Should first date conversations include relationship status?
by Rachel Sarah
Filed under All, Featured, Relationships
We know that many of you are dating — or thinking about dating again. So, we hope that you’ll offer some advice to this single mom who wrote to us. Thanks.
This mom — who asked to remain anonymous — became single when she was pregnant and living abroad. We were honored to hear that she’d read both of our books — The Complete Single Mother and Single Mom Seeking — as she made some very tough emotional decisions.
After finding out that her husband had been having an affair, she decided to move back to the United States. She gave birth here, and then hired a lawyer to get divorced.
“But after my ex was served with papers, he told me that he wanted to work things out,” she tells us. “I believed it/wanted it/remained suspicious — but I clung to that idea that I’d have a ‘real’ family. ”
So, she went abroad with her six-week-old daughter to meet him. In the meantime, it was clear that not much had changed. Emotionally, he was distant. Moreover, he wasn’t helping her financially and she had a hard time finding a job. Clearly, he was not committed to working things out. So, when a job came through back in the States at the end of 2009, she decided to move back home again.
“In the meantime, my ex has since fathered a child with his girlfriend,” she says, “Yes, it’s the same woman he was having an affair with when we were married.”
To make matters more complicated, her lawyer says that she needs to reside in her current state for at least one year before she can file for divorce. She is eager to file for divorce this December.
In fact, she has posted her profile on an online dating site — and marked off the “divorce” box.
“I’m very ready to date again,” she says. “That’s a given. But I’m not sure how honest I need to be before I actually meet a guy in person. I don’t want to have to tell a guy that I am not yet divorced until I know that I want to date him,” she explains. “I don’t want my separation status to be the subject of first date conversation.”
She has already learned the hard way that revealing too much too early — like detailing her history with her ex by email or IM — is a big turn off. “Yet, I want to be honest about what happened,” she says, “to explain why I’m no longer with the father of my child.”
Many of you have said that dating someone who isn’t honest about his/her relationship status is a red flag.
Frankly, we can see both sides of this dating quandary. So, we’d love to hear from you:
Have you dated when you were just separated?
Is your relationship status an essential part of the first date conversation?
Or, can these disclosures wait until a relationship shows some promise?
~~~
Photo courtesy of Simon Lawrence
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
Related posts:
- How do you tell a *man* you’re a single mom? This is exactly the question that Kate, pictured above, a fellow blogger and valued neighbor @Singlemommyhood, asked this week. Here’s...
- Break up: how do you “he-tox” him for real? – A single mom blogger whom you might know has asked this great question: “How long does it take to...
- What does “more space” really mean? When single guys — who are dating single moms — write to us, we’re always fascinated by their perspective on...
- Can a relationship with a parent do more harm than good? When we talked about “no show” co-parents, you enthusiastically agreed that a Plan B was essential. You told us that...


Follow Singlemommyhood on Twitter




Twitter @ http://avigail74.blogspot.com
I do have a rule for myself—I won’t date any man until one year after the divorce has been finalized. Separations, upcoming divorces are very, very different from a divorce–and even more so after a year. Before the divorce, there are still paperwork, legal work and angst/stress before the big D day, and it does affect the relationship. I would consider it dishonest if a man wrote divorce when he wasn’t yet.
Avigail74´s last blog ..The Four Day Trip
I have a rule about not dating separated guys, too, but when I was separated and doing online dating, I chose divorced. Hypocrite! I was very upfront with them about it after our first contact though, and I always told them in an email before the first date. I just hated the idea of getting pushed out of search results and not getting a chance to know someone just because I separated.
As the single mom who wrote in…let me add a few things.
(1) We lived together in “holy matrimony” a total of 2 months. I was 6 weeks pregnant when HE left the house because I accused him of having an affair.
(2) I have been separated for a year and a half now as in physically not living under the same roof and not having relations and the ONLY reason I’m not divorced is that there are strict legal rules governing divorce where I live and HE refuses to file in his native country where we were married and would be able to do a one day divorce.
(3) There are no emotions left (my daughter just turned 1 year old and he is not involved in her life in any way). I don’t have angst about D day, because the marriage has really been only on paper .
(4) Because I was living with the man I married such a short period of time, I almost feel as if I was never married (even when I considered reconciliation we did not live together).
Ironically, like Corey, I am not really interested in dating guys who are separated. I think my situation is a little on the rare side though. Also, I am trying to be morally upstanding (technically dating even while separated is illegal and immoral) despite the errors of my husbands ways.
Twitter @ http://scribblingsofasoccermom.com
I think you *HAVE* to be honest–whether it’s telling someone you’re not fully divorced or telling someone you won’t date anyone who’s not been divorced for a certain amount of time. It was one of the first things I told my current fiancee when we started talking–the first was that I had children who were too important for me to explain! Anyway, I think all relationships are leaps of faith. I didn’t check the divorced box on the online dating sites though…I didn’t want anyone to think I was hiding something. I would date a guy who’s separated and not divorced, provided I saw that the situation was progressing. I say be up front from the get-go!
Soccer Mom´s last blog ..reminiscing
Twitter @ http://singlemommindy.blogspot.com
I also have a policy not to date men who are only seperated and not yet divorced. Divorce is a big deal and once those papers are signed and filed, life changes.
That being said, I dated a guy who told me he was divorced and then 6 months into our relationship he dropped the bomb that he was actually still married (they had been seperated for over a year when he and I met). I felt like our whole relationship was built on a lie, especially since he knew about my policy. I dated him and became attached under false pretenses and then I stayed with him after he told me the truth. As it turned out, when he did get his divorce finalized, he ended our relationship within a month. I got my heart broken by a guy I never would have dated had he been honest from the start. Witholding the truth is not being fair to the other person.
Mindy@SingleMomSays´s last blog ..Acronyms That Make Ya Wanna Drink
Twitter @ /
@J: Thanks so much for chiming in and adding more details to clarify your feelings.
Twitter @ http://www.cathouseteri.blogspot.com
I did date when I was just separated. I saw no reason to be secretive about it, if asked. But I didn’t bring it up. I also made it very clear that I was in no way looking for something serious. This was just for fun. Most men say they are cool with that, and then after a time, they want more. Which is fine. I would tell them to move on. I wasn’t ready and I knew it.
If a man says he is separated, I consider him married. Or if he is living with a woman, I consider him married. Most certainly, these men are datable. As long as you know that they are “married.” I’ve had friends ask me if they should date a married man they know. I say, “If you are okay with being treated like a whore, then go for it.” Because you will be treated like a whore. No matter what happens, the wife will take precedence.
Now, in this case, there are clearly extenuating circumstances (as I mentioned earlier, the above statements were generalizations). I see nothing improper about J dating men. But if asked, I would just say “I’m in the process of getting a divorce.” And leave it at that. No details should be required. If a man wants more details, he is a little too insecure to deal with this special situation. Dating should be a fun relief of the stress that one is going through, not added stress.
Catty Gramma Teri´s last blog ..Becky Jo and George Happy Anniversary!
Twitter @ fraizerbaz
Honesty is ALWAYS the best policy.
If a guy did that to me, I would drop him like a hot potato.
fraizerbaz´s last blog ..To My Friends
Twitter @ singlemomonabud
In my opinion, honesty is the best policy. J, herself, says that she is not interested in dating separated men. Men likely feel the same.
If you do not have a relationship based on honesty and the REAL “whole you”; you have nothing. I think we all, men and women, should have the right to decide based on full disclosure. Think of it this way, if the other party isn’t interested after knowing the truth then that person isn’t the one for you. There are plenty o’ fish in the sea. Paddle on.
No matter how ready *you* are to date, if you are not divorced there is baggage and I think it is only fair to be forthright about that. I had a very bad divorce (first) and a very good one (second) and even when everything was amicable and there were no issues or fighting words it was extremely taxing and difficult. Whoever you choose to date will have to endure that.
To J, December isn’t too far away in the grand scheme of things. If you are uncomfortable about putting the separated you out there maybe you should wait for the divorced you.
I am not saying do not date if the opportunity arises, I am simply saying be honest. Oh, and I don’t recommend giving all the ugly details. Ever. If you are getting divorced there is a reason and if you are really *over it* you shouldn’t feel the need to defend your decision.
Jill
Twitter @ lildevilmama
Okay, while I was never married, the Bio and I were together for almost five years and lived together and shared incomes and the whole kit and kaboodle. After we split, I was also preggers, I waited until I felt comfy and then gave only the details I felt needed to build up to the place where I would let the person in on everything.
With that being said, I did date one guy who was seperated but chose to hide it from me until the beans were spilled by a friend of his, after we’d been seeing each other for three months. I was a smidgen upset by the revelation, but it wasn’t a dealbreaker for me. We talked about the how and the why, and his divorce was pending sale of property. So, it wasn’t an emotional thing just a matter of timing.
I think when you are getting to know someone in the first stages, it’s a matter of learning if this is the ‘kind’ of person you want to be with and then revealing the bits and pieces of your past as you feel comfortable. I don’t tell men off the bat about what my Ex put me through, or how we function and go to therapy together…it’s personal until that person is a part of my personal life.
Good luck and I hope you have a great time getting back out there!!
Twitter @ iswirls
I understand that this is a woman filled audience, but women are more concerned with relationship status than men. If this story was reversed with a man, a woman would be crushed if the man didn’t tell her upfront that his divorce wasn’t over/final.
Honestly a man isn’t overly concerned about the technicality of the divorce. That’s just how it is. Women are more concerned than a man.
I say date and go with the flow.
Twitter @ http://www.vomitcomit.wordpress.com
I’ve been separated “technically” for about 7 months now, and I always tell people I’m seeing. However for me, the marriage was dead long before, and there’s no going back, so I don’t worry about it. We all have baggage of some sort and in my experience lately, it’s how we deal with it, not what it is.
Honesty works. Period.
thordora´s last blog ..Sometimes there’s no poison like a dream
Twitter @ http://goingsaneinacrazyworld.blogspot.com/
Be honest about it since it will come out later on. Even though you maybe ready for a relationship it does take time. Most therapists will say 2 years so there is no hurry to change the separation status. Yes it will make some people stay away from you, but you will meet people in the same boat as you.
Mike´s last blog ..Flying Kid @ Walmart
YES YES YES YES!!!!!!! YES! If there’s even a hint of a possibility of dating, both people should be up front and specific, i.e., “we haven’t been together in years but aren’t legally divorced”, which gives the other person to make an informed decision….it’s REALLY inconsiderate to tell someone during the 5th or 6th exchange….
Twitter @ http://mommasunshine.wordpress.com
It doesn’t need to be a first date conversation. In my opinion, the official divorce is just a piece of paper (this says the woman who still isn’t offically divorced, dating a man who isn’t offically divorced either).
I wouldn’t lie about it, but it’s not one of those “must ask” questions, either.
Momma Sunshine´s last blog ..Thumbs Up!
Twitter @ freshstartdad
To me, the answer is simple: tell the truth…all of it. While this situation is indeed unique, and the relationship is very clearly over and done with, she still isn’t divorced and should not indicate that she is.
Very often on a first date the subject “how long were you married?” and/or “how long have you been divorced?” will come up for me. I usually responded with “Emotionally, or legally?” As Momma Sunshine says, the “official” divorce is just a piece of paper. But the topic will come up and it should not be avoided; what are you trying to hide?
Being up front with the person and saying that you’re not yet divorced, sharing the reasons why, and explaining the situation honestly will help to ensure that any future relationship with that person – if there is one – won’t be started with a lie; even a lie of omission. Besides, would you really want to spend time with someone that doesn’t appreciate the story?
(I wouldn’t share the details via e-mail though. A story like this requires the listener to hear the emotions connected with the telling of it.)
Fresh Start Dad´s last blog ..I’m Hungry- Farmer’s Market Pizza
Twitter @ http://jeanieinparadise.blogspot.com
Really? There are so many reasons for people to be single parents, as long as you are single physically (as in not living with a significant other) and emotionally (as in not having a 20 minute conversation about how your ex was either your one true love and/or the portent of your doom) then I think you can tick whatever box YOU would chose on the single sites.
I actually can’t even remember what box I or my husband ticked to be connected on a dating site – but it worked – even though TECHNICALLY I had never been married but had I been would have been in the widowed box and he hadn’t quite got all the ducks lined up for the divorce box even though his ex and he had been separated for over 4 years (but were still friends).
Life is complicated.
jeanie´s last blog ..August
Twitter @ msjennixoxo
I don’t think it’s something that needs to be brought up – not unless someone she went out on a date with brought it up first. If a question like, “So how long have you been divorced?” pops up, then it’s only fair to truthfully answer.
J lives in the US, her ex-husband does not. So if even though she is technically still separated, I don’t think any reasonable man would fret over her relationship status. And I don’t see any harm in putting “divorced” as her status on a dating profile. I would probably do the same thing, seeing that I’m now in CA, and my ex lives in DC.. and we’re technically just separated too. But with being on completely separate coasts, I would like to think a sensible man would realize that my ex poses no threat.
As far as online dating goes, it’s known that being listed as “separated” can scare perspective dates away. When I was on Match, it never seemed much of a problem – ironically enough, it seemed that men had bigger problems being listed as separated, than women did. Strange.
But say don’t think too much into it, or even bring it up, unless the first dates leads to several more. Good luck!
Jenni´s last blog ..I Am The Norm
Twitter @ KatWilder
Not to be a party-pooper but … why is she even dating yet?
She says she’s ready to date but … shouldn’t she be looking at what went wrong in the relationship, what she’s accountable as far as that, spend time being a new mom in a new home, learning what life is like as a single mom?
You can’t just sweep all that under some rug, or hope to drag someone else into that.
She’s gone through a lot!
OK, maybe she has done some of that. Maybe she’s done a lot of that. (although I remember reading that it takes about two years to get over an affair). If that’s so, then by all means be honest — there’s nothing to hide. Because, if saying she’s not yet divorced yet makes her feel uncomfortable (or chases men away), the problem isn’t that she’s not divorced; the problem is she, like most not-yet-divorced people, aren’t ready, and those who have been dating a while know that (or at least have experienced that).
Kat Wilder´s last blog ..Your perception is your reality
Twitter @ http://www.howdoesshedoitmom.com
I was only divorced a year and a half after the separation took place and I most definitely dated in that time. I never really thought about this “relationship status” thing until I read this post to be honest.
I was always upfront with men when they asked me. I am a true believe in honesty being the best policy and I also believe that if we have to “hide” things to win a guy over there is a big problem.
If a man was going to get scared off because I was separated but not yet legally divorced he wasn’t for me! I have always been a kind of take it or leave it gal and after going through the divorce I was not about to “settle” on anything…man included!!
My advice be honest if it comes up….
How Does She Do It Mom´s last blog ..Life- Love & Lemons…Episode 3
@Kat, in my house there are no rugs. I have been a single mom for most of my pregnancy and all of my daughter’s first year of life. I have been through some terrible crap, but I’m a strong woman with a strong support system.I don’t need a man, but yes I miss companionship (and sex) and hope to find both in the future. I will still be a single mom navigating single momhood while dating and I’m not looking for a new daddy and an end to single momhood today, tomorrow or next week but I am looking for an eventual life partner. I’m more than emotionally ready for this. You shouldn’t believe everything you read in a book and make judgements as someome who has never been divorced. It’s the idea of meeting people like you that are judgemental that make me uncomfortable revealing certain things on a first date. There is no way I would tell a first date about the who and why of my separation on a first date.The online world unfortunately is a mixed bag of people with varied intentions.As I indicated, I revealed my separation status in an IM with a guy who then started to analyze my life story, tell me it made no sense and needless to say ended when he asked if [my daughter was] “black.” This clearly wasn’t the emotionally sophisticated or mature man I’m seeking. I don’t talk about ex-boyfriends on first dates either. I don’t reveal details of my marriage and separation to new people I meet before a friendship has developed. Most people infer I’m divorced until I tell all. But my friends know it all and my being able to discuss with friends, family and professionals what I been through have made the healing easier. Why should I be dating? Why not? Should a choice mom not date in her child’s first year of life? Should a never married mom whose partner took off in pregnancy wait until her child turns two to date?
I now live by a hard fast rule and that is i will not date anyone who hasn’t been out of their previous relationship at least a year.I don’t want to get caught up in that “taffy” game couples play with each other. Not to mention how can you be emotionally available in such short periods of time.
I guess if it’s just fun and nothing serious wanted on either persons part it might work,but I’m always serious so that’s a no go for me.
Twitter @ BigLittleWolf
I believe it is essential to be honest about where you are in the process. When people are at different stages – separated, newly divorced, long-term divorced – expectations of the dating relationship are typically different.
I also find it surprising that there was a comment about “why is she even dating already?”
I daresay that if it were a man, no one would ask that question. Most of divorced men I know began dating as soon as they moved out of the house (or the wife did), and dated throughout their separations. Most of the women waited a considerable period.
Draw your own conclusions. More sentimental, more hurt, more cautious, not to mention advised by attorneys to not date. Funny – that doesn’t seem to have stopped the men.
BigLittleWolf´s last blog ..The Problem with “Positive Denial” is Denial
I just joined a dating site and I am still legally married, but have been separated for six years. I have filed for divorce. It’s complicated because my ex is in contempt of court for not paying child support and not taking ordered classes. That said, I listed myself as divorced on the dating site. That may be misleading in some eyes, but there is no chance in hell I would get back together with my ex. It is my unfinished business and it’s not like I am planning to get married any time soon. I feel like it’s a turnoff to have separated status. That said, the guy I have dated, very casually I might add, did bring it up
A few times but I don’t think it affected our relationship. He had his own baggage of residing in the same household of his ex girlfriend since they bought the house together. I really don’t feel dishonest because I have filed. I really don’t know how I would feel if it were the other way around. Tough call.
Twitter @ Summerknows
i have learned my lesson on not being too honest about your past to someone whom you just met, and for that, to a possible prospect in the future. I have been honest to a fault, that somehow drove 2 men away. Men or some people, tend to be too judgmental on your plight or whatever happened to you in the past. Others even psycho-analyze you. I have also been a ‘victim’ of society – rules that somehow try to manipulate your being. Don’t let other’s opinion get in the way. You know yourself better than anyone else. You be the judge, and I’m sure you’re the better one at that, when it comes to knowing when you’re ready to date. Although, healing from pain or hurt takes a bit of time, and perhaps seek more time to be with company of good people, not just family but friends who do understand what you’re going thru. I have been separated for 12 years and have filed annulment 3 times, just that have not worked out, since lawyers just take money from me. I live in a country where divorce isn’t allowed, sad to say, and really bad for those who want to start a new life. Dating for me has been somewhat somehow a sad thing since, some men would prefer those who are totally available. I would want to also have or be with someone to be with when I grow old, not just my kids who, later on will have families of their own. I have tried those dating online sites (but not anymore now) and never hesitated ticking the separated box. Somehow, there are men who can be interested, although not too interesting at all. It’s always that you can be honest when the question pops up. But telling all those details of your past relationships, perhaps when you are finally have come to that part when you most certainly feel that he wants to be a part of your life – good or bad. After all, whatever is being said here, would still be up to your decision in the end, because no two individuals are alike…
Summer: Thanks so much for sharing your experiences with us. We agree with much of what you said . . .you’re the only one who can make decisions for YOU. Do visit us again soon.