Should I give my kid an allowance in the New Year?

by Rachel Sarah  
Filed under Single Moms

As the holidays wind down, are you looking forward to getting back into your routine? We really get it.

One single mom wrote to us this week to say that although she should feel well-rested after the holidays, she’s exhausted. “It was great to have the extra time to clean my apartment from top to bottom, but picking up after my son all the time was just TOO much!”

As a single parent, you understand: the laundry, the dirty dishes, the sticky kitchen floor, the art supplies, the Legos, the Barbie accessories, you name it.

Although her son has done his part to pick up his toys, he’s getting older now. He turned six over the holiday break, and now she wonders: “Should I start giving him an allowance to help out around the house?”

Ideally, she wishes that her son would do some chores around the house just because. That’s how her best friend — whose kids are in middle school now — does it. This friend doesn’t believe in allowance because, she explains, being part of a family means being responsible.

Her friend’s kids have helped out since they were little — with everything from folding laundry to washing dishes to packing their lunches — and they’ve received money when they needed it. But the friend has never doled out a weekly allowance.

Still, this mom wonders if it’s a good time to teach her son about money. If he starts saving money — and uses it to buy “extra” things on his own — maybe this is a great way to learn about budgeting?

Yet she also wants to know if if age six is too young to start giving him an allowance? Is there an ideal age?

We’d love to know if you give an allowance to your kids. If “yes,” do you give money to them for normal chores? Or, for extra work done?

If you don’t give an allowance at all, please chime in! Are there certain circumstances when you do give your kids extra spending money? (Say for a movie or new clothes?).

We’d love to know what works best for you!

Thanks @ItsToni for reminding us that loving family members – besides moms and dads – wonder about allowances.

(Photo courtesy of Lorenzodom via Flickr)

Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

Related posts:

  1. New (school) year resolutions? A contest! It’s the end of summer, and I don’t know about you, but every time this year, it’s time to make...
  2. Break up or give the relationship another try? A while back, many of you chimed in about breaking up when you’re pregnant. Your stories were powerful. We...
  3. Are you planning changes in the New Year? We just can’t get that fired up to make a whole bunch of New Year’s resolutions. That’s because we’ve...
  4. How do you handle those unexpected expenses? No matter how well you plan, life can catch you off guard. As a single parent, you know about...

Comments

8 Responses to “Should I give my kid an allowance in the New Year?”
  1. Solomother says:

    Twitter @ solomother
    My son has been getting an allowance since July. He also has a savings account, and has saved almost $200 already. The bank account came with the allowance, and we fill in the deposit slips, do the math, walk to the teller, etc. He can see what saving means.

    He’s also learning the value of money. Now, when he asks me to buy something, I tell him, “You have your own money, you buy it. But know that that thing costs five weeks of allowance.”

    He doesn’t buy it.
    Solomother´s last blog ..Teen angst sets mom on fire? My ComLuv Profile

  2. Martini Mom says:

    Twitter @ martinimom
    I do both with my son. He’s *always* been expected to help out with chores (laundry, making his lunch, cleaning his room, picking up after himself) so when I started giving him an allowance, there was no need to tie it directly to his chores. (He does, however, lose portions of his allowance for bad behavior.) I can imagine being six years old and being introduced to formal chores for the first time, an allowance or other direct reward might help make the transition into helping out. I don’t think that’s such a bad thing.

    Regardless of whether it’s tied to chores or not, I think an allowance is a great way to teach kids about budgeting and about “money not growing on trees.” My son is learning that, regardless of how much you want something, you simply can’t buy it if you don’t have enough money in the bank. (Fingers crossed this will help with the credit card temptation later in life!) He’s eight now, and I think I started giving him an allowance around 4 or 5.

    He’s allowed to spend a portion of his allowance on whatever he wants. He’s made some bad decisions, and he’s learned from them. What could be better than that?

    Another portion is required to go into his savings bank, and a third portion is required to go into a “charitable giving” bank (he has three piggy banks to keep it all separate). He uses the charitable giving bank every year to buy a Christmas gift for a child at a local shelter for abused women and their children.

    It’s been an excellent learning opportunity, and I highly recommend it whether or not it’s tied to chores!
    Martini Mom´s last blog ..Product Review: my very own bro bag My ComLuv Profile

  3. Lauren says:

    Twitter @ laurenmli
    Martini Mom – I love that you have your son split his money into three “accounts.” I intend to do the same with my son, when he starts receiving an allowance.

    I personally don’t think that allowance and chores should be tied together for the same reason that this mom’s friend doesn’t tie them — I think that chores are a responsibility a child has as a member of the family. I believe that allowance is a great way to teach kids about money, budgeting, saving, giving and making choices. But by tying it to chores, it gives the children the idea that the chores are optional, depending on whether they feel they need their allowance that week.

    When I was young, I had an allowance, but I did not earn it doing chores. Chores were my responsibility as someone who lived under my parents’ roof. If I didn’t complete my chores by 12:00 p.m. on Saturday, I didn’t get to go out for the rest of the weekend. Of course, this was once I was in middle school and high school, but a more age appropriate consequence could be applied. I think this was an effective approach, as I always did my chores!

    When I was in grade school, my allowance was for toys and candy and whatnot, but by the time I was in middle school and high school, my allowance was how I paid for my weekend entertainment, clothes beyond the seasonal shopping trip with my mom, gadgets, knick-knacks, etc. Basically, anything non-essential.

  4. Lauren says:

    Twitter @ laurenmli
    I forgot to mention the reward technique I’ve used that has worked with my son.

    I have a clear plastic tube that we draw a fill line on. We keep with us a baggie full of plastic chips that fit in the tube. When he does something exceptionally good, he gets a chip to put in the tube. He doesn’t get chips for doing what’s already expected of him – but when he goes above and beyond, he scores one. When he gets to the fill line, he gets to pick out a prize the next time we’re at Target (or where ever). I have a spending limit, of course.

    This might help in getting your son accustomed to doing chores without committing to paying an allowance for doing chores forever. At first, he will be doing something that is above and beyond, as it hasn’t been expected of him before. If he understands the chips are not for regular expectations, you should be able to ween him off of them after not to long (for doing chores, anyway). I use the tube and chips that come with the LRC game. Hope this is helpful!
    Lauren´s last blog ..Bonus Blog Post – My 2010 Goals Have Been Set My ComLuv Profile

  5. Zoeyjane says:

    Twitter @ Zoeyjane
    Like MartiniMom, I plan on the three piggy-banks allowance, and believe that chores are everyone’s responsibility.

    Fact is, I don’t plan to start an allowance until Zoë is four in the summer (and then, like, a REALLY small amount of money) and she’s had “housework” to do for almost two years already – I may have had the only nearly-two year old that cleaned up her own room without being asked more than once!

    My point is: tying chores and allowance together could be a double-edged sword, whereas starting to issue age-appropriate responsibilities without income is never a bad idea.
    Zoeyjane´s last blog ..On promises My ComLuv Profile

  6. Dr. Leah says:

    @solomother Neat idea! This makes it “real” for your son and likely teaches valuable lessons about thrift. Thanks so much for sharing your thoughts.

  7. Twitter @ BigLittleWolf
    This is one I’ve struggled with over recent years. My kids had an allowance when I had an income, starting when they were about 6 years old. It was a very small amount, but to encourage them to understand about money. However, in recent years, financial pressures have made that nearly impossible. They are also older – everything is more expensive, and $1 or $5 even won’t do them much good, unfortunately. They have friends who may be getting $20/week, and that’s not possible in our world. Yet when they want something really badly – and they are aware of our finances – they will ask, or they will work some sort of odd job somehow – to pay as much of it as they can.

    A different sort of lesson.
    BigLittleWolf´s last blog ..Facebook : efficace dans la vie romantique, ou le contraire ? My ComLuv Profile

  8. Travis says:

    Twitter @ CulminatingLife
    I used allowance to learn how to obtain money by working for it, This started at the age of 8. Up until eight, you were taught what you could get with work but I took care of their needs. Kids being flaky and all, but by the time they were eight, they knew what they could get, and knew what efforts they needed to do, to get their allowance.

    If they balked at the chores, it was given to the other children who wanted the extra pay for it. that changed super fast when they saw their money going to someone else.

    win-win.. they learned good work behaviors and the house was maintained reasonably well (not perfect.. their kids and all)

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled
ss_blog_claim=2dba28946b740b47821f4be875666330