to assume that single mother’s have it easier because they can distance themselves from the men that hurt them. As a single mom, I can assure her what you think and feel is with you, is in your head, where ever you go, no matter where he is in the picture. You can’t escape your own thoughts and feelings.
If she is going to go thru a divorce, and settle an agreement for co-parenting, she is fooling herself if she thinks it will be easier than it is for her now. LOL
Barbara Doduk´s last blog ..Cat Breath
Twitter @ http://onesmarmymama.blogspot.com
Once again, great words from WhitewaterAtty…
FWIW, The last three or four years of my marriage were pretty terrible, and my husband was abusive. We went to therapy for two years, and I went to individual therapy for two more. At the end of the day, I can hold my head up and say that I truly did everything I could to salvage my family and I honestly put 110% into being the best wife and mother I could be. It wasn’t always the case…..I can also admit that my actions in the first half of our marriage definitely contributed to where we ended up.
But at the end of the day, I didn’t just walk away, I tried my hardest, I did everything I should have done. I think that’s what makes it possible for me to be truly happy now……….I have no baggage holding me back, no “what ifs” nagging me. And I’m much better equipt to be a good co-parent AND to be in a healthier relationship next time.
C Lo´s last blog ..The Big Easy
Twitter @ WhitewaterAtty
C Lo, exactly right!
“We went to therapy for two years, * * * At the end of the day, I can hold my head up and say that I truly did everything I could to salvage my family * * * I didn’t just walk away, I tried my hardest, I did everything I should have done.”
Twitter @ http://twohappyhomes.blogspot.com/
Jeez, these comments have me torn. I understand both sides, but ultimately I truly believe that if she feels like she needs to get out – then she does.
Personal experience – counseling didn’t work for me – I was already gone, which it sounds like she is as well. It’s hard to judge not knowing a lot of the history in this particular situation. But I don’t think it’s right or fair to tell her that she’s not doing enough when no one knows exactly what she has done up until this point. Or for that matter, what his behavior was in the past.
I feel like in these situations if someone is hurting as much as she is than instead of belittling her and making her feel like she’s doing something wrong, then she could really just use a little support instead. I guess I’m not really the “tough love” type!!

traci whitney´s last blog ..Divvying up co-parenting chores
I was in a similar situation and I had to simply wait for the right moment to leave. I waited till I was earning again and felt strong enough. I left when my son was 18 months because I felt if he was any older it would be more traumatic. I carried on doing things for my husband for about 6 months after we split because I wanted him to be a father.
Thankfully, 6 years on he is still involved in his life in a positive way although he does leave me to have all the responsibility. I would have found it easy to leave if I didn’t have a child, but in this instance I had to take my time to make sure it was the right decision. My son is still affected by the breakup even thought he has no memories of us being together. I sometimes feel guilty because it was better for me NOT necessarily better for my son. I was simply too vulnerable to leave any sooner and had to make sure I could provide for my son. However, being a single mum is nothing like feeling like a single mum, it’s a million times tougher.
Jo: You sound like a brave woman. And we’re happy that things are working out reasonably well for you and your son. Guilt seems to shadow so many of us. It’s undeserved! Thanks for joining he conversation. Please visit us again soon.
I didn’t leave my husband because I feared that if I did, he’d end up with the kids. He was completely uninvolved, and got violent and abusive if he “had” to care for them (or me). I just let him be alone. He was never around.
To the outside, at that point, it might have looked peaceful, because I no longer had any expectations of him, I just kept the kids out of his way and avoided him. Even so, he got meaner. Friends told me to see lawyers and put away money. I felt so guilty and sneaky.
When our separation happened, he closed out accounts, had all the money, the job, etc. He was absolutely furious at me, which was a bit of a surprise, given he’d blissfully happy to ignore me and the kids up to that point. (Except when he wanted us, then he demanded our presence and started breaking things and raging, if we didn’t come through.)
I survived (and got an atty) only because of the money I put away, the fact that he was so lazy he’d never gotten a credit card in his own name, etc. But I was right. He ended up with the kids, much, much more. For over two years, he kept me in court, with increasing demands for contact with the kids and accusations about me. Social services, police, gossip, slander. It’s so unusual for a man to say he wants his kids — he had the whole system on his side, those words were magic, no matter what his behavior.
The kids went downhill, after a year. They managed to cope at first, but it was so long and horrible. Grades plummeted, they had nightmares, went on meds, lost friends. Throughout all of this, as my financial situation worsened, I couldn’t look for or find work, since I was being accused of being incompetent and changing their “lifestyle”. I couldn’t risk NOT being a stay at home mom. Another change. ]
In the end, as I predicted from day one, he disappeared. No one had believed me — they’d ask, why is he fighting for them? To control me. What will he do, if he realizes he can’t win this? “Disappear”. And he did.
After all that fighting I was left with two abandoned kids, thousands of dollars in legal bills and a mediocre alimony and child support settlement I had agreed to only to keep the kids from him as much as possible. Which hadn’t worked.
Sometimes the system does not work — at all. It breaks down the most when there are no bruises, no witnesses, when the man uses words like “care” and “love” and “father’s rights”. My kids spent more time with their dad after the separation and they will probably be affected for years, if not always, by it. The abandonment is another issue, on top of that.
It’s true people shouldn’t give up on marriages for “minor” things, but only the person in the marriage knows what’s minor (and, personally, I revealed “minor” stuff to people and avoided more painful stuff, so don’t assume you know what’s really going on). I was in charge of all our finances, home repairs, purchases, shopping, child care, etc. I did it all. Absolutely all. It was exhausting and there was the constant threat he’d swoop down and demand a Kodak moment, at any time. People like me don’t say “abuse” easily and I am much more likely to talk about uninvolved he was than about the abuse I feared and suffered when I or the kids demanded he be involved. Or negotiated for him to be involved. Say, going to his own kid’s birthday party. Yeah, really, it was that bad. And, in court, he got considerable custody — because he just blamed his lack of involvement on ME. He’d always WANTED to be a dad, he just had a terrible spouse and he was trying to be a dad, post separation/divorce and said terrible spouse was alienating his kids from him. Despite what you may read online, the courts, mediators and attorneys could care less what the kid’s previous parental relationships were, who took them to doctors, haircuts, etc. It boils down to money. He had (has) the money.
In my case, people told me it’d get better, as this battle went on. After 18 mos they stopped saying that. Even my most optimistic, pollyann-ish friend, said she couldn’t say it, anymore, wouldn’t. It did finally end, but only because he ended it. Because he abandoned them, reverted back to the uninvolved person he’d always been (in action and words).
I don’t know the story of the person above, I just know in my case it took 2 1/2 years for my ex to prove himself the uninvolved, selfish person he’d always been. Even saying that, there are many people who still believe him and feel another dad has been kept from his kids by system that favors mothers. That’s ok. I have my kids, back, at last.
mommii: Thanks for joining the conversation. Your statement …stopped having expectations …hit home for me. We’re guessing others in our community felt the same way. We appreciate your candor. Please stop by again soon.
i know this forum is mainly for moms, but I’m living the life of a single mother while still married to my wife. we have our problems and issues as all new parents and newlyweds. like the person above, my wife is less involved in the day to day activities of our two children, she spends her days at work, and parties most of the week. i have custody of our children 98% of the time. she and i both don’t want a divorce but her reluctance to be more involved in the kids’ lives and her lack of communication with me suggest otherwise. So, silently, I’ve been planning a divorce. She controls all the finances as I lost my job a year ago and have been a full time stay at home dad.
@Jose: We always appreciate hearing from dads, and we are so honored that you took the time to write. We are here for you; please stay in touch.
Twitter @ WhitewaterAtty
Jose:
Please, please, please before you make a set plan to exit the marriage FIRST communicate more with your spouse as best you and, POSSIBLY MORE IMPORTANT, try to bring professional counseling into your marriage. You made a vow to be with your wife in good times AND BAD. This a bad time, and — at the least for your children — you really should do what you can to see if the marriage can be rectified… and this obligation is more important when you have children.
When you have a child, your decision to end your marriage has SERIOUS consequences. Thus, absent abuse — and you ONLY mention your wife’s working schedule and communication as the problem — you owe it to you, your spouse, and your children to communicate with your wife and TRY (hopefully with therapy/counseling) to see if your marriage can be saved.
You and your wife might be able to reconnect to what you once had, but you will need help — and counseling can be that help. I know that your wife might resist going, but you just MIGHT be able to have a happy life/home that you desire with your children’s two parents together in one home/family. And wouldn’t it be SO MUCH BETTER to have that happiness without having to go through extremely painful and emotionally scaring divorce/custody issues?
@WhitewaterAtty we have tried counseling and i ended it because it seemed like she was getting validated for everything and i was getting the sit back and take it…since ending the counseling, we’ve continued to speak, but it bars on what she’s ready to talk about, and when she’s ready to talk about it. leaving me feeling isolated and frustrated. remaining in an unhappy marriage seems like a bigger disservice to me than staying till she figures things out, considering she says she wasnt ready to be a parent or a wife, as well as dealing with her issues with being a bi-sexual female. i didnt plan on being a married single dad and never planned on a divorce but given the uncertainty of where she is emotionally with herself, us and most important our children, i just feel it would lessen the stress of it all.
jose´s last blog ..hold my hand daddy
Twitter @ WhitewaterAtty
Jose,
Thanks for responding. Clearly, you and your wife are in a very rough spot, and I’m glad you both tried therapy, but divorce is very serious and is final. While you should NOT stay in a marriage that has no hope for happiness, getting a divorce to “lessen the stress of it all” seems like you may be looking for the easy way out. Have you considered another therapist? And what was your wife getting validated for?
Even if she’s talking to you in a productive manner, counseling and couples work takes A LOT of time. Even though it sounds like this is not what you want to hear (and I’m NOT saying you should stay in a suffering marriage, and I’m NOT saying your wife in is any way right about her actions), even if it’s the HARD ROAD to spend some more time trying to fix the marriage, such a road could lead to an ultimate happy life for you and your family.
If, after working on the marriage, you can look yourself in the mirror and say with confidence that you did EVERYTHING in your power to make the marriage work and it just was not fixable… then start the process. But, unless you fear abuse, doing so covertly only yields resentment, more problems, and does not start off with strong footing for a quality co-parenting relationship with your then-soon-to-be Ex.
thats just it, i feel like im the only one in this marriage, as if she is already gone but doesnt have the heart to say that she really wants a divorce, she says she just needa space, no definable amount of space just space. it has already been two yrs, not much has changed about her attitude or support. as im in a financially dependent position with her it only makes matters worse. she holds an iron fist over the money, and though we have agreed to a child support payment of 200 every two weeks lately she hasnt been giving me that support, while also digging us further into debt with over spending on her nights out, which are frequent. at times i feel like her actions are directed at punishing me, versuses her own immaturity and unpreparedness of becoming a parent and wife. her response is always, this isnt the life she wanted, and that shes merely trying to get back to the life she envisioned and leave the life she has. this is why im silently planning a divorce, because she isnt trying or even considering coupling the two together, she just wants the one life and it seems that its the one that doesnt include a marriage and children.
jose´s last blog ..hold my hand daddy
Twitter @ WhitewaterAtty
Life is tough right now, I get it. You and your wife aren’t connecting, I get it. You feel like you are running the household without her, I get it. You *believe* that you wife doesn’t want to be married, I get it.
…but these things are not automatically permanent or currently threatening issues. Think of your vows and your children — Wouldn’t they be better off if you COULD make it work with your wife? Wouldn’t it be wonderful if you COULD find that happy-place with her? It will be a tough road (assuming the marriage can be fixed), but the guilt from not trying and the pain caused from divorce will be A LOT worse if it’s true that reconciliation is POSSIBLE. Looking at short-term relief has long-term consequences.
And I know you also don’t want to hear this (and I wasn’t there, so I don’t have an opinion), but ask yourself why you ended the counseling sessions? Did you not want to face the tough questions and hard work? And have you considered that there could be some truth in what your prior marriage counselor said in her/his validation of your wife’s actions?
i was the one who initiated the counseling…as to the tough questions i would have gladly answered and asked them. it wass her reluctance in asking and answering them that became a problem for me…the counselor validated her abject silence causing me to see that i was in a lose lose situation. i do love my wife and want very much to rebuild our marriage, just not at the expense of my own sanity…she wants the ability to cheat whenever the mood should strike her, and this is not something i am willing to allow because it is a break in the very vows we took. currently as we are seperated im being dictated to and not being communicated with..the seperation she wants also isnt something i want and cannot accept…no matter my understanding of her issues i dont see the purpose of a protracted and indefinite seperation, without a real sense of communication from her.
jose´s last blog ..hold my hand daddy
Twitter @ WhitewaterAtty
– “she wants the ability to cheat whenever the mood should strike her”
– “we are separated im being dictated to and not being communicated with”
– “a protracted and indefinite separation, without a real sense of communication from her.”
Jose, these are all truly more significant problems than just you doing most of the child raising. Have you had a discussion about divorce with her? If so, and she has chosen to separate from you — it sounds like your decision to get a divorce isn’t so secretive, and you may have no other options.
That said, whatever you do, make sure that you will be comfortable honestly answering your children’s questions years from now (which are likely to be asked): “Daddy, did you do everything you could to keep our family together?”
i have had several discussions with her about divorce..she continues to say that she doesnt want a divorce, just space to figure things out..granted we’ve only been physically seperated for four months, it has been two years since we’ve truly communicated..we’ve also only been married for a year and a half. the seperation came after many months of arguing, two occassions of physical abuse (on both sides), and the loss of our apt. ive always known she was bi-sexual, but she has only just revealed that she could not see herself staying in this marriage if she could not cheat. which led me to exploring my options when it comes to a full divorce.
jose´s last blog ..hold my hand daddy
Twitter @ mightbeatranny
i will never explain my life choices to my children. i’m the adult and if i make a choice it is not open to discussion or questions from my children, or anyone else for that matter.
and since when is “keeping the family together” the goal? i want happy children who life w/o fear of being abused by another “family” member.
i could have stayed with my abusive husband. i, pretty sure he would take me back now. what kind of example would that be to my children? mom doesn’t matter…mom being hurt is okay…us being hurt is okay because “daddy” really loves us. BS ON THAT.
Twitter @ WhitewaterAtty
No one here, including me, is saying (or has said) that anyone should EVER suffer through an abusive relationship. Further, no one is saying that “keeping the family together” should trump all other considerations. If you are in an abusive relationships you owe it to yourself (and your children, if you have any) to remove yourself from that abuse without any qualifications whatsoever.
*BUT* keeping the family together SHOULD be a goal if your only complaints are that you are currently not happy. In *ANY* relationship, you go through periods of unhappiness and not liking your family members — during those times, in my opinion, one’s reaction should NOT be: “I’m unhappy, I’m going to plan a divorce.” Rather, I believe, you owe it to your spouse and your children to work on your spousal relationship and go to counseling if needed.
Plainly, due to the CLEAR difficulties and CLEAR emotional trauma of divorce, “keeping the family together” should be *A* goal, even if that goal doesn’t trump all other issues.
And also, in my opinion, the choices you make as an adult do affect your children in serious ways and in certain cases do justify questions by them. For example, if one makes the “life choice” to be a drug addict or to kidnap one’s children from their other parent, and the children are seriously affected by those choices… when the children are older, I believe questions about that choice are appropriate and the parent would owe them an apology.
well for me the relationship wasnt and isnt abusive its suffering from a breakdown in communication, which gave room for emotional and physical displays of miscontent we both have owned up to our wrongs its really now about are we ready to take the steps needed to either rebuild or conclude our marriage relationship. the answer to that last question isnt easy..i do want to say thank you to all the advice i have gotten since joining…i do love my wife and now understand better that she loves me, but the truth of staying together isnt an easy thing question for her to respond to because she hasnt let go her anger at me and most especially at herself…but i am strong enough for the two of us to allow her the room she needs to sort those things out…
jose´s last blog ..1002
My husband also went emotionally and physically AWOL after our baby was born last year. When I almost died from a staph infection shortly after the birth he was unavailable in every way that I needed him. A year later and after literally trying everything including counseling, he finally admitted that he was using drugs to cope with everything he couldnt handle… And not just when the baby came, but long before during other trials in our 11 year relationship. We are currently doing a trial separation but I am definitely planning my way out and the end of my marriage. He doesn’t know that I cannot go back or that through forgiving what happened I can no longer be with him. For me forgiving means giving up the hope that the past could be or feel different. I believe I can either limp along and wait to see if he changes and makes it up to me or I can forgive what happened and move on. For me it is this simple. I definitely relate to this mom and am not sure when or how I will tell him it’s over for good. I already feel more free with him out of our space and I know that beautiful things exist for me on the other side of this seemingly impassible mountain.
Nicole: We’re rooting for you. Lots of us have made that seeming impossible journey and have found joy and contentment. Please stay in touch with us.