When it’s NOT just about a birthday card. Help!

by Dr. Leah  
Filed under Kids

The single mom reader of an eight-year-old daughter sent us an urgent email this week telling us that her ex has never contributed financially or emotionally or acted like a responsible parent. In what began with a one night stand — and ended with a string of broken promises — this single mom has resolved to have “zero communication” with her ex.

This single mom added emphatically: “If my daughter wants to contact him that’s fine with me. My daughter told me she’s not really interested because she doesn’t know him anyway.  But,  I do not want him to contact her.”

“Frankly, I don’t know him and don’t trust him. And  I don’t see him as a parent for very good reasons.”

Many of us have struggled with  serious co-parenting (or not) dilemmas.

And we can relate to how unexpectedly things can change.

Here’s the perplexing situation facing this  determined single mom:

“I got to the mail box before my daughter today. There was an envelope from him addressed to me.”

“In the envelope was money and a birthday card for my daughter.”

“I’m sending the money back because there is nothing I want from him.”

And, here’s the parenting dilemma this single mom is confronting: “I believe in open communication with my daughter. I’m concerned that if I hide things related to her biological father from her that she will do the same with me. And it’s important to me that I do not break her trust in me.”

“At the same time,” she adds, “I want my daughter to have a carefree childhood and happy memories. “The ‘zero communication’ decision is not as clear cut as I first thought.”

So, this single mom is asking for your help.  After all,  this decision is not just about a birthday card.

The choice this single mom makes now will impact her daughter no matter what she decides.

So, she desperately needs some advice from you.  (She’s adamant about sending back the money. )

Should she send her daughter’s birthday card back to her ex?

Or, should she give her daughter the birthday card from her father?

Should she let her daughter know her decision  not to accept money from her ex?

Or is this a private matter between this single mom and her ex?

~~~~~~~

(Photo courtesy of loopy lou p)

–

Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

Related posts:

  1. When you’re still madly in love with your ex We know that some of you might scream when you read that headline — “No!!!” — but we also know...
  2. Can a relationship with a parent do more harm than good? When we talked about “no show” co-parents, you enthusiastically agreed that a Plan B was essential. You told us that...
  3. When parenting time choices are OUTRAGEOUS We’re both solo parents who’ve been raising our kids without our ex in the picture.  So, when it comes to...

Comments

20 Responses to “When it’s NOT just about a birthday card. Help!”
  1. thordora says:

    Twitter @
    Keep the card for when she’s older, but disregard for now? Depends on the kid, but it might be important for her later, even if right now it’s not necessarily the best thing. I don’t think you’d be hiding anything so much as protecting her-and as someone who found her biological mother and relatives at 19, and had it end badly-sometimes you need protecting from the very thing you want.

    As for the money-don’t send it back. Sock it in some sort of savings for her for schooling or whatnot. I understand wanting nothing from him, but I need any bit of money I can get, especially when it comes to saving for schooling.

    Man, what a hideous position to be in.

  2. Paige says:

    Twitter @
    As a single Mother myself I would suggest sending the money back just as she had plan to do so. I would show her the card and let her know that it is at her decision of if she would like to speak to him or not. I am thankfully not to that point in my daughter’s life where she can contact her Father if she would like. I pray that whenever the time comes that she will decide against it, men of this nature are nothing but full of lies and more broken promises in the end.

  3. AH says:

    Twitter @
    It seems as though if I understand correctly, how should you shelter your child is the issue. If this is the case I present this fact to consider… Is the child mature enough to understand/handle the situation, and it sounds as though you believe she is. I base this upon the fact that you’ve already had discussions with her about her father beleiving she was mature enough for you to introduce the precedence of allowing her to make the decision of whether or not she wanted to contact him. This being the case, why wouldn’t you also allow her to decide whether or not she wants to accept a birthday card. yes I know, the dissappointment if one does not come next year. However since you thought it important to allow her to deciding whether or not she wanted to contact him. You may want to consider letting her know that her father sent her a bday card, prefacing it with the history (ie although your father sent you one this year..), and continue letting her make the call.

  4. Twitter @
    I’m really confused here as to why you would send the money back and not give her the card. The card and money are gifts for her and she should have them. Sending the money back is childish and I can tell you as a child who was abandoned by her father that this would make me VERY angry. My father was never present in my life. Hey, his choice, he has to live with it. But still to this day it makes me mad that my mom never accepted money from him or took him to court to make sure he paid child support. He owed me at LEAST that, and I could have used that money growing up or when I went away to college.

    You haven’t said how old your daughter is, but from the letter it seems she’s old enough to know she doesn’t want a relationship with her biological father. This card may change her mind or it might not. But let her make the decision. You chose this man to be her father, but I don’t think you get to choose what kind of relationship they have.
    Elita @ Blacktating´s last blog ..Sweet Songs: Benefit Album for Mother’s Milk Bank at Austin My ComLuv Profile

  5. Legal Editor Mom says:

    It’s a difficult situation to be in, and it’s very unfortunate for the child. However, this mother is letting her personal feelings cloud her judgment. She is the one who slept with this man and created a child, and now she has to make the best of that action. As parents we natually want to protect our children; however, we should be cautious not to do things that will cause our children to resent us later, particularly when we’re acting on their behalf without their knowledge or consent if they’re old enough to understand. And since the mother and daughter have already had conversations about this, I’d say the girl is old enough.

    She should show her daughter the card, let her know it’s from her father, and leave it at that. Later on the girl will probably have questions about her father and may want to pursue a relationship or at least learn more about him, and like it or not, she has right to do any or all of these things, as long as he doesn’t pose a threat to her. The mother should also not send the money back. Yes SHE doesn’t want anything from him, but it’s not for her! She can put it into a college fund or savings for her daughter for later.

    My ex is a poor excuse for a father and if I could drain every ounce of his blood from our daughter I would do so, but unfortunately I can’t. So I bite my tongue in a lot of situations, never talk bad about him to our daughter, save any bit of money he offers for her, and most importantly, I establish guidelines and boundaries for him and their interactions since he has shown time and time again that he’s not reliable. Yet he is still her father and she deserves to have a relationship with him if she wants to. All I can do is be there for her and help her through it as best I can.

  6. brokenpromisering says:

    If he has gone this far, he isn’t going to stop, even if she sends both the money and the card back.

    It’s time for a discussion with her daughter, in simple terms, telling her what has happened. She should explain (again) why the father is not in their lives, and all the reasons why she thinks he shouldn’t be (in practical terms, without emotion). Give her the option to have the card and put the money into her bank account. If she wants it, offer to open and read it together and talk about how it makes both of you feel.

    But don’t leave it at that. She should have a few conversations about this with the daughter because her feelings will change over time and the mom should be open and available to talk and help her through her feelings. The daughter needs to feel supported no matter what she decides going forward. Chances are that the card will be forgotten quickly and life will go back to normal. But he will probably try again.

    I think sometimes we (as parents) need to see ourselves as shepherds. We are there to protect yes, but also to help our children grow into responsible and emotionally mature adults. If you stay close by and involved, and help them think and feel their way through things when they are young (instead of just making decisions for them), they will be able to deal with the big stuff that comes up as they get older.

  7. Laura says:

    Twitter @
    Honesty is the best policy. It’s hard – but try to set aside emotion and think about it objectively. The man addressed the card to you – not your daughter, which shows some sensitivity to the situation. He’s not trying to make an end-run around you. Your daughter, though she may say otherwise, in all likelihood will appreciate the card and her father’s gesture. It’s a tiny gesture, true – but somehow more sincere than an odd grand gesture.
    So give her the card and the money (or put the money into a college account for her) – and talk to her about how she’s feeling. Keep your feelings out of it. Our baggage isn’t their baggage. Easier said than done, I know – believe me. And give yourself permission to rethink your “no contact” rule. As parents we have to adjust our thinking over time, as circumstances change.
    It sounds like you’re a terrific mom who is doing all the right things – and you’ll do the right thing in this situation, too. The fact you’re reaching out for advice says you know it won’t hurt to bend a bit – just a bit – on the no contact rule. When she’s grown, she’ll appreciate your honesty.

  8. Jenni says:

    Twitter @
    The most important question is: How old is the daughter, and is she old enough to make decision on her own?

    I am adopted by my great aunt and uncle, who has been “mom and dad” since I was 2-years-old. My parents were very upfront about my adoption, and my parents. My biological mother, their niece, was 18 when she had me.. and my father was a drunk junkie who tried to kill her. I was dropped off by my mother, and she never came back for me. End of story.

    My parents split, and when I turned 14, I asked to get in contact with my biological mom.. and I was given her phone number. We have been in off-and-on contact ever since – my bio mom is a very hot-and-cold woman.

    As for my biological father, he has never tried to contact me, and I have never had any interest in him. His sister called my mom once, asking to talk to me. I told my mom if she called back, to tell her I wasn’t interested.

    If the daughter is old enough LET HER CHOSE. I feel like the mom is overstepping her boundaries, and being a little too over protective. If something like this happened, and my mom had kept it from me, I would be absolutely furious. And believe it or not, kids are capable of handling their own emotions: she might be overwhelmed. She might decide to contact him, and attempt a connection. Or she might completely blow him off, feeling indifferent. But these are her decisions to make about her father.. the mom needs to just plan on being there, if/when she’s needed.
    Jenni´s last blog ..Bad Romance My ComLuv Profile

  9. Natasha says:

    Twitter @
    Wow, this question hits home for many reasons.

    My parents separated when I was 2. My fab single mom raised me with the help of her mother. She passed away a few years ago, and while going thru her papers, I found a mountain of letters from my father.

    They had a multi-year debate re: his contact with me. What I remember is the random bday and Christmas gifts. They were never regular and often inappropriate (a gift suitable for a 6yo given to a 10yo). Then I heard nothing from him for 6 yrs. Then I received a few letters in my mid teens that were helpful and insightful.

    What I now know is that he was in jail. He desperately wanted to reconnect. My mom refused his requests initially. She didn’t think I needed the stress. She wanted to protect me. Eventually she agreed to let him send me letters; they were sent to her, and she gave them to me.

    So, my advice: you know your daughter. Put your emotions away and think only about her. Would reading his card make her feel better?
    You said it yourself, this was a one-night stand. Your darling daughter is all that’s between the two of you. Don’t make it into anything more.
    And regarding the $: if you give her the card, give her the money. If you chuck the card, put the money in her college fund. Paying for his daughter is his JOB.

  10. Darby says:

    Twitter @
    While I certainly understand her anger and frustration, I think she needs to step back from the shock and think this through. A lot of us have children who are forced to cope with bad parents. And, while we wish we could protect them, we simply can not. This is their reality and we helped create it. If she is mature enough to have had a conversation about him, she should also know that he tried to contact her. Is this opening up a can of worms, probably so. But, this is her father, for better or worse. I know that it’s terrifying when you’re moving along just fine, and they come in and try to change things, but it’s our job to adjust in a manner that is best for our children without clogging up the decision with our emotions.

    How about the fact that he addressed the card to the mom rather than the daughter? That tells me that this man is trying to be respectful. He may be a complete loser, but at least he is being respectful of his place.

  11. Twitter @
    While I would recommend against telling the child about the card, nobody knows her better than her mother; Mom will have to choose. But there is more to this than just the card.

    It sounds like it has taken this man 8 years to step up and do anything with regard to his daughter. Is the birthday card a demonstration of his desire to do more, or is it simply a token gesture in a moment of clarity?

    The first thing I would do is contact the ex and ask he thinks he’s doing. Be honest with him, and let him know that he isn’t trusted. A birthday card from her father is an emotional trigger for 8 year old. If all he wanted was to send her the card for her birthday, then the presentation of the card can be done with that in mind, and the child told as much. Future expectations are very clearly laid out; all he wanted to do was give you this card.

    If he claims that he wants to start becoming more involved in his child’s life, then that is a whole other story, and I would actually not give the card in that case. Telling the 8 year old about this can easily lead to false hope on the child’s part. At that age, despite what the child may say, a child is not always emotionally equipped to deal with the reality of someone not changing their strips. Her seeing the card from a father that has never been there may give her that hope. Hold onto the card, and see what the father does; does he hold to his word.

    The money part is easy: it’s for the daughter and should go to her. If the daughter gets the card, then she should get the money. If she doesn’t get the card, the money from the card should be put into a 529 plan so that it is there for her future. Delivery of the card is an emotional thing. There are fewer emotions if the card is not delivered and the money saved for later.
    Fresh Star Dad´s last blog ..Dear Mother Of My Children… My ComLuv Profile

  12. Momma says:

    Twitter @
    She should let her daughter choose. Be as open as possible. Let her know the good, bad and ugly and make sure she understands all of what you are telling her. Allow her to fully understand the most likely outcome of contact vs no contact. Make sure you explain why you have chosen not to have contact with him up to this point. Explain it in terms she can understand. Then ultimately let her choose and support her in her choice and if she chooses differently later support her in that as well.

  13. alley says:

    Twitter @
    The money and the card are both the child’s right. The biological father may not be responsible enough to parent and he may not be there to share the load in parenting, but this isn’t a bad break up that she can decide to just ignore. The man has sent his child a gift, the mother needs to either give the money and card to the child or spend the money on things the child could use or enjoy and give her the card. Sending it back is mean, foolish, and in the state I live in where the child’s right to be supported by both parents is law, illegal.
    alley´s last blog ..Why I hate Mother’s Day My ComLuv Profile

  14. Twitter @
    I guess it would depend on the kid. But if she’s been honest with her up until now, then there’s no reason not to be at this point. Perhaps the father is a changed man and this is his way of opening up the door to a relationship…who knows.

    If it were my child, I would give her the card. Hell, I might even give her the money, too, who knows? She should be honest with her daughter about how SHE feels about it, but let the rest be up to the girl.
    Momma Sunshine´s last blog ..Rough Week My ComLuv Profile

  15. avigail74 says:

    Twitter @
    This is a hard place to be, I know–but even harder to understand that this relationship is between the daughter and the father. Many of us readers from this blog of difficult exes who don’t step up to the plate–who do strange things for strange reasons–who we wish would disappear from the face of the earth—but the bottom line is, the child has a father. For once, and it may be the last, he thought of her and gave her a gift. The gift must be given to her—simple as that. She can then decide what to do with it and/or decide later how she wants to think of him.

    My daughter has a father who calls at strange times—very infrequently, less and less as she gets older—hasn’t given her a gift in a long time—has even said to me, “Mommy, I know you, grandpa and bubbe would do anything for me, and my father will only do something if I’m in the hospital.” She’s eight. We visit her birth-city quite a bit, and I always forewarn her that there’s a chance that she may not see her dad—she always replies, “If I get to see him once, that would make me happy…” and I have to hope very hard that he will take the one day to visit her. See, she’s only 8. She knows.

    If I hid a gift from her—and she found out years later, I can only hear her yelling at me tell me that it was wrong to hide a gift from her father. After all, it’s only a card with money.
    avigail74´s last blog ..Gypsy Family My ComLuv Profile

  16. Twitter @
    If the kid has said she didn’t want to contact him….Id send the card back. Hell, Ive sent boxes of clothes back to Cali because wtf am I gonna tell the kid?! You got a package, of clothes, from nobody? She doesnt know my ex, his family etc…so when they just randomly decide to acknowledge her (which btw is also rare) I send the shit back. You can’t buy her for goodness sake and I may be broke all the time but I always manage to provide for my child…I hate the half ass shit, come around when you want, when it works for you.
    Being a parent is all or nothin…not this part time shit. That is just insulting.
    singlemama_cc´s last blog ..Being a mom rocks~ My ComLuv Profile

  17. Twitter @
    It’s not an easy situation but I do think you have to put your feelings aside and give the card and money to your daughter. Ask her what she thinks about putting it away for college or if she;d like to do something else with it. She’s going to have lots of emotion around it and this way, you don;t create anything extra – like her dad coming back one day saying.”I always sent you bday money…”

    Let her decide – she can do it (my daughter is 8 too – they are amazing in what they can handle). She needs to build up tools to deal with him (and his popping in and out) under your guidance rather than being plunged into it as a teen.

    Swati
    Swati Bharteey´s last blog ..The Strange Smell in Your Family Room (Happy Mother’s Day!) My ComLuv Profile

  18. Jane says:

    Twitter @
    I do not think you should send the money back. I do not think, however, now is the time to just hand a card over to her, she is 8. I also, do not beleive in “open” communication, either. she is a little girl, why does she need to be burdened with grownup issues. Now is the age, and the time, t start talking about difference, in people, choices, responsibilities, and accountability. People really do change, and I think it is smart and healthy for you to lay the ground work for her, and teach her in ways that will enable her to make healthy choices for future relationships, that involve acceptance, healthy parameters, and a lifestyle that is based on choices, needs, and not judgements. This is extremely doable, as long as you take your emotion out of it regarding her dad, as it is her dad, and allow her the ability to make her choice when the time comes, based on what you have taught her. I have four girls that I raised this way, and yes, years later, their dad is starting to poke his noes around…and I will tell you it is very interesting, as little girls always want to know about and meet their dads. Oh, they will tell us differently, but deep inside, they always want to know. And we must as, single parents not confuse great survival instincts with maturity. All kids can handle a lot, but we must be protective of them, and guard when we can, their emotions. Best of luck.
    Jane´s last blog ..Parenting: A man’s POV My ComLuv Profile

  19. wondermom says:

    Twitter @
    She can do what she wants with the money but I think she should give the card to her daughter. Whatever the meaning behind it, whatever doors (or cans of worms) it may open, I would not be able to live with myself keeping something like that from my children.

    I know a lot of adults of single parents who are furious and bitter that their parent (usually the mother) worked to keep their father away from them, rejected his attempts to be involved, hid cards, letters, gifts, calls, etc. I’ve never heard anyone say “I’m so glad my mother lied to me and didn’t tell me my dad wanted to be a part of my life.”
    wondermom´s last blog ..Maybe I’m not ready after all… My ComLuv Profile

  20. Daniella says:

    Twitter @
    If I’ve learned anything from my divorce of 6 years it’s the not so simple fact that I cannot shield my daughter from her father’s character flaws. Furthermore, I cannot control his actions good, bad, and/or different. Conversely, I can continue to be a sounding board with open communication to help her work through any emotions she feels towards her father good, bad and/or indifferent.

    Always,
    Daniella
    Daniella´s last blog ..Single Parenting | Belonging My ComLuv Profile

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled
ss_blog_claim=2dba28946b740b47821f4be875666330