When you’re a one night stand mom

We’ve had many conversations about bio-dads, who are men that are only biological fathers. You’ve told us about conceiving with a married bio-dad — and hiding that fact from him. Many of you shared concerns when your child’s bio-dad was someone you barely knew. We thought we had this topic covered. So, when we heard from a single mom with this unusual bio-dad question, it caught our attention.

Here’s the dilemma:

“I got pregnant after a one night stand,” this mom says. “Unfortunately, I can’t remember any details  –  not even his name.”

She’s now the proud mama of a sweet 10-month-old daughter. She’s right to anticipate that her daughter will ask “Daddy questions” in the future. Crafting a loving, supportive, and consistent response to her daughter’s inevitable questions won’t be easy. And this is not exactly the typical parenting dilemma that’s easily brought up in a playgroup or at Mommy and Me.

So, this mom is asking for YOUR advice:

How can she best respond to her daughter’s questions about her father – when she doesn’t even know his name?

Personal experiences are always welcome.

Just in case you’re new to our community: we don’t judge here.

~~~

Photo via Flickr: mandolin3142

Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

No related posts.

Comments

23 Responses to “When you’re a one night stand mom”
  1. StephanieRe says:

    Twitter @
    I’ve checked this blog for comments 3 times. I want to know what this mom should say, too. I have a similar situation and I’m at a loss for words every time I sit and wonder what I’m going to tell my daughter. I hope someone has an answer.
    StephanieRe´s last blog ..Dear Shaun T,My ComLuv Profile

  2. C Lo says:

    Twitter @
    You know….I don’t have personal experience so this is all just my opinion:

    I think that if it were me, I might make up a story for the todder/little kid years. Something like “You grew in my tummy just like magic because you are so special!” and leave it at that.

    At a certain point, your kid will get old enough and wise enough to know that is just a story, and I think at that point it would be a good time to start with age-appropriate truths. I don’t think it does any good to try to explain to a 3 year old any form of that truth………..none of it will sink it and it’ll just go other their head and possibly give them weird ideas. Once your kid is old enough to “get it” (around 8/9/10 usually) that a daddy is somehow required to make a baby, I think that would be the time to start having conversations.

    I think at that point I’d say something like “Your dad is a man I didn’t know at all before we made you. We weren’t even friends so I don’t know how to find him. I made some pretty bad choices when I was young but I was lucky enough to still have gotten you out of it.”

    I have a feeling that once your child is old enough to ask those questions, there is just not gonna be any easy way to handle it. So I think that telling the truth in an age appropriate way is probably the best. Face it head on and get through it and it hopefully won’t be too big of a deal.

    And, in the meantime, you have years before this comes up. Maybe you can put ads on Craigslist or do something to try to figure out who he is. Maybe by the time your kid starts asking, this will all be a moot point.

    Good luck.
    C Lo´s last blog ..Sometimes I Need A ReminderMy ComLuv Profile

  3. Twitter @
    This is a very sensitive question and the way you respond to your child questions are vital. She is very young now so don’t feel bad about down playing the situation to her because she is to young to fully understand.

    Let her know that Daddy isn’t here but mommy is, and that you love her and having her was a blessing. A child will lone for a absent parent when their isn’t someone to full that void. If you have brothers or cousins or any positive male role models ask them to spend some time with her as much as they can. The older she gets the harder the questions will get. It’s your choice on how you will explain how she was conceived. Be honest and let your heart guide you to the right time to tell her. Until then love her,love her,love her and be there for her.

    We single Moms can not afford to drop the ball when it come to our kids. Your situation can be a lesson that can be taught to her in her teen years. I’m a single mom and my Dad and brother have been great role models to my daughter — she is 6. My daughter doesn’t feel left out at all. I hope that this helps a little. I’m praying for you.
    Shanae Miller´s last blog ..My Father/Daughter FactorMy ComLuv Profile

  4. Danielle says:

    Twitter @
    I think that the important thing when daddy questions come up is that you express to her that no matter what happened between mom and dad that she is loved and was very much wanted. My children have already started asking “daddy questions” and although we weren’t a one night stand…we were a one night stand that wouldn’t end. I tell them whenever they ask that mommy loves them more than life and that we can’t control what daddy does or how he feels but that his not being around has nothing to do with how amazing they are. That daddy just wasn’t in a position to be a daddy yet and that is ok. Now I am also one to believe that once she is old enough when you are talking about love and sex to explain what happened with you and her father. That could help her make decisions differently if that is what is best for her.

    Hope it helps! This motherhood things sure isn’t easy…especially when you are going it alone!
    Danielle´s last blog ..Saturday MorningMy ComLuv Profile

  5. mightbeatranny says:

    Twitter @
    well, i don’t know what i would do….

    i did have a friend w/ a roommate who had been conceived this way, then she was put up for adoption. she later looked up her bio mom who told the girl her story. i remember being horrified because the mom said her “what can i say. we met at a bar. he said he’d pull out and he didn’t. i didn’t want a baby.”

    whatever you say, if you stress how thrilled you are to have the child, i think that’s what the child will take away.

    i’m not passing judgement, but it doesn’t sound very….”nice”, maybe is the word i was looking for. could you come up with a name and say it was a short term casual relationship, so you don’t have his last name.

    in a way, it WAS like going to a sperm bank (i might go w/ that now that i think of it. but that’s just me).

  6. Amber says:

    This would be an incredibly hard situation to be in. As A single mom myself, I had a hard time explaining why my son’s dad wasnt living with us (we never married) & they have a great relationship, so I could not imagine having to explain to my child why they dont have a father @ all & why I dont know who he is. I will just say honesty is the best policy ALWAYS. When the time comes for you to tell her about her dad be honest. Tell her the truth. Say when I was young I met a man & we had relations (sex, made love, were intimate…what word you wanna use) we created you & you grew inside me & on your birthday you came out. Unfortunately, your dad & I did not stay friends & he did not know you were born. Then help uour daughter possible find the man. Maybe you can put an ad in the paper saying if you met & your name on date @ location please contact & see if the man comes forward. He may turn out to be a stand up guy if he finds out he has a hild. You might even put safety measures in place through an attorney stating you want nothing from him if he comes forward otherthan for him to provide info where your child can make contact once she is old enough.

  7. VA Mom says:

    The best piece of advice I can give this new mother is to take a deep breath and exhale. It is going to be a long ride, with many questions along the way, both from her child and people they encounter throughout their lives. My daughter is 6 and has never seen her father. Yes I know who and where he is by I think my advice, at least in the short run holds true:

    1) You don’t owe anyone an explanation about how you conceived your child. People ask, people will pry and people will at times be rude about it, but you owe them nothing. To this day I simply say, “She’s never seen her father and he isn’t a part of our lives.” – short simple and the truth.

    2)Only answer the what your child asks you. This was the best piece of advice I have ever been given. Children generally ask very specific questions and want simple solution answers in return. When your child asks about not having a dad generally speaking it is because they are sorting and processing what’s going on in their world – both in comparison to their peers but also because they have seen/heard something that they need to reconcile. — example a family vacation was happening and I was not going, my daughter was a baby at the time. My nephew asked why I wasn’t going and I said because I didn’t want to take the baby. My nephew then asked why couldn’t she just stay with her Dad. I was about to launch into an explanation when I realized my nephew was simply asking a logistics question. He was going to stay with his mom while my brother went on the trip and assumed I would do the same. I told him that her father isn’t in our lives – and he simply said “Oh well that won’t work then”. He didn’t care why my daughter didn’t have a Dad, he was merely curious about why I wasn’t going on a trip. It is SO important to listen to what your child is actually asking you and answer that question.

    3) Know that as your child grows, your answer will expand and change. You need to get yourself comfortable with how you talk about it. Because your child will look to see how you respond when talking about it. If you are uncomfortable or embarrassed when people ask, your child will pick up on it and take their cues from you. One thing I was adamant about when I had my child was not to project my emotions/self reflection about how she came into the world onto her. When she was a baby and didn’t understand I would talk to her about families coming in all shapes and sizes. I got comfortable with my own way of talking about our family unit. And that families are born out of love.

    4) I made the choice to distinguish the term “father” from “dad”. This way as she hits an age where she learns about how babies are born, I can fall back on everyone has a father, but not everyone gets a dad. This has also come in handy when Father’s Day rolls around. My daughter in recent years has said – mommy everyone has a daddy but me – of course not true – but my response to her has been. You have dad’s who love you in your life – grandpa, uncles, and I would also add in names of male friends who have served as father figures. I would then tell her her, what we don’t have is a dad who lives with us.

    5) Last point – I firmly believe you can not miss what you have never had. Your child has never had a father, it doesn’t matter how they were concieved, that role/parent has never been a part of the fabric that your child’s life, happiness and security is based on. Don’t empower it because of a sense of guilt or societal pressure. Your child will have questions throughout their life about where they came from. Take them as they come, be honest within limits and don’t apologize for the choices you made – because without them you wouldn’t have this child you love so much.

  8. maew says:

    I am not in a situation similar to yours but as the child of a single mother who barely knows who my father at least I can give you a couple of ideas. My mother very early told me that she really really wanted a baby and she just got help from a special man who just came to make her dream (me) come true. My mother always put a lot of emphasis on how wanted I was and how loved I was. I also was very close to my uncle which helped me to have somekind of “kinda” dad relationship. I think I was pretty much Ok with growing up in a single mom household but when I grew up that is when I started to want to know who my father was and when I started to ask more detailed questions. All I can recommend you is to start thinking from now (you have many years still) how you are going to phrase the answers to her quesions in a delicate question. Please don’t EVER tell her she is the product of a one night stand! Maybe not everybody will agree with me but to me that is too shocking. As I said think about a way you can phrase it in a better like it was a man who just came into my life quickly to help me make you something like that. In my case the truth is my mother never gave me too many details. Just say you really don’t remember too much about him and if she wants to find out then you can do genetic testings together. In the beginning, I am not going to lie I was kinda angry about not knowing but now I think that what my mother did of giving me the less details was the best. When your child grows up just validate her feelings, listen to her, and if she wants to find out who her father is encourage her to get genetic testings (there are many sites who do genetic testings and can help to find relatives) by the time your daughter is an adult there will be much easier ways to find genetic roots than now. Just make sure you are always supportive and validate her feelings always.

  9. Chopperpapa says:

    Twitter @
    I’ll chime in as the male voice here. I think that C-Lo is right. When the question does come up, and you feel they have the capacity to understand, you owe it to your child to be honest with them. I have seen answers that ‘daddy isn’t here but mommy loves you’. That isn’t the point in this situation. The facts are what the facts are and offering up anything less than the truth isn’t protecting the child – it is simply covering up personal responsibility in the situation. And who knows hopefully, and if you want to, you’ll find a man one day who will assume the role of the dad in your child’s life which will make that process much easier. But in the event that doesn’t happen honesty should be the only course of action.

    I think as parents we want to assume a persona to our children that we are perfect infallible creatures that make no mistakes And when we do, because we know we aren’t perfect, instead of owning up to those mistakes and suffering the chance of being seen as ‘less than’ in our children’s eyes will make excuses and divert the conversation. All without knowing that eventually the truth, as it always does, will come out and when that happens we end up looking far worse than if we’d been straight forward in the first place.
    Chopperpapa´s last blog ..Dating a single dad – the best advice you’ll ever get.My ComLuv Profile

  10. MWC26 says:

    Twitter @
    I agree with Chopperpapa and CLo. I think it would be best when they are old enoguh and are asking to give the child age- appropriate truths. “Covering up” as chopperpapa said could also lead to other problems, like resentment or not trusting the mom, stuff like that. But in the mean time, I also wouldn’t sit by and just give up on trying to find out/figure out who her father is. You might be able to remeber some details and figure it out from there or hire a private investigator to help you out. Then when she is old enoguh and is asking, you might have the asnwers to give her, or maybe this man (if you find him that is) might want to be a father to this little girl.

  11. MLC says:

    My daughter’s father was a friend, (though no longer a boyfriend) who didn’t feel able to raise a child with me. I thought I was always straight about this, but daughter did go through a highly moral phase (aged 10 or so) when she thought I had been slutty and irresponsible. This was really hard to deal with, but fortunately I didn’t over-react – though I did stress that she needed to be respectful of me. And now she’s OK about it. One thing I have always emphasised is that, although my pregnancy wasn’t planned, I did make the choice to go through with it – my daughter is as loved and chosen as any child in a more conventional family.

  12. kims says:

    i feel so sad for this mom’s situation. i disagree with VA Mom’s statement that you can’t miss what you never had; i grew up w/o knowing my bio father & was painfully aware of his absense. one thing i would stress to her daughter, though, is that this type of behavior is not appropriate; as CLo stated, admitting that she mnade some very bad choices. because she very well may judge her mom for her actions, but she could also think, well my mom did it, i can, too. my parents used to say, do as i say, not as i do; but i believe its better to lead by example.

  13. Sami says:

    I haven’t read all the responses yet bjt I have to start by saying that I FULLY disagree with C Lo. I made some bad choices? Clearly this mama made a great choice or she wouldn’t have this beautiful baby girl!
    I also disagree to start out with a fairy tale, that she grew in your belly with magic. It will only make mom seem inconsistent and not trustworthy later on.
    Tell her that her daddy was a special man, that you didn’t know very well and you don’t know where he is now. But that the two of you shared some time together that made God want to bless you with her. Of course if you’re not religious or spiritual that won’t work.
    I’m currently working on a similar situation, my ex and I broke up when my LO was only 1 month and now he’s 1 year. I am definitely solidifying my answer now, so that when he does start asking questions I will know exactly what I’m going to say.

    I also want to say that I grew up not knowing my father until I was 18 and I was fine. My mother loved me so much that I never knew anything was missing. Knowing my father now, I firmly believe that I would not be as confident of a person if I had been torn between 2 homes my entire childhood. I stand behind my mother’s decision, and honestly my father has brought more stress than good into my life in the 10 yrs I’ve known him!

    Hope this helps! I think the fact that you are asking for help says a lot about your mothering, and I feel that when it comes time you’ll know exactly what to say!

  14. alley says:

    Twitter @
    “You dad and I liked each other a lot, but not enough to be together all the time. But I love you very very much, and we are a family because families come in all sorts of shapes and sizes”

    I’m not a fan of telling magical lies. And I don’t think a child needs to hear that mom got plastered, picked up a random dude, and didn’t even remember him by the time she knew she was pregnant. If the child gets older and presses for more details, tell her that you’ve tried all the old numbers and adresses and you just cant get ahold of him.
    alley´s last blog ..This is Why I Worry About HumanityMy ComLuv Profile

  15. Denise says:

    I think that she just needs to be honest and admit that she doesn’t know the father. But she also needs to be fully prepared for the fallout from that, ie. shock, tears, anger or maybe indifference. It is hard to say what the daughter’s reaction will be.

    Am I the only one that thinks this is really sad though? I think kids should at least know who their parents are. :-( At least a full name and an address would have been nice.

  16. Raising a Diva says:

    What’s done is done. I think focusing energy on the person who is absent gives weight to an issue that can not be resolved. She had a one night stand that resulted in a pregnancy. It happens. I don’t think she should let it define her family or who she is as a parent. Her baby is an infant so she has many many years ahead of her to deal with the inevitable questions. As in most things with parenting, she needs to figure out what she is comfortable with saying, embrace it and be consistent. If she wears this one moment in time as what defines her as a parent, she will impart that on her child. I don’t think she should make up a story, but I do think the truth has age appropriate limits. Not knowing a second parent does not have to be tragic and it doesn’t need to define who this child will become. I would say, focus on how much you wanted this child and love them. Know that your answer about Daddy questions will start as very baseline, logistical questions and then evolve as your child grows. Don’t over inform your child and remember to not spend energy apologizing for having a one night stand. It doesn’t define you and doesn’t define who you are as a parent.

  17. Melissa says:

    I think making up a story would be a terrible way to deal with this. This child will eventually grow up. And she will eventually discover the truth. It will hurt way more to find out your whole life was a lie, than to know early on that she just does.not.know. Dont add to the pain by lying. The child is only 10months old now. Chances are good if she digs around a little, she can figure out who dad is. But the longer she waits, the lower her chances will be of ever finding out. I like the craigs list idea. I would do everything you could do to figure this out. NOW. Not later.

  18. Natasha says:

    there are some great points here and at the end of the day, you will know what you are most comfortable with as a parent. Finding the bio-dad is a really personal choice that you may not want to make but tracking people down gets easier by the minute so be very careful and don’t feel rushed or pressured to make that decision.

    I became a single mom when I spent one night with someone (although we had been friends for many years so I had more information to work with.) When I got pregnant he made it very clear he wanted nothing to do with it, not now, not ever. There was no romantic relationship or promises of traditional family and I never want to mislead my son into thinking there were. If my baby ever does grow up to start digging around for the story, he would know I lied. Just like your daughter. If you lie to her now she will either start wondering why you “refuse” to give her the details later and resent it, or will find out the truth somewhere else and wonder what else you lied to her about. It may seem like you’re protecting her now but it could ruin your relationship in the future. What I tell my son (he started asking when he started daycare and people’s daddies came to pick them up, around age 2), is that when he came into my life I was so happy and excited to have him, I knew I loved him most in the whole wide world and brought him home to our family (I moved from Chicago to my hometown) so that his (I list all the family members and friends he loves in his life) could love him most of all as well. For now, he gets excited to play that game and list all of the people in his life. Then he walks away happy. When he asks specific questions about his father I answer as matter-of-factly as possible. When I don’t know the answer to his questions I tell him that as well. As he gets older I think about all of the questions he will ask and the pain he will feel because his family is different. All I know is I have to take it one day at a time. Until then, I also fill up our lives with as many untraditional families as I can find so he knows that everyone is different. I joined a meetup group for single parents so he is making friends his age who are asking the same questions and he responds really well to that. He will ask where those kids daddies are and we talk about how some of them live with just their mommy like him, some with just a daddy, and some live sometimes with their mommy and sometimes with their daddy. He seems to feel good about knowing it’s not just him. Last, I really recommend the book “Do I Have A Daddy.” It’s a kids book where the mom has to answer some of those hard questions and it has a guide for parents in the back. That book has been a fantastic guide and my son has always loved it. He memorized the entire book and will pick it up to point it out and say “Just like me mommy, his family is just like me.” It also has a point where he can list all of the strong male role-models he does have and it seems to make him feel really good about our life.

    I also just want to say that as the daughter of a single mom whose parents were in a relationship that fell apart. There have been specific points in my life where I have learned that I was lied to quite a bit about the situation. There were points that were true and comments that were purposefully made vague and it was one of the hardest things in my life to get over. I never fully forgave my mother for lying to me about my dad and their relationship. Sometimes she thought she was protecting me, sometimes she just wanted me to appreciate the sacrifices she made for me more. Those lines are easy to blur together and as a mother you can get caught up in that. I hate that she lied to me and it made me question everything she has ever told me. I always wish I had been trusted with the truth so I could have made my own decisions on how to feel about where I came from.

    Please don’t tell your daughter she was the result of a bad decision. You can word it so that she knows that she was exactly the right thing to happen to you but being a single parent is a struggle and you wish you could have provided her with a more traditional family. It’s really easy to cross the line between being honest about what your going through, and making a child feel like a life wrecking mistake. Of course, since you are already reaching out for help and asking the questions, it seems like you’ve already got that under control. You’re a good mom. :)

  19. Dr. Leah says:

    Natasha: Thank you for adding so much to this important conversation.

  20. Jenni says:

    Twitter @
    Very nice, Natasha. I appreciate all that you said.

    I am a single mom and my daughter has only met her father three times in her four years. I was in a relationship from the time she was 16 months old until a few months ago. During that time, her biological father decided he wanted some involvement. He’s only seen her once a year for the last three years. She doesn’t know he is her father. I don’t know what to tell her.

    It’s all kind of a mess really, as she calls my ex “papa”. He was, and still is completely wonderful to her. I know she is a little sad and confused that she doesn’t see him as much anymore. She has asked me for a sibling and “What is my dad’s name?” and I am just at a loss.

    Your message helped me realize that I can tell her she is loved by many people. I, too, moved back to my home state after her father and I broke up so that we could be close to my mother and my friends and their children. I think that angle is a good one.

    I just don’t like to think that she will know this occasional visitor is her father and not have a true relationship with him. I know I need to move-on from my recent past relationship, as well. All very hard. Thank you for the inspiration.
    Jenni´s last blog ..Move along. Move along. Nothing to see here.My ComLuv Profile

  21. Nichelle says:

    @VA mom…. Thank you so much! Your experience & advice hit it right on the head! I am a single mom to an 11mo old boy and he is the product of a one night stand with a guy I had just met. I have been able to stay in contact with the father and check in on him from time to time but he is adamant that he doesn’t want a relationship with my son. That’s fine. I know my son will still have a fulfilling loving home and family and will live a full life. I too have wondered what I will say to him when he’s of an age to ask questions and your response really put it onto perspective. I’m hopeful that one day the father will come around but even if he doesn’t, i won’t project that hope on to my son and give him false hope.

  22. Erika says:

    Twitter @
    A good friend of mine is in this situation, so I’ve thought about it a lot. I think there are a lot of great suggestions here. I know for me, I was a single mom just before my daughter’s first birthday. I thought I would be single for a long time, but met my husband when she was almost 3. She has 2 daddies in her life, both of them very involved. My only thought was you never know, perhaps you will meet someone special who will become your daughter’s daddy – before she really has any knowledge about not having had one. For my daughter, she only remembers having 2 daddies. I think it’s important to think about how to handle it, but I am just offering another possible scenario. If you do end up with someone in the next few years, you can always have that conversation when your daughter is much older.

    Truth is vitally important – children are very sensitive beings, and they will sniff out untruths on a subconscious level before they can rationalize it consciously. they will just feel something is ‘off.’ There should be a way that you can be authentic, and truthful, in a way that is loving and age appropriate. You could say “some children have only mommies, some have only daddies, and some have both.” No need to explain the reasons when she’s so young. I personally know of 4 single moms who have chosen have babies using artificial insemination, so they have a similar situation as well.

    Good luck, follow your heart….and you will do the right thing.

  23. Charismaga says:

    I was actually conceived via a one night stand. There are many great comments with good advice here. When I was old enough to realize that many other kids had dads, I started asking questions about my own father. My family always told me the same, honest thing – that they had met him shortly before I was conceived and that unfortunately they don’t have much info about him. But they always stressed that I was so loved and that they were so happy that I was born.

    When I was old enough to wonder why this guy didn’t want to be a part of my life they told me the truth – it was a very casual relationship and he couldn’t even be told I was conceived as they didn’t know how to find him. This was very helpful to me so I knew that I wasn’t abandoned by this guy, but that they honestly could not find him. This made a big difference to me.

    I also agree with the comments that a person cannot miss what they didn’t have. I have seen other friends have bad fathers come in and out of their lives. So I am grateful that I haven’t had to deal with toxic situations like others have had to deal with. I also don’t know what it would be like to have a dad in positive ways – someone to walk me down the aisle or go to my dance recitals. I have no clue what a father/daughter relationship is like, so I really don’t miss it as I never had it. Sometimes when growing up, not very often though, I would see fathers and daughters and feel a little pang of “what would that have been like” but I didn’t think about it that often to be honest.

    When I was in my early 20s, I considered trying to find my bio dad, as my family did know what his name was. But the few details they did know about him lead me to believe he wasn’t the greatest person and that it just wouldn’t be worth it.

    I really think honesty is the key. Your child won’t judge you – I didn’t. I am sure that you will always let your child know how much she is loved and if you are also honest with her so she knows that you aren’t withholding info but just don’t have much – that is what matters most :)

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled