Are you dating a “separated” guy?

3032863483_afff44d894_mWe’ve written before about dating someone who’s not yet divorced. Both of us know the perils of falling for a guy who is still attached to his ex.

Have you ever been on a great date with someone and heard that dreaded phrase? “I’m separated.” We understand this let down.

We also know this can be very confusing. After all, many of you have told us that you’re dating right now — before your divorce has been finalized.

So, how do you make sense of this? As a single parent, you’ve got your own priorities and issues. Hearing that someone is “separated” might mean lots of drama and complications you don’t need.

Here’s some advice to help you decide what’s right for you.

“Separated” does not always mean the same thing.

Married guys on the prowl often say “separated.”

On the other hand, “separated” can also mean that the legal wrangling continue, but the love and attachment are long past. Or the legal wranglings drag on because the passion has never died.

Some men will say “separated” just to try it out as they contemplate whether or not to split.

“Separated” can also describe some “situation” post huge blow-up that’s not going to be fixed with make-up sex, but might resolve with lots of counseling — or time to cool off.

Separated always means in limbo. There is unfinished business — whether it’s  emotional, legal, or financial.

So, first thing: find out what “separated” means in your case. Of course, you know what’s best when it comes to making a decision.

What do you really want? Fun with a boy toy? Great sex with no attachment?

Or, are you looking for love and a possible life partner?

So, we’d love to hear from you:

Can a future be forged with a guy who’s separated when you meet?

Or is dating a “separated” guy just a short-cut to heartbreak?

No one should make the “rules” in your life except you.

Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

No related posts.

Comments

105 Responses to “Are you dating a “separated” guy?”
  1. ylhoff says:

    If a woman is intimate with a man who is separated but not divorced, it doesn’t change the fact that he is still very married. Have single moms somehow been relieved of the obligation to live within a healthy relationship for their kids sake? If your daughter was in this situation would you advise her to hang in there while she got screwed over? Or would you want to injure the man who was causing your daughter the pain I’m reading in these posts? Do you love and give yourself the best much the way you give to your daughter? How would she know, watching you, that she deserved the best in a relationship? And yes, I have made this mistake.

  2. a betrayed wife says:

    My husband and I separated after he resumed contacting an old “friends with privileges” woman. After many months of going back and forth emotionally, we reconciled after the traumatic death of an old friend of mine. I was horrified to find out my husband had been catting around town the entire time of our separation, and further distressed that one of the women somehow felt she “owned” him in some way…even though he was married,had a family, child, wife and she knew it. What she did *not* know is that he was completely dishonest with her about why we separated in the first place, and that he was even cheating, with multiple women on her! She stalked us for a year, sent nasty things in the mail, etc. My husband had to get a restraining order on her. My husband has been diagnosed, from his therapist, with a personality disorder and a sex addiction. My life has been very painful and hard because of his disorders and I’m not sure our relationship will make it. Even so, the hurt I felt from realizing how many women are out there that DO NOT respect the boundaries of another woman’s marriage has been almost as heart-breaking as my husband’s actions. What a selfish society we have become.

  3. Dr. Leah says:

    a betrayed wife: Our hearts really go out to you. You’ve really been through hell. Your husband has some major mental health issues (according to his therapist), but you raise an excellent point. Disrespecting the boundaries of other people’s relationships can only cause heartache —to all involved. Please do stay in touch with us. You’re always welcome @Singlemommyhood.

  4. Meghan says:

    My parents were separated for 5 years before they finally divorced because neither one wanted to pay the fee for a summons or pay for a lawyer. They both dated. They both had money and they did finally divorce.

    I think these days especially with the financial reasons people are holding off on the process of divorce despite the marriage being over.

    Clearly- abetrayedwife- your situation is different that you reconciled but most things are different case by case- and this isn’t always the case. It is unfair to generalize towards single moms because of the bad one you dealt with, plus these situations can go both ways.

    I met my fiance when he was separated and we have been together for 6 years. He separated from his wife after trying to make things work and then found out she was pregnant. He is a nice guy and wanted to support her during her pregnancy but there relationship had been over since they had their 1st child 2 years earlier but it had dragged out while they were trying to fix it.

    He supported her through the whole pregnancy and still continues to be a great dad and although our relationship developed soon after the baby was born and at first his ex wasn’t too thrilled- their divorce went through and we actually get along.

    Every situation is different and sometimes the relationship is over for one person but not the other. Not all relationships end and you can place blame on someone.And sometimes the person actually still cares and doesn’t want to hurt someone who meant something to them or is a parent to their kids and so it a slow process and often messy.

    There is no one size fits all in any scenario. The women your husband was with shouldn’t have behaved that way. That’s a great a example of people not knowing when to let go– but that can go both ways.

    It is good to try and look at the big picture. Clearly you have it tough and your husband’s problems I am sure are very difficult and painful. I don’t want to sound insensitive but blame also lies with him and I am sure you know that. The boundaries of a relationship are decided by the two people in it and when someone doesn’t want to be in a relationship then that is a personal boundary that should be respected- by everyone. When he broke it off she should have respected it.
    Sorry for rambling I guess my point is you can’t generalize. Every situation is different.

  5. Soon2b says:

    Twitter @
    Wow, a betrayed wife is in a really tough situation. My heart goes out to her and hope that everything works out the way that she would like it to.

    Answering the original questions posed, this is a tricky situation. As mentioned, people have different definitions of “separated”. I’m separated but for me, that just means the marriage isn’t legally over. We have been having problems for a few years, have been physically separated for 6 months, will be filing all of the necessary papers this week and be divorced in less than a month. However, other people might say they are “separated” and hiding the fact a reconciliation could be in the works.

    If someone is separated by my personal definition, I think it is okay to find someone to have fun with. I know that I wouldn’t have the time and effort to put into a relationship right now (especially because I am trying to find myself again and take care of the number one man in my life, a 4 year old ;) ) but miss all the fun stuff that goes along with. As long as both parties protect their hearts, everything will be fine. Now if only I could follow my own advice…
    Soon2b´s last blog ..Look on the Bright Side My ComLuv Profile

  6. Dr. Leah says:

    Meghan: We agree that there is certainly NOT a “one size fits all” scenario in this kind of situation. Thanks for joining the conversation.

    Soon2B: As long as “both parties protect their hearts” …definitely, but often so much easier said than done. Thanks for sharing your personal perspective and life story with us.

  7. Soon2b says:

    Twitter @
    Dr. Leah: Oh yes, it’s *definitely* easier said than done. ;) I’ve unfortunately learned this… but I remind myself that what the heart wants at a specific time is not necessarily what the heart needs right then and there.
    Soon2b´s last blog ..Look on the Bright Side My ComLuv Profile

  8. Jenni says:

    Twitter @
    The Betrayed Wife, I think your situation is something that is of a whole different scenario. There are different levels are separation.

    With you it sounds like you felt there was a possibility of reconciliation.. which obviously happened. And for a lot of people, that is how a separation starts. You get away from each other for a bit, to take a break and see if you miss the other person or not. It also gives you time to think over your relationship, and whether it’s fixable or not.

    The other level of separation is when the relationship is OVER, and you’re just not divorced. A lot of people hold out to get divorced, simply because of cost. My ex was separated from his first ex-wife for 4 years before they finally got divorced – and they only did it because I was pregnant. I have a friend now that’s been separated for 3 years and counting. I’ve been separated for over a year now. It comes to a point where “separated” is just a relationship status, but in your mind your divorced, and your ex owes you nothing as far as dating other people, living with another person, etc.

    And honestly, after reading what you wrote, you can’t blame the other women for sleeping with and dating your husband. The only one who crossed any boundaries was the stalker, when you two got back together. The rest was your husband’s choice. I know it’s easy to point fingers at everyone else, except for the person you love. But you have to make everyone involved own up to their responsibility, and your husband was the #1 player in this game.

    I’m sorry now that you’re dealing with such hardships with his mental health, and that in time a clear decision for you to make will be put in front of you.
    Jenni´s last blog ..We Interrupt This Program- My ComLuv Profile

  9. Twitter @
    It always amazes me when I see women choosing so easily and without remorse to hurt other women, and in doing so to hurt themselves, possibly their kids -by their example and emotional state, – and the general image/power of women.

    Women are incredibly powerful when we find our internal strength. When we know we do not have to compete with other women, cut them down or exert ourselves to show that we are the “chosen” one (usually among men). In my experience, a woman must first chose herself. She must honor the light, talents, femininity, and strength within herself, and she will show this by respecting other women too. One who has found her internal strength has no interest in tangling with a man that is still tangled with other women. She who knows her own gifts won’t compete with another woman for the attention of a man. The mother who holds her own light as a treasure will teach her children the same and will not be controlled by the trappings of sex, romance or attention of a man who can’t respect her in the same way.

    Don’t go “out there” to be chosen by a man before you go inside and choose to honor yourself.

  10. Dr. Leah says:

    Soon2b: Well said! Thanks again.

  11. Dr. Leah says:

    Twiiter@OneLesson: Your comment is incredibly powerful —particularly the last line. Learning to honor ourselves has been a hard won victory for so many of us. Thank you for joining this conversation and for contributing so much.

  12. Twitter @
    I’m with Jenni…..levels of separation vary from couple to couple. I was separated for over a year with absolutely no intentions of every getting back together with the asshat. Clearly, a betrayed wife is thinking getting back together is an option and that’s her choice. However, to question what our society has become because your hubby found a hole to stick his winky in seems a bit much. I mean, come on, if your husband doesn’t respect you enough to keep his winky in his pants is society’s fault? The other woman doesn’t owe you anything, your HUSBAND does. If she wants to be a whore then thats on her. I think we pass the blame a bit too much in society. The hubby sounds like he’s got it made in the shade.
    singlemama_cc´s last blog ..I better get a will My ComLuv Profile

  13. Ewokmama says:

    Twitter @
    I was separated from my ex when I met my now-husband. I wasn’t even looking for a relationship – it just happened that I met the right person. There was no way I was getting back with my ex in any case. So yes, separation can mean exactly that!

    I actually had a guy ask me “so, you’re separated. where does that leave you?” I didn’t know how to respond – but I let him know that I had split with my ex and was pursuing divorce, that it was just a matter of paperwork. I never heard back from him, though. Which is fine with me!

  14. Thordora says:

    Twitter @
    I’m almost a yr separated and I will be filing as soon as finances allow. Anyone can break your heart-I have not considered myself married for months since he left. And now, I’ve found a man, out of nowhere it seems, and am moving on. We don’t all carry torches, especially if we find someone who is so right for us.

    My marriage was always the mistake. Separation is just a pause before restarting, for me anyway.
    Thordora´s last blog ..“Be brave Even if you’re not- pretend to be No one can tell the difference” My ComLuv Profile

  15. Sue says:

    Twitter @
    I just broke up with my manfriend after a 2 year relationship. We’re both in our early 60′s. Amoung other things about him, he also was separated but not divorced after 12 years. He promised me that he would get divorced, and we even talked about marriage, but he never even looked into getting an attorney like he promised. His children and other family members have also encouraged him over the years to divorce his wife, but he would refuse to discuss the matter or tell them why he wouldn’t do it. He would just refuse to talk about it. I told him several times that I didn’t like the fact that he was still married and he would always promise to clear up this part of his life. I finally broke it off with him, partly because of this. I found that his totally inert behavior about divorcing his wife, and many other matters concerning his life, was maddening and I lost all love for him. I think if he had no intention of divorcing, couldn’t afford to do so, or whatever his excuse was, he should have just told me at the get go that he had no plans on changing his marital status. I think for the most part, it’s not wise to be in a relationship with anyone who’s separated. If they’re at least upfront at the beginning of the relationship and levels with you about not divorcing, you can then make the choice to stay in the relationship regardless or leave it. I believed that my x would follow through with what he promised me through the 2 years, but he didn’t and never will. So, I think one has to tread very carefully when contemplating a relationship with someone who’s not divorced. It’s not a good road to go down.

  16. Rachel Sarah says:

    Sue: Thanks for opening up here and we truly hope you’re surrounded by support and love during this time.

  17. Sarah says:

    I also feel it’s very much on a case by case basis. The most ideal situation is to wait until the marriage is legally dissolved. Divorce final. But practically, it’s hard. Especially (as in my case) when one of the partners was DONE emotionally long before the divorce was filed and especially if the divorce drags on. I’ve been dating a separated man for three years and the end is finally in sight. Just waiting for signatures on the final divorce decree! In my case, things were not good for a couple years, then wife physically left for a year, came back and thought all would be normal, then he left the home, then divorce was filed and divorce has dragged on for two years already. We took many breaks at the beginning but I couldn’t get myself to break off completely. We’ve been living together for the past year now. He has 3 kids, I have one.

    I will say I have also dated divorced men who STILL had a lot of baggage left over who really weren’t ready to be in a serious relationship so that is not guarantee. My significant other on the other hand has not wavered (not that I could tell anyway) and has always been there for me from Day 1. However, the relationship was very much full of turmoil and drama especially the first year as he still needed to disentangle himself from his past life. It has gotten better but the Ex wife will always see him as the bad guy for having a relationship while separated and we will always have to deal with her bitter, twisted ways. But she may have been like that had they been divorced. You just never know.

    So I’m not saying never do it, but be very aware it is a much higher risk than an average relationship. But you take different kinds of risks of getting hurt in all relationships – you just have to decide if you’re willing to take on a higher risk relationship with a separated person.

    Would I do it again? I can’t say I regret staying with my man. I love him dearly. But if things were to not work out with him in the long run, I would be VERY skeptical and highly unlikely to go through that again with someone else. I have never felt such emotional highs and lows and don’t ever want to go through that again and had we not progressed, I would have broken things off.

    My other thought is: if you are the separated partner please be honest of where you are at and what your intentions are. Some people may choose to not date you, but there are others that will. There are even some women who are in the same boat as you and may even be OK with just a physical relationship. If you don’t feel ready or are scared of getting out there and lie about your circumstances but something blossoms anyway you could jeopardize a good thing. It’s always better to be straight forward and honest.

  18. Dr. Leah says:

    Sarah: Thanks for taking the time to share your perspective on this always touchy topic.

  19. In Love and being taken advantage of? says:

    I have been physically separated for 17 months. However, I was emotionally separated for at least a year if not more prior to that. Mine was an arranged marriage at a very young age. While I loved him as a human being and was the quintessential wife who did everything asked or wished of her…I could never bring myself to say I was “in” love with him. So I was honest. We married when I was 18.

    I separated from him once prior when my son was about 9 yrs old (briefly for about 6 months), but since I left to reside in a month to month lease apartment, and my son opted to stay with him…I visited often. Soon thereafter we were back together again.

    I stayed fully committed till my son graduated from high school. My husband was VERY controlling and did not like me to have friends/attend college/particpate in activities without him. But once my son graduated when he was 17 yrs old from high school…I found a new EMPOWERED me. By the time my son was 19, he had a great start to life and a wonderful government job. I assumed things would be alright and began distancing myself from my spouse till finally we were separated but living under one roof.

    I got a new job and met a co-worker who himself was in a marriage in which he was conflicted and saddened (or at least told me he was). We began dating. By now, my son was grown and doing his thing. My co-worker’s children were ages 2 and 5. We quickly fell in love. After dating for nearly a year his wife suspected he was involved. She guessed. He admitted.

    I moved out of my house at my son and husband’s urging and found a place that could accommodate my boyfriend and his 2 children. We have now been living together for over a year. The kids come over regularly. He is separated but to date no paperwork has been filed. I am divorcing. He makes more than 2x’s what I make annually. But since most of his money goes to support his wife who makes nearly the same as he, pay substantial private school tuitions for his kids, and condo fees and bills for a vacation unit they jointly own, but only she used last year (though they recently put it on the market), I wind up paying most of the bills to support us. I could live EXTREMELY well on my own with my salary with cash to spare. But instead, I opted to acquire a 3bdrm unit with extra utilities and cable to insure his kids could be easily accommodated.

    Tomorrow I will begin working a part time job to help support us and pay off credit cards we’ve had to tap into, in conjunction with my full time job. Neither he nor she has filed for divorce, though they have developed a divorce agreement between the two of them. I have voiced my concern about this. She lives extremely well. I live like a Pauper.

    I can’t tell you whether or not it’s okay to date a “separated man”. But I can tell you that I am one of the most completely unhappy women ever. I still love him and he says he loves me. But everyday I get a little closer to doubting that.

  20. Rachel Sarah says:

    @In Love: We are very taken by your story. You are clearly a strong, smart woman. Please let us know how you’re doing. We’d like to hear from you again.

  21. Amy says:

    I’ve just had a bad experience with this situation. I am a single mum & finally decided it was time to try & meet someone. I met a lovely man online, we had a whirlwind romance, I was over the moon! We both agreed that we thought this was it, the one. So he told his ex-wife who he has a 5yr old too about me. That it was serious etc. He said he told her out of respect, we live in a country town & he said he didn’t want it getting back to her before he had told her himself. Plus we were talking of introducing our girls to each other.

    Well it’s all over now & I’m shattered. His ex-wife turned up crying the day after he told her & begged him to give their marriage another go. I assumed they were divorced when he called her his ex wife but they were only legally & financially separated. They’d been apart for 2yrs after he had left her when he discovered she was having an affair for a year.

    I understand he feels an obligation to his child but really! She hadn’t asked him back once in 2yrs, as soon as he says he’s serious about me, the water works start & she says they owe it to their child to try. Makes me so mad!!

    I really fell hard for this man but I know that’s selfish. There is a child involved & if he really can forgive her then I guess he should :(
    But I will definitely be asking next time, divorced or separated! Not worth the heart ache.

  22. Dr. Leah says:

    Amy: SO very sorry to hear of your heart break. Thank you for sharing your story with us. We hope you’ve got supportive family and friends around you at this time. Stay in touch with us, please.

  23. Grace says:

    Twitter @
    My ex husband “officially” began dating a woman as soon as he moved out. When I would confront him that he was cheating on me, he would tell me he wasn’t because we were separated. In my book, dating while being separated doesn’t change the fact that “separated” does not mean “divorced”. There is still the reality that a relationship could be reconciled while being separated. His cheating all but destroyed me, as he was still trying to manipulate me into believing that we might resolve our issues and return to our normal married life. It also destroys the kids if they are introduced to the other person before the divorce is final. Kids, often, hope that their parents might get back together, and when you introduce another partner, it can destroy them as well.

  24. 1001 Nights says:

    When I met Paul, he’d been separated for 2 years, lived in his own wonderful apartment.

    I am an artist, and he’d just come to my show and bought art from me. The art “transformed”
    his home, he’d say. Initially, I wasn’t attracted to Paul – a successful lawyer, who loved my art! With my art agent, we’d visited his home to hang the paintings. He had two small kids – 5 and 7 and seemed like an adoring Dad. I wanted to help him. He seemed so sad. So, I asked him if he’d consider dating a friend of mine. He stepped in at that point and expressed his strong feelings for me, but told me he’d consider my friend, if I insisted. I still didn’t fancy him – until one day, the art gallery were being mean to me and he stood up for me, in a way that no man had done before! I let him know I was starting to have feelings for him. He was overjoyed! I also immediately let him know that I had never expected to develop feelings for a a legally married man.)

    It was Christmas time and I was going to be gone for 10 days or so. We maintained a very beautiful online connection. 5 days or so into it, I let him know that I was loving it, but had had a deep feeling that I wasn’t going to be able to sex with him while he was still separated. It was a personal choice. It jolted him, and then he was back. Very, very romantic – imagining my dreams (he’d be up when I was asleep, due to time difference.)

    Super romantic guy.

    When I returned from my trip – it was clear he wasn’t asking me out. He asked me if we could continue the way we had been, as “no sex” is actually good for him. I had fallen in love with him at this point, and didn’t want to rock the boat. He was enjoying bonding in a very new way – and I didn’t want to break that concept. 3-4 very intense weeks went by. I don’t believe in “leading” in a relationship, but I finally made a suggestion. We’d become such loving friends, loving friends also could have brunch together. But Paul was clearly not comfortable. He wouldn’t stop being in touch – and if I’d bring it down a notch, he’d speed it up. We did this for a few months, it was really really hard. I would regularly not cope – and he was very patient and not willing to let things go.

    His wife had cheated on him. And I felt like the girl in 1001 Nights – she had to pacify a King who’d been cuckolded. He would kill you if you slept with him – but she would tell these stories, and always leave a little untold for him to want more. She saved herself for 1001 Nights with these tales, and by the end, had pacified an angry King into a gentle ruler who made her his queen. As much as I love fairy tales – every 30-40 nights, I’d fall apart.

    We took a few short breaks, but neither of us could stand it.

    But eventually, and I’m not going to bore you with details – we just fell apart. He was going through his divorce (hadn’t told me because of our ups and downs.)

    I feel that had we seen each other from the beginning, dated with limited physical intimacy –
    I would have fallen apart less and we could have coped better. I feel angry with myself for accepting his terms – out of fear of losing him. Because e-mail only, would make me fall apart after a few weeks at a time. As a woman, I used to feel that a verbal-only communication was making me get more attached, while zero physical contact – not even for a simple brunch – had him fully protected (with men being more visual, physical.)
    How silly was I not to understand that?

    Do you think Paul asking for us to stay in an online
    connection (which was very romantic) – when I mentioned not wanting to sleep with him, too harsh a reaction on his part? He’d openly let me know that I was his “light” – I got him out of a very dark place. We cared for each other deeply, and he has 3 of my paintings hanging in his bedroom. But him not wanting to see me at all just broke me. I care for him deeply and we’ve been out of touch in a kind romantic way, for over a month now. He just got divorced (I found out through mutual contacts) – and I’d like to give him some space, anyway.

  25. Dr. Leah says:

    1001 nights: Thanks for sharing your painful story with us. It sounds like Paul did exactly what was good for him without much thought to what the emotional fall-out might be for you. Online connections can seem very intense and real. We understand. We hope you stay in touch with us.

  26. 1001 Nights says:

    Paul also let me know after 3 weeks, that he was a victim of child abuse (by his father.)
    I wasn’t just going through connecting with a separated man, but one who’d been sexually abused by his dad. His completely aversion to me taking sex off the table suddenly made sense. People with his background, often have only seen affection via sex only.
    Paul is a wondeful Dad, so, I’ve seen him be a person who isn’t into himself alone. But with adults, he has a problem and looks after himself first. Although I understand it, and how it’s related to his background, putting up with it was too hard. He went NUTS when I finally withdrew from him. I think he’s never experienced actually loving another adult (as no adult ever loved him.) But, I DID help him get over the hump of his separation and he did get divorced! I loved him as a human being, and in my heart, happy that he got over his dviorce. He was in bad shape when we met. And I didn’t sleep with him, and protected myself. My heart has been injured and needs to heal. But Frank had no one in this whole world. (Aside from a dead abusive father, and a mom he’s not close too.) Helping an adoring father heal, is not the worst thing in the world. Healing the rest of him, might be a harder task – and I’m glad to be taking a breather. But I wanted to share with your readers – that we can’t be judgemental about “separated” people. In real life, the only thing that makes me get over a deep boyfriend, is a new boyfriend. So, why should it be different for “separated” people? I made sure it was done with protection. I would have preferred if we hung out too, but helping a massively shattered person is always honorable. Surely. I’ll let you know how it proceeds and thanks for this forum. (even though I’m not a mommy!)

  27. 1001 Nights says:

    ooops – by “Frank”, I mean “Paul” in my last comment. I did want to commend you on your site – and point to the fact that there are far too few books on the subject matter (dating separated people.) This is a very real fact of life for a huge chunk of society – all going into it rather blindly, with so little precedent. I found one book – but nothing that was deep and emotionally mature. Perhaps you can compie a book, Dr. Leah – as there’s very little help that is deep – rather than the knee-jerk: “don’t do it!”

  28. Angela Copley says:

    I am with a guy who is still married having been separated for 13 yrs. His wife has MS. He states he was only trying to be nice and keep her on the insurance. That’s why he stayed married to her for so long. But he also tells me that his wife abuses prescription drugs. And that she cheated on him numerous times. Right now, she is living with another man. And he is living in his own apartment.

    I want to spend the rest of my life with this man. I don’t think it’s his responsibility to care for his wife—insurance or otherwise —if she’s living with another man. He’s made NO move to divorce her. Am I wasting my time staying with this guy? Please help.

  29. WhitewaterAtty says:

    Twitter @
    Angela,

    Obviously in changing a family situation through divorce, health insurance and other once-grouped items need to be considered. It’s totally understandable to put off the final stages of divorce for a short while out of consideration of one’s ex-spouse/co-parent… However, at some point it becomes too much and can become a dependency (on the former spouse) situation.

    While I don’t know your guy’s full situation, Thirteen Years seems like an inordinate amount of time for anyone’s transition. Kindness is a wonderful trait to have, but your situation appears to have gone beyond kindness. Keeping his wife as his wife at this point may be hurting her and not helping her get her life back together. You need to talk with him about this… and unfortunately, as tough as it sounds, you need to consider how he addresses this issue and your feelings — to determine, as you say, whether you are “wasting [your] time staying with [him]“.

  30. 1toughcall says:

    So I’ve met an incredible guy, but he’s “separated” and my better judgement tells me to run for the hills but my heart doesn’t want to. The connection was instant, and is amazing. We have so much in common, from our kids (who are the same age) to our own childhood. I’ve never felt so immediately close to someone.. Like, this is a guy I could see myself marrying. But then reality sets in- he already is married, just not to me.

    My friends are telling me to call it off and logically, I agree. I even wrote him explaining how I felt and that I couldn’t see him anymore. He’s not giving up that easy, though. He responded asking me not to give up on this once in a lifetime connection because of fear. He says I have nothing to worry about – that there is no possiblity of a reconciliation and that she has a boyfriend now and he even told her about me. He says he’s in love with me (and that doesn’t make this any easier).

    Now I’m left in limbo.. I don’t know if I can move forward even dating this guy knowing that I’ll be so terrified. But he isn’t just any guy. I’m crazy about him. And if I call it off, I think I’ll regret it. Technically, he is separated, getting a divorce and she’s dating other people. What would you do?

  31. jessi says:

    Twitter @
    Sometimes, you’ve just gotta trust. Sometimes, you’ve just gotta take a risk and be willing to open yourself up to possible hurt. If he’s an amazing guy, and he’s separated but the divorce proceedings are taking longer than expected – why run for the hills?

    Life is about having no regrets and living to the fullest, trust more, laugh more, and love easier :)
    jessi´s last blog ..Pregnancy Update- 12 WeeksMy ComLuv Profile

  32. Caroline says:

    Twitter @
    There is no future in a married man, even if he is separeted, but do what you think is best for you. Just make sure he gets those divorce papers soon, because it sounds like he is in love with you.

  33. jessi says:

    Twitter @
    (Comment was directed at situations like 1touchcalls)
    jessi´s last blog ..Pregnancy Update- 12 WeeksMy ComLuv Profile

  34. Roxanne says:

    Twitter @
    @1toughcall. I think you have to follow your gut. It sounds like your gut is telling you to take it very slow or call it off. Your heart might be saying something else. But given that his wife is dating and knows about you and he’s getting divorced yet you are still concerned? Well, your gut just isn’t entirely comfortable. You deserve to be comfortable. My own divorce took a long time. I dated a guy once before it was final who was really torn about it. He even talked to a Episcopal priest. (Which I thought was crazy. He turned out to be a nut.) I respect that people are bothered by it. But often the marriage is over a long long time before the divorce is final. The wheels of justice turn slowly. However, if I’m ever in that situation where I’m dating someone separated I would want to know whether divorce papers have been filed and served. If not, that would be huge red flag for me.

  35. Amanda says:

    Twitter @
    I’d wait until the divorce is finalized.

  36. Dr. Leah says:

    Amanda: Thanks for chiming in. Welcome! Please visit us again soon.

  37. Julia says:

    Twitter @
    I do not agree with this at all. I am in the middle of a separation from my husband it has only been 3 months and he has a girlfriend and is exposing our children to her I have no idea who she is. Doesn’t say much for either one of them if you ask me.

  38. Dr. Leah says:

    Julia: Thanks for taking the time to remind us all that there are always different perspectives. We wish you well.

  39. wiser says:

    1toughcall: I hope you will listen to your gut. I had the exact same experience as you. I was also separated when I met Mr. Perfect, separated only 9 months. We connected instantly, had similar backgrounds, kids the same age, similar personalities, goals, and great chemistry. I had never felt such a connection with anyone before. We went slow and dated other people but continued to get closer, and I REALLY liked him. Our lives began to connect in other ways: the kids met, we had professional connections. He made all kinds of “future” references about us….then things cooled. He said I “scared” him; he wasn’t ready to fall in love; he couldn’t give me what I needed, etc.

    I have now been divorced for over a year…and he hasn’t filed yet. There is always some reason. We have both been dating other people for the past year, but have maintained contact the whole time. He recently told me he has feelings for someone else. I really cared for this man, and SO thought we had a future together. His work life and divorce process are insane, and, if I met him today I wouldn’t touch him with a 10-foot pole. He is SO not ready for anything with anyone! After going through this painful process, I know that I want a guy that is ready to put both feet in and let a real relationship unfold. Not waiting around and will not be someone’s rebound, transition or therapist! If it is meant to be, your guy will come back to you when he is clear and done.

    And so will mine.

  40. Barb says:

    I was just left heartbroken after being in a serious relationship with a newly divorced man. He was separated 3 years when we started dating….were fixed up mutual friends & other friends had tried to fix us up previously. I have known him for years so we were not strangers. He was in a loveless marriage but I had a two year rule….wouldn’t date someone unless their divorce was final 2 years due to being burned before and all the emotional ” stuff” that needs to be dealt with.

    I broke that rule….and am now very much reminded why I have this rule. We talked about our future together, he actually talked about it more than I did. But eventually I got the dreaded text….he needed time & couldn’t date right now…had to get his kids comfortable with the divorce before getting more serious. OK….but found out he’s dating again….he’ll end up breaking another heart, but I won’t let myself fall into the love trap again….for a long time.
    Barb´s last blog ..Thoughts Bouncing Around in My HeadMy ComLuv Profile

  41. ThisSucks says:

    I’m dating a man who is separated. The state he got married in has optional marriage contract called a covenant marriage, which ties the legality of the marriage in with the catholic church. They are under a covenant marriage. I looked it up on a .gov website to make sure what he was telling me was legit, turns out that it is. Well, the beauty of this little contract is that they are bound by the church to do everything within their power to reconcile the marriage before they file for divorce, this means he can either admit to adultery and be done with it or go through counseling that has “failed” and be able to file for divorce that way. He won’t admit to adultery on account of being with me, because he doesn’t want to paint me in a bad light. He says that if after counseling he can’t be granted a divorce, he will claim adultery but will never say it was with me. He wants his family to actually LIKE me one day. Here’s the thing:

    This man is my high school sweetheart. We broke up at the end of high school and he was devastated. I just wanted to explore the world. Years passed, he got married, I realized that I lost the best thing I ever had in him and was pretty upset about it, but also figured there was no chance with him again because he got married and figured I would have to settle for a relationship with someone else. Here we are now, almost 5 years later… I ran into him again while he was going through a failing marriage that is now a separation and is going to take a long difficult process for him to get out of. They don’t live together, he doesn’t support her, and she wants to work it out but he has made it clear to her that he wants divorce and is taking steps to get one. He has told some of his family and friends about me, but not the ones that might reveal to the ex-wife that he is with me.

    He has told me he loves me and that he knew we were soulmates from when we dated in high school. He would give up the shirt off of his back for me and has always been this way towards me, he’s in school and working a lot and gives me all of his spare time. Treats me like a queen. I realize that every situation is different, but what if you think that this person is the love of your life and just made a mistake that they are now going to take some time to get out of? Someone please tell me I am not a stupid woman, I see so much disdain for women who are dating separated men out there.

  42. Dr. Leah says:

    ThisSucks: No judgments here! Frankly, we never heard of a covenant state. It’s a tough situation for both of you. Thanks for sharing your story with us. Please visit again soon.

  43. Nyota Vargas says:

    Twitter @
    I am separated and have been since 2009. I define myself as being divorced. There is no hope or a second thought as to my husband and I getting back together. He has moved on, and I haven’t yet, because I want to get myself together as opposed to just diving in.So for some people its a matter of semantics but for me its not.

  44. Lilystar says:

    This is my story its a bit long but I hope it is a warning for others:

    So I met someone some time ago, we were just friends, we were both married and having problems in our marriages and on the verge of leaving our marriages (my problems were my husband was an alcoholic, his was that his wife was cheating, of which he had indisputable evidence)

    Anyway, we leaned on each other for support and I had moved out of my marital home. He said he was moving out also, i said (stupidly and far too quickly) he could stay with me for a bit, and my 3 year old daughter (i know i know) til he got something figured out. That was 10 months ago. Anyway we fell deeply in love and I really felt like he was the best thing that ever happened to me. We had a lot going against us….we had to live in secret because we didnt want either of our spouses to know until both our divorces were final, his wife was relentless sometimes in pursuing him, begging him to come back to her, there was some seriously questionable things she did that made me think she could be a narcissist which he thought also. he filed for divorce

    Also during this time, my husband developed cirrossis and nearly died. so we have dealt with a lot but as he said ‘baby we will get thru everything’

    But he was weak when it came to her, he let her manipulate him so much, she would call and he would let her stay on the phone crying for ages and honestly it would drive me mad. I suppose you would say he is quite submissive and whilst I tried to bring that out of him and make him more confident, she exploited that part of him and she definitely emasculated him.

    He realized this and said he was never going back to her, he was so glad he met me, he was never as happy as this etc etc.
    I told him several times that maybe he should go back and make it work, that plenty of people forgive their spouses and move forward. He said no way, that even if i told him to leave, he was never going back to her as he realized he was somewhat emotionally abused by her and she almost certainly was a narcissist (no wife bashing here, just facts)
    So i go to my hometown to visit family and while I am there 3 days before i am due home, he says she turned up at his work, with messages from me on Facebook (she hacked into his account??) and 3 copies of lie detector tests saying she didn’t cheat. and i said so are you going back to her? and he sad yes i think i am. It was DAYS before there divorce was final.

    I was knocked for six! totally devastated. I get home and all his things are gone, he has moved in with her, they live in the same neighborhood as me too. hes just gone, like he never existed!

    He wouldn’t even come to my apartment to give me my keys back because ‘she wouldn’t let him’ he came to my friends house to drop them off and she was with him! ugh! spineless coward he is!

    I am so hurt and angry, he couldn’t say goodbye to me properly or say goodbye to my daughter who adored him and who he claimed to love (i feel incredibly guilty about that now)

    All he can say is he is very sorry and just feels like he had to give his marriage another shot and a fair chance that he feels he owes it to her and himself.
    I said how could you have such a change of heart in a matter of HOURS!!! I mean we were talking about having a baby! (they do not have kids BTW – which makes this even more weirder)

    But he cannot offer me any explanation. said he never lied to me, he wasn’t even thinking about going back to her, something just triggered in him. god knows what she said to him, she already threatened suicide a number of times….

    And I am just paralyzed with grief and heart ache and just cant believe he did this to me. And I am so sad at the loss of him, or the person i thought he was anyway.

    And I understand that he wanted to give it another chance with her (although I did not see that coming at all!), many people do.
    But its the way he did it and the way he treated me afterwards that is so heartbreaking. Its only been 5 weeks week since he dropped this bombshell so it is still raw but i feel like i will never ever get over it

    And now he is so cold, I just don’t understand how he cud have done such a 180. I feel a fool, and so hurt. If I thought for a second he would give his marriage another go, I would not have gone near him. he said that cheating was an absolute deal breaker for him and her denial of it made it worse.

    I just don’t understand how he could have left something so wonderful to go back to something so miserable like a horse galloping back to a burning barn! I suppose the hold she still had over him should have been a gigantic red flag.

    Thank you so much for reading this.

  45. Dr. Leah says:

    Lilystar: We’re sorry this happened to you. Her (repeated) suicide threats may have been more than he could withstand. We hope you have close family and friends nearby to support you at this horrible time. Stay in touch with us, please.

  46. Lilystar says:

    thank you Dr Leah. Yes i do, but they all say I have to start moving on, which of course they are right, but its hard to move past something that doesnt make any sense at all.
    He wont even talk about it to me, in face he has gone no conatct mode and I am left with this gaping hole of pain and confusion.

    will never ever get involved with a gut again unless hes been divorced for at least a year!
    Im going to find it very hard to trust anyone again honestly.

  47. 1001 Nights says:

    Lilystar: I’m so sorry this happened to you. A “separated” person is often a loose cannon. I would just accept that. They have layers that suddenly surface out of no-where. My feeling is that when you were away – ie. the slightest amount of fragility created for him, and he freaked out, and his -ex swooped right in.
    I’ve had this with a separated guy, too. They are more needy than most, and the smallest withdrawal and they can’t cope. On some level, you going on that trip made him feel he was “left” and coupled with her knocking on his door, he fell right through the cracks again.

    Separated people are fragile. They may not think so, but they are. Enough of them, that you can only take partial risks. (I told my guy I wouldn’t sleep with him, and I didn’t.)

    Your guy has gone back to try and salvage his hurt. Kind of hoping the cheating didn’t happen, so that he could deny having to face the pain – he’s so badly avoiding. Which to me, means that he had never dealt properly with the pain of being cheated on. It leaves men in a terrible state. Far worse than women. Physical betrayal to them is just unbearable. The moment he was left alone when you went on your trip, his fragile psyche caught up with him and he did what he did. The reason you shouldn’t be with him, at least for now, isn’t because he went back to x y or z – but because he’s clearly so fragile, and hasn’t healed enough – is even in denial about the cheating, it seems.

    They say the best way to get some of your dignity back, is to write an empowerment letter. Hand written. Something that cool-ly agrees with what happens: “I now understand better that you were more fragile than I thought. Regardless of what action you chose to take, what I take from this is seeing that you’re not “ready” – still have wounds. In some ways, this is the best thing that could have happened to me and my daughter. I wish you the best as you heal.”

    This kind of note, makes you be the “rejector” and often makes the guy want to come back. Not that you should want this guy back – because he truly doesn’t sound ready. Be the strong woman you know you are!!!

    I hope this helped.

  48. Sara78 says:

    It was really great to read all of these comments. It’s comforting to know that I am not the only one that is going thru this. I am a mother and I have been divorced for about 1 1/2 years. I started dating right after my divorce. I don’t think I could have dated anyone while separated. I can only really handle one situation at once. I have been in a few relationships since and have jumped in way too quick in all situations. To say this has been a difficult time is an understatement. I am currently dating someone who is still married. He moved about 3 hours away for work from his wife an kids. He has been separated for about 2 years or so, but are still not legally divorced. I have been dating him for about 3 months. Up until recently, it has been a great relationship. I have stayed at his house multiple times, so i know that he is telling me the truth about the separation. He has talked in such depth about the separation that I tend to believe him. On the weekends that he has his children, we do not speak on those weekends. I didnt really question it. He recently told me that he has been staying at his old home in a guest room when he goes home to see his children. He had originally told me that he stayed with his brother and his family.
    He says that he barely sees his kids and he still owns the house, so he feels its his right. First, i sometimes wonder if i am being a fool. Since they have not started the divorce process, I have no way of even checking if he is really getting a divorce. I wonder if this is me being paranoid. I have trusted him so far, but maybe I am being naive? Even if he is 100% truthful, i think it a little messed up that he is staying in the house on the weekends. Any feed back would be greatly appreciated.

  49. Shanna says:

    Twitter @
    I don’t know much about dating married men, but I am still legally married (divorce will be finalized July 28) and I am in a relationship. I’ve been separated over 2 years but as a single parent, I could not afford the divorce. My son was only a year old when my ex and I separated so he does not remember life with the two of us together. For me separated meant no attachments to the ex. He lives 9 hours away now and has started a new life as well. I think everyone has to take each situation as an individual basis, and not be too quick to let your heart get in the way of what’s right. For me, it was just a missing piece of paper from court, for others it is a lie.

  50. mightbeatranny says:

    Twitter @
    SARA,
    what are you looking for from this relationship? if you are happy and this is enough, then there you go. i think that when you are in a relationship you have to trust the other person. otherwise you shouldn’t be in the relationship. so if you believe him that’s enough.

    my husband dated as soon as we were seperated (but then he dated during the marriage). i didn’t care and the marriage was OVER, no question. i’d date a guy that was seperated, because in my situation the marriage was over. what is seperated if it not the path to divorce? anyway, my husband still wanted to get back together. we had a really BAD marriage, no sex in YEARS, literally no eye contact by the time i left, and yet it would have been enough for him to stay in the marriage just so he didn’t have to say he was DIVORCED.

    i think some men feel an almost ownership of their wife. your guy might want to make sure that she isn’t with anyone else. not that he wants her back, just he doesn’t like the idea of HIS wife w/ another man.

    do you ever watch the millionaire match maker? she says that you need to keep a man chasing you, keep his interest high by always making him want to see you just little bit more than he does. so keep busy when he’s gone and see how it goes. and men are weird about their “house”. they are providers, so i don’t hink its odd that he wants to stay there, but i think its mighty odd that the wife allows it.

    does he call you when he’s there? can you call him? if you don’t hear from him while he’s there, be unavailable for awhile when he comes back. make him work for it.

    BETRAYED WIFE;
    , “the hurt I felt from realizing how many women are out there that DO NOT respect the boundaries of another woman’s marriage”. how can you be serious? if your own husband doesn’t respect the marriage enough to honor the vows why would a stranger? you took back this man after he betrayed you sexually and emotionally, and brought some nut job into your life. where is your line in the sand on behavior? it doesn’t sound like you have one. if you think there is a reward for allowing a man to treaat you poorly you’re wrong. all he’s going to learn is that no matter what; you are there to accept it. you might complain, or act like a victim, but you aren’t going anywhere. virtue is its own reward. but you know what, standing up for yourself and deciding that you are in charge of your life and that you deserve better feels a lot more empowering.

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled
ss_blog_claim=2dba28946b740b47821f4be875666330